Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear friends It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate house in natal chart as lagna and analyse. Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse (native's mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said to signify mother. Same is the case for mother. Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important relations in chart. Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. Best regards Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Narayanshree, Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India takes 10th house. 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the opinion of 10th house. Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall in 7th from the house of mother. Regards Utpal vedic astrology, "narayanshree" <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > Dear friends > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate house > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse (native's > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said to > signify mother. > > Same is the case for mother. > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > relations in chart. > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > Best regards > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Utpal Ji I had read exactly what you have said but it leaves the problem without solution. One approach may be: the house which works best in majority of chart for father. Another approach may be: we accept what sages said. Can you throw some light on above approach. And, what do we do with bhavat bhavam dictum if above are not in agreement with it. Best regards Shree Narayan vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" <vedic_pathak> wrote: > Dear Narayanshree, > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India takes > 10th house. > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > opinion of 10th house. > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > in 7th from the house of mother. > > Regards > > Utpal > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > Dear friends > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > house > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse (native's > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > to > > signify mother. > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > relations in chart. > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > Best regards > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Narayan Shree, This is not the only issue of varied opinions, there are several much more controversial then that and you surely know about those. in such situation, i take as many charts i can and try to see for my self which works better and form the opinion accordingly. What sages must have said and meant, all the scripts are not available for us now and hence it is always better to verify with the Approach-1 mentioned by you. best regards, utpal vedic astrology, "narayanshree" <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > Dear Utpal Ji > > I had read exactly what you have said but it leaves the problem > without solution. > > One approach may be: the house which works best in majority of chart > for father. > > Another approach may be: we accept what sages said. > > Can you throw some light on above approach. And, what do we do with > bhavat bhavam dictum if above are not in agreement with it. > > Best regards > > Shree Narayan > > vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > <vedic_pathak> wrote: > > Dear Narayanshree, > > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > takes > > 10th house. > > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > > opinion of 10th house. > > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > > in 7th from the house of mother. > > > > Regards > > > > Utpal > > > > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > > Dear friends > > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > > house > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > (native's > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > > to > > > signify mother. > > > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > > relations in chart. > > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > > > Best regards > > > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu || Dear Utpal and NarayanShree, Namaste ! Utpal,your explanation really sounds good. I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by Holy Shri B.V Raman) But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th House) and its strength. These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us more in these situations. || Hare Rama Krishna || Regards, krithi vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" <vedic_pathak> wrote: > Dear Narayanshree, > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India takes > 10th house. > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > opinion of 10th house. > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > in 7th from the house of mother. > > Regards > > Utpal > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > Dear friends > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > house > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse (native's > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > to > > signify mother. > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > relations in chart. > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > Best regards > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Krithi and Utpal What approach Sanjay Ji and other noted scholars of present take .. can you throw some light on it. What has been your experience about it in various charts analysed? Regards Shree Narayan vedic astrology, "Krithigaivasan Radhakrishnan" <krithi.hayagriva@g...> wrote: > || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu || > > Dear Utpal and NarayanShree, > > Namaste ! > > Utpal,your explanation really sounds good. > > I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also > quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by Holy > Shri B.V Raman) > > But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of > native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th House) > and its strength. > > These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors > always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us more > in these situations. > > || Hare Rama Krishna || > > Regards, > > krithi > vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > <vedic_pathak> wrote: > > Dear Narayanshree, > > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > takes > > 10th house. > > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > > opinion of 10th house. > > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > > in 7th from the house of mother. > > > > Regards > > > > Utpal > > > > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > > Dear friends > > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > > house > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > (native's > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > > to > > > signify mother. > > > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > > relations in chart. > > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > > > Best regards > > > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 I think Sanjay ji takes 9th, Dr Raman use to consider 9th, K.N.Rao ji considers 9th. Ashwin Rawal takes 10th....... I also consider 9th after having more experiences (Earlier, i mean 6 years back, i use to take 10th). one more thing is also noteworthy is that following of Ancestoral profession concept has almost died. what would you prefer? regards, utpal narayanshree <shree.narayan (AT) fluor (DOT) com> wrote: Dear Krithi and UtpalWhat approach Sanjay Ji and other noted scholars of present take .. can you throw some light on it.What has been your experience about it in various charts analysed?RegardsShree Narayan--- In vedic astrology, "Krithigaivasan Radhakrishnan" <krithi.hayagriva@g...> wrote:> || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu ||> > Dear Utpal and NarayanShree,> > Namaste !> > Utpal,your explanation really sounds good.> > I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also > quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by Holy > Shri B.V Raman)> > But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of > native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th House) > and its strength.> > These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors > always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us more > in these situations.> > || Hare Rama Krishna ||> > Regards,> > krithi> > > > > > > > --- In vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > <vedic_pathak> wrote:> > Dear Narayanshree,> > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father.> > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > takes > > 10th house.> > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > > opinion of 10th house.> > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > > in 7th from the house of mother.> > > > Regards> > > > Utpal> > > > > > --- In vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote:> > > Dear friends> > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > > house > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse.> > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > (native's > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > > to > > > signify mother.> > > > > > Same is the case for mother.> > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > > relations in chart.> > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts.> > > > > > Best regards> > > > > > Shree NarayanArchives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Start your day with - make it your home page Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 || Om Gurave Namah || Dear Friends, The Bhavata Bhavam principle has to be used with thought. Just applying the House meaning 'as is' to other houses from houses may lead to mistakes. For example if 12th is called Vyaya and one calls Vyaya as Loss, then if apply 12th from 10th is loss of 10th. Then you get Dharma is 'Loss' for Karma!. Which is not true. Now the students may think as to how exactly to use 'Bhavaat Bhavam' principle. Regarding 10th house, 10th house is the heaven or sky, it's diety is Indra, Indra is like Vishnu for Bhu loka needs(only). 10th house is the provider. In single income family there is usually one person who earns or in case of Joint families where married siblings stay together All income is usually given to the Head of the family, There fore that person acts as the 10th house. Usually it's the Father of the house. Warm Regards Sanjay P Hari Om Tat Sat vedic astrology, "Krithigaivasan Radhakrishnan" <krithi.hayagriva@g...> wrote: > || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu || > > Dear Utpal and NarayanShree, > > Namaste ! > > Utpal,your explanation really sounds good. > > I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also > quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by Holy > Shri B.V Raman) > > But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of > native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th House) > and its strength. > > These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors > always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us more > in these situations. > > || Hare Rama Krishna || > > Regards, > > krithi > vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > <vedic_pathak> wrote: > > Dear Narayanshree, > > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > takes > > 10th house. > > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > > opinion of 10th house. > > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > > in 7th from the house of mother. > > > > Regards > > > > Utpal > > > > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > > Dear friends > > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > > house > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > (native's > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > > to > > > signify mother. > > > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > > relations in chart. > > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > > > Best regards > > > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Sanjay Ji & friends While I agree that this principle should be applied carefully, I have slightly different opinion about the example given for 10th house. 10H is for karma. 9H is for dharma. 12th house from any house is vyay. When one gets "more" involved in karma, his dharma starts to suffer. Best example is in family: when one starts to spend more time in office (karma) his care for family starts suffering (dharma). In fact its convers is also true: when one gets more involved in dharma, his karma starts suffering. again, above example is applicable only in other direction. Is it not bhavat bhavam extended here. shall appreciate if you can clarify. best regards Shree Narayan vedic astrology, "sanjayprabhakaran" <sanjaychettiar@g...> wrote: > || Om Gurave Namah || > > Dear Friends, > The Bhavata Bhavam principle has to be used with thought. Just > applying the House meaning 'as is' to other houses from houses may > lead to mistakes. > For example if 12th is called Vyaya and one calls Vyaya as Loss, then > if apply 12th from 10th is loss of 10th. Then you get Dharma is > 'Loss' for Karma!. Which is not true. Now the students may think as > to how exactly to use 'Bhavaat Bhavam' principle. > > Regarding 10th house, 10th house is the heaven or sky, it's diety is > Indra, Indra is like Vishnu for Bhu loka needs(only). 10th house is > the provider. > In single income family there is usually one person who earns or in > case of Joint families where married siblings stay together All income > is usually given to the Head of the family, There fore that person > acts as the 10th house. Usually it's the Father of the house. > > Warm Regards > Sanjay P > > Hari Om Tat Sat > > > > > > vedic astrology, "Krithigaivasan Radhakrishnan" > <krithi.hayagriva@g...> wrote: > > || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu || > > > > Dear Utpal and NarayanShree, > > > > Namaste ! > > > > Utpal,your explanation really sounds good. > > > > I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also > > quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by Holy > > Shri B.V Raman) > > > > But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of > > native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th House) > > and its strength. > > > > These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors > > always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us more > > in these situations. > > > > || Hare Rama Krishna || > > > > Regards, > > > > krithi > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > > <vedic_pathak> wrote: > > > Dear Narayanshree, > > > > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related to > > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of Father. > > > > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > > takes > > > 10th house. > > > > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of Karma > > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father was > > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence the > > > opinion of 10th house. > > > > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma to a > > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't fall > > > in 7th from the house of mother. > > > > > > Regards > > > > > > Utpal > > > > > > > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > > > Dear friends > > > > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the appropriate > > > house > > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > > (native's > > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is said > > > to > > > > signify mother. > > > > > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most important > > > > relations in chart. > > > > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > > > > > Best regards > > > > > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Hare Rama Krishna Dear Narayanashree & friends, Namaskar Let me answer it this way:- We know that the position of planets we take is a geo-centric representation. The purpose of erecting a kundali is to study the native born on the planet Earth. Same way the application of Jyotish principles is to capture the native's point of view. (it can certainly be extended but to a limited extent) Consider the following, if you are reading two brothers' charts and arrive at two different descriptions(not necessarily physical) of their father, what it means; it means that these are the two descriptions of the same father from their respective view points. We should not take this toofar to say that mother is the wife of Father, daughter of grand father and so on and so forth. My opinion is it is not meant to be used in this manner. For the naive 4th from Lagna is Mother, 9th from Lagna is Father etc.,. If younger sibling is 3rd house & elder sibling is 11th house - should we see 5th, from 11th i.e., 3rd, to understand younger sibling? Confusing. So, this arguement may not be used for saying 10th as the house of father. Also to read parents, D12 is the more appropriate chart. 9th house in D1 can be father or Guru etc., also. Just a view point :-)) Any comments?!! regards Surya > > vedic astrology, "sanjayprabhakaran" > <sanjaychettiar@g...> wrote: > > || Om Gurave Namah || > > > > Dear Friends, > > The Bhavata Bhavam principle has to be used with thought. Just > > applying the House meaning 'as is' to other houses from houses may > > lead to mistakes. > > For example if 12th is called Vyaya and one calls Vyaya as Loss, > then > > if apply 12th from 10th is loss of 10th. Then you get Dharma is > > 'Loss' for Karma!. Which is not true. Now the students may think > as > > to how exactly to use 'Bhavaat Bhavam' principle. > > > > Regarding 10th house, 10th house is the heaven or sky, it's diety > is > > Indra, Indra is like Vishnu for Bhu loka needs(only). 10th house is > > the provider. > > In single income family there is usually one person who earns or > in > > case of Joint families where married siblings stay together All > income > > is usually given to the Head of the family, There fore that person > > acts as the 10th house. Usually it's the Father of the house. > > > > Warm Regards > > Sanjay P > > > > Hari Om Tat Sat > > > > > > > > > > > > vedic astrology, "Krithigaivasan > Radhakrishnan" > > <krithi.hayagriva@g...> wrote: > > > || Haya Mukha Siddhi Rastu || > > > > > > Dear Utpal and NarayanShree, > > > > > > Namaste ! > > > > > > Utpal,your explanation really sounds good. > > > > > > I remember that in Prasna Tantra,Shri Neelakanta Daivagyna also > > > quotes 10th house for Father.(Ref Prasna Tantra translated by > Holy > > > Shri B.V Raman) > > > > > > But in BPHS Maharishi Parasara clearly explains the life of > > > native's father by considering the lord of Dharma Bhava(9th > House) > > > and its strength. > > > > > > These difference of opinion between the great divine scholors > > > always confuses the learners like us.May be gurus shall guide us > more > > > in these situations. > > > > > > || Hare Rama Krishna || > > > > > > Regards, > > > > > > krithi > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > vedic astrology, "utpal pathak" > > > <vedic_pathak> wrote: > > > > Dear Narayanshree, > > > > > > > > Though there is no difference of opinion for the house related > to > > > > mother, there is some difference of opinion for the house of > Father. > > > > > > > > Major astrological fraternity considers 9th house as house for > > > > Father, some astrologers, especially in northern part of India > > > takes > > > > 10th house. > > > > > > > > 10th house is 7th from mother's house and also the house of > Karma > > > > (Profession). In those earlier days, native use to take-up the > > > > profession of his father (ancestors) in most cases and father > was > > > > usually the main guiding force in work area for jataka, hence > the > > > > opinion of 10th house. > > > > > > > > Father is the first person, who gives the knowledge of Dharma > to a > > > > native, hence the majority (especially in south India) of > > > > astrologers considers 9th house for father even if it doesn't > fall > > > > in 7th from the house of mother. > > > > > > > > Regards > > > > > > > > Utpal > > > > > > > > > > > > vedic astrology, "narayanshree" > > > > <shree.narayan@f...> wrote: > > > > > Dear friends > > > > > > > > > > It is said that to know about any relation take the > appropriate > > > > house > > > > > in natal chart as lagna and analyse. > > > > > > > > > > Taking this priciple for Father (9th house) - his spouse > > > (native's > > > > > mother) i.e. 7th from 9th is 3rd house whereas 4th house is > said > > > > to > > > > > signify mother. > > > > > > > > > > Same is the case for mother. > > > > > > > > > > Why this priciple is not applicable for these two most > important > > > > > relations in chart. > > > > > > > > > > Shall appreciate if you can claer my doubts. > > > > > > > > > > Best regards > > > > > > > > > > Shree Narayan Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 We know that the position of planets we take is a geo-centricrepresentation. Would love to hear the gurus' verdict on this one, because I don't use geocentric settings in JH. We should not take this too far to say that mother is the wife of Father In some cases, she could be, you know :^)If younger sibling is 3rd house & elder sibling is 11th house - should we see 5th, from 11th i.e., 3rd, to understand younger sibling? I thought the logic behind this was that 3rd from 11th is the younger, and 3rd thereon (which is the 3rd house) the other younger one. Much like how the 6th represents higher education, being 3rd from 4th.Energumen-----Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play?Tired of spam? Mail has the best spam protection around Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 14, 2005 Report Share Posted July 14, 2005 Dear Energumen Just a query: does 5H represent primary education & 5th to 5H i.e. 9H higher education... or 6H shows higher education? Regards Shree Narayan vedic astrology, Energumen <vernalagnia> wrote: > SuryaViswanadham <vishwanatham@g...> wrote: > We know that the position of planets we take is a geo-centric > representation. > > Would love to hear the gurus' verdict on this one, because I don't use geocentric settings in JH. > > We should not take this too far to say that mother is the wife of Father > > In some cases, she could be, you know :^) > > If younger sibling is 3rd house & elder sibling is 11th house - should we see 5th, from 11th i.e., 3rd, to understand younger sibling? > > > I thought the logic behind this was that 3rd from 11th is the younger, and 3rd thereon (which is the 3rd house) the other younger one. Much like how the 6th represents higher education, being 3rd from 4th. > > > > Energumen > > ----- > Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play? > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 15, 2005 Report Share Posted July 15, 2005 Higher: 3H from 4H = 6H Narayana dasa of D-1, which is essentially a form of progression of the lagna, should also give vital clues.narayanshree <shree.narayan (AT) fluor (DOT) com> wrote: Dear EnergumenJust a query: does 5H represent primary education & 5th to 5H i.e. 9H higher education... or 6H shows higher education?RegardsShree NarayanEnergumen-----Other than that, Mrs. Lincoln, how was the play? Start your day with - make it your home page Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.