Guest guest Posted May 1, 2006 Report Share Posted May 1, 2006 Dear Souvik RAM KRISHN HARE Please find some replies below. Your views are in . "They were united in an islet in the middle of the river. This act was hidden from the prying eyes of the world, with the aid of a mist, created by the yogic powers of Parasara. This child was Vyasa." Anil: Parashar united at that time as he knew importance of that momement. Only an astrological genius can calculate it that accurately. No wonder, the child was great expert and Chirangeevee. Afterall what is the best application of Jyotish? To get a child whose chart ensures very-very long life with all sorts of knowlege and who is incarnation of GOD too! "However, in the complete BPHS, we see an inevitable biasedness towards Sri Hari and Parasara's attempt to boil down astrology to Vishnu forms." Anil: Parashar was very great Vishnu-Bhakt but I do not see it except in Chapter 2. If you read remedies for bad Dasha/Ashtakvarg you will see that Vishnu appears only for Budh. "Parasara couldn't have known about Sri Krishna if he wrote Hora shastra before the 4th. generation from him." Anil: You are wrong. He was Vyas in earlier(26th) Dwaper Yug. So his knowledge and longivity are very high. All Vyas are chirangeevee. People having longivity upto end of kalp reside in Maharlok(above Swarg). "Gautam Buddha was not born when Parasara was alive! This could have been amended when Vishnu Purana was amended in later years." Anil: Sage Valmiki also wrote Ramayan long before it actually happened. He was not an educated person like sage Parashar but due to his dedicated recital of Ram-Nam in reverse order,he got siddhi and became sage who wrote first ever epic in the history of mankind. Sage Parashar was born in the family of great Rishi like Vashisth. He was well educated and was well respected even by great Rishis at an age of mere 7 years! It was certainly a kids-play for him to see future. He was a trikal-gyani. No wonder he knew about the incarnation of God long before its occurance. "The Imperceptible part of the Lord is endowed with dual powers, while the Perceptible with triple powers." Anil: Experts like Jagad-guru Kripaluji Maharaj say that God has different names based on functions.I will state 3 forms. First: Param-Brahm(not lord Brahma) is nirgun nirakar. HE exist even before and after creation. HE has all powers but they remain unmenifested. Second: Prakriti appeared as a result of Param-Brahm's desire 'Ekoham Bahusyam' and Parm-atma remains present every where in the form of Atma to witness various actvities of Prakriti. HE has all powers but HE is still Nirgun, Nirakar. HIS two powers are omnipresent and Sakshi. Third: Bhagwan is Sagun-Sakar form. HE can take any form and show any quality. HE is normally refered by people with several names. All powers are fully menifested in HIM.This form has a combination of GOD with Prakriti while above ones are pure. First and Second are imperceptible while third is perceptible. Since first two do not have prakriti,they are immortal while third one has to go when Prakriti vanishes in Parm-Brahm. As you might be knowing,Mahat-Tatwa is created by Prakriti which then produced Ahamkar and from Ahamkar,Panch tatwa,Indriyas,Mana and Deities were created.Dark matter/energy may be related to Mahat-Tatwa at most(personally I do not agree) but it can not be beyond that. How can imperceptible things beyond Prakriti be known by means in prakriti? "Buddha episode is a very improper documentation-to say that Sri Hari took an incarnation to take Asuras away from the marg of Dharma and assigning it to Buddha could NEVER been the words of Maharshis." Anil: Avtars occure to establish Yug-Dharm. What HE did in Vaman- Avatar? Bali was extreamly religious still HE cheated him and that was just the beginning of Treta-Yug and Dharm was still full.If Bali had refused,his Dharma would have lost. He accepted to loose everything but retained Dharm. In Kali-Yug this was not the case. Several Asuras killed in Mahabharat war were born as kings. As they were not killed by God,they were not libarated. Buddha successfully stopped Yagyas and stopped their growth. Arambh(starting) Sandhi of each Yug is for establishing new rules that will be practised mostly during that Yug. During Viram(ending) Sandhi, most of the achievements etc. reach their height and due to excess of them, they are destroyed to mark the end of that Yug. eg. Kaliyug will take 36000 years to establish(Dharm will reduce from 50% to 25%) then for 360000 years,it will remain stable and in last 36000 years, excess of Kaliyug will reduce Dharm to almost zero. At this time,due to Kalki Avtar or some war/natural disaster etc. Sinful people will be destroyed and at the end of Kaliyug again 25% Dharm is restored. After this Satyug's Sandhi(transition) period will take Dharm from 25% to 100%. Just imagine if Dwaper technology is available to people in Kaliyug, terrorists will convert an ordinary arrow into Brahmastr and destroy the universe. To avoid this,Shree Krishn ensured that all such kings including HIS own family members are fully destroyed before Kaliyug begins. All acts of God are to maintain Yug-Dharm. HE considers entire universe not just earth for deciding HIS actions. "why would any author write more than one book on a factual matter?" Anil: Parashar wrote different books on different matters. For a common man,Science means all aspects of the subject but for a learned one,physics and chemistry are two completely different subjects. " if I had to assume that Veda Vyasa did write all the 18 Puranas then how come that the story of creation (even birth of Gods) are contradictory?" Anil: If you read original Puranas carefully, you will know that different Puranas give stories from different Kalp. Different Kalp start on different Tithis. Now you know that if creation charts of Kalp are different,things will happen at different times. It is similar to the fact that marriage of different persons born at different time are celebrated at different time. Education,job,marriage etc. are events in human life and occure in most charts but at different times.These are not daily events. Every day we have more or less same routine. Mostly similar events occure in every Kalp but at different times. When we sleep,our regular day-time activities end.Similarly when Lord Brahma sleeps,His activity (creation of world) ends.The routine then continues from next day with or without minor variations. " What was the requirement of so many versions of just one fundamental truth? why did Vyasa forget to mention such an important event in any of the other Puranas?" Anil: As I wrote above,these are stories of different Kalp(day of lord Brahma).If you read them carefully,you will see that each of them gives some additional details on things which may not be available in other Puranas. In fact there is only one Puran which has 1 billion verses! Since in Kaliyug,no one can remember/read such volume,he gave essence in 400,000 verses divided in several puranas for better learning. These stories may have several meanings. A doctor may find names of herbs for treatment of diseases while same verse may give calculation of some Dasha to an astrologer but we have no keys to confirm this points. Even the count of verses are not matching. Due to huge size of hand written books,they were stored in parts and were divided like property among sons.So some parts are either lost or they are still hidden with someone. What you think important,is a non-significant event when we consider that 1 Kalp means 4.32 billion year and several such Kalpas are covered in Puranas.Since Vyasji wrote Puranas at the end of Dwapar,he kindly gave some events in Bhavishya-Puran. "The astral conditions mentioned in Srimad Bhagvatam for the advent of Kalki will come to pass on 27th. July 2014 AD" Anil: You are giving your views. Can you give what astral conditions are satisfied? Kalki Avtar will occure at the end of Kaliyug when 821 years will be left. We are just in 5107 th year. Again all 10 Avtars of lord Vishnu will not occure in every cycle of chaturyug. SreeRam avtar occured in 24th Treta while SreeKrishn avtar occured in 28th Dwapar.So there may be a diference in Yug/Manvantar/Kalp. Birth-date,time,place,parents and many information of Kalki avtar are given in Puranas but we have no software that can make HIS chart. So Forget about such long term predictions. It is only possible for sages. "why Vishnu avatars like Narasimha and Varah represented by malefic planets should be considered to be 100 per cent Paramatmansha avatars. Entirely Paramatmaansha avatars of Rama and Krishna represented by the luminaries is more understandable!" Anil: Narasimha and Varah also appeared for killing His cursed door- keepers Jay and Vijay. Since they were at gates of Vaikunth,they were already above all residents of various lokas below Vaikunth. In fact they were very close to union with God. For this reason,it was not possible for any lesser avtar to kill them.While He killed both in Ram and Krishn avtars,He needded two separate avtars to kill them because of special boons received by them. Visti: "Puranas were written down by the son of Vyasa" Anil: what is the basis for this statement? What was the name of that son? "Whereas in Western Astrology, certain point are given quite some importance apart from just Ascendant (Lagna) like Descendant, Midheaven etc., Indian methods prescibes a lot of important to Eastern Horizon. Any views why?" Anil: Classics ask us to see vargas of Bhav-cusp counted not only from Lagn but also from planets.So our canvass is much bigger. It is a differet matter how we are using it due to personal bias/lack of knowledge. "Udayadishu bhaveshu khetasya bhavnneshu va" Here the term Udayadishu can indicate all Lagnas including special ones. Some examples are AL,UL,BL,HL,GL,PPL,VL,SL,Gulik Lagn etc. The imortance give to Lagn is just to avoid multiplication.we are told to see other houses exactly in similar way so what is true for lagn,is also true for any house from any reference when that is taken as lagn for the purpose of analysis. Several Rashi Dashas can be used with advantage from relevent house/karak as lagn. "Effects of Sub-Grahas. If one of these afflicts Sûrya, the native's dynasty will decline, while Candr and Lagn, respectively, associated with one of these, will destroy the longevity and wisdom. So declared Lord Brahma, the Lotus-Born" Anil: You need to check in relevent varg. D16 and D60 are most important. If relevent vargas are not afflicted by Dhoom etc.,they will not give much problem. A planet in Kendra to Dhoom gives good results in its Dasha. "Do these charts require correction or is it that by bhava Parasara was referring to something else not houses. PP in various houses in described in Chapter 25 of BPHS." Anil: Pran-pad shows life-force. In good houses it gives life to good things.However when other planets also join,situation changes accordingly. Vargas will show relevent details based on PP.These things apply to all sub-grahas etc. Pran-Pad is a special Lagn. bhav L = 2 hours = sign/1 hora L = 1 hours = sign/2 Ghati L = 24 min. = sign/5 PP Lagn = 6 min. = sign/20 (1 sign takes 120 min. on average) You can see that BL,HL,GL correspond to 1,2,5 house matters. Extending it to PPL, 20 will give 8th house(life = Pran!). >From this it is very clear that PPL shows life-force. Use of PP Lagn may be explored on this basis. Kal(time) is strongest so division based on time indicates strength/force. These are divisions of time and not space. There are 2 view about calculation of PPL. Say A(in degrees) = Isht(in minutes)*5 + Sun(in degrees) (1) PPL = A + 360/240/120 if Sun is in Char/Sthir/Dwiswabhav Rashi (2) PPL = A + 360/240/120 if Lagn is in Char/Sthir/Dwiswabhav Rashi 1,4,7,10 signs show that life is active! 11,2,5,8 signs are badhak to Char and show obstruction to life. If Badha is stronger then life,troubles in life/Dasha are certain. Incidently,For Char Lagn 11th is badhak which is Sthir Rashi for which 9th is badhak. 9th from 11th is 7th so partner/spouse will prove helpful to obstruct badha for Char Lagn. Similarly for Sthir Lagn also 7th is helpful for removing badha. Link of Pran-Dasha(5th level) with Pran-Pad also needs consideration. [PVR has proposed following sequence for dasha interpretation: Ravi-Chandr-Lagn-AK-Pranpad_lagn-Lagn.] I found that you have skipped qualities of planets.These are extreamly important and each quality needs a separate post/example/illustration. Please try to cover basics in depth. Thanks Anilkumar OM TAT SAT -------------------------------- Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.