Indus vally civilization was AFTER Mabhaharata and vedic period says Kishore

[Guest guest]

, " kishore mohan "

<kishorepatnaik09 wrote:

>

> Please read my mail once again.

 

Hey guys,

 

You can tone it down because you're both saying the same thing and

there's no need to feud Whether or not you read each others' posts,

most of us do

 

+++

RK, if you're reading this, no answer to why I've an 'iffy nettonym'

[Guest guest]

Hi flippy,

 

That is what i am trying to impress sreenadh.

 

Btw, where on earth have you disappered?

 

Kishore patnaik

 

, " vernalagnia "

<vernalagnia wrote:

>

> , " kishore mohan "

> <kishorepatnaik09@> wrote:

> >

> > Please read my mail once again.

>

> Hey guys,

>

> You can tone it down because you're both saying the same thing and

> there's no need to feud Whether or not you read each others' posts,

> most of us do

>

> +++

> RK, if you're reading this, no answer to why I've an 'iffy

nettonym'

>

[Guest guest]

, " kishore mohan "

<kishorepatnaik09 wrote:

>

> Dear saurav,

>

> Thnx for sending the piece by private mail.

>

> it is laughable to call this as a research article. It is written by a

> christian jesuit, heavily coming against Hinduism and propogating his

> religion. There is no ressearch in it nor there is anything new in

> the lies and half lies and wrong interpretations being proliferated.

>

> Please exercise extra caution in becoming a foolish instrument in

> pontification of India.

>

> Kishore patanik

 

Kishore,

 

The problem isn't any of this. It lies more in ideology. All

ideologies are basically the mental equivalent of a virus, since the

brain is held captive and free thought dies. Totalitarian ideologies

(communism, fascism, religions that rule life itself, etc.) are all

turmoil-fraught if taken seriously.

 

+++

[Guest guest]

Dear friend,

 

I accept the role of ideology when it comes to interpretation. Ie I

intrepret an event as per my ideology and you do as per yours.Even

in vedas, it is said that Ekat Sat viprah bahuda vadanthi (truth is

one but the learned will talk of it in different ways) That I think

we should accept, as it indicates we have an open mind.

 

But in Indian History, even in accepting the facts, the ideology is

playing a major role. Ie instead of helping people to interpret an

event from various angles, an ideology is proving to be a mental

block in accepting the truth and polemics is taking the front seat,

stabbing the truth to die. ie to say the History is being written in

accordance to the ideology and whatz worse is that these half lies

and often whitelies are being forced on young minds as being the

whole truth.

 

The marxists want not just interpret the History as per their

ideology but they want to WRITE history as per their whims and

fancies. This is bad.

 

The best eg is the book written by Romilla Thapar on Somnath. She

left just short of eulogising the invader, while everyone knows what

are the general facts of the massacre of Somnath.

 

To be frank, it is very easy to see how the Marxists WRITE the

history-even contemporary history. If you take the Godhra issue, even

the Indian press, which is full of marxists, has given a back seat to

the basic proximate issue of Godhra massacre and much was made of

Best Bakery case. Few Moslem lives seem to be more valuable than

those of a train ful Hindus. Well, guess we are living in India where

we are ordained to be second rate citizens.

 

Kishore patnaik

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

n , " vernalagnia "

<vernalagnia wrote:

>

> , " kishore mohan "

> <kishorepatnaik09@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear saurav,

> >

> > Thnx for sending the piece by private mail.

> >

> > it is laughable to call this as a research article. It is written

by a

> > christian jesuit, heavily coming against Hinduism and propogating

his

> > religion. There is no ressearch in it nor there is anything new

in

> > the lies and half lies and wrong interpretations being

proliferated.

> >

> > Please exercise extra caution in becoming a foolish instrument in

> > pontification of India.

> >

> > Kishore patanik

>

> Kishore,

>

> The problem isn't any of this. It lies more in ideology. All

> ideologies are basically the mental equivalent of a virus, since the

> brain is held captive and free thought dies. Totalitarian ideologies

> (communism, fascism, religions that rule life itself, etc.) are all

> turmoil-fraught if taken seriously.

>

> +++

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Kishore ji,

The document was not worthy, and I requested Gaurav ji to delete it,

and he did it. So I don't think it is good to discuss it any more in

the group.

You can follow the link to Subhash kak ji's (Distinguished Professor

of Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, Louisiana State

University, Baton Rouge, USA)site, or follow the link provided to his

site in the Links section of the forum. He had also permitted us to

upload his articles in the files section of our forum, and so feel

free to do so if someone wants to direct the attention of others in

the direction of his research in any subject.

P.S.:1: Kishore ji, for sure you will find Subhash ji's articles

worth reading. His researches points ot the direction of Vedic and

Sindhu-Sarasvaty civilizations sharing one and the same continuity.

2: Dear Verna ji, I agree with you as well.

3: Please don't under estimate the possible contributions of Gourav

ji, in serious discussions in the forth coming days. My regards to

him.

Love,

Sreenadh

 

, " vernalagnia "

<vernalagnia wrote:

>

> , " kishore mohan "

> <kishorepatnaik09@> wrote:

> >

> > Dear saurav,

> >

> > Thnx for sending the piece by private mail.

> >

> > it is laughable to call this as a research article. It is written

by a

> > christian jesuit, heavily coming against Hinduism and propogating

his

> > religion. There is no ressearch in it nor there is anything new

in

> > the lies and half lies and wrong interpretations being

proliferated.

> >

> > Please exercise extra caution in becoming a foolish instrument in

> > pontification of India.

> >

> > Kishore patanik

>

> Kishore,

>

> The problem isn't any of this. It lies more in ideology. All

> ideologies are basically the mental equivalent of a virus, since the

> brain is held captive and free thought dies. Totalitarian ideologies

> (communism, fascism, religions that rule life itself, etc.) are all

> turmoil-fraught if taken seriously.

>

> +++

>

[Guest guest]

Dear sreenadh,

 

1. Because the discussion was done here to send the paper etc., Ihave

posted it here.

 

2. I Know Mr Subhash Kak and we have had very serious discussions, as

we are on the same side of the fence. But this was all more than 2

years ago, when I was more than serious about Indian History. In

fact, I have personally requested Dr Kalyanraman, an eminent

Historian (he is also like subhash Kak and started seriously

pursuing History , especially about Indus valley to publish several

volumes on the subject after his voluntary retirement from his well

paying and high flying job)to discuss the history of astrology, if he

is interested. I have referred this group to him and if he comes back

to me, I will certainly talk about it here.

 

3. I have no intention of underestimating anyone, if that PS is for me

(which I hope is not)

 

Kishore patnaik

, " Sreenadh "

<sreesog wrote:

>

> Dear Kishore ji,

> The document was not worthy, and I requested Gaurav ji to delete

it,

> and he did it. So I don't think it is good to discuss it any more

in

> the group.

> You can follow the link to Subhash kak ji's (Distinguished

Professor

> of Department of Electrical & Computer Engineering, Louisiana State

> University, Baton Rouge, USA)site, or follow the link provided to

his

> site in the Links section of the forum. He had also permitted us to

> upload his articles in the files section of our forum, and so feel

> free to do so if someone wants to direct the attention of others in

> the direction of his research in any subject.

> P.S.:1: Kishore ji, for sure you will find Subhash ji's articles

> worth reading. His researches points ot the direction of Vedic and

> Sindhu-Sarasvaty civilizations sharing one and the same

continuity.

> 2: Dear Verna ji, I agree with you as well.

> 3: Please don't under estimate the possible contributions of

Gourav

> ji, in serious discussions in the forth coming days. My regards to

> him.

> Love,

> Sreenadh

>

> , " vernalagnia "

> <vernalagnia@> wrote:

> >

> > , " kishore mohan "

> > <kishorepatnaik09@> wrote:

> > >

> > > Dear saurav,

> > >

> > > Thnx for sending the piece by private mail.

> > >

> > > it is laughable to call this as a research article. It is

written

> by a

> > > christian jesuit, heavily coming against Hinduism and

propogating

> his

> > > religion. There is no ressearch in it nor there is anything

new

> in

> > > the lies and half lies and wrong interpretations being

> proliferated.

> > >

> > > Please exercise extra caution in becoming a foolish instrument

in

> > > pontification of India.

> > >

> > > Kishore patanik

> >

> > Kishore,

> >

> > The problem isn't any of this. It lies more in ideology. All

> > ideologies are basically the mental equivalent of a virus, since

the

> > brain is held captive and free thought dies. Totalitarian

ideologies

> > (communism, fascism, religions that rule life itself, etc.) are

all

> > turmoil-fraught if taken seriously.

> >

> > +++

> >

>