Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Share Posted January 14, 2007 When little kids inquire about a near one whom death has taken away, they are told by older kids (like us) that God needed them more and hence called them to his home. God is a concept which is positively appealing and can be attributed all the reasons for the events which are otherwise not understood by us. Whether there is God or not is a different question, but the concept of God itself has a lot of benefits for people whose emotional blocks do not permit them to think beyond a certain point. It would have been good if this concept was utilised to merely lift away the fears about death, poverty and disease. But, the more clever ones of us grown up kids have found this concept and its hold on other not so clever kids to be a potent weapon to attain power over these not so clever ones. The Popes, Mullahs, Priests, Pandits, politicians, dictators, etc, have been utilising this weapon to be in unquestionable powerful positions since ages. In all cultures, regions, countries, in all times, this has happened and will keep on happening always. Whoever has opposed this weapon has ended up being made a new weapon in turn, after his death. Jesus, Mohammed, Buddha, the list is endless.... We should ask ourselves whether we really need such a concept. Is there no other way of making the humans behave peacefully and in discipline? Can we not judge our actions as good or bad by looking at their outcomes for the long term good or bad of the majority of the people? We have become short sighted. We elect leaders and give them powers only on the basis of our short term and emotional gains in mind. The Saddams, the Bushes, the Hitlers, etc, could not have been successful if these motives were not supported, knowingly or unknowingly, by us. Do these leaders really believe in anything like God? NO. In my daily practice as an astrologer, I usually meet successful and aspiring politicians, religious leaders, Godmen, etc. And, believe me, this breed of humans do not believe in God. Their God is power. It has to be attained at all costs. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Share Posted January 14, 2007 An intriguing post, carrying on from where Richard lefts us with his stimulating philosophical insights about our existence. Consider that when constructing a model, the theoriser relies heavily on one key overriding assumption that enables the fundamentals of the model to function in a plausible manner. Let's imagine for a moment imagine that 'God' is the key assumption of the 'religious model'. Whether of not this assumption is correct is irrelevant as long as it enables the 'model' to function in line with the purpose for which it is constructed. This purpose in this case being, of course, positive social behaviour. Thus millions of 'religious' people behaving 'as if' there is a God or operating under the 'assumption' that there is a God and the subsequent implications for the after-life exerts a powerful force of positive influence on the human brain. After all, the scientific method is to construct, test and then accept/reject a model on the basis of its success in achieving its objective or satisfying its predictions. On this basis it would be unscientific and irrational to reject the religious 'model' as it is extremely robust in achieving its objectives and satisfying its predictions (of improved human behaviour). Of course the religious model just like any other effective 'scientific' model can be manipulated for increasing power, oppression or extremism. This is subject to the mind set of those whose hands it falls in. But the trade-off in terms of the positive results derived from the religious model vs the negative results surely indicate that the positive results dominate? Therefore the 'rejection' of this model at this juncture in time is neither plausible nor scientific. However, as the words of Ashutosh imply, the construction of a `superior' model that can further extend the positive portion of this trade-off would certainly in scientific terms lead to a transformatory evolution. Would this be achieved by replacing that all-important 'assumption' of God with an innovate notion? This would indeed be a giant leap for mankind and certainly a prospect one is able to entertain when one is faithful to the doctrine that propounds Kaliyug to be a metaphorical crawling baby at this moment in time that will eventually begin to walk. Maybe it is when such an alternative model gathers a popular mass following that Kali will have truly risen to his feet. But until then we shall continue to speculate. For that is all our limited mortal mind in this limited lifetime gifts us the capacity to indulge in, subconsciously aware that the real truth will only arrive when we make our exit from this body. Or will it?............................. valist, "astrologerashutosh" <astrologerashutosh wrote: > > When little kids inquire about a near one whom death has taken away, they are told by older kids (like us) that God needed them more and hence called them to his home. > > God is a concept which is positively appealing and can be attributed all the reasons for the events which are otherwise not understood by us. Whether there is God or not is a different question, but the concept of God itself has a lot of benefits for people whose emotional blocks do not permit them to think beyond a certain point. > > It would have been good if this concept was utilised to merely lift away the fears about death, poverty and disease. But, the more clever ones of us grown up kids have found this concept and its hold on other not so clever kids to be a potent weapon to attain power over these not so clever ones. > > The Popes, Mullahs, Priests, Pandits, politicians, dictators, etc, have been utilising this weapon to be in unquestionable powerful positions since ages. In all cultures, regions, countries, in all times, this has happened and will keep on happening always. > > Whoever has opposed this weapon has ended up being made a new weapon in turn, after his death. Jesus, Mohammed, Buddha, the list is endless.... > > We should ask ourselves whether we really need such a concept. Is there no other way of making the humans behave peacefully and in discipline? Can we not judge our actions as good or bad by looking at their outcomes for the long term good or bad of the majority of the people? > > We have become short sighted. We elect leaders and give them powers only on the basis of our short term and emotional gains in mind. The Saddams, the Bushes, the Hitlers, etc, could not have been successful if these motives were not supported, knowingly or unknowingly, by us. Do these leaders really believe in anything like God? NO. > > In my daily practice as an astrologer, I usually meet successful and aspiring politicians, religious leaders, Godmen, etc. And, believe me, this breed of humans do not believe in God. Their God is power. It has to be attained at all costs. > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 14, 2007 Report Share Posted January 14, 2007 Hi Atma Gnan (Knowledge of Soul) and Ashutosh (Siva, ³easily pleased²) >From Richard (Heart of a King) Friends, Komrades! On the religious model verse scientific, Atma spoke about whether one is better for the huddled masses. Well, here¹s what I have to say on that: Fact is, people don¹t easily change. The Hare Krishna movement pushed books by a staunch religionist (Prabhupada) into people¹s hands worldwide, and nothing happened. Mostly the books went to heaven in the landfill and used book stores, all of which have many stacks of these books. I was talking to a Jyotish practicing friend in Ireland the other day, and she related how the Catholics just won¹t budge. No matter how hard you try, their conception is so deeply engrained into them, and they believe they are right. You can lead a horse to water, but you can¹t make him drink. So really, to discuss these matters is for those who are ³there², or, ³at that point². Real thinkers are rare- that is, persons whose karma it is to be able to, and actually wanting to, consider, think, and discuss various options on how to think about the cosmos and the reality of the soul. Most people want nothing of that. Rather, they want only more of the same which they are used to. They are continuing ³In the name of the father....², so to speak. So there¹s no point in fancifully considering ³what if² as regards this matter. It won¹t change. Actually, nothing is changeable just because we will it to change. Sure, society changes slowly over time, but it cannot be changed by the agreement of any committee, or the presence of any occupying force. It does it when it wants to, when it¹s ready. Illuminating examples in my mind: Why would any IRA gunman in Ireland want to fight for more independence and freedom for Ireland and it¹s people (from British rule), when all they seem to do with the freedoms they already won in 1922 or so is follow the oppression of priests and nuns? Similarly, I find it unbelievable that Iraqi based fighters who are trying to remove the US presence are doing so knowing, even hoping, that Sarira law will later come in and be imposed upon them. If I were them, I¹d be helping the US kick everything, including Islam, out of there. So, people are who they are, and no amount of discussion by smart people will change the dumb masses. That¹s a scientific fact, and religious fact. By religious ³fact², I mean simply this: Krishna says in the Gita ³do not disturb the minds of the ignorant, instead, encourage them to continue in religious devotions². So basically the supposed God is himself saying to encourage religious mind slavery. Why? Because smart people know that when you unsettle the minds of the dumb masses, you wake a sleeping dog, and all hell is gonna break loose if that¹s done. Only really rare saints actually follow religious principle when the going gets tough. When the masses are aroused, they loose control of themselves, and begin to fight, loot, murder, seek retribution for many remembered past wrongs, gangs form, civil wars get going, etc. Religioun keeps a lid on a lot of that, maintains a status quo of goodness and order, true. Studies have shown that where there are the MORE temples, there is MORE violence, and where there are NO temples, there is MORE violence, and where there is a MEDIUM number of temples, there you find more peace and order. So too much or too little religion tends to cause violence amongst humans, was the conclusion. Hare Krishna devotees ignored Albert Einstein, Carl Sagan, and any and all other persons with an opinion outside of their own. That I know for a fact.. They believe in Prabhupada and his kind, period, no other. That is very typical of religious people- to further their own party line, only. So, again, the talks of smart people don¹t matter. It¹s all about speculating for OUR OWN benefit alone. It¹s all theoretical only. Perhaps however, one of the smart will DO SOMETHING based on their findings, which TOUCHES the masses, and that is where change happens. I bet Jesus thought a lot, in a smart way, before he started his preaching mission. Like that. I think that thinking well, sometimes leads to actions, which change the course of history. The fact is WE DON¹T KNOW if there is exactly a God, or what exactly He or She is like, or what the nature of the SOURCE really is, but we can infer, and we have the inferences of the thinkers before us, and on we go. I still believe that there is SOME GREAT SOURCE and it remains for me A GREAT MYSTERY, and for me, that doesn¹t ³free me to sin², because I CAN SEE that ³what you do comes back at you² to a BASIC FACT of this creation. I can see that because I¹m smart. I can see that others, many, do NOT see that, because they are dumb. Se la vie Peace smart brothers and sisters, and, whatever, to you dumb ones, Richard Edward Wurst Richard Edward Wurst aka Das Goravani or Please use email if possible das (AT) goravani (DOT) com Secure online ordering of Goravani Jyotish 2.5 and Jyotish Studio 3 (JS3) Hindu Astrology Software and Video Training All Transactions made out to/mailed to: Please visit my YouTube Channel for my videos: (free) http://www.youtube.com/RichardEdwardWurst Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 15, 2007 Report Share Posted January 15, 2007 Richard, May Lord Ganesh remove all obstacles from your path and grant you peace and prosperity! Two things come to me as I read your response. Metaphorically, 1. It makes little sense to me.meaning I agree with you and the cited scripture, to stand on the mountain top (or anywhere on the mountain that is above the masses living at the base of the mountain) and shout to them, "Why can't you see the glory of all that I see?" 2. I must remember that I, at one time, was living at the base of the mountain; and it took me overcoming my fears (of heights.no; of the hurt I would experience if I moved from my comfortable place at the base of the mountain) to start my climb up the mountain. I believe the scripture is saying that change must come from within and not from any reason (or desire) to please someone else. It is not a matter of "smart" versus "dumb" in the usual sense of those words due to the often inferred meaning associated with these words; i.e., something along the line of "big me, little you". As Dr. David R. Hawkins says in his books "Power Versus Force" and "Eye of the I", truth exists at many different levels (of understanding and belief). This is much like the situation of the four blind men describing an elephant based on touching different parts of the animal. It is all a matter of perspective. I believe you to be saying this, too. That which is "A Great Mystery" to you is exactly what the Native Americans call "God". Hmmmm, I wonder if these are the same <smile>. Namaste, David LaGrone P. O. Box 2339 Glen Rose, TX 76043 dvdlagr (AT) valornet (DOT) com Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.