Guest guest Report post Posted January 19, 2002 Dear Henry, While compiling for 'Significators', I saw and consulted every book available including B V Raman's books but none could assign a planet to father in law. That is why my book does not list it. Regarding 9th or 10th house controversy for father, both will have to take into account. How? 9th house stands for boss or authority over native. Also ascendant i.e. native is child of 9th house. So 9th house is for biological father i.e. the true father. 10th house is for husband of the mother, being 7th from 4th house. So 10th house stands for father of the native in the eyes of the society. The income of 10th house i.e. 8th house (11th from 10th) decides volume of inheritance i.e. 8th house of native. The wealth house of 10th i.e. 2nd from 10th, the 11th house is income of the native in the form of pocket money. From legal angle 10th house stands very well to represent father. But biological role and guiding role leads to 9th house. If the two kind of fathers are the same as in most of the cases are, it is well and good to consider both houses. And in case, they are two different persons, both houses will still play role for two kind of fathers. This way the two houses should be looked at for father. One can advance it as analogy for wife's father too. Father in law should also have two houses, the 3rd and the 4th houses. I am CC-ing it to the list for other's opinion. May be we get some more light on it. Best wishes, Shiv Chadha - Astrologer Shiv Chadha Thursday, January 17, 2002 11:13 PM Re: father in law many thanks your in depth reply but at the moment I do not know what to think ! North India would take 10th from 9th = 4th ! Does not Parasa state to use Kethu for wife's relatives ? Another astrologer says to use 10th bhava and SUN is the planet. I think that after *thousands of years Vedic astrologers cannot agree on father in law , that it is very sad. You have written a book on significators, what do you use ? did B V Raman give an opinion ? Many thanks, Henry Thanks, Henry - Shiv Chadha Astrologer Thursday, January 17, 2002 10:15 AM Re: father in law Classics don't given any clue for father-in-law. 3rd is 9th from 7th, so qualifies as far as house is concerned. Take 3rd from Karakansh, Arudha Lagna too. Among planets, try 3rd in reverse from Darakarak i.e. Putrakarak as father in law. Why? K S Charak researched and found bhratrakarak to represent father. Taking same argument, 3rd from DK in increasing degrees PK should become wife's father. What do you think? - Astrologer Shiv Chadha Thursday, January 17, 2002 1:37 AM father in law I use 3rd bhava for father in law but what planet should I use to represent ?. I know Parasa said Kethu for wife's relatives: but am told that sanjay rath uses Venus. I am confused would appreciate your opinion. Thanks, Henry Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
Guest guest Report post Posted January 19, 2002 Dear Shiv Chadha, Venus represents the in laws as per Jaimini Sutras, 9th from Venus the father in law and 4th from Venus mother in law. Have enjoyed your book over the years. Best Regards,Ernst Wilhelmwww.vedic astrology.netKala Vedic Astrology Software & Kala Occult Publishers - Shiv Chadha Astrologer Cc: vedic astrology Saturday, January 19, 2002 12:07 PM [vedic astrology] Re: father in law Dear Henry, While compiling for 'Significators', I saw and consulted every book available including B V Raman's books but none could assign a planet to father in law. That is why my book does not list it. Regarding 9th or 10th house controversy for father, both will have to take into account. How? 9th house stands for boss or authority over native. Also ascendant i.e. native is child of 9th house. So 9th house is for biological father i.e. the true father. 10th house is for husband of the mother, being 7th from 4th house. So 10th house stands for father of the native in the eyes of the society. The income of 10th house i.e. 8th house (11th from 10th) decides volume of inheritance i.e. 8th house of native. The wealth house of 10th i.e. 2nd from 10th, the 11th house is income of the native in the form of pocket money. From legal angle 10th house stands very well to represent father. But biological role and guiding role leads to 9th house. If the two kind of fathers are the same as in most of the cases are, it is well and good to consider both houses. And in case, they are two different persons, both houses will still play role for two kind of fathers. This way the two houses should be looked at for father. One can advance it as analogy for wife's father too. Father in law should also have two houses, the 3rd and the 4th houses. I am CC-ing it to the list for other's opinion. May be we get some more light on it. Best wishes, Shiv Chadha - Astrologer Shiv Chadha Thursday, January 17, 2002 11:13 PM Re: father in law many thanks your in depth reply but at the moment I do not know what to think ! North India would take 10th from 9th = 4th ! Does not Parasa state to use Kethu for wife's relatives ? Another astrologer says to use 10th bhava and SUN is the planet. I think that after *thousands of years Vedic astrologers cannot agree on father in law , that it is very sad. You have written a book on significators, what do you use ? did B V Raman give an opinion ? Many thanks, Henry Thanks, Henry - Shiv Chadha Astrologer Thursday, January 17, 2002 10:15 AM Re: father in law Classics don't given any clue for father-in-law. 3rd is 9th from 7th, so qualifies as far as house is concerned. Take 3rd from Karakansh, Arudha Lagna too. Among planets, try 3rd in reverse from Darakarak i.e. Putrakarak as father in law. Why? K S Charak researched and found bhratrakarak to represent father. Taking same argument, 3rd from DK in increasing degrees PK should become wife's father. What do you think? - Astrologer Shiv Chadha Thursday, January 17, 2002 1:37 AM father in law I use 3rd bhava for father in law but what planet should I use to represent ?. I know Parasa said Kethu for wife's relatives: but am told that sanjay rath uses Venus. I am confused would appreciate your opinion. Thanks, HenryArchives: vedic astrologyGroup info: vedic astrology/info.htmlTo UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic astrology-....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... Quote Share this post Link to post Share on other sites
