Anwer to Question 2 - Attn: P. Kumar

[Guest guest]

Kumar-ji,

If you see my quiz I had said in the beginning that "I can assure

members that the time of birth is correct". See my quiz. No one can

assure TOB correctness to the exact minute or the second. First let us

learn to do basic analysis of a chart based on Rashi and Navamsha. You

talk of "basics" in chart interpretation and you also talk of TOB

sensitive things like Shastyamsha. You are contradicting.

I do know that Shastyamsha changes every 2 minutes. It is precisely

the reason you should refrain from using Shastyamsha. Add to this the

different ayanamsha's that astrologers use; Shastyamsha lagna can

change by 3 signs depending on the ayanamsha. Use Raman ayanamsha and

see what happens to most divisional charts. Unless you have 30 years

of hardcore astrology experience I suggest you don't even think of

shastaymasha.

 

Well if you have another version to the analysis of the quiz why don't

you come up with your version? Use any dasha or any technique. I am

willing to learn. I suggest you have an open mind to member's views

and give due credit where it is deserved. You can't be narrow minded

in complimenting some one.

 

BTW to post a quiz doesn't require one to have the kind of depth of

the subject that you are talking of. I know that I know little of the

vast ocean of Jyotish but will not stop praising & learning from

someone who knows more at every turn.

 

Regards,

Vinay Kumar

 

 

Now see the conditions and pre-qualifications I had referred to:

1) Before posing such queries, correctness of a chart must be assured

or helpful hints must be provided for rectification. That is why I

always ask for 'source of TOB' and 'margin of error possible'. From

Rasi to Shashtyamsha every chart has its own importance. Shashtyamsha

changes every 2 minutes. Thus, need of rectification can never be

undermined.

2) The person posing such queries and commenting on responses received

must be a good astrologer himself. Only then a person can appreciates

the depth of astrology and will never comment on an analysis the way

you had commented on the one given by Sreenivas. I consider it quite

misguiding and hence most irresponsible.

 

Most persons deviate from basics and start justifying the events on

any given chart as though giving astrological prediction is a child's

play. One should always stick to basics, follow undisputed classical

dictums and apply sound common sense. I always try to stick to basics

illustration of which can be seen in my article on the website of

respected Shri K.N.Rao at the link given below: