Astrology fake or real - Comments Sanjay Sinha

[Guest guest]

Dear Sanjay ji, Well said! I agree with you. //> While going to an astrologer, we go with a chart (may be real or fake), sit like dumb. We expect that the astrologer should tell all about him every thing about him/her, all about their family members, about their diseases, about community etc. // True!!! All the astrologer might have experienced this, for sure. You presented it well. Your comparison of Astrology and Medicine was excellent to say the least - and this comparison will not fade out for long! Let me quote it again -// Medicine:> When any body is sick, he/she will go to doctor (MBBS, MD etc), the doctor will ask him lots of question to find out disease and the prescribe lots of medicine, if patient is not cure then doctor is prescribed another medicine. If patient is not cured then doctor suggest him lots of test and if also not cured then he suggest him operation or left him on GOD. We accept this by saying/thinking this, that the doctor has tried a lot but what to do.> The patient goes to another doctor and cycle repeats.Astrology:> While going to an astrologer, we go with a chart (may be real or fake), sit like dumb. We expect that the astrologer should tell all about him every thing about him/her, all about their family members, about their diseases, about community etc. Out of many predictions, if all prediction are right, and if one prediction is wrong then we straight ways say that the astrologers is fake and astrology as subject is fake.> > Why this happens to the subject Astrology, why not with any other subjects like Medicines there are lots of fake doctors in the society who are playing within persons life, and there is movement against them..// Excellent comparison! Love and regards,Sreenadh , "Sanjay Sinha" <sanjaykrsinhain wrote:>> Hi All,> > May I ask Mr. Sanat, that if astrology is a fake then why he has written a book on this and why he is a member of this community. Astrology is a subject like any other subjects. It is fully scientific, based on astronomical calculations.> > If astrology is fake, that means that astronomy is a fake, that's means that all the planets , stars, nakshatras are fake.> > I also believe that there are many fake astrologers in the society, they are spoiling the society. If you are fighting against this then you are right. But if the fight is against the subject astrology than I am totally against this. Any subject is not fake.> > I am asking you one question, if any body has guts to answer this.> > When any body is sick, he/she will go to doctor (MBBS, MD etc), the doctor will ask him lots of question to find out disease and the prescribe lots of medicine, if patient is not cure then doctor is prescribed another medicine. If patient is not cured then doctor suggest him lots of test and if also not cured then he suggest him operation or left him on GOD. We accept this by saying/thinking this, that the doctor has tried a lot but what to do.> The patient goes to another doctor and cycle repeats.> > While going to an astrologer, we go with a chart (may be real or fake), sit like dumb. We expect that the astrologer should tell all about him every thing about him/her, all about their family members, about their diseases, about community etc. Out of many predictions, if all prediction are right, and if one prediction is wrong then we straight ways say that the astrologers is fake and astrology as subject is fake.> > Why this happens to the subject Astrology,why not with any other subjects like Medicines there are lots of fake doctors in the society who are playing within persons life, and there is movement against them..> > For your information, if the subject is fake then why there are over ten millions astrology sites from USA, UK and European Countries. It is believed that USA, UK, Europeans do not believe without any scientific base. If they believe then there must be some scientific base/logic behind this.> > Mr. Sanat is requested to forward this message to Randi Foundations or provide id of the so called society.> > Regards> Sanjay Sinha>