Guest guest Posted July 21, 2006 Report Share Posted July 21, 2006 Dear Kumarji, You say "Real reasons still lie elsewhere." and your purpose of writing this mail is to save people from being misguided"... If that so, why wouldn't you guide people with the real reason or the correct analysis in this case. Blessings Renu vedic astrology, "P.Kumar" <pkumar24 wrote: > > Dear Vinay, > I would like to comment. Hitting correct prediction and giving correct analysis are two different things. You said that 'his logic and explanation are most correct'. I beg to differ. I don't think him right here. For instance, he has taken 4th house for education. Shri K.N.Rao and many others take 5th house. Then, in my opinion, he had exaggerated the role of the Sun and Mercury. Real reasons still lie elsewhere. I didn't cast the horoscope till you posted the answer as I feel some conditions and prequalifications necessary for posing such queries. > > Purpose of writing this mail is to save people from being misguided. Giving correct predictions is the most difficult task. An instance or two of correct predictions is not a proof of correct analysis. Then here your question was objective type (multiple options given) where even a stranger could hit to the correct choice. Therefore, be careful to accept a reasoning as correct unless a person gives consistently good predictions. > > P.Kumar > > > > - > "Vinay Kumar" <vinay69 > <KNRaoJyotish>; <>; <vedic astrology> > Wednesday, July 19, 2006 11:37 PM > Anwer to Question 2 > > > Dear All,. > Here is the answer to my Question 2 – Quiz! > > The correct answer to my quiz is Option 2 which was: > > "Had a brilliant academic performance. Was a topper all along, in > school, graduation, and post graduation. Stood 1st for the state > twice. Has to her credit 200 proficiency certificates for various > extracurricular activities apart from her outstanding formal > education" > > - Had brilliant schooling (always 1st or 2nd) > - The native stood 1st for the state in 10th STD. > - Stood 1st at the university at the pre-university level (Arts stream) . > - First in graduation. (Bachelor of Arts) > - First in PG (MA, M.Phil, JNU) > - Has several proficiency certificates for debates, elocutions, NCC > (president' sliver medal winner), drama's, compeering, extempores etc. > Was extremely popular in school. > > Congrats to Sreeram Sreenivas. His logic & explanation was the most > correct. Quite a lot to learn from his nice analysis. I thought his > analysis was nearly perfect. As usual very few people took a shot at > the quiz. There were hardly 6-7 responses. I wonder where all the > talented jyotishis of these groups have gone!? Most of them got it > wrong. Just one more person got it correct using KN Rao's conditional > Chara dasha. (I forget his name and am not able to trace his mail, > think his name was White) > > The most important reason for her brilliant academic career was the > vargottama debilitated Guru who lords the dusthanas 3rd and 6th. It is > placed in the 4th house of education. Guru by itself is excellent > here. Sreeram's analysis of combustion is perfect. Combustion always > increases the inner qualities (the intangibles) in this case > education. Combustion harms the houses the combust planet owns. > Mercury the 9th lord getting combust has to add to the good education. > > To Sreeram's excellent analysis I will add a couple of more points > that he probably missed: > 1. Jupiter participates in a powerful Gajakesri Yoga. Moon lords the > powerful 10th house of public reputation and sit sin the lagna. > 2. In Navamsha Guru is debilitated in the 8th house (highly > favourable) and aspects the 4th house of education. > 3. Saturns's aspect on it's own 5th house and 4th house (retrograde so > one previous) is good for education. In Sani dash her brilliant spell > had to continue. > > > Regards, > Vinay Kumar > > Posted by: "sreeram srinivas" sreeram64 Sre_eram > Wed Jul 19, 2006 12:06 am (PST) > > I would opt for the option - TWO. > > 2. Had a brilliant academic performance. Was a topper all along, in > school, graduation, and post graduation. Stood 1st for the state > twice. Has to her credit 200 proficiency certificates for various > extracurricular activities apart from her outstanding formal > education. > > Analysis: > The Mahadasha Lord is Jupiter upto 21 Aug. 1973 - Aug. 1989. Jupiter is > 3HL & 6HL and is debilitated and is also vargottam. ( Note Jupiter position > in > D-9 ). Debilitated planets of Upchaya Houses give excellent results in > their mahadasha. This Jupiter is conjunct with 11HL Sun & 9HL & 12HL > Mercury(Combust). Combust Mercury adds the required "fire" to the > debilitated Jupiter catapults the qualities of Jupiter. Jupiter is wisdom, > Mercury is intelligence. The father of all fires.....11HL Sun conjunct to > "already burning planets "!!!! Sun is in short is giving its "lustre and > sheen" in 4H of education. > > Adding to above the 4HL & 5HL Saturn is retrograde and having come out > debilitation. This retrograde Saturn is in the house of Venus i.e. > Taurus....supposed to give excellent results for the dispositor of Saturn is > in 3H i.e. 8HL is in 8H from itself !!! That too in Jupiter Sign !!! This > Venus is conjunct with Rahu both in Jupiter sign and that too in 3H. House > of communication and exceptional courage..... Venus gives the native to > delve deep into research topics or ability to probe.......It is a sure shot > for exceptional educational career !!! > > Further, Sun is exalted in D-9 alongwith Ketu & Mercury !!! Three strong > benefics in kendra to 4H.....hence, got to be good.. > > Jupiter is in Nakshatra of Uttarshada whose Lord is Sun !!! ( upachaya house > lord + upachaya house ) > Sun is in Nakshatra of Shravana whose Lord is Moon !! ( royal planet > combination -sanyog...) > Mercury is in nakshatra of Shravana whose Lord is Moon ! ( mercury in moon > lordship gives good results ) > Venus is in the nakshatra of Poorva Ashada whose Lord is Venus!! ( own self > !! ) > Rahu is in nakshatra of Poorva Ashada whose Lord is Venus ( Rahu - Student > is in the mind control of Venus - Guru ) !!! > > With so many things confirmed and so apparent...... I would once again > reaffirm my belief on Option -TWO of the total four choices given in the > original mail of Mr. Vinay Kumar posted in Vedic-astrology forum & Jyotish > Group & KNRao Jyotish Groups.......all at .com > > with regards, > sreeram srinivas > sreeram64 > Cell : 98682-31817 > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.