Guest guest Posted April 5, 2002 Report Share Posted April 5, 2002 Dear Arun,and list members, This is good chart for study. Cast the chart using Krushna's Ayanansha 22:06:02. Dasha will change. All the events given are mostly in line with the work sheet. In this system all the results are indicated by numerical value, of numerical strength of the planets for each house. If you cast the worksheet for this chart, it will be easy to study the chart and it's events. Other comments are below events in Capital. > > pL HAVE A LOOK AT HIS ONE TOO FOR SOME UNEXPLAINABLE EVENTS AND > ANSWER MY QUERY: > > I an sending a chart for study.there have been some unexplainable > events here. > > 1. Male ( ENGINEER.phd EDUCATIONWISE ),born on saturday ,21st > september 1946,10 am > > Place : Lar Village,DEORIA district ,Uttar pradesh india. SATURN AND MARS IN NAVAMANSHA INDICATES OF HIS BEING ENGINEER > I think that the latitude and longitude shld be 26.31 N and 83.47 E > > ( or shld it be 26.23N and 83.42 E.??) > > BALANCE DASHA OF SANI AT BIRTH 6 YR,3 MTHS,13 DAYS,7 HRS. KARKA > RASHI,PUSHYA NAKSHATRA ,LANGA LORD MANGAL . tHIS CHANGES WITH THE AYANANSHA. > > First some events in the life of the native for tallying sake with > the analysis: > > 1. In 1949-50 ,became suddenly unwell and presumed to be dead by all > one day ,revived suddenly.(sounds strange but true!) THE SATURN FOR THE CHART IS HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. SATURN BEING LORD OF 3RD HOUSE KARAK FOR DEATH, AND JUPITER IS LORD OF HOUSE D. AT THIS TIME JUPITER SUB IN SATURN MAIN WAS RUNNING. JUPITER IS HAVING GOOD POINTS FOR 6TH ALSO, MAY BE THE REASON FOR HIS SERVIVAL. > > 2.In 1956-57,almost escaped being drowned in village pond. sATURN AND VENUS ARE NATURAL SAMDHARMI. ACCIDENT IS INDICATED FROM 7TH HOUSE, AND SATURN IS LORD OF D, CAN BE SUBSTITUTED BY VENUS. AT THIS TIME HE WAS HAVING VENUS SUB. SO NO DANGER TO THE LIFE. > > 3.In 1963 there was an armed robbery at his hostel,escaped un hurt > rAHU SUB REPRESENTS vENUS HAVING LESS POINTS FOR 8TH. > anyways, then 4. in 1964 got ist class in intermediate and was > admitted to engg college at a place away from birth. > IT WAS A GOOD PERIOD > 5.May 1969 passed engg with distinction. > vENUS PERIOD WAS GOOS. > 6.SElected for air force but did not join for family reasons. > > 7.1972 may got married( LOVE CUM ARRANGED WIFES BDATE 8TH NOV,1948 4 IT IS IN rAHU SUB = VENUS AGAIN REPRESENTS SATURN. ( SATURN IS LORD OF D AND ASPECTS C) MOST POWERFUL FOR MARRIAGE. > AM AT 25.34 AND 81.59e ). 1973 first son born 1974 second son > AGAIN JUPITER AND SATURN ARE POWERFUL FOR CHILD BIRTH. FIRST CONCEPTION IN RAHU SUB AND SECOND IN JUPITER OR SATURN HAVING HIGHEST 19 AND 22 POINTS. > 1974 govt job thru UPSC ,change in 1975 , 82-84 various promotions > IN THE SUB OF RAHU (VENUS LORD OF D) HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. > > 8.MAY 1988 first heart attack in Madras. SATURN SUB MOST POWER FUL BUT ALSO STRONG FOR 3RD AND 6TH. > > 9.1993-97 senior govt position. ACEPT FEW MONTHS OF MARS ALL ARE FAVORABLE. > > 10.SEPT 2000 second heart attack. AGAIN VENUS FOR SATURN > > HE HAS A YOUNGER BROTHER WHO IS PERMANENTLY SETTLED ABROAD FROM MORE > THAN 10 YEARS NOW. > > Query : > > 1.NOW FROM 1998 TO 2001 THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL HINDERANCES IN JOB > PROMOTIONS ETC-ADMN RIVALRY ETC. > THIS IS DUE TO ILL HEALTH, > 2.ILL HEALTH( TO SELF WIFE AND HIS PARENTS( BOTH PARENTS STILL ALIVE) > > SO REGARDING HEALTH AND PROFESSION WHAT EXACTLY IS THE CAUSE? WHAT > CLD BE THE REMEDY? OTHER THAN ADITYA HRIDUYA STROTA FOR SUN. > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES ABOVE? mOON MAIN DASHA WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN SUB INDICATES TO TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN WIFES KUNDALI REDUCE > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO OCT 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE DETAILS, LEFT FOR MEMBERS TO STUDY. iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS CHART, IT WILL GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > ARUN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2002 Report Share Posted April 5, 2002 Dear Krushnaji, What Latitude and Longitude did you take for the place. Arun is not too sure according to this email, what have you taken. Thanks, Ash , " krushanain " <krushanain> wrote: > Dear Arun,and list members, > This is good chart for study. Cast the chart using Krushna's > Ayanansha 22:06:02. Dasha will change. > All the events given are mostly in line with the work sheet. > In this system all the results are indicated by numerical value, of > numerical strength of the planets for each house. If you cast the > worksheet for this chart, it will be easy to study the chart and it's > events. > Other comments are below events in Capital. > > > > pL HAVE A LOOK AT HIS ONE TOO FOR SOME UNEXPLAINABLE EVENTS AND > > ANSWER MY QUERY: > > > > I an sending a chart for study.there have been some unexplainable > > events here. > > > > 1. Male ( ENGINEER.phd EDUCATIONWISE ),born on saturday ,21st > > september 1946,10 am > > > > Place : Lar Village,DEORIA district ,Uttar pradesh india. > SATURN AND MARS IN NAVAMANSHA INDICATES OF HIS BEING ENGINEER > > I think that the latitude and longitude shld be 26.31 N and 83.47 E > > > > ( or shld it be 26.23N and 83.42 E.??) > > > > BALANCE DASHA OF SANI AT BIRTH 6 YR,3 MTHS,13 DAYS,7 HRS. KARKA > > RASHI,PUSHYA NAKSHATRA ,LANGA LORD MANGAL . > tHIS CHANGES WITH THE AYANANSHA. > > > > First some events in the life of the native for tallying sake with > > the analysis: > > > > 1. In 1949-50 ,became suddenly unwell and presumed to be dead by > all > > one day ,revived suddenly.(sounds strange but true!) > THE SATURN FOR THE CHART IS HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. SATURN BEING > LORD OF 3RD HOUSE KARAK FOR DEATH, AND JUPITER IS LORD OF HOUSE D. AT > THIS TIME JUPITER SUB IN SATURN MAIN WAS RUNNING. JUPITER IS HAVING > GOOD POINTS FOR 6TH ALSO, MAY BE THE REASON FOR HIS SERVIVAL. > > > > 2.In 1956-57,almost escaped being drowned in village pond. > sATURN AND VENUS ARE NATURAL SAMDHARMI. ACCIDENT IS INDICATED > FROM 7TH HOUSE, AND SATURN IS LORD OF D, CAN BE SUBSTITUTED BY VENUS. > AT THIS TIME HE WAS HAVING VENUS SUB. SO NO DANGER TO THE LIFE. > > > > 3.In 1963 there was an armed robbery at his hostel,escaped un hurt > > rAHU SUB REPRESENTS vENUS HAVING LESS POINTS FOR 8TH. > > anyways, then > 4. in 1964 got ist class in intermediate and was > > admitted to engg college at a place away from birth. > > IT WAS A GOOD PERIOD > > 5.May 1969 passed engg with distinction. > > vENUS PERIOD WAS GOOS. > > 6.SElected for air force but did not join for family reasons. > > > > 7.1972 may got married( LOVE CUM ARRANGED WIFES BDATE 8TH NOV,1948 > 4 IT IS IN rAHU SUB = VENUS AGAIN REPRESENTS SATURN. ( SATURN IS LORD > OF D AND ASPECTS C) MOST POWERFUL FOR MARRIAGE. > > AM AT 25.34 AND 81.59e ). 1973 first son born 1974 second son > > AGAIN JUPITER AND SATURN ARE POWERFUL FOR CHILD BIRTH. FIRST > CONCEPTION IN RAHU SUB AND SECOND IN JUPITER OR SATURN HAVING HIGHEST > 19 AND 22 POINTS. > > 1974 govt job thru UPSC ,change in 1975 , 82-84 various promotions > > IN THE SUB OF RAHU (VENUS LORD OF D) HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. > > > > 8.MAY 1988 first heart attack in Madras. SATURN SUB MOST POWER FUL > BUT ALSO STRONG FOR 3RD AND 6TH. > > > > > 9.1993-97 senior govt position. ACEPT FEW MONTHS OF MARS ALL ARE > FAVORABLE. > > > > 10.SEPT 2000 second heart attack. AGAIN VENUS FOR SATURN > > > > HE HAS A YOUNGER BROTHER WHO IS PERMANENTLY SETTLED ABROAD FROM > MORE > > THAN 10 YEARS NOW. > > > > Query : > > > > 1.NOW FROM 1998 TO 2001 THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL HINDERANCES IN JOB > > PROMOTIONS ETC-ADMN RIVALRY ETC. > > THIS IS DUE TO ILL HEALTH, > > 2.ILL HEALTH( TO SELF WIFE AND HIS PARENTS( BOTH PARENTS STILL > ALIVE) > > > > SO REGARDING HEALTH AND PROFESSION WHAT EXACTLY IS THE CAUSE? WHAT > > CLD BE THE REMEDY? OTHER THAN ADITYA HRIDUYA STROTA FOR SUN. > > > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES ABOVE? mOON MAIN DASHA > WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN SUB INDICATES TO > TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN WIFES KUNDALI REDUCE > > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO OCT > 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE DETAILS, LEFT FOR MEMBERS > TO STUDY. > iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS CHART, IT WILL > GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > > > ARUN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2002 Report Share Posted April 5, 2002 Dear Ash, 26N23, 83E42 Ayanansha 22:06:02 krushna , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73@h...> wrote: > Dear Krushnaji, > What Latitude and Longitude did you take for the place. Arun is not > too sure according to this email, what have you taken. > Thanks, > Ash > > , " krushanain " <krushanain> > wrote: > > Dear Arun,and list members, > > This is good chart for study. Cast the chart using Krushna's > > Ayanansha 22:06:02. Dasha will change. > > All the events given are mostly in line with the work sheet. > > In this system all the results are indicated by numerical value, > of > > numerical strength of the planets for each house. If you cast the > > worksheet for this chart, it will be easy to study the chart and > it's > > events. > > Other comments are below events in Capital. > > > > > > pL HAVE A LOOK AT HIS ONE TOO FOR SOME UNEXPLAINABLE EVENTS AND > > > ANSWER MY QUERY: > > > > > > I an sending a chart for study.there have been some > unexplainable > > > events here. > > > > > > 1. Male ( ENGINEER.phd EDUCATIONWISE ),born on saturday ,21st > > > september 1946,10 am > > > > > > Place : Lar Village,DEORIA district ,Uttar pradesh india. > > SATURN AND MARS IN NAVAMANSHA INDICATES OF HIS BEING > ENGINEER > > > I think that the latitude and longitude shld be 26.31 N and > 83.47 E > > > > > > ( or shld it be 26.23N and 83.42 E.??) > > > > > > BALANCE DASHA OF SANI AT BIRTH 6 YR,3 MTHS,13 DAYS,7 HRS. KARKA > > > RASHI,PUSHYA NAKSHATRA ,LANGA LORD MANGAL . > > tHIS CHANGES WITH THE AYANANSHA. > > > > > > First some events in the life of the native for tallying sake > with > > > the analysis: > > > > > > 1. In 1949-50 ,became suddenly unwell and presumed to be dead by > > all > > > one day ,revived suddenly.(sounds strange but true!) > > THE SATURN FOR THE CHART IS HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. SATURN BEING > > LORD OF 3RD HOUSE KARAK FOR DEATH, AND JUPITER IS LORD OF HOUSE D. > AT > > THIS TIME JUPITER SUB IN SATURN MAIN WAS RUNNING. JUPITER IS > HAVING > > GOOD POINTS FOR 6TH ALSO, MAY BE THE REASON FOR HIS SERVIVAL. > > > > > > 2.In 1956-57,almost escaped being drowned in village pond. > > sATURN AND VENUS ARE NATURAL SAMDHARMI. ACCIDENT IS INDICATED > > FROM 7TH HOUSE, AND SATURN IS LORD OF D, CAN BE SUBSTITUTED BY > VENUS. > > AT THIS TIME HE WAS HAVING VENUS SUB. SO NO DANGER TO THE LIFE. > > > > > > 3.In 1963 there was an armed robbery at his hostel,escaped un > hurt > > > rAHU SUB REPRESENTS vENUS HAVING LESS POINTS FOR 8TH. > > > anyways, then > > 4. in 1964 got ist class in intermediate and was > > > admitted to engg college at a place away from birth. > > > IT WAS A GOOD PERIOD > > > 5.May 1969 passed engg with distinction. > > > vENUS PERIOD WAS GOOS. > > > 6.SElected for air force but did not join for family reasons. > > > > > > 7.1972 may got married( LOVE CUM ARRANGED WIFES BDATE 8TH > NOV,1948 > > 4 IT IS IN rAHU SUB = VENUS AGAIN REPRESENTS SATURN. ( SATURN IS > LORD > > OF D AND ASPECTS C) MOST POWERFUL FOR MARRIAGE. > > > AM AT 25.34 AND 81.59e ). 1973 first son born 1974 second son > > > AGAIN JUPITER AND SATURN ARE POWERFUL FOR CHILD BIRTH. FIRST > > CONCEPTION IN RAHU SUB AND SECOND IN JUPITER OR SATURN HAVING > HIGHEST > > 19 AND 22 POINTS. > > > 1974 govt job thru UPSC ,change in 1975 , 82-84 various > promotions > > > IN THE SUB OF RAHU (VENUS LORD OF D) HAVING GOOD STRENGTH. > > > > > > 8.MAY 1988 first heart attack in Madras. SATURN SUB MOST POWER > FUL > > BUT ALSO STRONG FOR 3RD AND 6TH. > > > > > > > > 9.1993-97 senior govt position. ACEPT FEW MONTHS OF MARS ALL ARE > > FAVORABLE. > > > > > > 10.SEPT 2000 second heart attack. AGAIN VENUS FOR SATURN > > > > > > HE HAS A YOUNGER BROTHER WHO IS PERMANENTLY SETTLED ABROAD FROM > > MORE > > > THAN 10 YEARS NOW. > > > > > > Query : > > > > > > 1.NOW FROM 1998 TO 2001 THERE HAVE BEEN SEVERAL HINDERANCES IN > JOB > > > PROMOTIONS ETC-ADMN RIVALRY ETC. > > > THIS IS DUE TO ILL HEALTH, > > > 2.ILL HEALTH( TO SELF WIFE AND HIS PARENTS( BOTH PARENTS STILL > > ALIVE) > > > > > > SO REGARDING HEALTH AND PROFESSION WHAT EXACTLY IS THE CAUSE? > WHAT > > > CLD BE THE REMEDY? OTHER THAN ADITYA HRIDUYA STROTA FOR SUN. > > > > > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES ABOVE? mOON MAIN > DASHA > > WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN SUB INDICATES TO > > TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > > > > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN WIFES KUNDALI > REDUCE > > > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO > OCT > > 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE DETAILS, LEFT FOR > MEMBERS > > TO STUDY. > > iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS CHART, IT > WILL > > GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > > > > > ARUN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 5, 2002 Report Share Posted April 5, 2002 Dear Krushnaji and List Members, Here is my Attempt. > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES ABOVE? mOON MAIN DASHA WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN SUB INDICATES TO TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN WIFES KUNDALI REDUCE > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO OCT 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE DETAILS, LEFT FOR MEMBERS TO STUDY. iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS CHART, IT WILL GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA Point 4. : Longetivity. Jupiter Sub is lord of D for the 8th house and hence eager to give results and also the 12th lord for the 3rd House + Jupiter is also in Libra and may act malefic. Jupiter is also Samdharmi to Venus and Mars. Mars' period comes before Jupiter. Mars is also LOE for the 1st house and Mars is Samdharmi to Venus which is LOD for 3rd house hence eager to give life. Is that why you have not taken Mars's sub. Thanks, Cheers !!! Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 6, 2002 Report Share Posted April 6, 2002 Dear Ash, You are perfect in understanding the logic of the system krushna , " ashsam73 " <ashsam73@h...> wrote: > Dear Krushnaji and List Members, > Here is my Attempt. > > > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES ABOVE? mOON MAIN DASHA > WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN SUB INDICATES TO > TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN WIFES KUNDALI REDUCE > > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO OCT > 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE DETAILS, LEFT FOR MEMBERS > TO STUDY. > iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS CHART, IT WILL > GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > > > Point 4. : Longetivity. > > Jupiter Sub is lord of D for the 8th house and hence eager to give > results and also the 12th lord for the 3rd House + Jupiter is also in > Libra and may act malefic. Jupiter is also Samdharmi to Venus and > Mars. Mars' period comes before Jupiter. Mars is also LOE for the > 1st house and Mars is Samdharmi to Venus which is LOD for 3rd house > hence eager to give life. Is that why you have not taken Mars's sub. > > Thanks, > Cheers !!! > Ash Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 8, 2002 Report Share Posted April 8, 2002 hello sir i m mailing u once again pls tyell me is there any site on net to generate the janam patrika thanking u ajay --- krushanain <krushanain wrote: > Dear Ash, > You are perfect in understanding the logic of > the system > krushna > > > > > > , " ashsam73 " > <ashsam73@h...> > wrote: > > Dear Krushnaji and List Members, > > Here is my Attempt. > > > > > > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES > ABOVE? mOON MAIN > DASHA > > WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN > SUB INDICATES TO > > TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > > > > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN > WIFES KUNDALI > REDUCE > > > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN > JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO > OCT > > 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE > DETAILS, LEFT FOR > MEMBERS > > TO STUDY. > > iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS > CHART, IT WILL > > GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > > > > > > > Point 4. : Longetivity. > > > > Jupiter Sub is lord of D for the 8th house and > hence eager to give > > results and also the 12th lord for the 3rd House + > Jupiter is also > in > > Libra and may act malefic. Jupiter is also > Samdharmi to Venus and > > Mars. Mars' period comes before Jupiter. Mars is > also LOE for the > > 1st house and Mars is Samdharmi to Venus which is > LOD for 3rd house > > hence eager to give life. Is that why you have > not taken Mars's > sub. > > > > Thanks, > > Cheers !!! > > Ash > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 8, 2002 Report Share Posted April 8, 2002 Dear Ajay, You can go to any search engine and do a search on Astrology Software. You will get the information. Regarding the Anayamsha used in this system, please refer to the lessons in the file section and details are given there in. Hope that helps. Cheers !!! Ash , ajay dandge <kari4ajay> wrote: > hello sir > i m mailing u once again > pls tyell me is there any site on net to generate the > janam patrika > thanking u > ajay > > --- krushanain <krushanain> wrote: > Dear > Ash, > > You are perfect in understanding the logic of > > the system > > krushna > > > > > > > > > > > > , " ashsam73 " > > <ashsam73@h...> > > wrote: > > > Dear Krushnaji and List Members, > > > Here is my Attempt. > > > > > > > > > > 3.WILL CHANDRA DASHA FROM 2003 SOLVE ISSUES > > ABOVE? mOON MAIN > > DASHA > > > WILL BE MORE TROUBLE SOME, JUPITER SUB AND SATURN > > SUB INDICATES TO > > > TAKE CARE FOR HEALTH. > > > > > > > > 4.WHAT WOULD BE THE LONGETEVITY? DO PLANETS IN > > WIFES KUNDALI > > REDUCE > > > > ILL EFFECTS OF HIS PLANETS?? TAKE CARE IN > > JUPITER SUB JUN 04 TO > > OCT > > > 05.......DELIBERATELY I HAVE NOT GIVEN MORE > > DETAILS, LEFT FOR > > MEMBERS > > > TO STUDY. > > > iF ANY BODY TRY TO TAKE TROUBLE TO STUDY THIS > > CHART, IT WILL > > > GIVE MUCH MORE. .....KRUSHNA > > > > > > > > > > > > Point 4. : Longetivity. > > > > > > Jupiter Sub is lord of D for the 8th house and > > hence eager to give > > > results and also the 12th lord for the 3rd House + > > Jupiter is also > > in > > > Libra and may act malefic. Jupiter is also > > Samdharmi to Venus and > > > Mars. Mars' period comes before Jupiter. Mars is > > also LOE for the > > > 1st house and Mars is Samdharmi to Venus which is > > LOD for 3rd house > > > hence eager to give life. Is that why you have > > not taken Mars's > > sub. > > > > > > Thanks, > > > Cheers !!! > > > Ash > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 8, 2007 Report Share Posted January 8, 2007 Does God Value Free Will? A common Christian argument in defense of the existence of evil in the world revolves around free will: God values our free will so much that even the existence of evil caused by free will is better than an absence of evil and an absence of free will. But just how much could such a god value free will anyway? Horia George Plugaru writes for Talk Reason that there is a reason to think that perhaps free will wouldn't have as much value to God as believers assume: Human beings are so conceived that their proper functioning requires the daily abandon of FW [free will]. I am talking about the sleep period. Usually we sleep at least 5 hours per day (some doctors say the ideal sleep period is 7-8 hours per day). This means that a person who lives say, 50 years, sleeps during his life at least 90,000 hours. ... And so the question arises: if God values our FW so very much, why did he create us in such a way that for an important period of our lives we are forced to abandon our FW? In other words, if FW is so important from God's point of view, then why didn't he create us so that we would use our FW non-stop during our lives? At first one might think that this is a rather trivial and childish argument, but I'm not so sure. Plugaru's general argument is that if anything is so valuable that it justifies the existence of extreme evil like the Holocaust, it seems implausible that there should be a reason to abandon it for significant portions of our lives. There is, I think, some merit to that. Apologists have to place a great deal of value on free will in order to make their case, but it seems quite indispensable. There is another point which Plugaru doesn't mention but helps his case. Sleep is needed for good health; therefore, temporary abandonment of free will is necessary and acceptable for the maintenance of good health. If that is the case, why not allow for the suspension free will to protect the health of others? If our bodies shut down and go to sleep against our will in order to keep us functioning right, why doesn't our free will shut down against our will to prevent us from harming others? It's an interesting question. Read More: a.. Religion 101 b.. Theism 101 c.. Does God Exist? Wednesday June 23, 2004 | comments (0) Email to a Friend | Digg this story Display Latest Headlines | | | Read Archives powered by WordPress Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.