Paulo's kind offer to do chinese and maybe western as well ...

[Guest guest]

Paulo,

 

Sorry I missed this kind offer from you.

 

I have a better proposition for you. Since no astrological system can

ever be proven entirely through one successful reading (I am sure

being a rational astrologer you would accept that as true!) because

things such as intuition, Barnum Effect and so on play a role as you

must know already: How about you do this while helping all the

reading posters on this forum? Reading requests get posted by the

dozen here and if you look through the archives you may find quite a

few unanswered ones. By doing this, on the one hand you will be

establishing the usefulness of non-jyotish astrological systems and

hopefully also be helping some of the reading seekers who are looking

for guidance.

 

Crossposting those readings on other forums as you are eager to -- is

your personal decision and between you and moderators on the forums.

 

Win-win situation? Even you have to agree!

 

RR

 

 

, "paulo mendes"

<woodwater1000 wrote:

>

> ok send me your birthdata and ill do a chinese reading and maybe

western as well.Iposted the same in other lists hoping that someone

will get the right answers to the test. I want to prove that

astrology works.It is better for all us astrologers, otherwise people

will keep on looking at us sideways at least in the west

>

> Cheers

> Paulo

> -

> Rohiniranjan

>

> Sunday, October 22, 2006 11:17 PM

> CROSSPOSTING -- Re: tests

>

>

> Paulo,

>

> You may be doing this innocently but if I understand correctly,

cross-

> posting is not very welcome on this forum. Particularly as in the

> case of this message, in which I responded to your half-cocked

> message on vedic astrology which you then cross-posted here as

well!

>

> I am sure there must be similar intolerance to cross-posting on

vedic

> astrology forum, so please do this cautiously. I am responding to

> your messages only because I do believe that though you are going

> through the uncertain-sceptic-questioning phase that all new

> astrologers go (at least the non-religious types) and so you are

> testing the waters, but your technique to do so may raise some

doubts

> and concerns. Unless you can first raise the level of trust in

your

> seriousness and sincerity, you will not be very successful in

getting

> a response that will help you develop your trust. Perhaps

something

> similar happened with the western astrologers you tested earlier.

>

> I would have much preferred that you could have spent some time

in

> demonstrating that you have studied western and chinese astrology

> seriously and sincerely. You would have convinced me of that if

> instead of making claims about tropical zodiac being superior and

> giving no adequate basis for your claims -- you switch gears and

> throw your quiz at two jyotish forums and that too kind of

hastily

> leading to multiple postings that are confusing the issue. Maybe

you

> do want to confuse the issue or maybe you just have to improve

your

> internet messaging skills.

>

> Either way, you should demonstrate your sincerity or else you

will

> just be considered by serious astrologers as a sceptic who is

> dangling between two faiths, yet another fence sitter!

>

> Don't take this too personally as I realize you may be new to

> internet and have not quite figured this posting a message thing.

> Like I said, communication and counselling are two training

modules

> that I would recommend to you for a future in astrological

> counselling!

>

> Take care. Have you ever tried some of the Goanese dishes that

blend

> the Portugese and Indian cuisine. Do you know of the linked

karmic

> history of your forefathers and their association with India and

> Indians?

>

> RR

>

> , "paulo mendes"

> <woodwater1000@> wrote:

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > all the people in the tests are males

> >

> > paulo

> > -

> > Rohiniranjan

> > vedic astrology

> > Sunday, October 22, 2006 7:30 PM

> > [vedic astrology] Re: Fw: tests

> >

> >

> > What is the first test, Paulo?

> > Figuring out what the quiz is through horary astrology? ;-)

> >

> > RR

> >

> > vedic astrology, "paulo mendes"

> > <woodwater1000@> wrote:

> > >

> > > hi folks

> > > hers a scientific test for astrologers. You have to match the

> dates

> > given with the attributes given in tables 3a and 3b.western

> > astrologers failed so far.

> > >

> > > Read this article carefully, because it is about a MASTER

> > astrologer!

> > > So far I have not found any astrologer who could match his

> > qualities.

> > >

> > > TEST 2 is the one you should accomplish.

> > >

> > >

> > > l

> > >

> > >

> > >