Anwer to Question 2 - Mr. Satish

[Guest guest]

Namaste Satish,

While I buy Sreeram's analysis of combustion which is quite correct

even I had not seen the chart as mentioned in your point 2 which was:

 

"Adding to above the 4HL & 5HL Saturn is retrograde and having come

out debilitation. This retrograde Saturn is in the house of Venus i.e.

Taurus....supposed to give excellent results for the dispositor of

Saturn is in 3H i.e. 8HL is in 8H from itself !!! That too in

Jupiter Sign !!! This Venus is conjunct with Rahu both in Jupiter sign and

that too in 3H. -------This point I have no idea what Venus the

dispositor of 4th lord in 8th from shani..etc means"

 

Point 3 also might seem a little far fetched (Rahu in the Nakshatra of

Poorvashada….) but upon thinking there is some truth in it.

 

It would be nice if Sreeram explained this point in detail. May be it

is a concept that we all need to learn. In fact this is the object of

a quiz so that we learn how members look at the same thing

differently.

 

Regards,

Vinay

 

Re: Anwer to Question 2

Posted by: "SPK" aquaris_rising aquaris_rising

Thu Jul 20, 2006 1:22 pm (PST)

Hello P. Kumar,

 

Except for the 3rd and 6th lord debilited in 4th house

(Guru also having bad lordship). This exception was

missed by myself.

 

Reading the analysis in detail, I find it to be not

rooted in basics. One has to give credit for correct

answer, however rest of the analysis is very difficult

to digest.

 

I give you a few instances from the analysis

 

1)----

Combust Mercury adds the required

> "fire" to the

> debilitated Jupiter catapults the qualities of

> Jupiter. Jupiter is wisdom,

> Mercury is intelligence. The father of all

> fires.....11HL Sun conjunct to

> "already burning planets "!!!! Sun is in short is

> giving its "lustre and

> sheen" in 4H of education.

-----

 

This needs a lot of explaining.

 

2)---------

Adding to above the 4HL & 5HL Saturn is retrograde

> and having come out

> debilitation. This retrograde Saturn is in the house

> of Venus i.e.

> Taurus....supposed to give excellent results for the

> dispositor of Saturn is

> in 3H i.e. 8HL is in 8H from itself !!! That too in

> Jupiter Sign !!! This

> Venus is conjunct with Rahu both in Jupiter sign and

> that too in 3H.

-----------------

 

This point I have not idea what venus the dispositor

of 4th lord in 8th from shani..etc means

 

3)-------

Rahu is in nakshatra of Poorva Ashada whose Lord is

> Venus (Rahu -Student

> is in the mind control of Venus - Guru ) !!!

-----

Can anyone explain this statement to me.

 

Overall except for the first point made about 3rd and

6th lord debilited rest of the analysis needs a lot of

explaining.

 

Again congratulation for the right answer, however

just because the answer was correct does not imply all

the analysis is great.

 

Satish