Guest guest Posted August 7, 2006 Report Share Posted August 7, 2006 Dear Gaurav, I wanted to know if you also have experience to back those recommendations (conditional, provisional and all that), seeing your site-size exposition on the matter. I'd have appreciated if you had faced at least one point I raised squarely, say for example why not when in 9th if in 5th. (Who knows that would set off a discussion?) Instead, I get to read an egregious line of illustration w.r.t. Ju in 2nd in Cancer: " it cannot make the native start dreaming of someone > like Laxmi Mittal or bill Gates..howver, other things shld be kept > in mind... " We alway keep other things in mind. But how much 'other'? Other than where Moon, the sign lord, is? How the planet in the varga is disposed? And so on. Thus generalisations (subject to satisfation of other things) are too blunt to be at all used. See, books on astrology and gems are being written no end. Those who prescribe, we see of them no end. And those who prescribe are churlish, if not charlatons. We here try to clear one another's doubts and share what insights we have. The book you have followed obviously follows Anukulavaada. So why bring in the practice of the other theory (in Bengal...)? If you still want me to tell you what I want you to engage in, here it is: Does the 5th house (+ Libra ) placement of Ju score over 9th (+ Auq) in causing a " great raja yoga " ? By the way, how many `karako bhaavanashaya' situations we have for Ju? Four? In 2nd hse, 5 th hse, 9th hse and 11th hse? All these placements irrespective of lagna are no good! What is it that we mean or they (rishis and daivijnas of yore) meant by karako bhaavanashaya? How do we apply the rule to Ju in second house for Aqu lagna, for example? Think, write. We'll love to read you on the site. Best RK , " " <gg_0202 wrote: > > ||Jai Ramakrishna|| > Dear Shree RKji, > As i have mentioned in the beginning on the top of that article, > that i have taken help of " Gems in Vedic Astrology " by Neeraj > Lalwani.... > You must be aware that Jupiter for Gemini Lagna/Virgo lagna, suffers > from Kendradhipatya Dosha..so during its period & sub-periods it > will hardly confer any good results...in 2nd house Jupiter doesnot > give good results " Karako Bhavanashaya " ....even if in Cancer for > gemini lagna..it cannot make the native start dreaming of someone > like Laxmi Mittal or bill Gates..howver, other things shld be kept > in mind... > In bengal, i have seen astrologers advising gems for those who are > weak or not well placed...i donno the rationale behind this & it > totally differs from the article as i have given... > Thanq > With Humbleness, > Wish u all success, > > http://gauravastro.150m.com > ------------------No private messages please----------------------- - > > > > , " arkaydash " > <arkaydash@> wrote: > > > > Dear Gaurav, > > I visited your website. Encountered a stubborn pop-up, which is > > irritating. > > > > Read the article on gems. Under Pokhraj (for Gemini Lagna) you > write: > > > > 3. Gemini –Jupiter suffers from Kendradhipati Dosha. Jupiter in > > 5th house can confer great yoga if Pukhraj is used. Jupiter in > > 1/2/4/7/9/10 houses from Lagna with the use of Pukhraj promote > > professional life. > > > > Why? And why not when placed in 9th hse? Why professional life > only > > why not marital life? Isn't Sag (7th hse) its Mooltrikona sign? > > > > Have you researched enough in this? I mean the placement " in > > 1/2/4/7/9/10 houses " for this lagna. Hope you have. > > > > I feel, with Ju in 2nd ie Cancer, one needn't (perhaps should not) > > wear the Ju gem. The super-stengthening of the 7th lord without > the > > relative fortification of 1st lord, is that advisable, esp. when > the > > planet is in another death-house (2nd)? If you make any averment, > > pls also do on the basis of your experience and case studies. > > > > Finally, why do you single out its 5th house placement and not 9th > > hse placement for conferment of great yoga? > > > > RK > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.