birth details = yogada/ mahayogada = a doubt

[Guest guest]

dear gurus,

we had a discussion regarding planets becoming yogadas and mahayogas

in charts. i also that when a planet is yogada or mahayogada - than

during its dasas/antardashas - it gives good results also.

 

this is where i am confused.

 

20 november 1978 - 2.51pm - bombay.

 

in my chart i have lagna pisces - lagna lord jupiter in 5th combining

with HL & GL and aspecting lagna - so it becomes mahayogada = agreed.

 

again----------

 

moon which is 5th lord in 5th - HL & GL in 5th - combining with lagna

lord jupiter - and aspecting lagna - so it becomes m.yogada = agreed.

 

BUT ---------

 

as far as yogada is concerned i have still 3 planets in my chart

which becomes yogada. sun & mars & mercury placed in 9th house -

aspecting lagna & HL & GL (1-5-9 aspects).

 

NOW -----------

 

according to vimshottari dasas - dasas started with shani which is in

leo in 6th house. than from 1992 mercury dasa started and still going.

according to yogada theory = my mercury dasa should have given me

good results which was not and from 1992 things slowly started

getting bad and worse. but the shani dasa from birth time till 1992

was extremely good and wonderful - WHAST THE REASON FOR THIS ?

 

1. is it because MERCURY is a BADHAK in my chart ? --- OR

2. is it becasue MERCURY is AK in my chart ? ---- OR

3. is it because of MARS in scorpio ? -------- OR

4. is it because SHANI - lord of 12th in 6th (forming one of the

yogas gave me good results) ?

 

20 november 1978 - 2.51pm - bombay

 

mr.doshi.