Guest guest Posted June 19, 2006 Report Share Posted June 19, 2006 Dear All, Suppose some AD(ketu-venus/mars-venus) is running under a mahadasha.. If the result for AD is bad ,do we see bad results in case of complete corresponding MD too (here venus) .. We see MD from Sun,AD from Moon and PD from Lagna,if I am correct!! Regards, Amit Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 20, 2006 Report Share Posted June 20, 2006 WHAT?? Vimshottari? I see it from lagna though the seed comes from moon. I do see it with Mahadasha treated as lagna. Even doing that gives me a big headache (low I.Q, to blame :-( If I followed your system, I would have given up astrology long ago -- thank God I did not meet you back then! RR , "ak_131" <agrawal.amitk wrote: > > Dear All, > Suppose some AD(ketu-venus/mars-venus) is running under a > mahadasha.. If the result for AD is bad ,do we see bad results in case > of complete corresponding MD too (here venus) .. > We see MD from Sun,AD from Moon and PD from Lagna,if I am correct!! > Regards, > Amit > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 20, 2006 Report Share Posted June 20, 2006 Dear Shri Rohini ji, Your mails are difficult to understand !! Anyway, the main reason to ask AD/MD relation was to see" is there any relation between the results of AD/MD or AD/AD, suppose somebody had a bad Mercury-Mars dasha ,will he be having bad Ketu-mars and bad Venus-Mars too .. Same way ,about the MD ,if somebody had a bad Ketu-Mars, will Mars MD be good for him too. Best wishes and Regards Amit , "crystal pages" <jyotish_vani wrote: > > WHAT?? > > Vimshottari? I see it from lagna though the seed comes from moon. I do > see it with Mahadasha treated as lagna. Even doing that gives me a big > headache (low I.Q, to blame :-( > > If I followed your system, I would have given up astrology long ago -- > thank God I did not meet you back then! > > RR > > > , "ak_131" <agrawal.amitk@> > wrote: > > > > Dear All, > > Suppose some AD(ketu-venus/mars-venus) is running under a > > mahadasha.. If the result for AD is bad ,do we see bad results in case > > of complete corresponding MD too (here venus) .. > > We see MD from Sun,AD from Moon and PD from Lagna,if I am > correct!! > > Regards, > > Amit > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted June 20, 2006 Report Share Posted June 20, 2006 Dear Shri Amit ji, I thought what I was saying was that the suggestion you wrote about, namely considering the different periods, subperiods from different orientations (one from sun another with moon the third with lagna) could really make matters so complex that it would be nearly impossible for most individuals like me to understand and apply. What I wrote was far less complex than the scheme provided. Please understand I am not criticizing you or your technique, which may have worked perfectly in your experience for all I know. It is in the same category if someone comes and tells me a very unusual value for ayanamsha is the true one or even more fantastic was what I had seen some jyotishis do some 30 years ago. They would use a certain ayanamsha but tweak around the chandra to get dashas to line up. Moon became a moving duck and they kept applying further corrections to the moon without touching other planets. All of these fantastic techniques make me go in panic mode as I say to myself: Thank God astrology is not based on such complex and volatile systems! If it were, where would simpletons like me go? Now mind you, sudarshan chakra has its very valid uses but the principle of sun, moon and lagna being the centre of attention or orientation should not be carried too far. Unless, of course, someone is willing to show how these somewhat out of the ordinary methods work. I can't even quote the page and verse but I have read about the method I was talking about, where the dasha lagna is considered to be the sign where mahadayesh is placed and then seeing the next level ruler from there. But it is one layer in the collage of jyotish reading and not the only one. And it does not work all the time. I can anecdotally say that I looked for such 'exchanges' MD-AD becomes AD-MD in another phase of life and see some common threads, but it did not really jump out enough to continue that pursuit. But it is a reasonable consideration. There is another recommendation I have heard over the years and that is that the third level (anthara or pratyantara in S and N Indian labels) period planet's transit influence becomes significant. I did not really dig into it but the few times I tried it did not bring me significantly closer to the event. What I have seen though and this was the first breakthrough in my understanding was the scheme given by KP. The source, nature aspect. I did not find too frequent positive indications based on the nakshatra sub indicating success or failure. But that could be ayanamsha even though I have tried a few different ones. Like I said, this is all anecdotal but that is all I can share at this moment. Take it or leave it, as kids these days say! RR , "ak_131" <agrawal.amitk wrote: > > Dear Shri Rohini ji, > Your mails are difficult to understand !! Anyway, the main reason > to ask AD/MD relation was to see" is there any relation between the > results of AD/MD or AD/AD, suppose somebody had a bad Mercury-Mars > dasha ,will he be having bad Ketu-mars and bad Venus-Mars too .. > Same way ,about the MD ,if somebody had a bad Ketu-Mars, will Mars > MD be good for him too. > Best wishes and Regards > Amit > > > , "crystal pages" > <jyotish_vani@> wrote: > > > > WHAT?? > > > > Vimshottari? I see it from lagna though the seed comes from moon. I do > > see it with Mahadasha treated as lagna. Even doing that gives me a big > > headache (low I.Q, to blame :-( > > > > If I followed your system, I would have given up astrology long ago -- > > thank God I did not meet you back then! > > > > RR > > > > > > , "ak_131" <agrawal.amitk@> > > wrote: > > > > > > Dear All, > > > Suppose some AD(ketu-venus/mars-venus) is running under a > > > mahadasha.. If the result for AD is bad ,do we see bad results in case > > > of complete corresponding MD too (here venus) .. > > > We see MD from Sun,AD from Moon and PD from Lagna,if I am > > correct!! > > > Regards, > > > Amit > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.