Guest guest Posted November 10, 2005 Report Share Posted November 10, 2005 om namo bhagavate vasudevayaDear Chandrasekhar What I have said about K N Rao is not at all odd and is very very sweet compared to what KN Rao has said for years about the real father figure Dr Raman and PUBLISHED about so many vedic astrologers in India and abroad. What I said was the truth when I said that he went to look for 'books under his bed'. Rohini Ranjan and other astrologers were also there in that Majordomo list. Has Sri Rao found those books from under the bed by now or is he still looking? I will be the first to withdraw my statements about him if he publicly apologizes for what he has said about Dr Raman. I have given all the answers to Sri Surya Rao and have asked him to demonstrate how he uses the saptamsa varga...he chose to leave. If he wishes to continue his debate with me in any other forum, I shall be most willing to continue. Can you check with the Jyotish List moderator if they want me there to continue the debate? Do not ever be any any wrong impression that I am leaving. I may be slow, I may be bogged down with work, but I will never say die when it comes to standing up for Parasara and Vyasadeva. Please ask Sri Surya Rao to give the answer to the questions I have listed. Jaya Jagannath Krishna! With best wishes and warm regards,Sanjay Rath* * *Sri Jagannath Center®15B Gangaram Hospital Road New Delhi 110060, Indiahttp://srath.com, +91-11-25717162* * * - Chandra Sekhar vedic astrology Thursday, November 10, 2005 5:23 PM Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his students Dear Shree Rao, Iam happy that you recognize the services of Sri KN Rao and has openely expressed appreciation for him. I am writing this because just two days before, when Mr. Rath snubbed Shree Shreenadh, he had made a derogatory remark like 'Are you a student of KN Rao?' pointing to that there is something wrong with KN Rao and his students. Such language against a father figure of astrology from another Guru sounds very odd. As you said humility is one quality everyone must develop. In your previous mail you have explained the discipline expected but it is my personal feeling that asking somebody to have the homework correctly or not to ask silly question is not a very offensive thing if you see your own Guruji's words with which he guided/snubbed Shree Shreenadhji. Your role as a moderator and starter and thus the owner of the group is justified but at the same time you should have given a better treatment to Shree Surya who had made some brilliant postings to which neither you nor your Guruji had no answer. So it may look as if you and Narayana Iyer deliberately intervented to create a conflict and insult the man for the offence of challenging your wisdom. The man who raised impertinent question should also have been humble enough not to stray into an area where Paramguru was engaged in discussion. So even though you say there is a level playing field, it looks as if you have gunned another abhimanyu by orchestrated effort to avoid inconvenient questions that exposed the intellectual bankruptcy of your guru-brigade and its captain. After all it is your group and it is your discretion to run it in any manner you like. I must thank you for appreciating Shree KN Rao whom your Paramaguru had made something like a "bad character" in his mail. With warm regards, Chandrasekhar "Narasimha P.V.R. Rao" <pvr (AT) charter (DOT) net> wrote: Dear Ranjan, Thanks for the thoughts. Just a couple of quick thoughts based on my personal views. The field of Jyotish is undergoing a transformation for sometime now. Sri KN Rao brought one wave of revolution in 1990's. He kicked off the long process of renaissance. Now, a lot of hidden knowledge is coming out and people are seriously discussing BPHS, Jaimini Sutram etc. As I see it, the next quantum leap that is an integral part of the ongoing Jyotish renaissance started a few years back. As a part of this, some good knowledge and some bad knowledge becomes common place. Some people try to resist the change. Some people try to change its direction. People start thinking about the basic issues. Several schools of thought are entering the chruning for Truth, which will continue for 2-3 decades to come. They will all contribute to the on-going process of renaissance. During the transformation time, this will seem like chaos. But this is quite necessary for Truth to come out. Various brawls we see on various Jyotish lists from time to time are a sign of just this. Some people have a scholarly and mature way of dealing with this chaos and contributing to the churning process. Some hot-blooded people unfortunately get carried away and become impatient and violent. That's unfortunate, but they too will learn with experience. I too was hot-blooded. First I learnt faking humility. Then it slowly changed into genuine humility within myself. If I could change, anybody could. But I am confident that a lot of genuine and correct knowledge will come out of all this churning in the next 20-30 years. I am quite confident of that. To see the evolution of Jyotish knowledge in society, look at Jupiter-Ketu conjunctions. Study the rasi and chaturvimsamsa in which they occurred in the last several decades! I predict that 2020-2026 will be a period when the floodgates of Jyotish knowledge will open. Just as I finished writing this line, there was huge lightening outside the window on the east and a really really bright light and a thunder too. I take it as a favorable omen for what I wrote... May Jupiter's light shine on us, Narasimha ------------------------------- Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org ------------------------------- > Dear Akashji/avbhat2005ji,> > Since the moderators have not expunged your message as you wrongly > feared I am tempted to probe a bit further regarding your > observations. Just to clear the air, first, I am not associated with > SJC in any way, other than admiring the work done by some of its > members and senior representatives, some of whose work goes back to > the best of my understanding before they were associated with SJC, > indeed perhpas from even before SJC was formed (some I know since mid > nineties).> > Why do you think this phenomenon of so much repressed anger coming > out over the last couple of months or so, not just on this list but > several other jyotish lists? I also follow a few non-jyotish lists > (mostly science related) and there is no similar phenomenon there. So > we cannot blame it on mars or jupiter or whatever else is happening > in transits. Yet it is curious that it is affecting jyotishis, but > not others, including western astrologers (though I sample more > jyotishis than tropical astrologers so could be a sampling bias).> > Why, dear fellow-astrologers??> > RR> > > --- In vedic astrology, "baksh5" <avbhat2005> > wrote:> >> > Om Namh! Shivaya!> > > > Respected and Learned members of this group.> > > > Moderators you are free to expunge this message. > > > > I have been observing for quite some time the nature and pattern of > > discussions happening in this group. Excellent discussions are > > happening w.r.t Vargas/Divisional charts, Sandhi shanti etc... > which > > is helping students like me in the field of astrology.> > > > But the disturbing point what I noticed is, when certain pointed > > questions are asked, the responders ( can be SJC Guru or anybody > > else) take a defensive attitude and always take the step of exit > > from the discussion or the group.> > > > The latest instance of such a case is from Sri Ramadoss. Everybody > > knows he is a well respected and a learned scholar/astrologer. So > as > > soon as a person asks a detail about Sandhi Shanti, Sri Ramadoss > > says he is turning to spirituality and leaving Jyotisha. It may be > a > > personal choice for Sri Ramadoss, but the timing seemed a bit > > inappropriate for me.> > > > Another instance is of Mr. Surya Rao. He also seems to be a great > > scholar of astrology but his latest outbursts against Sri. PVR > > seemed unwarranted. This is not my call. But I felt it was > > unnecessary.> > > > Another instance is of Mr.Partha who being a SJC guru left his > group > > in a huff!.> > > > Another instance is of Mr. Utpal. He was having very good > > discussions but suddenly felt that he needs to leave this group and > > pursue his other matters.> > > > In all this I felt Sri. Rath and Sri. PVR, Pradeep, Sreenadh and > > couple of other learned members stood their ground and tried to > > clarify the doubts raised and presented their thoughts.> > > > This is an open forum and has the biggest disadvantage that un-> > identified people can come and say whatever derogatory remarks they > > want and scoot without any remorse.> > > > The only point I would like to make is, "Students like me are > > missing the learnings/gyan of astrology in this forum due to exit > of > > gurus/scholars from this group". An earnest request to all is to > > continue with the great discussions and predictions being given in > > this forum from one and all.> > > > With Regards> > /Akash.. FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2005 Report Share Posted November 10, 2005 Dear Mr.Rath, I should answer your first mail addressed to me, before we start a conversation. I appealed you to review the comments, but you didn't. Therefore, presuming your silence as a permission I am into that task. > Don't make cheap remarks. Perhaps - It comes from prejudice of all knowingness! > Learn to give respect and take > respect. Respect should come naturally, and as you are projecting yourself as a guru, you should know it better than me. I am neither a sishya to you nor a guru. We can utmost be friends or not, let the time decide. > and talk straight. If you knew that, you don't have made such statements and would have started a scholarly discussion on the topic at hand. But instead you are trying to agitate the opponent, twist the subject of discussion, and thus trying to escape from facing the real questions! > you sound like K N Rao. > Are you his student? Well, it is dream to be compared to Mr. K. N. Rao. Thanks for you compliment. There might be several students of KN Rao posting in this list, or reading these mails. Try to respect them !!! [To those who don't know who is Mr.K N Rao, here is a small note: Mr. K.N. Rao was a former Auditor General of India, retired in 1990 and is attributed to have single handedly revived the astrology in Northern India. 80% of Astrologers of today owe their knowledge base to him. He fought a case in Supreme Court of India, when UGC introduced astrology as subject in Indian Universities, which was opposed by few and a case was filed in Supreme Court. Mr. K.N. Rao later demonstrated the "super science " called astrology in the Court, and won the case. None of the so called proponents of astrology even when placed in New Delhi, did not attend or contribute to this legal fight. see the top postings on his website www.journalofastrology. com] Only thing I know about you is that once you asked for some data about the researches of Chandra Hari on Ayanamsa to me, and when I send it to you, you never even bothered to say a Thanks !!! That is my first hand impression about you. It is a feeling of great pride when people ask one's Guru - for "such question" is often raised in last, by the persons who reached a logical blind end !!! ( It is also considered as a acknowledgement of a worthy disciple of a Guru !!! ) The name of my Guru may not be known to you, because he is not an Internet buddy - his name is "Raghavan Nambyar". [if I want to boast, I can put it like this: Raghavan Nambyar is the direct sishya of V P K Pothuval, the famous ephemeris creator of Kerala. I have several gurus in various subjects of astrology, and one of them the current scholar member of Edakkade Kokkaniyal family. If you don't know, Kokkaniyal is the prime disciple of Edakkade Namboothiri who wrote Presnamarga. So I could say that my Guru parampara goes up to Presnamargacharya. Now this Kokkaniyal was a sishya of Pazhoor Mana, where Thalakkulathu Bhattathiri, who wrote the Desadhyayi Bhashya of Varaha Hora lived. If you don't know about Desadhyayi, then take Presnamarga and read its first chapter. You will know how much importance Presnamargacharya gives to Desadhyayi and Krishneeyam. So come to the ground, and let us talk about the subject under discussion as two normal people. ( As for the Guru lineage is concerned technically, I am better placed !! ) I appreciate Mr. PVR for his contribution inspite of being "in heat of discussions" and for his astro_product JHC resulting growth of astrology, and because of the fact that he gave the result of his hard work (JHora software) free to the world. I know that he is sincere to the subject he is indulged in. He puts his technical differences with others including you in a polite manner, since he considers you as his Guru, and guru ninda is considered a sin according to Indian tradition. But remember you are neither my guru and nor I am yours. So let us speak like two common individuals who are after the de- mystifying the elements constituting astrology. PVR's goodness act "might" have indirectly helped the cause of SJC or its other SJC-Guru's. Let us talk about the subject in hand like: two sincere seekers of knowledge and the system of astrology, who are willing to share the little knowledge they have. You are just like any other member of the forum, as far as I am concerned, and treat me the same. If my mail sounds rude, then it was asked for. Forget these 2 mails and let us start the discussion. And there also I am interested to talk to you if only it is a debate where both would accept logically correct arguments without prejudice. If one is stubborn and wants to prove that he is right, even when it becomes revealed to others that he is wrong, then I am not interested to enter into controversies.. Now If you are interested to proceed, then let us humbly approach the arguments and astrology systematically, and let us try to draw some conclusions - if at all possible. Let us accept that there might be several areas in this vast subject, where my or your knowledge won't be enough to reveal the possibilities and truths of the original system. But let us try to understand what we can. Finally, we agree to agree or agree to disagree or disagree to disagree !!! I instinctively extend my hand of friendship (our mutual common bond between us i.e. Astrology ) - to accept or reject is your prerogative !! Love, Sreenadh > "Sanjay Rath" <guruji > Mon Nov 7, 2005 11:26 pm > Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Transits in Varga > charts sanjayrath > om namo bhagavate vasudevaya > Sreenadh > Don't make cheap remarks. Learn to give respect and > take respect and talk straight - > you sound like K N Rao. > Are you his student? > With best wishes and warm regards, > Sanjay Rath vedic astrology, "Sanjay Rath" <guruji@s...> wrote: > > > om namo bhagavate vasudevaya > Dear Chandrasekhar > What I have said about K N Rao is not at all odd and is very very sweet compared to what KN Rao has said for years about the real father figure Dr Raman and PUBLISHED about so many vedic astrologers in India and abroad. What I said was the truth when I said that he went to look for 'books under his bed'. Rohini Ranjan and other astrologers were also there in that Majordomo list. Has Sri Rao found those books from under the bed by now or is he still looking? > I will be the first to withdraw my statements about him if he publicly apologizes for what he has said about Dr Raman. > > I have given all the answers to Sri Surya Rao and have asked him to demonstrate how he uses the saptamsa varga...he chose to leave. If he wishes to continue his debate with me in any other forum, I shall be most willing to continue. Can you check with the Jyotish List moderator if they want me there to continue the debate? > > Do not ever be any any wrong impression that I am leaving. I may be slow, I may be bogged down with work, but I will never say die when it comes to standing up for Parasara and Vyasadeva. Please ask Sri Surya Rao to give the answer to the questions I have listed. > > Jaya Jagannath Krishna! > > With best wishes and warm regards, > Sanjay Rath > * * * > Sri Jagannath Center® > 15B Gangaram Hospital Road > New Delhi 110060, India > http://srath.com, +91-11-25717162 > * * * > - > Chandra Sekhar > vedic astrology > Thursday, November 10, 2005 5:23 PM > Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his students > > > Dear Shree Rao, > > Iam happy that you recognize the services of Sri KN Rao and has openely expressed appreciation for him. I am writing this because just two days before, when Mr. Rath snubbed Shree Shreenadh, he had made a derogatory remark like 'Are you a student of KN Rao?' pointing to that there is something wrong with KN Rao and his students. Such language against a father figure of astrology from another Guru sounds very odd. As you said humility is one quality everyone must develop. In your previous mail you have explained the discipline expected but it is my personal feeling that asking somebody to have the homework correctly or not to ask silly question is not a very offensive thing if you see your own Guruji's words with which he guided/snubbed Shree Shreenadhji. > > Your role as a moderator and starter and thus the owner of the group is justified but at the same time you should have given a better treatment to Shree Surya who had made some brilliant postings to which neither you nor your Guruji had no answer. So it may look as if you and Narayana Iyer deliberately intervented to create a conflict and insult the man for the offence of challenging your wisdom. The man who raised impertinent question should also have been humble enough not to stray into an area where Paramguru was engaged in discussion. So even though you say there is a level playing field, it looks as if you have gunned another abhimanyu by orchestrated effort to avoid inconvenient questions that exposed the intellectual bankruptcy of your guru- brigade and its captain. After all it is your group and it is your discretion to run it in any manner you like. I must thank you for appreciating Shree KN Rao whom your Paramaguru had made something like a "bad character" in his mail. > > With warm regards, > Chandrasekhar > > "Narasimha P.V.R. Rao" <pvr@c...> wrote: > Dear Ranjan, > > Thanks for the thoughts. Just a couple of quick thoughts based on my personal views. > > The field of Jyotish is undergoing a transformation for sometime now. Sri KN Rao brought one wave of revolution in 1990's. He kicked off the long process of renaissance. Now, a lot of hidden knowledge is coming out and people are seriously discussing BPHS, Jaimini Sutram etc. As I see it, the next quantum leap that is an integral part of the ongoing Jyotish renaissance started a few years back. As a part of this, some good knowledge and some bad knowledge becomes common place. Some people try to resist the change. Some people try to change its direction. People start thinking about the basic issues. > > Several schools of thought are entering the chruning for Truth, which will continue for 2-3 decades to come. They will all contribute to the on-going process of renaissance. During the transformation time, this will seem like chaos. But this is quite necessary for Truth to come out. Various brawls we see on various Jyotish lists from time to time are a sign of just this. > > Some people have a scholarly and mature way of dealing with this chaos and contributing to the churning process. Some hot-blooded people unfortunately get carried away and become impatient and violent. That's unfortunate, but they too will learn with experience. I too was hot-blooded. First I learnt faking humility. Then it slowly changed into genuine humility within myself. If I could change, anybody could. > > But I am confident that a lot of genuine and correct knowledge will come out of all this churning in the next 20-30 years. I am quite confident of that. > > To see the evolution of Jyotish knowledge in society, look at Jupiter-Ketu conjunctions. Study the rasi and chaturvimsamsa in which they occurred in the last several decades! > > I predict that 2020-2026 will be a period when the floodgates of Jyotish knowledge will open. Just as I finished writing this line, there was huge lightening outside the window on the east and a really really bright light and a thunder too. I take it as a favorable omen for what I wrote... > > May Jupiter's light shine on us, > Narasimha > ------------------------------- > Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net > Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org > Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org > ------------------------------- > > > Dear Akashji/avbhat2005ji, > > > > Since the moderators have not expunged your message as you wrongly > > feared I am tempted to probe a bit further regarding your > > observations. Just to clear the air, first, I am not associated with > > SJC in any way, other than admiring the work done by some of its > > members and senior representatives, some of whose work goes back to > > the best of my understanding before they were associated with SJC, > > indeed perhpas from even before SJC was formed (some I know since mid > > nineties). > > > > Why do you think this phenomenon of so much repressed anger coming > > out over the last couple of months or so, not just on this list but > > several other jyotish lists? I also follow a few non-jyotish lists > > (mostly science related) and there is no similar phenomenon there. So > > we cannot blame it on mars or jupiter or whatever else is happening > > in transits. Yet it is curious that it is affecting jyotishis, but > > not others, including western astrologers (though I sample more > > jyotishis than tropical astrologers so could be a sampling bias). > > > > Why, dear fellow-astrologers?? > > > > RR > > > > > > vedic astrology, "baksh5" <avbhat2005> > > wrote: > > > > > > Om Namh! Shivaya! > > > > > > Respected and Learned members of this group. > > > > > > Moderators you are free to expunge this message. > > > > > > I have been observing for quite some time the nature and pattern of > > > discussions happening in this group. Excellent discussions are > > > happening w.r.t Vargas/Divisional charts, Sandhi shanti etc .... > > which > > > is helping students like me in the field of astrology. > > > > > > But the disturbing point what I noticed is, when certain pointed > > > questions are asked, the responders ( can be SJC Guru or anybody > > > else) take a defensive attitude and always take the step of exit > > > from the discussion or the group. > > > > > > The latest instance of such a case is from Sri Ramadoss. Everybody > > > knows he is a well respected and a learned scholar/ astrologer. So > > as > > > soon as a person asks a detail about Sandhi Shanti, Sri Ramadoss > > > says he is turning to spirituality and leaving Jyotisha. It may be > > a > > > personal choice for Sri Ramadoss, but the timing seemed a bit > > > inappropriate for me. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr. Surya Rao. He also seems to be a great > > > scholar of astrology but his latest outbursts against Sri. PVR > > > seemed unwarranted. This is not my call. But I felt it was > > > unnecessary. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr.Partha who being a SJC guru left his > > group > > > in a huff!. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr. Utpal. He was having very good > > > discussions but suddenly felt that he needs to leave this group and > > > pursue his other matters. > > > > > > In all this I felt Sri. Rath and Sri. PVR, Pradeep, Sreenadh and > > > couple of other learned members stood their ground and tried to > > > clarify the doubts raised and presented their thoughts. > > > > > > This is an open forum and has the biggest disadvantage that un- > > > identified people can come and say whatever derogatory remarks they > > > want and scoot without any remorse. > > > > > > The only point I would like to make is, "Students like me are > > > missing the learnings/gyan of astrology in this forum due to exit > > of > > > gurus/scholars from this group". An earnest request to all is to > > > continue with the great discussions and predictions being given in > > > this forum from one and all. > > > > > > With Regards > > > /Akash.. > > > > -- ---------- > FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. > > > > > > To UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology- (AT) (DOT) com > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > > > Astrology chart Astrology reading Vedic astrology > Divination tool > > > -- ---------- > > > a.. Visit your group "vedic astrology" on the web. > > b.. > vedic astrology > > c.. Terms of Service. > > > -- ---------- > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2005 Report Share Posted November 10, 2005 Dear PVR, If you feel like taking action against someone, you should take action against this person :RATH: who writes such words to a decent member Lokesh: > You can fall at his feet at that is your funeral. > it was your choise to write this nasty mail, > so I have replied and wasted another 15 minutes on another man > who didn't deserve this time. I can't see any decency, manners or diplomacy in such sentences!!! Still this man is boasting that "I am one of the Gurus of Narasimha.." and so and so!!!! You said to me: "If you feel that somebody is behaving arrogantly and insulting others in an astrological discussion, please send a mail to vedic astrology-owner with the offensive mail and a description of exactly what offended you." I am providing that web-address here again for others to send such mails to you. If you are sincere 'take action' !!!! Love, Sreenadh > Sanjay Rath <guruji@s...> wrote: > > om namo bhagavate vasudevaya > Lokesh > > Very sorry that you have also tried to jump into the fray but I will be the spokesperson for a person who is no longer in his body and whose kind words encouraged meto come out of my little orissa world and teach jyotish. > > Have you checked how much he was charging when in the US? Why don't you write to ACVA to find out what he was up to? > > You can fall at his feet at that is your funeral. I will always stand by Dr Raman - whether yesterday, today or tomorrow. I don't want your regard nor that of anyone who has anything to do with KN Rao. That man is the greatest slur that has happened to Vedic Astrology and his back stabbing of Dr Raman shall be remembered by astrologers for many many years to come. > > You, Chandrasekhar and others can write whatever you want, but I am unflinching in this for I cannot forget those few words that Dr Raman wrote as a blessing when he published my first article in the Astrological Magazine. I will stand by him whether he be in his body or not. > > This shall be my last mail on this topic, and I am one of the Gurus of Narasimha and the others are Dr Raman and his father. He has a habitof being pleasant and organises this list - I can be unpleasant with some sometimes. And it was your choise to write this nasty mail, so I have replied and wasted another 15 minutes on another man who didn't deserve this time. > > With best wishes and warm regards, > Sanjay Rath > * * * > Sri Jagannath Center® > 15B Gangaram Hospital Road > New Delhi 110060, India > http://srath.com, +91-11-25717162 > * * * > - > Lokesh Khosla > vedic astrology > Friday, November 11, 2005 8:25 AM > Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his students > > > Mr Rath, > > Are you spokesperson of Dr Raman.? I am not only suprised at your comments but also sense a feeling of jealousy of Mr Rao's success. KN Rao is not only a legend but also a gentleman. I will give you many examples and the prime is the NIS_SWARTH commitment towards astrology. You have no reason to ask for apologise for anyone. If Mr Rao has said something about Dr Raman, he has done it professionally and backed it up with technical reason. At the same time you and lot of your students who will not give PREDICTIONS and not even stand by it. > > On this list I have met Mr Narsimha personally and have great respect for him and when I came to know you were his guru I held you in high regards too . After this email I have no regards for a person who is trying to be vindictive and trying to get back to another person. That is like 2 yrs old. > Secondly, I do respect Mr Rao because I have met him personally, not only he has given predictions , he stood behind them and also look at his commitment, he could have made millions on astrology if he wanted to. Have you looked at horoscopes of individuals and given predictions and Stood by it and that too without any monetary involvement from anyone? Donot bring up here that there is a need to have money in astrology to make it professional. That's totally absurd which I hear from money making astrologers. > > Please be humble and look at your own concious before making such bold statements and that too about someone who has proven time and again that "THERE IS NO BETTER ASTROLOGER THAN MR KN RAO". > > Regards > Lokesh > > > Sanjay Rath <guruji@s...> wrote: > > om namo bhagavate vasudevaya > Dear Chandrasekhar > What I have said about K N Rao is not at all odd and is very very sweet compared to what KN Rao has said for years about the real father figure Dr Raman and PUBLISHED about so many vedic astrologers in India and abroad. What I said was the truth when I said that he went to look for 'books under his bed'. Rohini Ranjan and other astrologers were also there in that Majordomo list. Has Sri Rao found those books from under the bed by now or is he still looking? > I will be the first to withdraw my statements about him if he publicly apologizes for what he has said about Dr Raman. > > I have given all the answers to Sri Surya Rao and have asked him to demonstrate how he uses the saptamsa varga...he chose to leave. If he wishes to continue his debate with me in any other forum, I shall be most willing to continue. Can you check with the Jyotish List moderator if they want me there to continue the debate? > > Do not ever be any any wrong impression that I am leaving. I may be slow, I may be bogged down with work, but I will never say die when it comes to standing up for Parasara and Vyasadeva. Please ask Sri Surya Rao to give the answer to the questions I have listed. > > Jaya Jagannath Krishna! > > With best wishes and warm regards, > Sanjay Rath > * * * > Sri Jagannath Center® > 15B Gangaram Hospital Road > New Delhi 110060, India > http://srath.com, +91-11-25717162 > * * * > - > Chandra Sekhar > vedic astrology > Thursday, November 10, 2005 5:23 PM > Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his students > > > Dear Shree Rao, > > Iam happy that you recognize the services of Sri KN Rao and has openely expressed appreciation for him. I am writing this because just two days before, when Mr. Rath snubbed Shree Shreenadh, he had made a derogatory remark like 'Are you a student of KN Rao?' pointing to that there is something wrong with KN Rao and his students. Such language against a father figure of astrology from another Guru sounds very odd. As you said humility is one quality everyone must develop. In your previous mail you have explained the discipline expected but it is my personal feeling that asking somebody to have the homework correctly or not to ask silly question is not a very offensive thing if you see your own Guruji's words with which he guided/snubbed Shree Shreenadhji. > > Your role as a moderator and starter and thus the owner of the group is justified but at the same time you should have given a better treatment to Shree Surya who had made some brilliant postings to which neither you nor your Guruji had no answer. So it may look as if you and Narayana Iyer deliberately intervented to create a conflict and insult the man for the offence of challenging your wisdom. The man who raised impertinent question should also have been humble enough not to stray into an area where Paramguru was engaged in discussion. So even though you say there is a level playing field, it looks as if you have gunned another abhimanyu by orchestrated effort to avoid inconvenient questions that exposed the intellectual bankruptcy of your guru- brigade and its captain. After all it is your group and it is your discretion to run it in any manner you like. I must thank you for appreciating Shree KN Rao whom your Paramaguru had made something like a "bad character" in his mail. > > With warm regards, > Chandrasekhar > > > "Narasimha P.V.R. Rao" <pvr@c...> wrote: > Dear Ranjan, > > Thanks for the thoughts. Just a couple of quick thoughts based on my personal views. > > The field of Jyotish is undergoing a transformation for sometime now. Sri KN Rao brought one wave of revolution in 1990's. He kicked off the long process of renaissance. Now, a lot of hidden knowledge is coming out and people are seriously discussing BPHS, Jaimini Sutram etc. As I see it, the next quantum leap that is an integral part of the ongoing Jyotish renaissance started a few years back. As a part of this, some good knowledge and some bad knowledge becomes common place. Some people try to resist the change. Some people try to change its direction. People start thinking about the basic issues. > > Several schools of thought are entering the chruning for Truth, which will continue for 2-3 decades to come. They will all contribute to the on-going process of renaissance. During the transformation time, this will seem like chaos. But this is quite necessary for Truth to come out. Various brawls we see on various Jyotish lists from time to time are a sign of just this. > > Some people have a scholarly and mature way of dealing with this chaos and contributing to the churning process. Some hot-blooded people unfortunately get carried away and become impatient and violent. That's unfortunate, but they too will learn with experience. I too was hot-blooded. First I learnt faking humility. Then it slowly changed into genuine humility within myself. If I could change, anybody could. > > But I am confident that a lot of genuine and correct knowledge will come out of all this churning in the next 20-30 years. I am quite confident of that. > > To see the evolution of Jyotish knowledge in society, look at Jupiter-Ketu conjunctions. Study the rasi and chaturvimsamsa in which they occurred in the last several decades! > > I predict that 2020-2026 will be a period when the floodgates of Jyotish knowledge will open. Just as I finished writing this line, there was huge lightening outside the window on the east and a really really bright light and a thunder too. I take it as a favorable omen for what I wrote... > > May Jupiter's light shine on us, > Narasimha > ------------------------------- > Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net > Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org > Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org > ------------------------------- > > > Dear Akashji/avbhat2005ji, > > > > Since the moderators have not expunged your message as you wrongly > > feared I am tempted to probe a bit further regarding your > > observations. Just to clear the air, first, I am not associated with > > SJC in any way, other than admiring the work done by some of its > > members and senior representatives, some of whose work goes back to > > the best of my understanding before they were associated with SJC, > > indeed perhpas from even before SJC was formed (some I know since mid > > nineties). > > > > Why do you think this phenomenon of so much repressed anger coming > > out over the last couple of months or so, not just on this list but > > several other jyotish lists? I also follow a few non-jyotish lists > > (mostly science related) and there is no similar phenomenon there. So > > we cannot blame it on mars or jupiter or whatever else is happening > > in transits. Yet it is curious that it is affecting jyotishis, but > > not others, including western astrologers (though I sample more > > jyotishis than tropical astrologers so could be a sampling bias). > > > > Why, dear fellow-astrologers?? > > > > RR > > > > > > vedic astrology, "baksh5" <avbhat2005 > > > wrote: > > > > > > Om Namh! Shivaya! > > > > > > Respected and Learned members of this group. > > > > > > Moderators you are free to expunge this message. > > > > > > I have been observing for quite some time the nature and pattern of > > > discussions happening in this group. Excellent discussions are > > > happening w.r.t Vargas/Divisional charts, Sandhi shanti etc... > > which > > > is helping students like me in the field of astrology. > > > > > > But the disturbing point what I noticed is, when certain pointed > > > questions are asked, the responders ( can be SJC Guru or anybody > > > else) take a defensive attitude and always take the step of exit > > > from the discussion or the group. > > > > > > The latest instance of such a case is from Sri Ramadoss. Everybody > > > knows he is a well respected and a learned scholar/astrologer. So > > as > > > soon as a person asks a detail about Sandhi Shanti, Sri Ramadoss > > > says he is turning to spirituality and leaving Jyotisha. It may be > > a > > > personal choice for Sri Ramadoss, but the timing seemed a bit > > > inappropriate for me. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr. Surya Rao. He also seems to be a great > > > scholar of astrology but his latest outbursts against Sri. PVR > > > seemed unwarranted. This is not my call. But I felt it was > > > unnecessary. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr.Partha who being a SJC guru left his > > group > > > in a huff!. > > > > > > Another instance is of Mr. Utpal. He was having very good > > > discussions but suddenly felt that he needs to leave this group and > > > pursue his other matters. > > > > > > In all this I felt Sri. Rath and Sri. PVR, Pradeep, Sreenadh and > > > couple of other learned members stood their ground and tried to > > > clarify the doubts raised and presented their thoughts. > > > > > > This is an open forum and has the biggest disadvantage that un- > > > identified people can come and say whatever derogatory remarks they > > > want and scoot without any remorse. > > > > > > The only point I would like to make is, "Students like me are > > > missing the learnings/gyan of astrology in this forum due to exit > > of > > > gurus/scholars from this group". An earnest request to all is to > > > continue with the great discussions and predictions being given in > > > this forum from one and all. > > > > > > With Regards > > > /Akash.. > > > > > > FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. > > > FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. > > > > > > To UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology- (AT) (DOT) com > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > > > > > > > Visit your group "vedic astrology" on the web. > > > vedic astrology > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 10, 2005 Report Share Posted November 10, 2005 I did astrology readings for free for ten years, then, a very senior astrologer told me that I must charge with this reasoning: People tend to take those astrologers seriously who charge. Morever, if you think an Astrologer is providing a service that has a potential to change the native's life for the better, why shouldn't he/she charge? What one charges is immaterial - You can still do it free with those who cannot afford to pay and charge more from those who can. Why should an Astrologer not support himself? Would you say the same thing about Doctors, etc.? I do not mind if Sri K. N. Rao charges or Sri Rath. It is their choice. To All others In my view, Astrology is not a competition wherein the best is decided. There are Yogis, Astrologers and devoted men, who can read more about a person by simply looking at the person than the people we are discussing. Swami Vivekananda himself met such a man who could read any thought you had in your mind and in whatever language. I think he has mentioned that in one of the volumes of Complete works. Forget Yogis, there are some great astrologers who are not known, but read the chart very accurately. I recently met such a pundit. He is from a temple near Har Ki Pauri, Haridwar. There is a lady palmist in Rajpura, near Patiala who is quite good in hand reading. Something can be learnt from others however little their know-how may be. In other words, there will always be someone who knows better than you as long as you are in Maya. Why have such words against each other? If Sri Rao has done some wrong or right action, the Lord is there to give him adequate results and the same goes for Sri Rath or me or you or anyone else. Who are we to decide which human being should get what result? Having said that, I request all to please close this topic. Thanks and Regards Bharat On 11/11/05, Lokesh Khosla <lokesh_khosla2000 > wrote: Mr Rath, Are you spokesperson of Dr Raman.? I am not only suprised at your comments but also sense a feeling of jealousy of Mr Rao's success. KN Rao is not only a legend but also a gentleman. I will give you many examples and the prime is the NIS_SWARTH commitment towards astrology. You have no reason to ask for apologise for anyone. If Mr Rao has said something about Dr Raman, he has done it professionally and backed it up with technical reason. At the same time you and lot of your students who will not give PREDICTIONS and not even stand by it. On this list I have met Mr Narsimha personally and have great respect for him and when I came to know you were his guru I held you in high regards too . After this email I have no regards for a person who is trying to be vindictive and trying to get back to another person. That is like 2 yrs old. Secondly, I do respect Mr Rao because I have met him personally, not only he has given predictions , he stood behind them and also look at his commitment, he could have made millions on astrology if he wanted to. Have you looked at horoscopes of individuals and given predictions and Stood by it and that too without any monetary involvement from anyone? Donot bring up here that there is a need to have money in astrology to make it professional. That's totally absurd which I hear from money making astrologers. Please be humble and look at your own concious before making such bold statements and that too about someone who has proven time and again that "THERE IS NO BETTER ASTROLOGER THAN MR KN RAO". Regards Lokesh Sanjay Rath <guruji (AT) srath (DOT) com> wrote: om namo bhagavate vasudevayaDear Chandrasekhar What I have said about K N Rao is not at all odd and is very very sweet compared to what KN Rao has said for years about the real father figure Dr Raman and PUBLISHED about so many vedic astrologers in India and abroad. What I said was the truth when I said that he went to look for 'books under his bed'. Rohini Ranjan and other astrologers were also there in that Majordomo list. Has Sri Rao found those books from under the bed by now or is he still looking? I will be the first to withdraw my statements about him if he publicly apologizes for what he has said about Dr Raman. I have given all the answers to Sri Surya Rao and have asked him to demonstrate how he uses the saptamsa varga...he chose to leave. If he wishes to continue his debate with me in any other forum, I shall be most willing to continue. Can you check with the Jyotish List moderator if they want me there to continue the debate? Do not ever be any any wrong impression that I am leaving. I may be slow, I may be bogged down with work, but I will never say die when it comes to standing up for Parasara and Vyasadeva. Please ask Sri Surya Rao to give the answer to the questions I have listed. Jaya Jagannath Krishna! With best wishes and warm regards,Sanjay Rath* * *Sri Jagannath Center®15B Gangaram Hospital Road New Delhi 110060, India http://srath.com, +91-11-25717162* * * - Chandra Sekhar vedic astrology Thursday, November 10, 2005 5:23 PM Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his students Dear Shree Rao, Iam happy that you recognize the services of Sri KN Rao and has openely expressed appreciation for him. I am writing this because just two days before, when Mr. Rath snubbed Shree Shreenadh, he had made a derogatory remark like 'Are you a student of KN Rao?' pointing to that there is something wrong with KN Rao and his students. Such language against a father figure of astrology from another Guru sounds very odd. As you said humility is one quality everyone must develop. In your previous mail you have explained the discipline expected but it is my personal feeling that asking somebody to have the homework correctly or not to ask silly question is not a very offensive thing if you see your own Guruji's words with which he guided/snubbed Shree Shreenadhji. Your role as a moderator and starter and thus the owner of the group is justified but at the same time you should have given a better treatment to Shree Surya who had made some brilliant postings to which neither you nor your Guruji had no answer. So it may look as if you and Narayana Iyer deliberately intervented to create a conflict and insult the man for the offence of challenging your wisdom. The man who raised impertinent question should also have been humble enough not to stray into an area where Paramguru was engaged in discussion. So even though you say there is a level playing field, it looks as if you have gunned another abhimanyu by orchestrated effort to avoid inconvenient questions that exposed the intellectual bankruptcy of your guru-brigade and its captain. After all it is your group and it is your discretion to run it in any manner you like. I must thank you for appreciating Shree KN Rao whom your Paramaguru had made something like a "bad character" in his mail. With warm regards, Chandrasekhar "Narasimha P.V.R. Rao" <pvr (AT) charter (DOT) net> wrote: Dear Ranjan, Thanks for the thoughts. Just a couple of quick thoughts based on my personal views. The field of Jyotish is undergoing a transformation for sometime now. Sri KN Rao brought one wave of revolution in 1990's. He kicked off the long process of renaissance. Now, a lot of hidden knowledge is coming out and people are seriously discussing BPHS, Jaimini Sutram etc. As I see it, the next quantum leap that is an integral part of the ongoing Jyotish renaissance started a few years back. As a part of this, some good knowledge and some bad knowledge becomes common place. Some people try to resist the change. Some people try to change its direction. People start thinking about the basic issues. Several schools of thought are entering the chruning for Truth, which will continue for 2-3 decades to come. They will all contribute to the on-going process of renaissance. During the transformation time, this will seem like chaos. But this is quite necessary for Truth to come out. Various brawls we see on various Jyotish lists from time to time are a sign of just this. Some people have a scholarly and mature way of dealing with this chaos and contributing to the churning process. Some hot-blooded people unfortunately get carried away and become impatient and violent. That's unfortunate, but they too will learn with experience. I too was hot-blooded. First I learnt faking humility. Then it slowly changed into genuine humility within myself. If I could change, anybody could. But I am confident that a lot of genuine and correct knowledge will come out of all this churning in the next 20-30 years. I am quite confident of that. To see the evolution of Jyotish knowledge in society, look at Jupiter-Ketu conjunctions. Study the rasi and chaturvimsamsa in which they occurred in the last several decades! I predict that 2020-2026 will be a period when the floodgates of Jyotish knowledge will open. Just as I finished writing this line, there was huge lightening outside the window on the east and a really really bright light and a thunder too. I take it as a favorable omen for what I wrote... May Jupiter's light shine on us, Narasimha ------------------------------- Free Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net Free Jyotish software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org Sri Jagannath Centre (SJC) website: http://www.SriJagannath.org ------------------------------- > Dear Akashji/avbhat2005ji,> > Since the moderators have not expunged your message as you wrongly > feared I am tempted to probe a bit further regarding your > observations. Just to clear the air, first, I am not associated with > SJC in any way, other than admiring the work done by some of its > members and senior representatives, some of whose work goes back to > the best of my understanding before they were associated with SJC, > indeed perhpas from even before SJC was formed (some I know since mid > nineties).> > Why do you think this phenomenon of so much repressed anger coming > out over the last couple of months or so, not just on this list but > several other jyotish lists? I also follow a few non-jyotish lists > (mostly science related) and there is no similar phenomenon there. So > we cannot blame it on mars or jupiter or whatever else is happening > in transits. Yet it is curious that it is affecting jyotishis, but > not others, including western astrologers (though I sample more > jyotishis than tropical astrologers so could be a sampling bias). > > Why, dear fellow-astrologers??> > RR> > > vedic astrology, "baksh5" <avbhat2005> > wrote:> >> > Om Namh! Shivaya! > > > > Respected and Learned members of this group.> > > > Moderators you are free to expunge this message. > > > > I have been observing for quite some time the nature and pattern of > > discussions happening in this group. Excellent discussions are > > happening w.r.t Vargas/Divisional charts, Sandhi shanti etc... > which > > is helping students like me in the field of astrology.> > > > But the disturbing point what I noticed is, when certain pointed > > questions are asked, the responders ( can be SJC Guru or anybody > > else) take a defensive attitude and always take the step of exit > > from the discussion or the group.> > > > The latest instance of such a case is from Sri Ramadoss. Everybody > > knows he is a well respected and a learned scholar/astrologer. So > as > > soon as a person asks a detail about Sandhi Shanti, Sri Ramadoss > > says he is turning to spirituality and leaving Jyotisha. It may be > a > > personal choice for Sri Ramadoss, but the timing seemed a bit > > inappropriate for me.> > > > Another instance is of Mr. Surya Rao. He also seems to be a great > > scholar of astrology but his latest outbursts against Sri. PVR > > seemed unwarranted. This is not my call. But I felt it was > > unnecessary.> > > > Another instance is of Mr.Partha who being a SJC guru left his > group > > in a huff!. > > > > Another instance is of Mr. Utpal. He was having very good > > discussions but suddenly felt that he needs to leave this group and > > pursue his other matters.> > > > In all this I felt Sri. Rath and Sri. PVR, Pradeep, Sreenadh and > > couple of other learned members stood their ground and tried to > > clarify the doubts raised and presented their thoughts. > > > > This is an open forum and has the biggest disadvantage that un-> > identified people can come and say whatever derogatory remarks they > > want and scoot without any remorse. > > > > The only point I would like to make is, "Students like me are > > missing the learnings/gyan of astrology in this forum due to exit > of > > gurus/scholars from this group". An earnest request to all is to > > continue with the great discussions and predictions being given in > > this forum from one and all.> > > > With Regards> > /Akash.. FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. Astrology chart Astrology reading Vedic astrology Divination tool Visit your group "vedic astrology" on the web. vedic astrology Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2005 Report Share Posted November 11, 2005 Well said Bharat! A true astrologer who can see the past and the future should be more spiritual than an ordinary man entangled by maya. But this is earth not heaven. We take birth here to enjoy the blend of good and bad. Let's enjoy the vivacity. > In other words, there will always be someone who knows better than you as > long as you are in Maya. Why have such words against each other? If Sri Rao > has done some wrong or right action, the Lord is there to give him adequate > results and the same goes for Sri Rath or me or you or anyone else. Who are > we to decide which human being should get what result? > > Having said that, I request all to please close this topic. > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 11, 2005 Report Share Posted November 11, 2005 Well said .Astrology is also one of the pious divine tools to alleviate the suffering of the souls . But a few ,the well intentioned service oriented members of such forums and living in other parts of the world rendering astrological service also have potential to become gaurdians of dharma in future as always had been in the past. Noname Noname <nameisego > vedic astrologyTo: vedic astrologySubject: Re: [vedic astrology] Re: Narasimha Rao appreciation - Renaissance - KN Rao & his studentsThu, 10 Nov 2005 19:25:18 -0800 (PST) Dear Friend, You wrote, "Please be humble and look at your own concious before making such bold statements and that too about someone who has proven time and again that "THERE IS NO BETTER ASTROLOGER THAN MR KN RAO" Well, I do not agree with your statement. Not because what you said is wrong . Sri K.N Rao is a very good astrologer no doubt but calling him THE BEST is what I contest. India has many many pious,Vaksiddh astrologers strewn all over who live in villages and have no access to modern technology.They are no less than any Mr. KNR or Sri.SR or Chi. PVNR or such. I hope you understand . Tatvam-Asi FareChase - Search multiple travel sites in one click. Archives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Visit your group "vedic astrology" on the web. vedic astrology Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.