RE: Research data for medical-astr ology

[Guest guest]

Dear Friends,

 

The exercise provided by Kansal-ji was good for learned members.

 

We ( the beginners) watched the in AWE the capacity of astrologers

in finding out the seemingly impossible data.

 

Thank you all for the same.

 

However, it appears that if these sets of data were mixed with few

DOB of healthy children .... then may be we would know the difference

between a real killer planetary position and a normal one.

 

Please note that I am not asking for testing of calibre of learned astrologers.

But, as pointed out by Bhaskaran-ji, I find it very difficult to know the basic

differences about two charts

 

regards

 

chakraborty

 

 

 

 

sunil nair [astro_tellerkerala]Thursday, August 14, 2008 12:40 PM Subject: Re: Research data for medical-astrology

 

 

 

Hare rama krishna

 

respected bhaskaran ji

 

I agree with all points which u pointed out ,which very much true .

even if we know ( means many astrologers those who r good and has nativs chart ,prashna and nimmittas --so he knows it if consulted personly and in face to face ) but the speling out the truth is real problem .

 

Even sastras underlines many pre conditions b4 we predicting ,even we cannot predict bad or death of some ones life partner ( unless we sure abt the intention of quesriest --astrologicaly mainly and also logicaly ) as some may came to devise some bad plan and it can back fire on astrologer as he was a party in that bad karma .same is the case with other bad sounding predictions the dilemma of astrologer is there .

 

thank u for a thought provoking mail

 

regrds sunil nair

om shreem mahalaxmai namah .

 

, "Bhaskar" <rajiventerprises wrote:>> > Dear Shri Kursija ji and the learned members,> > I agree completely with Shri Kursijaji, here. The astrologers job is> enough to pin point the area of disease, whether it would be fatal or> recoverable, if recoverable then when ? These issues if an astrologer is> able to solve, then it is just more than enough. Anything better than> that is always welcome, of course, but not within the framewok of the> astrologer, and neither expected from him.> > Longevity ise is another isue which is not easy to be tackled at all. So> however much a astrologer may learn about balarishta yogas, it would be> difficult for him to point out early death, and even if he does so, how> could one tell the parent that " Your child would die early , as I find> this disease setting up in his body " To achieve this perfection in> astrology is not a easy cake walk, to tell a parent about incoming death> of their new born child is a grave task, and a solid reason would have> to be told to the parents supplementing this revelation, as to what> disease is seen incoming.> > Which emans that the astrologer would have to be perfect on 2 counts -> > 1) Predicting longevity, in this case early death to the new born.> > 2) Predicting the disease.> > Because if the astrologer only talks about the first point without> mentioning the 2nd point to the parent, he would be thrown out of the> house of the native within no time.> > Hope I am making some sense .> > Another point, Shri Shyam Kansalji , Medical enquiry comes first in> medical cases ad then comes astrological enquiry. If the Doctor cannot> predict early death to the child with hundreds and thousands of means> and resources, an astrologer may not be able to help much in those cases> of early deaths. For instance, the sex- determination is more easier> with a sonography done on the pregnant lady, rathr than goin to a> astrologr and asking him what could be my childs sex. ( This is a> seperate matter tha its no longer legal, but almost all private clinics> do unofficially reveal , what is being enquired ).> > Astrologers would do better at predicting other matters of day to day,> rather than predicting balarishta or sex determination, or the exact day> of marriage, or answering such intense queries, because for that one> needs a rigourous discipline, a life of austerity and yama and niyama ,> of all types, for the astrologer, coupled with a good volume of> knowledge concerned to astrology and astronomy, strengthened with> experience due to the major part of his Life devoted to studying> astrology. And not many of us, pass this test.> > best wishes,> > Bhaskaran.>