Guest guest Posted November 29, 2003 Report Share Posted November 29, 2003 I remember reading some where that the stronger of moon and lagna is to be used for determining the vimsottari dasa of a person. Most astrologers seem to be intent upon using the moon exclusively. This may work well at the level of analysis that most people use which typically stops at the third level. 1. If more than one starting point is possible, and we are just using the strongest influence among a multiplicity of possible starting points to determine the dasas, isn't it logical that when you go to such a fine analysis as the sixth level of analysis you will encounter a high level of inaccuracy? 2. Also, can you please quote which texts prescribe using Surya lagna to analyze Rasi chart? It is surprising to me that you give Surya lagna precedence over both lagna and chandra lagna. If this is a strategy that you developed on your own, it would be interesting to know what kind of statistics you used to come to this conclusion. Best, Krishna > Om Gurave Namah > Namaste friends, > > I taught Vimsottari dasa interpretation at an SJC workshop at Edison, NJ on Vijaya Dasami day (4th October 2003). I covered the interpretation of Vimsottari dasa upto six levels (upto deha- antardasa). Pt. Sanjay Rath, my guru, told me to write a small article on it on this list, so that those who do not have access to the CD's also get this important knowledge. I did not get chance to do that until now. > > This topic was covered for 1.5-2 hours. The Vimsottari dasa workshop was for 2 days. I taught for 1.5 days and Narayan Iyer taught for half a day. Those who want to go through the rest of the material and want to get the CD's when they are ready may kindly contact Narayan at narayan@s... > > * * * > > Warning > > If there is an error of 1 minute in birthtime, Vimsottari dasa start dates can change by upto 5 days! If there is an error of just 1 arc-min in the ayanamsa used, Vimsottari dasa start dates can change by upto 9 days! Thus, the Vimsottari dasa dates one has can be off by many days. So, it is pointless to analyze Vimsottari dasa upto six levels without finely rectifying the birthtime. > > Even after the birthtime is finely rectified, it is possible that Vimsottari dasa start days are slightly off by a few days. Even if the birthtime is accurate and lagna and special lagnas in all divisional charts are correct, still there may be a minute error in Moon's longitude and there may be an error in the dasa dates because of it. This can be due to a minute error in ayanamsa or many such reasons. For example, we take the gravitational center of Moon when finding the longitude (sphuta) of Moon. It is possible that Moon's influence on our fortunes is not due to gravitational force and due to some other spiritual force that is yet to be understood by science. If that is the case and the spiritual center of Moon is slightly off from the gravitational center, that can also change Moon's longitude slightly. > > Thus, it is important to do the following when using Vimsottari dasa upto six levels. > > (1) Rectify the birthtime accurately, so that lagna and special lagnas in various divisional charts make sense > (2) Rectify the dasa dates and adjust them slightly if needed > > The standard example we will take was rectified by me, based on tens of life events. The birthdata is: 4th April 1970, 5:47:13 pm (IST), Machilipatnam, India (81e8, 16n10). Vimsottari dasa was further rectified by subtracting 1 day 4 hr 17 min from all the dates. This can be due to ayanamsa error or some other error that we do not yet understand. Please be advised that this error is not necessarily a constant for all charts (even if it is just an ayanamsa error). > > [Note: The latest version of Jagannatha Hora commercial software allows the users to play with the dasa dates and adjust them.] > > Interpreting Six Levels > > The following references can be used when interpreting the six levels: > > (1) Mahadasa (MD): Sun > (2) Antardasa (AD): Moon > (3) Pratyantardasa (PD): Lagna > (4) Sookshma-antardasa (SD): Atma karaka (AK, and other chara karakas) > (5) Praana-antardasa (PAD): Pranapada lagna (and arudha padas) > (5) Deha-antardasa (DAD): Lagna > > In addition, we can take the planet ruling a period as the reference when judging the results of the next level periods. For example, PAD lord can be taken as the reference when judging the DADs. > > Examples > > (1) The native got married on 1st August 1993 at 9:30 pm (IST). > > The dasa calculations are given below: > > Vimsottari Dasa (started from Moon): > > Sat MD: 1975-12-29 (8:04:41) - 1994-12-29 (4:56:06) > Jup AD: 1992-06-16 (2:18:46) - 1994-12-29 (4:56:06) > Ket PD: 1993-07-23 (6:05:02) - 1993-09-16 (11:33:05) > Ven SD: 1993-07-26 (12:03:05) - 1993-08-04 (18:36:08) > Sat PAD: 1993-08-01 (10:54:12) - 1993-08-02 (22:07:38) > > Deha-antardasas in this PAD: > > Sat: 1993-08-01 (10:54:12) - 1993-08-01 (16:28:52) > Merc: 1993-08-01 (16:28:52) - 1993-08-01 (21:28:17) > >>>> Ket: 1993-08-01 (21:28:17) - 1993-08-01 (23:31:35) > Ven: 1993-08-01 (23:31:35) - 1993-08-02 (5:23:49) > Sun: 1993-08-02 (5:23:49) - 1993-08-02 (7:09:32) > Moon: 1993-08-02 (7:09:32) - 1993-08-02 (10:05:39) > Mars: 1993-08-02 (10:05:39) - 1993-08-02 (12:08:55) > Rah: 1993-08-02 (12:08:55) - 1993-08-02 (17:25:53) > Jup: 1993-08-02 (17:25:53) - 1993-08-02 (22:07:38) > > Let us interpret this dasa using the navamsa chart, which was recommended by Parasara for seeing one's marriage. > > Saturn is the lord of Surya lagna. His MD is capable of giving marriage. Taking Moon as the reference, Jupiter is the 7th lord in 7th. His AD is capable of giving marriage. Ketu is the 7th lord from lagna and his PD can give marriage. Though Mars is also a 7th lord, Ketu is the 7th lord in 5th and Mars is the 7th lord in 8th. So Ketu is more capable of giving marriage than the other 7th lord Mars. > > The SD is of Venus. Why? Use chara karakas for SD. Moon is AK. Venus is in 1st house from him. Moreover, he is the 7th lord from DK (Mercury). DK shows spouse. The 7th from DK shows the native, from the point of view of interacting with spouse. Its lord is Venus. The link between AK and the 7th from DK should be seen for finding the SD of marriage. It is Venus here. > > Pranapada lagna in navamsa chart is in Aquarius. From Aq, Saturn is the 1st lord in 7th. Due to exchange with Sun, he in fact gives the results of 7th lord in 7th. So, he is the perfect candidate for giving marriage in his PAD. Finally, DAD is again that of Ketu and it was explained earlier. > > The native for married in Ketu DAD. Then all the guests had a dinner, but the native and his wife had to wait. They did more rituals and got a chance to eat only after Venus DAD started. They had dinner a little before midnight. Considering that Venus is the 2nd lord in rasi chart, he can give nice food. Being the 9th lord in rasi chart, he can also give rituals etc. The native and his wife continued the rituals for a few more hours, after the nice wedding dinner. They left for home early in the dinner and slept for a few hours. During Sun DAD, the native was sleeping. It may be noted that Sun is the lord of the 12th house of sleep. Especially, as Sun is placed in the 12th from PAD lord (Saturn) in rasi chart, apart from owning the 12th house from lagna, his DAD is perfectly capable of giving sleep. > > (2) The native lost his job on 12th August 2002 at 4:15 pm (EDT). > > The dasa calculations are given below: > > Vimsottari Dasa (started from Moon): > > Merc MD: 1994-12-28 (19:26:06) - 2011-12-29 (4:07:51) > Moon AD: 2002-01-27 (1:32:55) - 2003-06-29 (2:15:01) > Jup PD: 2002-06-27 (12:43:55) - 2002-09-06 (11:15:15) > Ven SD: 2002-08-01 (13:33:03) - 2002-08-13 (9:16:40) > Merc PAD: 2002-08-11 (0:36:45) - 2002-08-12 (16:45:13) > > Deha-antardasas in this PAD: > > Merc: 2002-08-11 (0:36:45) - 2002-08-11 (6:18:00) > Ket: 2002-08-11 (6:18:00) - 2002-08-11 (8:38:31) > Ven: 2002-08-11 (8:38:31) - 2002-08-11 (15:19:57) > Sun: 2002-08-11 (15:19:57) - 2002-08-11 (17:20:23) > Moon: 2002-08-11 (17:20:23) - 2002-08-11 (20:41:09) > Mars: 2002-08-11 (20:41:09) - 2002-08-11 (23:01:38) > Rah: 2002-08-11 (23:01:38) - 2002-08-12 (5:02:53) > Jup: 2002-08-12 (5:02:53) - 2002-08-12 (10:23:58) > >>>> Sat: 2002-08-12 (10:23:58) - 2002-08-12 (16:45:13) > > Let us interpret this dasa using the dasamsa (D-10) chart, which was recommended by Parasara for seeing one's career. > > From Sun, Mercury is the 5th lord in 1st. His dasa does NOT show getting laid off. But considering that this layoff was a small event in a 17-year MD, it may not show up. Let us focus on AD and the levels below it. > > Lord of AD is Moon. From Chandra lagna, Moon is the badhaka lord debilitated in 1st. Moreover, he is placed in the 7th from MD lord Mercury! The 7th house is the 2nd house (maraka sthana/killer station) for the 6th house of service. Thus, Moon MD can give a layoff and some uneasiness in career. > > PD lord is Jupiter. From AD lord Moon, Jupiter is in the 3rd house of short breaks. The 3rd house has virodha argala on the 6th house of service and breaks the sukha argala (driving intervention) of the 9th house (fortune). Thus, 3rd house withdrawal of the aid of fortune in one's career. > > Moreover, PD should be interpreted from lagna. From lagna, Jupiter is the 7th lord (again, 2nd lord from 6th, i.e. death of service). > > When it comes to SD, go to chara karakas. The 6th from AmK shows service (that is why palana devata is based on the 6th from AmK). Venus is in the 2nd from there, showing the death of service again. In fact, due to parivartana, Venus acts like Mercury, i.e. 2nd lord placed in 2nd (from the 6th from AmK). The result is even stronger. This Venus is placed in the 8th from AK. While the same Venus connected the 7th from DK with AK in a positive way in the last example, he connects the 6th from AmK with AK in a negative way here. His SD broke the career. > > When it comes to PAD, we see that Sun is the 7th lord from pranapada lagna, which is in Aq in D-10 too. Even taking the SD lord Venus as the reference, Sun is the 3rd lord showing a short break. So, clearly, Sun is the planet to give the result at the level of PAD. Because Sun and Mercury are together in D-10, Mercury can give Sun's result. Thus, Mercury PAD gave the layoff. > > Finally, when it comes to DAD, the answer is very clear. Always, the event happens in the DAD of the strongest candidate from lagna to give the result. When I started this example in the class, I asked people, without opening the dasa calculations, to guess the DAD at the time of layoff. Some guessed incorrectly at first. But, when somebody suggested Saturn, that was the final consensus. The class thought it should be Saturn. Then only I opened the calculations (we projected a laptop to the screen and had JHora running in the laptop, so that people could see all the calculations and interactively look at various things). > > Why did people guess Saturn and reach a consensus on Saturn? I will leave it to you to figure out. It's easy to see. > > If you cannot figure it out, I will give a hint. In fact, I'll give two hints: > > (1) 6th lord of service, > (2) marana karaka sthana! > > Conclusion > > These are just two simple examples. I covered many more examples in the workshop. And, this was just a two hour session. There were two complete days of the class, out of which I taught for 1.5 days. Almost anything conceivable on Vimsottari dasa was covered, within the limited time. It is not at all a bad idea to get the CD's. I think everybody will have something or the other to learn. If I get time later, I will try to write more on other things covered at the workshop. > > Especially, Kashinatha Hora was another very good session by me. If I get time later, I will try to post an article on it, so that the important knowledge reaches everyone. > > May Jupiter's light shine on us, > Narasimha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 29, 2003 Report Share Posted November 29, 2003 Typo: > 2. Also, can you please quote which texts prescribe using Surya lagna > to analyze Rasi chart? Should have been " ... to analyze maha dasa? ... " Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 30, 2003 Report Share Posted November 30, 2003 Hare Rama Krishna, Namaste Narasimha Ji, I am very thankful for the wonderful method you have taught us by giving few examples in your lesson. I have also applied this method on few charts with few events known to me and it works beautifully. Ofcouse the birth time accuracy was an important factor and the rectification was done prior to this exercise. But I am having a trouble of re-producing your example-1 using my JH 5 commercial version for your chart and I am gettinga different start time for your MD till DAD. Can you please tell me what I could be doing wrong and why I am not able to generate which should match to the dasa sequence's which you have given in your example-1. I am getting the following dasa sequence for the date "1st Aug 1993" by using the following (your) birth data:- =================================================== April 4, 1970 Time: 17:47:13 Time Zone: 5:30:00 (East of GMT) Place: 81 E 08' 00", 16 N 10' 00" ==== Vimsottari Dasa (started from Moon): Sat MD: 1975-12-30 (12:21:49) - 1994-12-30 (9:13:12) Jup AD: 1992-06-17 (8:31:33) - 1994-12-30 (9:13:12) Ket PD: 1993-07-24 (12:16:23) - 1993-09-17 (17:06:03) Ven SD: 1993-07-27 (18:13:46) - 1993-08-06 (0:43:16) Rah PAD: 1993-07-31 (2:00:20) - 1993-08-01 (11:23:13) Deha-antardasas in this PAD: Rah: 1993-07-31 (2:00:20) - 1993-07-31 (7:00:51) Jup: 1993-07-31 (7:00:51) - 1993-07-31 (11:27:54) Sat: 1993-07-31 (11:27:54) - 1993-07-31 (16:45:01) Merc: 1993-07-31 (16:45:01) - 1993-07-31 (21:28:45) Ket: 1993-07-31 (21:28:45) - 1993-07-31 (23:25:34) Ven: 1993-07-31 (23:25:34) - 1993-08-01 (4:59:20) Sun: 1993-08-01 (4:59:20) - 1993-08-01 (6:39:31) ==> Moon: 1993-08-01 (6:39:31) - 1993-08-01 (9:26:24) Mars: 1993-08-01 (9:26:24) - 1993-08-01 (11:23:13) Thanks for your help in advance. Regards Raghunadha Rao vedic astrology, "Narasimha P.V.R. Rao" <pvr@c...> wrote: > Om Gurave Namah > Namaste friends, > > I taught Vimsottari dasa interpretation at an SJC workshop at Edison, NJ on Vijaya Dasami day (4th October 2003). I covered the interpretation of Vimsottari dasa upto six levels (upto deha- antardasa). Pt. Sanjay Rath, my guru, told me to write a small article on it on this list, so that those who do not have access to the CD's also get this important knowledge. I did not get chance to do that until now. > > This topic was covered for 1.5-2 hours. The Vimsottari dasa workshop was for 2 days. I taught for 1.5 days and Narayan Iyer taught for half a day. Those who want to go through the rest of the material and want to get the CD's when they are ready may kindly contact Narayan at narayan@s... > > * * * > > Warning > > If there is an error of 1 minute in birthtime, Vimsottari dasa start dates can change by upto 5 days! If there is an error of just 1 arc-min in the ayanamsa used, Vimsottari dasa start dates can change by upto 9 days! Thus, the Vimsottari dasa dates one has can be off by many days. So, it is pointless to analyze Vimsottari dasa upto six levels without finely rectifying the birthtime. > > Even after the birthtime is finely rectified, it is possible that Vimsottari dasa start days are slightly off by a few days. Even if the birthtime is accurate and lagna and special lagnas in all divisional charts are correct, still there may be a minute error in Moon's longitude and there may be an error in the dasa dates because of it. This can be due to a minute error in ayanamsa or many such reasons. For example, we take the gravitational center of Moon when finding the longitude (sphuta) of Moon. It is possible that Moon's influence on our fortunes is not due to gravitational force and due to some other spiritual force that is yet to be understood by science. If that is the case and the spiritual center of Moon is slightly off from the gravitational center, that can also change Moon's longitude slightly. > > Thus, it is important to do the following when using Vimsottari dasa upto six levels. > > (1) Rectify the birthtime accurately, so that lagna and special lagnas in various divisional charts make sense > (2) Rectify the dasa dates and adjust them slightly if needed > > The standard example we will take was rectified by me, based on tens of life events. The birthdata is: 4th April 1970, 5:47:13 pm (IST), Machilipatnam, India (81e8, 16n10). Vimsottari dasa was further rectified by subtracting 1 day 4 hr 17 min from all the dates. This can be due to ayanamsa error or some other error that we do not yet understand. Please be advised that this error is not necessarily a constant for all charts (even if it is just an ayanamsa error). > > [Note: The latest version of Jagannatha Hora commercial software allows the users to play with the dasa dates and adjust them.] > > Interpreting Six Levels > > The following references can be used when interpreting the six levels: > > (1) Mahadasa (MD): Sun > (2) Antardasa (AD): Moon > (3) Pratyantardasa (PD): Lagna > (4) Sookshma-antardasa (SD): Atma karaka (AK, and other chara karakas) > (5) Praana-antardasa (PAD): Pranapada lagna (and arudha padas) > (5) Deha-antardasa (DAD): Lagna > > In addition, we can take the planet ruling a period as the reference when judging the results of the next level periods. For example, PAD lord can be taken as the reference when judging the DADs. > > Examples > > (1) The native got married on 1st August 1993 at 9:30 pm (IST). > > The dasa calculations are given below: > > Vimsottari Dasa (started from Moon): > > Sat MD: 1975-12-29 (8:04:41) - 1994-12-29 (4:56:06) > Jup AD: 1992-06-16 (2:18:46) - 1994-12-29 (4:56:06) > Ket PD: 1993-07-23 (6:05:02) - 1993-09-16 (11:33:05) > Ven SD: 1993-07-26 (12:03:05) - 1993-08-04 (18:36:08) > Sat PAD: 1993-08-01 (10:54:12) - 1993-08-02 (22:07:38) > > Deha-antardasas in this PAD: > > Sat: 1993-08-01 (10:54:12) - 1993-08-01 (16:28:52) > Merc: 1993-08-01 (16:28:52) - 1993-08-01 (21:28:17) > >>>> Ket: 1993-08-01 (21:28:17) - 1993-08-01 (23:31:35) > Ven: 1993-08-01 (23:31:35) - 1993-08-02 (5:23:49) > Sun: 1993-08-02 (5:23:49) - 1993-08-02 (7:09:32) > Moon: 1993-08-02 (7:09:32) - 1993-08-02 (10:05:39) > Mars: 1993-08-02 (10:05:39) - 1993-08-02 (12:08:55) > Rah: 1993-08-02 (12:08:55) - 1993-08-02 (17:25:53) > Jup: 1993-08-02 (17:25:53) - 1993-08-02 (22:07:38) > > Let us interpret this dasa using the navamsa chart, which was recommended by Parasara for seeing one's marriage. > > Saturn is the lord of Surya lagna. His MD is capable of giving marriage. Taking Moon as the reference, Jupiter is the 7th lord in 7th. His AD is capable of giving marriage. Ketu is the 7th lord from lagna and his PD can give marriage. Though Mars is also a 7th lord, Ketu is the 7th lord in 5th and Mars is the 7th lord in 8th. So Ketu is more capable of giving marriage than the other 7th lord Mars. > > The SD is of Venus. Why? Use chara karakas for SD. Moon is AK. Venus is in 1st house from him. Moreover, he is the 7th lord from DK (Mercury). DK shows spouse. The 7th from DK shows the native, from the point of view of interacting with spouse. Its lord is Venus. The link between AK and the 7th from DK should be seen for finding the SD of marriage. It is Venus here. > > Pranapada lagna in navamsa chart is in Aquarius. From Aq, Saturn is the 1st lord in 7th. Due to exchange with Sun, he in fact gives the results of 7th lord in 7th. So, he is the perfect candidate for giving marriage in his PAD. Finally, DAD is again that of Ketu and it was explained earlier. > > The native for married in Ketu DAD. Then all the guests had a dinner, but the native and his wife had to wait. They did more rituals and got a chance to eat only after Venus DAD started. They had dinner a little before midnight. Considering that Venus is the 2nd lord in rasi chart, he can give nice food. Being the 9th lord in rasi chart, he can also give rituals etc. The native and his wife continued the rituals for a few more hours, after the nice wedding dinner. They left for home early in the dinner and slept for a few hours. During Sun DAD, the native was sleeping. It may be noted that Sun is the lord of the 12th house of sleep. Especially, as Sun is placed in the 12th from PAD lord (Saturn) in rasi chart, apart from owning the 12th house from lagna, his DAD is perfectly capable of giving sleep. > > (2) The native lost his job on 12th August 2002 at 4:15 pm (EDT). > > The dasa calculations are given below: > > Vimsottari Dasa (started from Moon): > > Merc MD: 1994-12-28 (19:26:06) - 2011-12-29 (4:07:51) > Moon AD: 2002-01-27 (1:32:55) - 2003-06-29 (2:15:01) > Jup PD: 2002-06-27 (12:43:55) - 2002-09-06 (11:15:15) > Ven SD: 2002-08-01 (13:33:03) - 2002-08-13 (9:16:40) > Merc PAD: 2002-08-11 (0:36:45) - 2002-08-12 (16:45:13) > > Deha-antardasas in this PAD: > > Merc: 2002-08-11 (0:36:45) - 2002-08-11 (6:18:00) > Ket: 2002-08-11 (6:18:00) - 2002-08-11 (8:38:31) > Ven: 2002-08-11 (8:38:31) - 2002-08-11 (15:19:57) > Sun: 2002-08-11 (15:19:57) - 2002-08-11 (17:20:23) > Moon: 2002-08-11 (17:20:23) - 2002-08-11 (20:41:09) > Mars: 2002-08-11 (20:41:09) - 2002-08-11 (23:01:38) > Rah: 2002-08-11 (23:01:38) - 2002-08-12 (5:02:53) > Jup: 2002-08-12 (5:02:53) - 2002-08-12 (10:23:58) > >>>> Sat: 2002-08-12 (10:23:58) - 2002-08-12 (16:45:13) > > Let us interpret this dasa using the dasamsa (D-10) chart, which was recommended by Parasara for seeing one's career. > > From Sun, Mercury is the 5th lord in 1st. His dasa does NOT show getting laid off. But considering that this layoff was a small event in a 17-year MD, it may not show up. Let us focus on AD and the levels below it. > > Lord of AD is Moon. From Chandra lagna, Moon is the badhaka lord debilitated in 1st. Moreover, he is placed in the 7th from MD lord Mercury! The 7th house is the 2nd house (maraka sthana/killer station) for the 6th house of service. Thus, Moon MD can give a layoff and some uneasiness in career. > > PD lord is Jupiter. From AD lord Moon, Jupiter is in the 3rd house of short breaks. The 3rd house has virodha argala on the 6th house of service and breaks the sukha argala (driving intervention) of the 9th house (fortune). Thus, 3rd house withdrawal of the aid of fortune in one's career. > > Moreover, PD should be interpreted from lagna. From lagna, Jupiter is the 7th lord (again, 2nd lord from 6th, i.e. death of service). > > When it comes to SD, go to chara karakas. The 6th from AmK shows service (that is why palana devata is based on the 6th from AmK). Venus is in the 2nd from there, showing the death of service again. In fact, due to parivartana, Venus acts like Mercury, i.e. 2nd lord placed in 2nd (from the 6th from AmK). The result is even stronger. This Venus is placed in the 8th from AK. While the same Venus connected the 7th from DK with AK in a positive way in the last example, he connects the 6th from AmK with AK in a negative way here. His SD broke the career. > > When it comes to PAD, we see that Sun is the 7th lord from pranapada lagna, which is in Aq in D-10 too. Even taking the SD lord Venus as the reference, Sun is the 3rd lord showing a short break. So, clearly, Sun is the planet to give the result at the level of PAD. Because Sun and Mercury are together in D-10, Mercury can give Sun's result. Thus, Mercury PAD gave the layoff. > > Finally, when it comes to DAD, the answer is very clear. Always, the event happens in the DAD of the strongest candidate from lagna to give the result. When I started this example in the class, I asked people, without opening the dasa calculations, to guess the DAD at the time of layoff. Some guessed incorrectly at first. But, when somebody suggested Saturn, that was the final consensus. The class thought it should be Saturn. Then only I opened the calculations (we projected a laptop to the screen and had JHora running in the laptop, so that people could see all the calculations and interactively look at various things). > > Why did people guess Saturn and reach a consensus on Saturn? I will leave it to you to figure out. It's easy to see. > > If you cannot figure it out, I will give a hint. In fact, I'll give two hints: > > (1) 6th lord of service, > (2) marana karaka sthana! > > Conclusion > > These are just two simple examples. I covered many more examples in the workshop. And, this was just a two hour session. There were two complete days of the class, out of which I taught for 1.5 days. Almost anything conceivable on Vimsottari dasa was covered, within the limited time. It is not at all a bad idea to get the CD's. I think everybody will have something or the other to learn. If I get time later, I will try to write more on other things covered at the workshop. > > Especially, Kashinatha Hora was another very good session by me. If I get time later, I will try to post an article on it, so that the important knowledge reaches everyone. > > May Jupiter's light shine on us, > Narasimha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2003 Report Share Posted December 10, 2003 Dear PVR JI RAM KRISHN HARE Your article on vinshottary Dasha is good but not useful for future predictions.Since you know all dashas before hand,it is easy to justify them for any given event.I would like to suggest that you provide first dasha selection.Out of 9 planets,which are capable of giving it and why other 8 planets have not given the results.We have to repeat this for 6 levels which means 9*6=54 placements are to be checked.If you can include this kind of analysis,even post-event analysis can be used with advantage to teach the techniques. Some more observations: You have not used natural Karakas in your entire article. You have not used any arudha(bhav or grah). You have not used Hora/Ghati Lagn. Do you mean that these things should not be employed in analysis of Vinshottary dasha? Should we calculate HL and GL also from centre of sun's Disk like pranpad lagn? You have used extensively the principle of taking parent dasha-lord as Lagn.It looks that this overrdes basic reference points in all dashas. Can you kindly explain the preference parameters for two references? I believe that you are misusing Sudarshan Chakr by extending it to Vinshottary dasha.It was explained by Sage Parashar when Maitraiy asked him some simple method for people in kaliyug.This was suggested for avoiding lots of dashas,avasthas,strengths and other complicated prediction techniques.Suggesting it for any other dasha,looks completely absurd.Again,Parasharji told that it must be used in conjunction with Ashtakvarg which you have never touched in your mails on this topic. Hope you will clarify. I am glad to see that you have finally advocated use of year based on Earth's Rotation.Do you recommend it for all UDU dashas including Kal-Chakr dasha or just for Vinshottary dasha and its variations only? THANKS ANILKUMAR OM TAT SAT Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted December 10, 2003 Report Share Posted December 10, 2003 ||Om Brihaspataye Namah|| Dear Anil Kumar, > I am glad to see that you have finally advocated use of year based on > Earth's Rotation.Do you recommend it for all UDU dashas including > Kal-Chakr dasha or just for Vinshottary dasha and its variations > only? Based on Narasimha's article, how did you deduce that 'he advocated use of year based on Earth's rotation (around the Sun)'?? I presume you refer to 360 degrees solar motion here? regards Hari Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.