Guest guest Posted July 26, 2003 Report Share Posted July 26, 2003 Dear Guru's and Members, I am following this thread and discussion for the past few days on Sarpa Yoga and struggling to understand the definition and its application in analyis. Definition:- ========== 1) BPHS- Page 487 (Chapter 37, Sloka 8) defines Sarpa Yoga as follows:- If 3 angles are occupied by malefics then the Sarpa Yoga is formed and produces inauspicious results. It also says: Sun, Sat and Mars occupy three angles/quadrants and no benefic is there in a ny algle, it si only then that Sarpa Yoga is formed. Based on the above, my understanding is nodes are not mentioned here. I think ChandraShekhar Ji had mentioned about this few times already. 2) VA an Integrated Approach - Page 102 ( Point 11.5.2), Narasimha Ji defines Sarpa Yoga as follows:- If three quadrants are occupied by natural malefics, this yoga is formed. If a benefic also occupies one of the quadrants, this yoga may not operate well. One born with this yoga is m iserable, unhappy, cruel, poor and dependent on others for food. This is a very bad combination. Sapra means Sepant. For example: Lagna is Sc, Mars is in Ta(7th), Rahu is in Leo(10th), and Ketu is in Aq(4th). This gives a Sarpa Yoga. Here Narasimha Ji have considered nodes can also contribute for forming of the Sarpa Yoga. So the above two do not match and giving a confusion to me and some of the studetns and members as well. Chart Analysis:- =============== Sanjay Ji had mentioned in his message : 29771, Rajesh has Sarpa yoga, even Rajesh also mentioned to me, he has Sarpa Yoga, but I am not able to tie the placements of the plantes to the above definitions. Let us take a close look at his chart and see, where I am missing the link: Lagna Aq with Ketu(1st) - Qualified for the Sarpa Yoga 4th House is Ta with Venu - Not qualified for Sarpa Yoga 7th House is Leo with Rah and Mars - Qualified for the Sarpa Yoga 10th House is Sag with no planets - Not qualified for Sarpa Yoga So in my opinion and follow the above definitions including nodes, the above chart is not having a Sarpa Yoga. Request to Guru's to answer the following Questions:- ==================================================== 1) Sarpa yoga formed only malefics in THREE or more DISTINCT quadrants, not having three malefics in A QUADRANT or TWO QUADRANTS. 2) Do we need to consider Rahu and Ketu ( Nodes ) in forming the Sarpa Yoga. 3) With my little understanding, If we consider all malefics inclusing nodes, I think more than 40 % population on the earth may be having the Sarpa Yoga and suffering till 43-45 years. May be god wants that way, may be not ? Please guide me where I am missing the link and why I can not see Sarpa Yoga in the above example. May be I do not want to see Sarpa Yoga most often. Regards Rao Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 27, 2003 Report Share Posted July 27, 2003 Hare Rama Krishna Dear Rao, Interesting points you have raised. i like to focus on your question no 3. I think, the percentage of cases with Sarpa yoga may come down if we consider benefics joining the quadrants. i also wonder why in the initial chapters of BPHS Rahu & Ketu were not mentioned!? anybody can share their views, please. Thanks & regards viswanadham P.S: i am yet to send you the three charts of Doctors, as i am yet to contact them for their verbal consent. vedic astrology, Rao Nemani <raonemani> wrote: > Dear Guru's and Members, > > I am following this thread and discussion for the past > few days on Sarpa Yoga and struggling to understand > the definition and its application in analyis. > > Definition:- > ========== > > 1) BPHS- Page 487 (Chapter 37, Sloka 8) defines Sarpa > Yoga as follows:- > > If 3 angles are occupied by malefics then the Sarpa > Yoga is formed and produces inauspicious results. > > It also says: Sun, Sat and Mars occupy three > angles/quadrants and no benefic is there in a ny > algle, it si only then that Sarpa Yoga is formed. > > Based on the above, my understanding is nodes are not > mentioned here. I think ChandraShekhar Ji had > mentioned about this few times already. > > 2) VA an Integrated Approach - Page 102 ( Point > 11.5.2), Narasimha Ji defines Sarpa Yoga as follows:- > > If three quadrants are occupied by natural malefics, > this yoga is formed. If a benefic also occupies one of > the quadrants, this yoga may not operate well. > > One born with this yoga is m iserable, unhappy, cruel, > poor and dependent on others for food. This is a very > bad combination. Sapra means Sepant. > > For example: Lagna is Sc, Mars is in Ta(7th), Rahu is > in Leo(10th), and Ketu is in Aq(4th). This gives a > Sarpa Yoga. > > Here Narasimha Ji have considered nodes can also > contribute for forming of the Sarpa Yoga. > > So the above two do not match and giving a confusion > to me and some of the studetns and members as well. > > > Chart Analysis:- > =============== > > Sanjay Ji had mentioned in his message : 29771, Rajesh > has Sarpa yoga, even Rajesh also mentioned to me, he > has Sarpa Yoga, but I am not able to tie the > placements of the plantes to the above definitions. > Let us take a close look at his chart and see, where I > am missing the link: > > Lagna Aq with Ketu(1st) - Qualified for the > Sarpa Yoga > 4th House is Ta with Venu - Not qualified for > Sarpa Yoga > 7th House is Leo with Rah and Mars - Qualified for the > Sarpa Yoga > 10th House is Sag with no planets - Not qualified for > Sarpa Yoga > > So in my opinion and follow the above definitions > including nodes, the above chart is not having a Sarpa > Yoga. > > > Request to Guru's to answer the following Questions:- > ==================================================== > 1) Sarpa yoga formed only malefics in THREE or more > DISTINCT quadrants, not > having three malefics in A QUADRANT or TWO QUADRANTS. > > 2) Do we need to consider Rahu and Ketu ( Nodes ) in > forming the Sarpa Yoga. > > 3) With my little understanding, If we consider all > malefics inclusing nodes, I think more than 40 % > population on the earth may be having the Sarpa Yoga > and suffering till 43-45 years. May be god wants that > way, may be not ? > > Please guide me where I am missing the link and why I > can not see Sarpa Yoga in the above example. May be I > do not want to see Sarpa Yoga most often. > > Regards > Rao > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted July 28, 2003 Report Share Posted July 28, 2003 I am all ears too- Annavishwanatham <vishwanatham (AT) rocketmail (DOT) com> wrote: Hare Rama KrishnaDear Rao,Interesting points you have raised. i like to focus on your question no 3.I think, the percentage of cases with Sarpa yoga may come down if we consider benefics joining the quadrants. i also wonder why in the initial chapters of BPHS Rahu & Ketu were not mentioned!? anybody can share their views, please.Thanks & regardsviswanadham P.S: i am yet to send you the three charts of Doctors, as i am yet to contact them for their verbal consent.vedic astrology, Rao Nemani <raonemani> wrote:> Dear Guru's and Members,> > I am following this thread and discussion for the past> few days on Sarpa Yoga and struggling to understand> the definition and its application in analyis.> > Definition:-> ==========> > 1) BPHS- Page 487 (Chapter 37, Sloka 8) defines Sarpa> Yoga as follows:-> > If 3 angles are occupied by malefics then the Sarpa> Yoga is formed and produces inauspicious results.> > It also says: Sun, Sat and Mars occupy three> angles/quadrants and no benefic is there in a ny> algle, it si only then that Sarpa Yoga is formed.> > Based on the above, my understanding is nodes are not> mentioned here. I think ChandraShekhar Ji had> mentioned about this few times already.> > 2) VA an Integrated Approach - Page 102 ( Point> 11.5.2), Narasimha Ji defines Sarpa Yoga as follows:-> > If three quadrants are occupied by natural malefics,> this yoga is formed. If a benefic also occupies one of> the quadrants, this yoga may not operate well.> > One born with this yoga is m iserable, unhappy, cruel,> poor and dependent on others for food. This is a very> bad combination. Sapra means Sepant.> > For example: Lagna is Sc, Mars is in Ta(7th), Rahu is> in Leo(10th), and Ketu is in Aq(4th). This gives a> Sarpa Yoga.> > Here Narasimha Ji have considered nodes can also> contribute for forming of the Sarpa Yoga. > > So the above two do not match and giving a confusion> to me and some of the studetns and members as well.> > > Chart Analysis:-> ===============> > Sanjay Ji had mentioned in his message : 29771, Rajesh> has Sarpa yoga, even Rajesh also mentioned to me, he> has Sarpa Yoga, but I am not able to tie the> placements of the plantes to the above definitions. > Let us take a close look at his chart and see, where I> am missing the link:> > Lagna Aq with Ketu(1st) - Qualified for the> Sarpa Yoga> 4th House is Ta with Venu - Not qualified for> Sarpa Yoga> 7th House is Leo with Rah and Mars - Qualified for the> Sarpa Yoga> 10th House is Sag with no planets - Not qualified for> Sarpa Yoga> > So in my opinion and follow the above definitions> including nodes, the above chart is not having a Sarpa> Yoga.> > > Request to Guru's to answer the following Questions:-> ====================================================> 1) Sarpa yoga formed only malefics in THREE or more> DISTINCT quadrants, not > having three malefics in A QUADRANT or TWO QUADRANTS.> > 2) Do we need to consider Rahu and Ketu ( Nodes ) in> forming the Sarpa Yoga.> > 3) With my little understanding, If we consider all> malefics inclusing nodes, I think more than 40 %> population on the earth may be having the Sarpa Yoga> and suffering till 43-45 years. May be god wants that> way, may be not ?> > Please guide me where I am missing the link and why I> can not see Sarpa Yoga in the above example. May be I> do not want to see Sarpa Yoga most often.> > Regards> Rao> > > > > SiteBuilder - Free, easy-to-use web site design software> Archives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.