Marriage Puzzle Answer ! (Narasimha)

[Guest guest]

Dear Jeyaram,

 

> But there is one question I am not able to answer: When an event > like

MARRIAGE is once-in-a-lifetime to a traditional Hindu, how > could the DASA(s)

not point the event correctly which TP was able to > point out? Are we missing

something here ? Does the DASA analysis > change if MOON SIGN is taken as lagna

instead of SCORPIO as it is > much stronger than lagna?

 

It is not true that dasas did not show the event. The problem is that multiple

dates out of the four dates given by you can be justified using dasas. On the

contrary, annual TP chart of one date really stood out.

 

As far as my understanding of dasas goes, there is no magical and consistently

replicable formula to say that marriage is given in the mahadasa of X and

antardasa of Y. There are multiple planets that become candidates to give an

event and it is not easy to pick one planet confidently at the mahadasa,

antardasa and pratyantardasa levels. Of course, it could just be a limitation

of my knowledge. But I am much more comfortable relying on annual TP charts to

make precise predictions.

 

Ideal application of dasas requires combining three factors - (1) natal chart,

(2) dasa pravesha chart and (3) transit chart. Dasas, antardasas etc should be

judged using these three factors. However, (2) is often ignored due to accuracy

considerations and often we ignore (3) too (for no reason). Relying on natal

chart alone to judge dasas is quite fallible. There may be 3 or 4 planets that

can give marriage as per natal chart. Why does only one planet give marriage in

its antardasa?

 

For example, I micro-rectified my own chart thoroughly and explained tens of

events upto deha-antardasa level (6th level!) of Vimsottari dasa, using a very

consistent methodology. What I found in that exercise is that dasa pravesha

chakra is very important. If your dasa calculations are extremely accurate

(which requires a superfine rectification, invariably involving many rounds of

trial and error), dasa pravesha chakra will work nicely.

 

A lot of Jyotish we do these days is an art rather than a science. But there are

scientific, systematic and replicable aspects of Jyotish. When the time comes,

they will come out in the open.

 

> Blessed are those who are able to get > answers from you and Sanjay ji during

their formative stages in > Astrology learning!

I am flattered, but honestly I just share my 2 cents based on my limited

reading, limited experience and limited thinking. If any students think that I

know a lot and that they are "blessed" to get clarifications from me, they have

wrong expectations. Sanjay ji is on a different intellectual plane altogether.

 

May Jupiter's light shine on

us,Narasimha-------------------------------Free

Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.netFree Jyotish software

(Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org

SJC website:

http://www.SriJagannath.org-------------------------------

 

> Dear Narasimha Ji,> > Namaste!> > Thanks for the encouraging remarks about the

puzzle. > > I am sorry that I missed the following message posted by Mr. >

Palanivelu before I posted the answer:>

vedic astrology/message/57260.> > I downloaded

the MP3 and listened to the audio. I must agree that it > was quite

inconclusive during the DASA ANALYSIS but TP gave a very > accurate picture. >

> My hearty congratulations to you and your students on getting it > right!> >

But there is one question I am not able to answer: When an event > like

MARRIAGE is once-in-a-lifetime to a traditional Hindu, how > could the DASA(s)

not point the event correctly which TP was able to > point out? Are we missing

something here ? Does the DASA analysis > change if MOON SIGN is taken as lagna

instead of SCORPIO as it is > much stronger than lagna? Blessed are those who

are able to get > answers from you and Sanjay ji during their formative stages

in > Astrology learning!> > Thanks & Respectful Regards> Jeyaram>

--> > > > ---

In , "pvr108" <pvr@c...> wrote:> > Namaste Jeyaram,>

> > > Congratulations to those who solved this puzzle correctly! This > >

puzzle is a trend-setter in several ways, as it was objective with > > A, B, C,

D choices and a nice summary of all the attempts is given > > at the end

complete with all the links!> > > > BTW, we discussed this puzzle in my Sunday

class at Dracut (near > > Boston) on last Sunday (May 22). My class too chose

option C.> > > > With Dwisaptati sama dasa and Narayana dasa, we did not get a

> clear > > picture. We jumped back and forth and were not sure. However, when >

> we saw the annual Tithi Pravesha chart (lunar return chart), we > were > >

fully convinced that May 9, 1997 must have been the marriage date. > > It was

crystal clear based on TP. So our final choice was option C.> > > > To hear

the discussion we had at my class on this puzzle, please > go > > to> > > >

http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net> > > > and downlaod lesson 42 (22 May

2005). I am happy for the students -> > > they started astrology only one year

back have solved yet another > > puzzle correctly!> > > > May Jupiter's light

shine on us, > > Narasimha > >

-------------------------------> > Free

Jyotish lessons (MP3): http://vedicastro.home.comcast.net> > Free Jyotish

software (Windows): http://www.VedicAstrologer.org> > SJC website:

http://www.SriJagannath.org> >

-------------------------------> > > > >

Respected Gurus & List Members,> > > > > > Many thanks for participating in the

Marriage Puzzle cross-> posted > > on > > > several . I must say

that it was a great learning > > > experience for me. I am sure that other list

members too would > > have > > > benefited immensely by the analyses of the

puzzle.> > > > > > Well, the answer to the puzzle is > > > > > > Option C) May

9, 1997> > > > > > Only Utpal Pathak & Panditji hit the bull's eye! My hearty >

> > congratulations to both of you!> > > > > > The other members who came very

close were Pradeep Gurav, > > Raghunath > > > Rao Nemani and to certain extent

Sarbani Sarkar. They all > arrived > > at > > > January 26, 1997 which was

incidently the date of the couples' > > > engagement.> > > > > > Thanking you

all once again,> > > Jeyaram> > > > > > Following is the message index of the

puzzle on various groups:> > > > > > Vedic Astrology Group:> > >

--------------> > > Marriage Puzzle :

vedic astrology/message/56925> > > Pradeep Gurav :

vedic astrology/message/56933> > >

vedic astrology/message/56945> > > Utpal Pathak :

vedic astrology/message/56935> > >

vedic astrology/message/57003> > >

vedic astrology/message/57004> > > Rema Menon :

vedic astrology/message/56943> > >

vedic astrology/message/57018> > > Ken :

vedic astrology/message/56950> > > Lyudmila :

vedic astrology/message/56975> > > Eveningwish :

vedic astrology/message/56977> > > Raghunatha Rao :

vedic astrology/message/57064> > > Panditji :

vedic astrology/message/57122> > >

--------------> > > > > > Gajapati Group:> > >

--------------> > > Marriage Puzzle :

Gajapati/message/784> > > Utpal Pathak : Gajapati/message/792> > >

Gajapati/message/806> > > Gajapati/message/807> > >

Hari : Gajapati/message/809> > >

Gajapati/message/843> > > Sarbani Sarkar : Gajapati/message/839> > >

--------------> > > > > > Srijagannath Group:>

> > --------------> > > Marriage Puzzle :

/message/13536> > > Samir Shah : /message/13554> >

> /message/13584> > >

/message/13618> > > --------------