Partha- please send article on Profession Profession- another puzzle

[Guest guest]

Dear Partha

 

Many of us, incl me, would be very grateful if you could send your

article on Profession, esp if its ready.

 

I apologise if I have hurt your feelings in any way. That was not my

intention at all. Being precise is important in counselling, not so

much in puzzles. Moreover, in front of the MahaShivaLingam, all ours

are infinitesimally negligible.

 

My point in your answer was not to do with precision, but in the

process you chose, which did not, to my mind, lead logically to your

conclusions. OTOH, in my words, u DID "hit bull's eye on the wrong

dartboard". This is VERY important, as it happens a lot with

experienced (& thus intuitive) astrologers. This intuit, in your &

other such minds, we must all unravel.

 

Many times, intuitive astrologers leave large gaps in explanations, &

jump to various conclusions. They are subconsciously choosing certain

logic-streams & not others. It is very important that u go back to

your mental process when u attempted the puzzle (your 1st, not 2nd

posting), & understand the astro-paths u chose out of other

possibilites. If u do come up with something, let us know - that will

help all of us.

 

Many moons back, when Mr N Rao's book VAIP had just come out, I had

asked him, wrt a particular example in his book, why he chose Saturn

as the primary logic-stream as karaka for profession , & found

aspects & argalas to it, to determine profession. He had completely

ignored 10, L10, d-10, etc in that SPECIFIC example. He never

answered, tho he answered virtually every other question in that

L..O..N..G e-mail of mine. Which could mean, that experienced

astrologers, DO choose certain references uniquely for a chart, for

reasons they have gathered from experience, but are unable to

explain. Why did influences to Saturn in THAT example explain

profession in THAT chart best.

 

This multi-reference frame is usually thought of to be Confluence (ie

if from both Moon AND Lagna, or if from all of the relevant karakas

for a domain, etc); sometimes also as meaning different aspects

altogether, for the same question. But I feel, there is some

uniqueness to every chart, depending on the specific planetary

positions, that makes certain reference-frames more useful: Jaimini

strength rules help in initialising dasas, choosing alternatives for

arudhas, etc, but doesn't, for what I am talking about.

 

So, request u to meditate on your thought process when u first saw

that chart- if u come up with anything, do let us know.

 

Further, in the same puzzle, nobody has answered why Jup with clear

NBRajYog, not just negation of deb, has been SO ineffective. Also,

nobody has clearly also explained the such a STARK difference among

the 2 brothers- in intelligence & achievement. Please try.

 

Best wishes

 

PS have u started daily meditation, as instructed in the SJVC

initiation process? I just have, along with my 5 yr old son, after so

many many years (last was with my dad when I was my son's current

age). My dad does, for the last 75 years. I have long last restarted.

It helps.

 

vedic astrology, "partvinu5" <partvinu5> wrote:

> dear Nomadeva

>

> i was ready with the article and was ready to post it also. But

today

> i was enlightened by a senior member of the list who said that we

are

> all novices and we should tread cautiously before commiting such

> profane acts. According to him we should be always thinking small

and

> try to be extremely perfect(perfectionism) in whatever we do. I

tend

> to agree with him as "perfectionism" is everything in astrology.

>

> regards

> partha

>

> ps: dear nomadeva your dasamsa has mars in 6th house of service and

> it is in its own house, thus your job is technical. I always see

the

> 6th house or the 7th house in the dasamsa chart for career. i had

> earlier explained this in the case of electrical engineer puzzle,

> where saturn is too good in the 6th house from the dasamsa lagna,

so

> despite the presence of moon in 10th, and mercury in 7th, he is an

> engineer.

vedic astrology, Nomadeva Sharma <nomadeva> wrote:

> > Dear Sri Sanjay Rath-ji,

> >

> > Does Ketu (headless) having anything to do with 10th

> > house in D-10 give a menial job?

> >

> > Also, your article on Dasamsa gives the impression

> > that such a person (with influence of Ketu on 10)

> > would be religious or philosophy oriented (Is this why

> > you have added the clause 'unless involved in some

> > social welfare'?).

> >

> > More puzzling is that despite mars having nothing to

> > do with 10th in D-10 for me, my job is quite

> > technical, being in software. Unlike many in software

> > who acknowledge their work to be 'headless typing',

> > mine so far has been a technical one, as acknowledged

> > by my seniors too. I am not sure where the

> > technicality is coming in (or is this a temporary

> > feature?). I am religiously minded, but profession is

> > not that. (Attached is the JHD).

> >

> > Given the puzzles on profession (Nandan, your puzzle

> > was too good!), it will be nice if an article on

> > reading of D-10 be posted, like Dasgupta-ji suggested

> > Partha to do.

> >

> > Regards,

> > Nomadeva