Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

before Lahiri which one? 2/6 p2

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Yes Prafulla, that kind of calculation takes the parallax error into

consideration. It is most significant for moon (closest body) and

lesser for other planets. Depending on the angular position of the

moon (rising, setting, medium coeli or nadir) the PE can be as high

as more than a degree amounting to a difference of upto a couple of

years if the moon is in the star of one of the longer duration

planets (venus, shani etc).

 

RR

 

, Prafulla Gang <jyotish>

wrote:

>

> Dear members

>

> there is another variation in ayanamsa - calculating geocentric

(taking from the center of earth...can someone find the center of a

ball) or topocentric (taking from the place of birth). In my

interactions with few local panchang writers, I observed the use of

topocentric calculations. Perhaps, that is one of the major

difference in different local panchangs.

>

> regards / Prafulla Gang

>

> No person was ever honored for what he received.

> Honor has been the reward for what he gave.

>

>

> >

> > gbp_kumar

> > Sat, 3 Jun 2006 01:00:21 -0700 (PDT)

> >

> > Re: Re: before Lahiri which one? 2/6 p2

> >

> > RR Ji,

> >    I have also said close to waht u said on the major

contributionf oh

> > Lahiri is the standardisation at least fo Hindu calander unlike

Islam,  i

> > sno mean achievemtn esp with the odds he was up against. esp th 

snakes

> > panchangams

> >    and now all we hat to do is work on the BASE LINE which is

Lahiris

> > +/-  xx ded xx mi  sssec say raman 1 Deg 26 min 26 sec.

Krishnnamurthy  0

> > deg 0 min 7' les to Lahiri.

> >    And is also nice that you did find some matter to look at and

> > appriciate as well apart from content the analagy, this spirit I

also

> > felt was needed when we did discuss Guru, becasue we do wrtie

with a  few

> > points, medtods, quotes and do expect them also to be commented 

good or

> > bad no problem and any suppliments or deletins we will like to 

be

> > correced as we are always learning. weleanr till we pass out of

this

> > world.

> >    And I always believe the traditions laid before us are

elastic and

> > not  plastic, to accept any modifications of the rules with the

times it

> > is  applied without over ruling or destroying the original

spirit of the

> > subject,

> >  crystal pages <rrgb> wrote:        Dear Satish ji,

> >    Though Sri Nirmal Chandra Lahiri is noted for his ayanamsha

(which he

> >    never called his own but simply pinned it to the star Chitra

or

> >    Spica -- hence properly named as Chitra navamsha. Similar

> >    misnomenclature also exists for the so called Yukteshwar

ayanamsha.

> >    Even more so, since unlike Lahiri, Yukteshwar Giri ji Maharaj

did not

> >    calculate or establish that ayanamsha but merely stated that

it was

> >    according to astronomical books -- possibly prevailing

panchangs

> >    followed by him). All this has been written with more

interesting

> >    similarities between it and Raman ayanamsha in earlier posts,

etc.

> >    Anyway, much more important than the ayanamsha he gave us,

Lahiri's

> >    primary contribution to the field of jyotish related

astronomy is the

> >    bringing out of accurate epehmeris/panchangs which were based

on

> >    mathematical calculations with modern terms and corrections

given by

> >    astrophysics. With Lahiri's ephemeris starting in 30s or

thereabouts

> >    the wild variabilities that characterized all but a few rare

> >    panchaangs became a thing of past and more importantly,

others were

> >    forced to follow suit and fine-tune their 'act'. Publishing

just

> >    anything and calling it a panchanng or panjika would not do,

any

> >    more!

> >    That, to me is the major contribution of Lahiri.

> >    Kumarji gave a beautiful analogy, or different ayanamshas

being like

> >    vision-correcting glasses. Mine would not work for you, yours

would

> >    not work for me! My own that worked ten years do not work for

me

> >    anymore <LOL>

> >    RR

> >    , "R Satish"

<rsatish1942@>

> >    wrote:

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >  Dear Friends,

> >    >

> >    >   Mentioning about Lahiri's Ayanamsa,remimded about my

experience

> >    > with a hard core Vedic scholar,from a place called

Kotipalli,on the

> >    > banks of Godavari in East Godavari Dt.

> >    >

> >    >   This Brahmin,80 +yrs runs  a Vedic Patshala which

trains Hindu

> >    > Priests for performimg various poojas etcand is residential

school.

> >    >

> >    >   When the subject of Ayanamsa came up,I had mentioned to

him about

> >    > the pabnchang difference between a Kakinada panchang and

Lahiri's

> >    > ayanamsa. He emphatically stated that Lahiri succumbed to

the then

> >    > govt's pressure manipulating the ephemeris.He stated there

is a

> >    > difference of" one pada",between the local panchang.Hence a

> >    > differneceof nearly 6-8 month's is not uncommon..I  had

gone to him

> >    > to  discuss my son's horoscope,about 3/4 yrs ago.Even in

my case,

> >    > there is a diffence of exactly one year in the balance of

Chandra

> >    > dasa,I have not been to reconcile this difference.

> >    >

> >    >  As stated by you stalwarts,finally it boils down to one's

> >    experience.

> >    > Fnaticism does not serve much purpose to the cause of

astrology.

> >    >

> >    >   This is one of my several experiemces with the'

stalwarts' .

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >  Regards,

> >    >

> >    >   Satish

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    >

> >    > , Prashant Kumar G B

> >    > <gbp_kumar@> wrote:

> >    > >

> >    > > Dear Pandit Arjun ji,

> >    > >

> >    > >   I have also shared some of these inputs directly and

indirectly

> >    > with  many in person and in the groups like  these the

most

> >    > remarkable  one being of ICAS founder Secy sri Late K.

Ashwattappa,

> >    > who had  contemopt for Raman like all others here as it was

> >    > fashionable to do so  by ciritising any pouplar person, 

and so for

> >    > his ayanamsa MOST OF  HIS critics do not even know the

difference

> >    > between Lahiri and Raman's  in terms of deg- min- sec and

MAJORITY

> >    > HAVE NEVER TESTED IT either,  just prejueice, jealous of

him.

> >    > >

> >    > >   But my association with him for over 15 yrs he felt

he must try

> >    > it and  did test them randomly and fouind in many cases

Rahu Dasa

> >    or

> >    > Ketu Dasa  at the end giving Good results than their

earlier part

> >    > once he shifted  the ayanamsa found it is Guru, or Sukra

periods

> >    that

> >    > gave the right  results as Subha phala need not wait til

then end

> >    of

> >    > the dasa to  deliver. eve Ketu or Rahu if well place can

give at

> >    > start not in tail  end. THIS I HAVE THE BENIFIT OF MNEXT

GURU S

> >    > SUBBANNA, AWHO GOT IT FROM  HIS GURU they are Mysore

Maharaja's

> >    > asthana Jyotishis for generations.

> >    > >

> >    > >   SO ANYONE WITH AN OPEN MID IF THEY TYR IT CAN GET

GOOD RESULTS

> >    it

> >    > is  open to them no vested interests, except that we want

the

> >    subject

> >    > to  have its good tols an dusers benifit if they try, it is

> >    possible

> >    > they  can stillg et good results in this or anyother left

to ones

> >    > intution,  instincts, knowledge, in RAMAN' success we know

we ar

> >    > einthe right  track so lets move along, and he hsued the

> >    traditional

> >    > ones which even  westerners beofe his birth have

acknowledged as

> >    the

> >    > genius of INDIAN  TRADITION's (Vedic)  RICHNESS.

> >    > >

> >    > >

> >    > > panditarjun2004 <panditarjun2004@> wrote:       

dear prashant ji

> >    > >

> >    > >   is is so nice of you to share your astro knolwedge

from your

> >    > three

> >    > >   decades of experience and since you are one of the

founding

> >    > members

> >    > >   of ICAS, your inputs are always lessons for amateurs.

> >    > >

> >    > >   earlier i was using lahiri for the past several years

and

> >    > sometimes

> >    > >   i did not get them right inlcuidng my own.  however,

after your

> >    > >   advise, i started using raman's ayanamsha and am

getting the

> >    > charts,

> >    > >   especially dasa periods, more accurately. 

unfortunately, these

> >    > >   ayanamashas can make or break a chart.

> >    > >

> >    > >   with best wishes

> >    > >   pandit arjun

> >    > >

> >    > >   , Prashant

Kumar G B

> >    > >   <gbp_kumar@> wrote:

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   > Hi Tarun

> >    > >   >   I had replied to you, there were 33 Ayanansa's

in vouge

> >    prior

> >    > to

> >    > >   Lahiri  stepping in and pushing his own, this is

like a judge

> >    who

> >    > >   could not  undersand the case but yet gave a verdit.

HIS OWN.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   the reason is numerous claims and counter

claims to deal

> >    with

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   esp in Tamil Nadu then Madras Province it more

a tamil

> >    > centric

> >    > >   problem  there are quite a few thoughts based on

their EQ [ego

> >    > >   quotient]

> >    > >   >   where most of them are based on hapazard Vakya

panchang no

> >    > >   corrections  took place ever and if a mistake was

made by one

> >    in

> >    > the

> >    > >   family chain it  continued as it was a brand name so

no way you

> >    > can

> >    > >   dispute it.   there was Madurai, Kanchipuram,

Srirangam,

> >    Tenkasi

> >    > >   etc groups  each had a different Panbu panchangam

[or snake

> >    > >   calander] quite  different from others. and say 

could not

> >    agree

> >    > >   comming from one  state where will the reminder in

India agree?

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   Even the tamils themselves had Gochara of Major

planets at

> >    > >   different  months variation, eclipses and all others

in chaos.

> >    no

> >    > >   scientific  basis. Lahiri brought in the Drik or

verifiable one

> >    > >   which is caliculated on established astronomical

principles at

> >    > least.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   about TAMIL EGO QUOTENT if I follow the lead of

RR here on

> >    > >   storry telling these are true ones though

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   DURIGN THE BRITISH RAJ DAYS THE SUPREME COURT

WAS IN LONDON

> >    > or

> >    > >   Privay  Council as it was called. dealt with a case

of Iyangars

> >    a

> >    > >   group of  Brahmins of the Vishnavas there are 2

groups in them

> >    > >   Vadagalai  [Northern] and Thengalai [southern]  in

a temple

> >    > function

> >    > >   there  was a dispute how to Mark the temple

elephant's

> >    forehaead

> >    > >   with a Y or U  shaped  Mark of the Vaishnava mark

> >    > >   >   [Vadagalis Mark it as U and Tehengalais s Y

with a middle

> >    > line

> >    > >   in red]

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   they had enough street brawls as Tamils do and

finally went

> >    > to

> >    > >   the PC  [prviy council]. so that being the case you

can never

> >    say

> >    > >   Lahiri had a  easy job at least he standadrised our

calander

> >    but

> >    > >   Islam is free  in  India each state Imam can see

the same

> >    Moon's

> >    > >   crecent on a  different days and have a different

holiday the

> >    > state

> >    > >   and Central govt  has. all laws are fo Hindus only.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   BTW the Tamil EQ's latest M karunadhi and

former CM. Ms

> >    JJ,

> >    > >   are  meeting in the assembly after 17 yrs normally

the other

> >    one

> >    > >   resigns if  they loose and don't face each other

directly.

> >    their

> >    > mud

> >    > >   slinging is of  unique depths.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   > ~~Tarun~~ <tarun_vst@> wrote:        Dear RR

ji,

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   yes Shri Nirmal Chandra Lahiri ji lived in

calcutta but

> >    since

> >    > >   varanasi was key centre for

> >    > >   >   astrology so the calculations were observed and

studied as

> >    > par

> >    > >   Varanasi.(as wht i know)

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   Actually sometimes a question arises that what

panchang was

> >    > used

> >    > >   before lahiri placed his

> >    > >   >   ayanamasa, what was the base of calculations

used while

> >    > making

> >    > >   chart in ancient times.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   i think this question is still unanswered.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   Thanks and Regards

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   Tarun

> >    > >   >   www.thevinayak.com

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   --- crystal pages <rrgb@> wrote:

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   > I think Nirmal Chandra Lahiri ji lived in

Calcutta and

> >    not

> >    > >   Varanasi!

> >    > >   >   >

> >    > >   >   > Not that it makes that big a difference

longitudinally or

> >    > >   >   > latitudinally but could mean several hours of

journey, if

> >    I

> >    > >   remember

> >    > >   >   > correctly between Baba Vishwanath or

Sankatmochan or

> >    Birla

> >    > >   temple and

> >    > >   >   > oh say Dakshineshwar or Kalibari! ;-)

> >    > >   >   >

> >    > >   >   > RR

> >    > >   >   >

> >    > >   >   > ,

~~Tarun~~

> >    > >   <tarun_vst@>

> >    > >   >   > wrote:

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > Dear RR ji,

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > no problem at all. you are very senior to

me.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > sir even in my chart i have the same prob..

if i use

> >    > raman

> >    > >   ayanamsa

> >    > >   >   > my dasha changes by 18 months.

> >    > >   >   > > the rahu placement in my chart also changes.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > actually raman livd in south india and his

location was

> >    > much

> >    > >   near

> >    > >   >   > to equator in comparison to

> >    > >   >   > > Kashi viswanath (base frm where Lahiri gave

his

> >    > >   calculations) so

> >    > >   >   > the diff is easily expected.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > my dob 19-07-1983

> >    > >   >   > > time:- 10.35 am

> >    > >   >   > > place:- Jodhpur Rajasthan

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > sir one shows mars rahu combination in 10th

and one

> >    shows

> >    > >   rahu in

> >    > >   >   > 9th .

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > i was always confused abt whom to follow.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > but if we consider mean node then too my

chart changes

> >    > and

> >    > >   if i

> >    > >   >   > consider true node then too my

> >    > >   >   > > chart changes.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > but as far as for Miss astro.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > i wil say venus ketu combination is not

> >    matching .because

> >    > >   venus and

> >    > >   >   > ketu dont give much better

> >    > >   >   > > results as she is descibing.

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > thanks and regards

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > tarun

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > --- crystal pages <rrgb@> wrote:

> >    > >   >   > >

> >    > >   >   > > > Tarun ji,

> >    > >   >   > > > <my apologies for mistyping your name as

Varun last

> >    > time!>

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > This is a very interesting situation

indeed, because

> >    > ketu

> >    > >   and

> >    > >   >   > venus

> >    > >   >   > > > though in different signs are hardly 3

degrees apart

> >    if

> >    > >   using

> >    > >   >   > Raman

> >    > >   >   > > > ayanamsha, but if using Lahiri we run

into another

> >    > >   conundrum!

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > If you are using true nodes, ketu and

venus are in

> >    same

> >    > >   sign and

> >    > >   >   > > > house (9th)

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > BUT, if one is using mean nodes,then the

two are in

> >    > >   different

> >    > >   >   > signs :-

> >    > >   >   > > > )

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > Thanks Miss Astro for sharing this chart

that brings

> >    us

> >    > >   against

> >    > >   >   > yet

> >    > >   >   > > > another wall in Jyotish -- "idhar jaaoon

yaa udhar

> >    > jaaoon -

> >    > >   -

> >    > >   >   > kidhar

> >    > >   >   > > > jaoon?" as some poet said! :-)

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > I am assuming that since you did not

react strongly

> >    and

> >    > >   comment

> >    > >   >   > on

> >    > >   >   > > > the two being in different sign, that you

utilize

> >    true

> >    > >   nodes?

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > Ayanamsha, equal vs unequal houses, mean

vs true

> >    nodes,

> >    > >   isn't

> >    > >   >   > Jyotish

> >    > >   >   > > > rich with material that will keep us all

engaged for

> >    > >   lifetimes?

> >    > >   >   > How

> >    > >   >   > > > much work there is to be done, by so few

sincerely

> >    > >   interested

> >    > >   >   > > > individuals on this Jyotish Island! And

yet some

> >    would

> >    > >   rather

> >    > >   >   > keep

> >    > >   >   > > > griping and whining about problems that

do not exists

> >    > but

> >    > >   only

> >    > >   >   > lie in

> >    > >   >   > > > their (mis)perception!

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > RR

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > ,

~~Tarun~~

> >    > >   <tarun_vst@>

> >    > >   >   > > > wrote:

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > Hii ???

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > well love happens when 5th lord is

strong.

> >    > >   >   > > > > but first thing is that...frm which

angle you find

> >    > venus

> >    > >   ketu

> >    > >   >   > > > combination in his chart.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > i m using lahiri ayanamsa to analyse.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > he is spiritual because guru is

aspecting lagna

> >    even

> >    > >   being

> >    > >   >   > worst in

> >    > >   >   > > > 7th house.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > currently his buddha dasha is

commencing which is

> >    > lord

> >    > >   3rd and

> >    > >   >   > 6th

> >    > >   >   > > > house.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > one more combination of moon+mercury is

in his

> >    chart.

> >    > >   and that

> >    > >   >   > too

> >    > >   >   > > > is a dobutful combination but

> >    > >   >   > > > > as moon is in amavasya then its effects

are null.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > about love marriage...its impossible in

his

> >    chart.as

> >    > >   mars in

> >    > >   >   > 5th

> >    > >   >   > > > house so it wont make him to do

> >    > >   >   > > > > that.

> >    > >   >   > > > > 7th lord and 9th lord has exchange and

that will

> >    > surely

> >    > >   make

> >    > >   >   > him to

> >    > >   >   > > > get in arrange marriage.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > i hope other astrologers will also

guide my answers

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > well he himself know abt the effects of

5th mars

> >    and

> >    > 7th

> >    > >   >   > jupiter as

> >    > >   >   > > > per lal kitab.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > Thanks and Best Regards

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > tarun.

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > --- miss_astro19 <miss_astro19@> wrote:

> >    > >   >   > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  his chart

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  dob--- 26/11/1981

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  tob--- 16.08

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  pob--- ajmer

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  he is very very shy of girls, and

with god

> >    > blessings

> >    > >   even

> >    > >   >   > being

> >    > >   >   > > > very

> >    > >   >   > > > > > smart and intelligent no girl has got

attracted

> >    > >   towards him

> >    > >   >   > to

> >    > >   >   > > > > > distract him, and tht too in this age

where any

> >    boy

> >    > >   can

> >    > >   >   > easily

> >    > >   >   > > > have a

> >    > >   >   > > > > > gf.

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >   many astrologers told he will

have a love

> >    > >   marriage,but our

> >    > >   >   > > > guruji

> >    > >   >   > > > > > said tht his shukra his weakest, and

jupiter in

> >    7th

> >    > >   wont

> >    > >   >   > allow

> >    > >   >   > > > him

> >    > >   >   > > > > > marriage wht to say abt love marriage.

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  he is an astrologer himself, and

tht too very

> >    good

> >    > >   one, u

> >    > >   >   > can

> >    > >   >   > > > view

> >    > >   >   > > > > > his posts on lalkitab group..

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >  his dreams come true, he saw many

world

> >    happening

> >    > >   much

> >    > >   >   > before

> >    > >   >   > > > they

> >    > >   >   > > > > > occured in his derams, like worl

trade towers

> >    > >   crashing,

> >    > >   >   > killing

> >    > >   >   > > > of

> >    > >   >   > > > > > abdul ghani loan, sunami etc.

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > >

,

> >    ~~Tarun~~

> >    > >   >   > <tarun_vst@>

> >    > >   >   > > > > > wrote:

> >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > > > Hii,

> >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > > > well i cant say about him. But this

combination

> >    > >   often shows

> >    > >   >   > the

> >    > >   >   > > > > > described things.

> >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > > > can u provide his chart so tht other

> >    astrologers

> >    > can

> >    > >   find

> >    > >   >   > it

> >    > >   >   > > > out

> >    > >   >   > > > > > the reason of him being good.

> >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > > > Take care

> >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >    > >   >   > > > > > > bye

> >    > >   >   >

> >    > >   >   === message truncated ===

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   Send instant messages to your online friends

> >    > >   http://in.messenger.

["]http://in.messenger.]

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >   SURRENDER JOYFULLY TO THE WILL OF THE ULTIMATE

DIVINITY AND

> >    > >   RELISH THE TASTE OF ABSOLUTE BLISS.

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >  >

> >    > >   >

> >    > >   >          

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest guest

I always presumed that they used topocentric positions because that

will give the drig position. Jyotish is based on the What you see is

what you get zodiac so the planet-body as seen from a point of

interest on the earth (city, town) would make sense. Which always has

led to the intriguing possibility -- if a person is born on earth but

moves to a future colony in space would the relocated chart apply

more? The same is claimed by some for people who moved from one

country to another. I have not made a lot of study of that but

generally speaking the natal chart seems to work for most who move

around on the globe.

 

I was kind of sold on the true nodes early on triggered by NC

Lahiri's statements in his ephemeris making a logical case for using

true positions of nodes as well, just like for other planets. I have

never really pitted mean against true to see if one is definitely

better than the other. Some people, though, make a very black and

white case against true or mean positions. Perhaps they have carried

out the work -- I don't know.

 

When it comes to astrology, I realize the multifactorial nature of

its operation and therefore, unless something is really broken

consistently, I do not tweak or fine tune things.

 

RR

 

, Prafulla Gang <jyotish>

wrote:

>

> Dear Ranjan ji

>

> There must be some reasoning in local panchang makers to use

topocentric calculations, whereas computerized chart makers takers

sets to default values of geocentric basis. I understand, the

problems in tracing correct ayanamsa; and you correctly said - if the

problem existed say 500 years back.

>

> When we normally consider planets as true position (not apparent

one); then should not we also, consider rahu / ketu in true position

(instead of mean position). I am sure, may of members, must have

tossed the possible alternatives, prior to fixing some of the

variables in chart computation.

>

> regards / Prafulla Gang

>

> No person was ever honored for what he received.

> Honor has been the reward for what he gave.

>

>

> >

> > rrgb

> > Sat, 03 Jun 2006 22:07:55 -0000

> >

> > Re: before Lahiri which one? 2/6 p2

> >

> > Yes Prafulla, that kind of calculation takes the parallax error

into

> >  consideration. It is most significant for moon (closest body) and

> >  lesser for other planets. Depending on the angular position of

the

> >  moon (rising, setting, medium coeli or nadir) the PE can be as

high

> >  as more than a degree amounting to a difference of upto a couple

of

> >  years if the moon is in the star of one of the longer duration

> >  planets (venus, shani etc).

> >  RR

> >  , Prafulla Gang <jyotish@>

> >  wrote:

> >  >

> >  > Dear members

> >  >

> >  > there is another variation in ayanamsa - calculating geocentric

> >  (taking from the center of earth...can someone find the center

of a

> >  ball) or topocentric (taking from the place of birth). In my

> >  interactions with few local panchang writers, I observed the use

of

> >  topocentric calculations. Perhaps, that is one of the major

> >  difference in different local panchangs.

> >  >

> >  > regards / Prafulla Gang

> >  >

> >  > No person was ever honored for what he received.

> >  > Honor has been the reward for what he gave.

> >  >

> >  >

> >  > >

> >  > > gbp_kumar@

> >  > > Sat, 3 Jun 2006 01:00:21 -0700 (PDT)

> >  > >

> >  > > Re: Re: before Lahiri which one? 2/6 p2

> >  > >

> >  > > RR Ji,

> >  > >    I have also said close to waht u said on the major

> >  contributionf oh

> >  > > Lahiri is the standardisation at least fo Hindu calander

unlike

> >  Islam,  i

> >  > > sno mean achievemtn esp with the odds he was up against. esp

thÂ

> >  snakes

> >  > > panchangams

> >  > >    and now all we hat to do is work on the BASE LINE

which is

> >  Lahiris

> >  > > +/-  xx ded xx mi  sssec say raman 1 Deg 26 min 26 sec.

> >  Krishnnamurthy  0

> >  > > deg 0 min 7' les to Lahiri.

> >  > >    And is also nice that you did find some matter to

look at and

> >  > > appriciate as well apart from content the analagy, this

spirit I

> >  also

> >  > > felt was needed when we did discuss Guru, becasue we do wrtie

> >  with a  few

> >  > > points, medtods, quotes and do expect them also to be

commentedÂ

> >  good or

> >  > > bad no problem and any suppliments or deletins we will like

toÂ

> >  be

> >  > > correced as we are always learning. weleanr till we pass out

of

> >  this

> >  > > world.

> >  > >    And I always believe the traditions laid before us are

> >  elastic and

> >  > > not  plastic, to accept any modifications of the rules

with the

> >  times it

> >  > > is  applied without over ruling or destroying the original

> >  spirit of the

> >  > > subject,

> >  > >  crystal pages <rrgb@> wrote:       

Dear Satish ji,

> >  > >    Though Sri Nirmal Chandra Lahiri is noted for his

ayanamsha

> >  (which he

> >  > >    never called his own but simply pinned it to the star

Chitra

> >  or

> >  > >    Spica -- hence properly named as Chitra navamsha.

Similar

> >  > >    misnomenclature also exists for the so called

Yukteshwar

> >  ayanamsha.

> >  > >    Even more so, since unlike Lahiri, Yukteshwar Giri ji

Maharaj

> >  did not

> >  > >    calculate or establish that ayanamsha but merely

stated that

> >  it was

> >  > >    according to astronomical books -- possibly prevailing

> >  panchangs

> >  > >    followed by him). All this has been written with more

> >  interesting

> >  > >    similarities between it and Raman ayanamsha in

earlier posts,

> >  etc.

> >  > >    Anyway, much more important than the ayanamsha he

gave us,

> >  Lahiri's

> >  > >    primary contribution to the field of jyotish related

> >  astronomy is the

> >  > >    bringing out of accurate epehmeris/panchangs which

were based

> >  on

> >  > >    mathematical calculations with modern terms and

corrections

> >  given by

> >  > >    astrophysics. With Lahiri's ephemeris starting in 30s

or

> >  thereabouts

> >  > >    the wild variabilities that characterized all but a

few rare

> >  > >    panchaangs became a thing of past and more

importantly,

> >  others were

> >  > >    forced to follow suit and fine-tune their 'act'.

Publishing

> >  just

> >  > >    anything and calling it a panchanng or panjika would

not do,

> >  any

> >  > >    more!

> >  > >    That, to me is the major contribution of Lahiri.

> >  > >    Kumarji gave a beautiful analogy, or different

ayanamshas

> >  being like

> >  > >    vision-correcting glasses. Mine would not work for

you, yours

> >  would

> >  > >    not work for me! My own that worked ten years do not

work for

> >  me

> >  > >    anymore <LOL>

> >  > >    RR

> >  > >    , "R Satish"

> >  <rsatish1942@>

> >  > >    wrote:

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >  Dear Friends,

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >   Mentioning about Lahiri's Ayanamsa,remimded

about my

> >  experience

> >  > >    > with a hard core Vedic scholar,from a place called

> >  Kotipalli,on the

> >  > >    > banks of Godavari in East Godavari Dt.

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >   This Brahmin,80 +yrs runs  a Vedic

Patshala which

> >  trains Hindu

> >  > >    > Priests for performimg various poojas etcand is

residential

> >  school.

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >   When the subject of Ayanamsa came up,I had

mentioned to

> >  him about

> >  > >    > the pabnchang difference between a Kakinada

panchang and

> >  Lahiri's

> >  > >    > ayanamsa. He emphatically stated that Lahiri

succumbed to

> >  the then

> >  > >    > govt's pressure manipulating the ephemeris.He

stated there

> >  is a

> >  > >    > difference of" one pada",between the local

panchang.Hence a

> >  > >    > differneceof nearly 6-8 month's is not

uncommon.I  had

> >  gone to him

> >  > >    > to  discuss my son's horoscope,about 3/4 yrs

ago.Even in

> >  my case,

> >  > >    > there is a diffence of exactly one year in the

balance of

> >  Chandra

> >  > >    > dasa,I have not been to reconcile this difference.

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >  As stated by you stalwarts,finally it boils

down to one's

> >  > >    experience.

> >  > >    > Fnaticism does not serve much purpose to the cause

of

> >  astrology.

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >   This is one of my several experiemces with

the'

> >  stalwarts' .

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >  Regards,

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >   Satish

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    >

> >  > >    > , Prashant

Kumar G B

> >  > >    > <gbp_kumar@> wrote:

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > > Dear Pandit Arjun ji,

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   I have also shared some of these inputs

directly and

> >  indirectly

> >  > >    > with  many in person and in the groups like 

these the

> >  most

> >  > >    > remarkable  one being of ICAS founder Secy sri

Late K.

> >  Ashwattappa,

> >  > >    > who had  contemopt for Raman like all others

here as it was

> >  > >    > fashionable to do so  by ciritising any pouplar

person,Â

> >  and so for

> >  > >    > his ayanamsa MOST OF  HIS critics do not even

know the

> >  difference

> >  > >    > between Lahiri and Raman's  in terms of deg- min-

sec and

> >  MAJORITY

> >  > >    > HAVE NEVER TESTED IT either,  just prejueice,

jealous of

> >  him.

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   But my association with him for over 15

yrs he felt

> >  he must try

> >  > >    > it and  did test them randomly and fouind in

many cases

> >  Rahu Dasa

> >  > >    or

> >  > >    > Ketu Dasa  at the end giving Good results than

their

> >  earlier part

> >  > >    > once he shifted  the ayanamsa found it is Guru,

or Sukra

> >  periods

> >  > >    that

> >  > >    > gave the right  results as Subha phala need not

wait til

> >  then end

> >  > >    of

> >  > >    > the dasa to  deliver. eve Ketu or Rahu if well

place can

> >  give at

> >  > >    > start not in tail  end. THIS I HAVE THE BENIFIT

OF MNEXT

> >  GURU S

> >  > >    > SUBBANNA, AWHO GOT IT FROM  HIS GURU they are

Mysore

> >  Maharaja's

> >  > >    > asthana Jyotishis for generations.

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   SO ANYONE WITH AN OPEN MID IF THEY TYR IT

CAN GET

> >  GOOD RESULTS

> >  > >    it

> >  > >    > is  open to them no vested interests, except

that we want

> >  the

> >  > >    subject

> >  > >    > to  have its good tols an dusers benifit if they

try, it is

> >  > >    possible

> >  > >    > they  can stillg et good results in this or

anyother left

> >  to ones

> >  > >    > intution,  instincts, knowledge, in RAMAN'

success we know

> >  we ar

> >  > >    > einthe right  track so lets move along, and he

hsued the

> >  > >    traditional

> >  > >    > ones which even  westerners beofe his birth have

> >  acknowledged as

> >  > >    the

> >  > >    > genius of INDIAN  TRADITION's (Vedic) 

RICHNESS.

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > > panditarjun2004 <panditarjun2004@>

wrote:      Â

> >  dear prashant ji

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   is is so nice of you to share your astro

knolwedge

> >  from your

> >  > >    > three

> >  > >    > >   decades of experience and since you are

one of the

> >  founding

> >  > >    > members

> >  > >    > >   of ICAS, your inputs are always lessons

for amateurs.

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   earlier i was using lahiri for the past

several years

> >  and

> >  > >    > sometimes

> >  > >    > >   i did not get them right inlcuidng my

own.  however,

> >  after your

> >  > >    > >   advise, i started using raman's ayanamsha

and am

> >  getting the

> >  > >    > charts,

> >  > >    > >   especially dasa periods, more

accurately.Â

> >  unfortunately, these

> >  > >    > >   ayanamashas can make or break a chart.

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   with best wishes

> >  > >    > >   pandit arjun

> >  > >    > >

> >  > >    > >   ,

Prashant

> >  Kumar G B

> >  > >    > >   <gbp_kumar@> wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   > Hi Tarun

> >  > >    > >   >   I had replied to you, there

were 33 Ayanansa's

> >  in vouge

> >  > >    prior

> >  > >    > to

> >  > >    > >   Lahiri  stepping in and pushing his

own, this is

> >  like a judge

> >  > >    who

> >  > >    > >   could not  undersand the case but yet

gave a verdit.

> >  HIS OWN.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   the reason is numerous claims

and counter

> >  claims to deal

> >  > >    with

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   esp in Tamil Nadu then Madras

Province it more

> >  a tamil

> >  > >    > centric

> >  > >    > >   problem  there are quite a few

thoughts based on

> >  their EQ [ego

> >  > >    > >   quotient]

> >  > >    > >   >   where most of them are based on

hapazard Vakya

> >  panchang no

> >  > >    > >   corrections  took place ever and if a

mistake was

> >  made by one

> >  > >    in

> >  > >    > the

> >  > >    > >   family chain it  continued as it was a

brand name so

> >  no way you

> >  > >    > can

> >  > >    > >   dispute it.   there was Madurai,

Kanchipuram,

> >  Srirangam,

> >  > >    Tenkasi

> >  > >    > >   etc groups  each had a different Panbu

panchangam

> >  [or snake

> >  > >    > >   calander] quite  different from

others. and sayÂ

> >  could not

> >  > >    agree

> >  > >    > >   comming from one  state where will the

reminder in

> >  India agree?

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   Even the tamils themselves had

Gochara of Major

> >  planets at

> >  > >    > >   different  months variation, eclipses

and all others

> >  in chaos.

> >  > >    no

> >  > >    > >   scientific  basis. Lahiri brought in

the Drik or

> >  verifiable one

> >  > >    > >   which is caliculated on established

astronomical

> >  principles at

> >  > >    > least.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   about TAMIL EGO QUOTENT if I

follow the lead of

> >  RR here on

> >  > >    > >   storry telling these are true ones though

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   DURIGN THE BRITISH RAJ DAYS THE

SUPREME COURT

> >  WAS IN LONDON

> >  > >    > or

> >  > >    > >   Privay  Council as it was called.

dealt with a case

> >  of Iyangars

> >  > >    a

> >  > >    > >   group of  Brahmins of the Vishnavas

there are 2

> >  groups in them

> >  > >    > >   Vadagalai  [Northern] and Thengalai

[southern]  in

> >  a temple

> >  > >    > function

> >  > >    > >   there  was a dispute how to Mark the

temple

> >  elephant's

> >  > >    forehaead

> >  > >    > >   with a Y or U  shaped  Mark of the

Vaishnava mark

> >  > >    > >   >   [Vadagalis Mark it as U and

Tehengalais s Y

> >  with a middle

> >  > >    > line

> >  > >    > >   in red]

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   they had enough street brawls

as Tamils do and

> >  finally went

> >  > >    > to

> >  > >    > >   the PC  [prviy council]. so that being

the case you

> >  can never

> >  > >    say

> >  > >    > >   Lahiri had a  easy job at least he

standadrised our

> >  calander

> >  > >    but

> >  > >    > >   Islam is free  in  India each state

Imam can see

> >  the same

> >  > >    Moon's

> >  > >    > >   crecent on a  different days and have

a different

> >  holiday the

> >  > >    > state

> >  > >    > >   and Central govt  has. all laws are fo

Hindus only.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   BTW the Tamil EQ's latest M

karunadhi and

> >  former CM. Ms

> >  > >    JJ,

> >  > >    > >   are  meeting in the assembly after 17

yrs normally

> >  the other

> >  > >    one

> >  > >    > >   resigns if  they loose and don't face

each other

> >  directly.

> >  > >    their

> >  > >    > mud

> >  > >    > >   slinging is of  unique depths.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   > ~~Tarun~~ <tarun_vst@>

wrote:        Dear RR

> >  ji,

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   yes Shri Nirmal Chandra Lahiri

ji lived in

> >  calcutta but

> >  > >    since

> >  > >    > >   varanasi was key centre for

> >  > >    > >   >   astrology so the calculations

were observed and

> >  studied as

> >  > >    > par

> >  > >    > >   Varanasi.(as wht i know)

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   Actually sometimes a question

arises that what

> >  panchang was

> >  > >    > used

> >  > >    > >   before lahiri placed his

> >  > >    > >   >   ayanamasa, what was the base of

calculations

> >  used while

> >  > >    > making

> >  > >    > >   chart in ancient times.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   i think this question is still

unanswered.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   Thanks and Regards

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   Tarun

> >  > >    > >   >   www.thevinayak.com

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   --- crystal pages <rrgb@> wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   > I think Nirmal Chandra Lahiri

ji lived in

> >  Calcutta and

> >  > >    not

> >  > >    > >   Varanasi!

> >  > >    > >   >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   > Not that it makes that big a

difference

> >  longitudinally or

> >  > >    > >   >   > latitudinally but could mean

several hours of

> >  journey, if

> >  > >    I

> >  > >    > >   remember

> >  > >    > >   >   > correctly between Baba

Vishwanath or

> >  Sankatmochan or

> >  > >    Birla

> >  > >    > >   temple and

> >  > >    > >   >   > oh say Dakshineshwar or

Kalibari! ;-)

> >  > >    > >   >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   > RR

> >  > >    > >   >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   >

,

> >  ~~Tarun~~

> >  > >    > >   <tarun_vst@>

> >  > >    > >   >   > wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > Dear RR ji,

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > no problem at all. you are

very senior to

> >  me.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > sir even in my chart i have

the same prob..

> >  if i use

> >  > >    > raman

> >  > >    > >   ayanamsa

> >  > >    > >   >   > my dasha changes by 18 months.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > the rahu placement in my

chart also changes.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > actually raman livd in

south india and his

> >  location was

> >  > >    > much

> >  > >    > >   near

> >  > >    > >   >   > to equator in comparison to

> >  > >    > >   >   > > Kashi viswanath (base frm

where Lahiri gave

> >  his

> >  > >    > >   calculations) so

> >  > >    > >   >   > the diff is easily expected.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > my dob 19-07-1983

> >  > >    > >   >   > > time:- 10.35 am

> >  > >    > >   >   > > place:- Jodhpur Rajasthan

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > sir one shows mars rahu

combination in 10th

> >  and one

> >  > >    shows

> >  > >    > >   rahu in

> >  > >    > >   >   > 9th .

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > i was always confused abt

whom to follow.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > but if we consider mean

node then too my

> >  chart changes

> >  > >    > and

> >  > >    > >   if i

> >  > >    > >   >   > consider true node then too my

> >  > >    > >   >   > > chart changes.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > but as far as for Miss

astro.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > i wil say venus ketu

combination is not

> >  > >    matching .because

> >  > >    > >   venus and

> >  > >    > >   >   > ketu dont give much better

> >  > >    > >   >   > > results as she is descibing.

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > thanks and regards

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > tarun

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > --- crystal pages <rrgb@>

wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >   > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > Tarun ji,

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > <my apologies for

mistyping your name as

> >  Varun last

> >  > >    > time!>

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > This is a very

interesting situation

> >  indeed, because

> >  > >    > ketu

> >  > >    > >   and

> >  > >    > >   >   > venus

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > though in different signs

are hardly 3

> >  degrees apart

> >  > >    if

> >  > >    > >   using

> >  > >    > >   >   > Raman

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > ayanamsha, but if using

Lahiri we run

> >  into another

> >  > >    > >   conundrum!

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > If you are using true

nodes, ketu and

> >  venus are in

> >  > >    same

> >  > >    > >   sign and

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > house (9th)

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > BUT, if one is using mean

nodes,then the

> >  two are in

> >  > >    > >   different

> >  > >    > >   >   > signs :-

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > )

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > Thanks Miss Astro for

sharing this chart

> >  that brings

> >  > >    us

> >  > >    > >   against

> >  > >    > >   >   > yet

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > another wall in Jyotish --

"idhar jaaoon

> >  yaa udhar

> >  > >    > jaaoon -

> >  > >    > >   -

> >  > >    > >   >   > kidhar

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > jaoon?" as some poet

said! :-)

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > I am assuming that since

you did not

> >  react strongly

> >  > >    and

> >  > >    > >   comment

> >  > >    > >   >   > on

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > the two being in

different sign, that you

> >  utilize

> >  > >    true

> >  > >    > >   nodes?

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > Ayanamsha, equal vs

unequal houses, mean

> >  vs true

> >  > >    nodes,

> >  > >    > >   isn't

> >  > >    > >   >   > Jyotish

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > rich with material that

will keep us all

> >  engaged for

> >  > >    > >   lifetimes?

> >  > >    > >   >   > How

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > much work there is to be

done, by so few

> >  sincerely

> >  > >    > >   interested

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > individuals on this

Jyotish Island! And

> >  yet some

> >  > >    would

> >  > >    > >   rather

> >  > >    > >   >   > keep

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > griping and whining about

problems that

> >  do not exists

> >  > >    > but

> >  > >    > >   only

> >  > >    > >   >   > lie in

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > their (mis)perception!

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > RR

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > >

,

> >  ~~Tarun~~

> >  > >    > >   <tarun_vst@>

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > Hii ???

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > well love happens when

5th lord is

> >  strong.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > but first thing is

that...frm which

> >  angle you find

> >  > >    > venus

> >  > >    > >   ketu

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > combination in his chart.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > i m using lahiri

ayanamsa to analyse.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > he is spiritual because

guru is

> >  aspecting lagna

> >  > >    even

> >  > >    > >   being

> >  > >    > >   >   > worst in

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > 7th house.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > currently his buddha

dasha is

> >  commencing which is

> >  > >    > lord

> >  > >    > >   3rd and

> >  > >    > >   >   > 6th

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > house.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > one more combination of

moon+mercury is

> >  in his

> >  > >    chart.

> >  > >    > >   and that

> >  > >    > >   >   > too

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > is a dobutful combination

but

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > as moon is in amavasya

then its effects

> >  are null.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > about love

marriage...its impossible in

> >  his

> >  > >    chart.as

> >  > >    > >   mars in

> >  > >    > >   >   > 5th

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > house so it wont make him

to do

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > that.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > 7th lord and 9th lord

has exchange and

> >  that will

> >  > >    > surely

> >  > >    > >   make

> >  > >    > >   >   > him to

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > get in arrange marriage.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > i hope other

astrologers will also

> >  guide my answers

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > well he himself know

abt the effects of

> >  5th mars

> >  > >    and

> >  > >    > 7th

> >  > >    > >   >   > jupiter as

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > per lal kitab.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > Thanks and Best Regards

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > tarun.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > --- miss_astro19

<miss_astro19@> wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  his chart

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  dob--- 26/11/1981

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  tob--- 16.08

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  pob--- ajmer

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  he is very very

shy of girls, and

> >  with god

> >  > >    > blessings

> >  > >    > >   even

> >  > >    > >   >   > being

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > very

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > smart and intelligent

no girl has got

> >  attracted

> >  > >    > >   towards him

> >  > >    > >   >   > to

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > distract him, and tht

too in this age

> >  where any

> >  > >    boy

> >  > >    > >   can

> >  > >    > >   >   > easily

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > have a

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > gf.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >   many

astrologers told he will

> >  have a love

> >  > >    > >   marriage,but our

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > guruji

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > said tht his shukra

his weakest, and

> >  jupiter in

> >  > >    7th

> >  > >    > >   wont

> >  > >    > >   >   > allow

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > him

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > marriage wht to say

abt love marriage.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  he is an

astrologer himself, and

> >  tht too very

> >  > >    good

> >  > >    > >   one, u

> >  > >    > >   >   > can

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > view

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > his posts on lalkitab

group..

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >  his dreams come

true, he saw many

> >  world

> >  > >    happening

> >  > >    > >   much

> >  > >    > >   >   > before

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > they

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > occured in his

derams, like worl

> >  trade towers

> >  > >    > >   crashing,

> >  > >    > >   >   > killing

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > of

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > abdul ghani loan,

sunami etc.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > --- In

> >  ,

> >  > >    ~~Tarun~~

> >  > >    > >   >   > <tarun_vst@>

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > wrote:

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > > Hii,

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > > well i cant say

about him. But this

> >  combination

> >  > >    > >   often shows

> >  > >    > >   >   > the

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > described things.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > > can u provide his

chart so tht other

> >  > >    astrologers

> >  > >    > can

> >  > >    > >   find

> >  > >    > >   >   > it

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > out

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > the reason of him

being good.

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > > Take care

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > >

> >  > >    > >   >   > > > > > > bye

> >  > >    > >   >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   === message truncated ===

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   Send instant messages to your

online friends

> >  > >    > >   http://in.messenger.

> > ["]http://in.messenger.]

> >  ["]http://in.messenger.] []"]http://in.messenger.]]

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >   SURRENDER JOYFULLY TO THE WILL

OF THE ULTIMATE

> >  DIVINITY AND

> >  > >    > >   RELISH THE TASTE OF ABSOLUTE BLISS.

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >  >

> >  > >    > >   >

> >  > >    > >   >          

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...