Guest guest Posted December 12, 2008 Report Share Posted December 12, 2008 This is a forum that I love -- please make no mistake about that! I have stated that publicly -- go look please! Once in a while a Messiah comes along and tries to tell us how JYOTISH must be practiced! Interestingly from a *circumscribed* sector! But let us not digress! As I was growing up as a jyotishi, all on my own back in 60s and 70s there was KK Shah with his books. I reached out for them and they worked wonderfully in the first half dozen of charts but seriously FAILED subsequently. I was a teenager then and it really hurt me DEEPLY! And there was no internet or all its bevy of gifts that you all have, young and old that I never had back then. Then came KP and yes it helped me to get confidence in the subs etc. The Placidus and the ayanamsha bothered me as did Uchchishta Ganapathi! Eventually -- there was VK Choudhari and his system approach! If you read Choudhari -- his writings do make sense! It was never accepted on this forum and as Tanvir explained when I challenged -- the followers were to blame and not the SYSTEM! Personally speaking -- I find the System Approach closer to Parashari jyotish than KP! Placidus house system? A Western house system created because of the northern latituded and a hangover from the West -- not necessarily followed even in the west any more! NO mention of Gopal Krishna Rao, " Meena " ? Just because his cyclostyled Nakshatra Readers are not available any more? Uchchishta Ganapathi (magical and extraterrestREAL influences)? To me, Nargoal's KK SHAH'S system or KP and Systems Approach represent " ME TOO! " attempts in this Jyotish reality that have been around and just need to be DEMONSTRATED to the mainstream of jyotish and jyotishis and not just claimed! Please do not misunderstand me! As publicly stated in my writings, I hold Krishnamurty in high esteem because I happened to read his readers before I read Gopal Krishna Rao " Meena " 's writings! But 'PLACIDUS'? Please give us a break and let us hear from the KP followers! Since KP is allowed here on this forum of Tanvir the King, but Systems Approach is not! I wonder why!! Rohiniranjan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 12, 2008 Report Share Posted December 12, 2008 Dear Jyotishis, I want to know about Placidus system. From where I will find it out ? Can anyone of you give me details of this system ? I am interested learning about KP system. Thanks and regards. Ramesh Mishra Rohiniranjan <rohini_ranjan wrote: This is a forum that I love -- please make no mistake about that! I have stated that publicly -- go look please! Once in a while a Messiah comes along and tries to tell us how JYOTISH must be practiced! Interestingly from a *circumscribed* sector! But let us not digress! As I was growing up as a jyotishi, all on my own back in 60s and 70s there was KK Shah with his books. I reached out for them and they worked wonderfully in the first half dozen of charts but seriously FAILED subsequently. I was a teenager then and it really hurt me DEEPLY! And there was no internet or all its bevy of gifts that you all have, young and old that I never had back then. Then came KP and yes it helped me to get confidence in the subs etc. The Placidus and the ayanamsha bothered me as did Uchchishta Ganapathi! Eventually -- there was VK Choudhari and his system approach! If you read Choudhari -- his writings do make sense! It was never accepted on this forum and as Tanvir explained when I challenged -- the followers were to blame and not the SYSTEM! Personally speaking -- I find the System Approach closer to Parashari jyotish than KP! Placidus house system? A Western house system created because of the northern latituded and a hangover from the West -- not necessarily followed even in the west any more! NO mention of Gopal Krishna Rao, " Meena " ? Just because his cyclostyled Nakshatra Readers are not available any more? Uchchishta Ganapathi (magical and extraterrestREAL influences)? To me, Nargoal's KK SHAH'S system or KP and Systems Approach represent " ME TOO! " attempts in this Jyotish reality that have been around and just need to be DEMONSTRATED to the mainstream of jyotish and jyotishis and not just claimed! Please do not misunderstand me! As publicly stated in my writings, I hold Krishnamurty in high esteem because I happened to read his readers before I read Gopal Krishna Rao " Meena " 's writings! But 'PLACIDUS'? Please give us a break and let us hear from the KP followers! Since KP is allowed here on this forum of Tanvir the King, but Systems Approach is not! I wonder why!! Rohiniranjan Connect with friends all over the world. Get India Messenger. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.