Divisions of signs vs D-charts

[Guest guest]

Dear Nakai ji, Here also the answer is clear: "The sages DOES NOT Support D-charts. D-charts is a concept of recent origin, unsupported by sages and dates back only to around 200 years. But sages support Divisions of signs (Amsas/Vargas) * Divisions ARE OF SIGNS and they don't have a separate existence from Natal chart. * The concept 0f D-charts assume independent existence and analysis of D-charts and assume that Division is of the CHART itself and not of signs! They erroneously ascribe aspects, transit and what not to D-charts. Love and regards,Sreenadh , "Amit Nakai" <amit.nakai wrote:>> Thanks Sreenath Ji,> > For the information. Yes I had quoted the question wrongly.> > I would also like to ask the following:> > Which charts have major significance on a subject: D1, D2....... Dn> > If there is a good Yoga in any D chart then what is the significance of the yoga.> E.g . if there is Malavya yoga in D3, then is it strong than other Yogas in D1 ?> > Does dahsa system work in Dn charts, or we use the dasha of D1 and get resluts for other Dn charts.> > > Warm Regards> Nakai> > > Sreenadh > Friday, August 15, 2008 7:02 PM> > Re: Percentage of Transit with respect to Vishmottari Dahsa> > > Dear Nakai ji, > It don't think that it is something that can be correctly expressed in something like percentage!! (I have also heard that it is fools who use % too much in subjects other than mathematics and statistics that too especially when they don't know a 's**t' about the reality! For example politicizations always mention percentage with out doing even a bit of analysis, ppl use percentage even while discussing non-quantifiable things like love and affection!)> Any way coming to the current question, the 3 factors under consideration are -> 1) Yoga > 2) Dasa > 3) Transit.> Out of these three, traditionally the first 2 are given much importance and third the least. If I would have to judge from my use of the same, I would give Yoga (50%), Dasa (30%), and Transit (10%) and the remaining 10% still 'unpredictable'!!! Certainly others may differ about the percentage (or rather weightage) they give to Transit based on their experience. > So the point is - You are NOT going to get an exact or correct answer, because the question itself is wrong! Anyway you can arrive at your own percentage maths from your own experience (even though that too will not prove a thing)! > Love and regards,> Sreenadh> > , "Amit Nakai" amit.nakai@ wrote:> >> > > > Hi Learned People,> > > > We read from various scriptures, that Dasha has major influence on a person than the transit.> > > > What is the percentage of influence over a person during the dasha?> > > > What is the percentage of influence over a person during the transit?> > > > Warm Regards> > Nakai> >>