Nek and Manda

[Guest guest]

 

Dear Punit Ji,

 

'As far as my knowledge, merely planetary placement cannot decide nek or manda nature of the planet...... But I think if Jupiter is not showing ill results on it's karaks objects like father, guru, finance etc., it should not be taken as malefic. In such a case remedy of Jupiter can backfire.'

My understanding of 'Nek' and 'Manda' is same as yours because that's what I have understood from Mr.Bhatia and his messages to the group.

Ex.Rahu in 7th house:

1)Manda indication is that there will be loss of Laxmi-which means money and wife.

2)Nek Indiaction is good govt.job or rajyoga which also means good standing in society.

If a person is not having good relations with wife and is wasting money the suggested upaye of square silver piece in Gangajal in sealed can kept in house will help.

I have two charts with Rahu alone in 7 th house.One has all the indications of Manda i.e wastes money,does not have good relation with 2nd wife also and the other does not have,so the upaye has been suggested only to the first person.

With regards,

Jagmeet

PS.I have rahu in 7th but jupiter and mangal are also in 7th house.I was never able to save money for the first 38 years of my life.I was having problems in govt.job and I took premature retirement at the age of 37.I have pretty good relationship with my wife(we have been married for the last 20 years and we first met in school way back in 70's)My wife has Rahu in the 1st which was manda for her.I have kept Silver square piece in gangajal for the last nearly 10 years.I persume it has helped.

PPS:Sorry for the long message.

[Guest guest]

dear jagmeet ji,

 

Thats where the problem lies. Who to go by ? you have said :

 

Ex.Rahu in 7th house:

> " 1)Manda indication is that there will be loss of Laxmi-which means

money

> and wife. "

 

The Lal Kitab says :

 

budh shukra ka taraju ulte , stree mand parivara

daulat ka woh rakha howe , khaven dosta yara

 

Yes the result of stree will be mand ' manda parivara' but not of

money ' daulat ka woh rakha howe '

 

You further said :

 

" 2)Nek Indiaction is good govt.job or rajyoga which also means

good

> standing in society. "

 

But Lal Kitab says :

 

raj sambandh padvi unchi , dhan stree na sukhi ho

vrachha tale ho jis jaa baitha, ukharaa wahi jar jalta ho

 

that means even if Rahu is nek ' dhan stree na sukhi ho'

 

Now who do we go by? By the book or by what some one says. I would

prefer to go by the book because that alone is the authentic word

that I have.

sure i would accept the verification questions but I must know where

do they exist in the book ? Bhatia ji asked a question while

analysing Alpant's horoscope :

 

" if your grandfather was alive when you were 14 he should be alive

even today . "

what if Alpant were 60 himself when his horoscope was being

analysed ?

 

I searched all the editions of the lal kitab that I have and didn't

find any such indication. The closest I came to was :

 

" if the Jupiter is in the 8th house, his granfather might have

died before he is born.. if not .. and his grandfather stays alive

till the natives is 8 years old.. then the grandfather would live

upto the age of 80 years. "

 

 

Therefore jagmeet ji, I accept the book and what is written there as

the truth.

 

with regards,

upadhyay

 

 

 

 

 

lalkitab , jagmeet dheendsa <jsdheendsa@j...>

wrote:

>

> Dear Punit Ji,

>

> 'As far as my knowledge, merely planetary placement cannot decide

nek or

> manda nature of the planet...... But I think if Jupiter is not

showing

> ill results on it's karaks objects like father, guru, finance etc.,

it

> should not be taken as malefic. In such a case remedy of Jupiter can

> backfire.'

> My understanding of 'Nek' and 'Manda' is same as yours because

that's

> what I have understood from Mr.Bhatia and his messages to the group.

> Ex.Rahu in 7th house:

> 1)Manda indication is that there will be loss of Laxmi-which means

money

> and wife.

> 2)Nek Indiaction is good govt.job or rajyoga which also means good

> standing in society.

> If a person is not having good relations with wife and is wasting

money

> the suggested upaye of square silver piece in Gangajal in sealed

can kept

> in house will help.

> I have two charts with Rahu alone in 7 th house.One has all the

> indications of Manda i.e wastes money,does not have good relation

with

> 2nd wife also and the other does not have,so the upaye has been

> suggested only to the first person.

> With regards,

> Jagmeet

> PS.I have rahu in 7th but jupiter and mangal are also in 7th

house.I was

> never able to save money for the first 38 years of my life.I was

having

> problems in govt.job and I took premature retirement at the age of

37.I

> have pretty good relationship with my wife(we have been married for

the

> last 20 years and we first met in school way back in 70's)My wife

has

> Rahu in the 1st which was manda for her.I have kept Silver square

piece

> in gangajal for the last nearly 10 years.I persume it has helped.

> PPS:Sorry for the long message.