Need help: contradictory D-9 indications based on Lagnamsa vs. Karakamsa

[Guest guest]

Hello Gurus, particularly Visti, and others,

 

I am trying to understand Navamsa. Let me only present a small

picture of what I see, and you can tell me where my error is, or

where I should look to get more detail. When I look at my Navamsa (or

rather one possibly rectified version of it - I am an absolute

beginner at this), I see the following:

 

a) From Karakamsa (i.e. sign of Chara Atmakaraka in Navamsa): This is

Pisces. 9th from Pisces is Scorpio. Contains Jupiter, ruler of

Karakamsa and 10th from Karakamsa. Mars is in Virgo - 7 from

Karakamsa. This looks very good - ruler of 1st and 10th in 9th, house

of dharma (in the D-9 chart). Seems to point to good dharma?

b) From Lagnamsa (i.e. sign of Lagna in Navamsa): This is Aries. 9th

from Aries is Sagittarius. Contains Saturn. Ruler of 9th (Jupiter) is

in 8th (Asura Yoga?). Ruler of 1st and 8th is Mars which is in Virgo -

the 6th. This doesnt look good at all - ruler of 1st in 6th, ruler

of 9th in 8th (with Asura Yoga?). Seems to point to fallen dharma?

 

So you can see the highly contradictory indications when seen from

Karakamsa and when seen from Lagnamsa. How do I go about

explaining/resolving the differences? Of course, I am presenting the

above chart only as an example - what I really want to know is, in

general, FOR WHICH NAVAMSA INDICATION (other than Ishta-devata etc)

do I use Karakamsa and FOR WHICH NAVAMSA INDICATION do I use

Lagnamsa? Both seem to have been given a lot of importance in the

articles/books I have perhaps incompletely read.

 

Thank you,

 

Sundeep