More& India's chart

[Guest guest]

Dear Learned

Members,

 

This is a top level

discussion going on

and i know i must

not budge in. Many

have spoken on

behalf of good

intentioned Jay so i

wont say anything on

this . I agree with

you Sundeepji, but

if i am permitted to

suggest, if the list

is going to discuss

BJPs 14 year rule,

could the Gurus also

discuss along with

it India's chart for

the next 14 years

period - we could

atleast know if our

india would progress

or move backwards in

these 14 yrs to

come. Surely India

would become a

superpower i feel

but does it say

astrologically and

would poverty be

eradicated ( sorry

high hopes) or

atleast reduced and

literacy increased

in these periods.

 

 

i am quite sure many

people would like to

see this or compare

charts of the ruling

partys performance

and the countries

performance and see

if both match

astrologically

 

best Joy

 

 

Sunil John

Mumbai

------- Original

message -------

 

vedicastrostudent

<vedicastrostudent

Thu, 15 Jan

2004 19:24:42 -0000

Subject:

[vedic astrology]

Re: More links

 

Sorry for the

previous empty post.

I have to chip in

for Jay here

even though I dont

know him. His points

are undoubtedly

valid and

well meaning and

something I have

wondered as well. If

a strong

public prediction

such as this one is

made, then the

detailed

justification for it

must also be

publicly made,

however that

justification would

make no sense in the

Times of India,

since the

audience is not

astrology-savvy. But

in a publicly

maintained and

archived list like

this and others, it

would make a lot of

sense,

exactly as Jay says.

And it has to be

done now, not after

the fact.

 

In case the

prediction comes

right, or even if it

goes wrong, the

techniques can be

analyzed to the

benefit of all

students. I

personally wouldnt

even doubt Sanjay if

it went wrong - as

long as I

can see the post

mortem analysis of

the previously

posted detailed

justification and

learn from the

mistakes if any.

 

JMHO,

 

Sundeep

 

 

 

--- In

vedic astrology,

"pvr108" wrote:

> Dear Jay,

>

> Just because a

leading astrologer

ridiculed such

long-term

> predictions in

another list, don't

assume that these

> predictions are

risky or just

guessworks as

alleged by him.

>

> I am pretty sure

Sanjay ji made the

prediction on a

sound

> basis, using the

chart of the BJP

party. Of course,

> political parties

also have charts and

they are as

> important as the

charts of political

leaders.

>

> Have you checked

the dasas running in

the BJP chart?

>

> May Jupiter's

light shine on us,

> Narasimha

>

> > Dear Sanjay,

> > I gladly share

this happy occasion

of publicity to you,

Jyotisha

> and SJC.

> > However reading

the article I could

not resist lifting

an

eyebrows

> when I

>

> read this:

> > years.>

> >

> > I am not into

mundane astrology,

but isn't it a bit

dangerous to

> make such a

>

> long term

political statement

?

> > Imagine all the

"anti astrology"

forces just waiting

for this

kind

> of

>

> statement to go

wrong, especially

when it is made for

a political

> party, not a

>

> single person.

> > I humbly expect

you to at least make

us (who could not

participate

> in the

>

> conference) a bit

wiser and reveal the

underlying

astrological

facts

> that lead

>

> to this statement.

> >

> > Kindest regards

> > /Jay Weiss

 

 

Archives:

vedic astrology

 

Group info:

vedic astrology/info.html

 

To UNSUBSCRIBE:

Blank mail to

vedic astrology-

 

...... May

Jupiter's light

shine on us .......

 

|| Om Tat Sat ||

Sarvam Sri

Krishnaarpanamastu

||

 

To visit your group

on the web, go to:

vedic astrology/

 

To from

this group, send an

email to:

vedic astrology

 

Your use of

Groups is subject

to:

 

Book cheap flights http://www.cheapflights.co.uk/?source=lycosgen , holidays

http://www.cheapholidaydeals.co.uk/?source=lycosgen and short breaks

http://www.cheapholidaydeals.co.uk/short-breaks/?source=lycosgen now!

Cheapflights.co.uk http://www.cheapflights.co.uk/?source=lycosgen ; the web's

travel search engine

[Guest guest]

Dear Sunil,

I am a lot less knowledgeable than you are so the "ji" title is

really undeserved. However, my point is a bit different from yours -

you want a lot of things discussed which is very good. I am only

asking a bare minimum as a rigorous protocol to be followed for

building a solid and invincible reputation. For e.g. when Einstein

claimed e=mc**2, in the public newspapers you see only something

like "Energy Mass Equivalence Discovered!!!". But in the public

research journals of physics, you see the full detail. I am only

suggesting a similar approach, and ONLY for public predictions. Times

of India: "BJP will stay in power for 14 years says leading

astrologer". SJC list or some public astrological forum: the details.

This is what I believe Jay had in mind.

 

Sundeep