Guest guest Posted December 31, 2001 Report Share Posted December 31, 2001 Dear Mr Gaurango Das 1. Shri Rath's message in sjvc message# 1121 dt 21/11/01: "Dear Nandan, The nodes are the cause of KALI in this yuga and to say that they do not participate in warfare is preposterous. they are always fighting. they are born to do just that chasing after the moon - Rahu always pulling the Moon upwards and Ketu puling it down. Poor Moon - the curse of Ganesha must bear. All nodes and planets are treated equally in war especially look out for Mars & ketu and Jupiter and rahu..check the date when they crossed in battle recently ..Sept 11 2001!" 2. The above was in reference to some miscommunication on my part in an earlier mail, & some further questions from me ref message 1131. BUT ignore all that, as it would lead to more confusion (as what Pt Rath said is as above, & what all I asked, etc in other mails regarrding these is irrelevant). 3. Please refer to my recent mail just sent in response to Visti's reply on this, before I recd your reply. I am attaching my clarificatory query on this, which I asked in that mail to Visti: "OK, from your reply, can I summarise that: a) both the nodes eclipse both the luminaries if they conjoin (is there any orb, or the normal same-sign definition alone holds) AND this is irrespective of which has the higher/ lower longitude, as they dont need to participate in yudh with the luminaries; & b) the nodes do NOT eclipse the other planets, but do participate in yudh with them, with the caveat that the degrees are to be counted from the BEGINNING of the sign even for the nodes, & it is particularly virulent for Ra-Jp & Ke-Ma yudhs" NOW, could you or Visti or Pt Rath clarify the question in the last para above, which is, I think, quite clearly enunciated on this "nodes conjoining planets" thing, unlike my usual queries Best wishes Nandan vedic astrology, "Gauranga Das" <gauranga@b...> wrote: > JAYA JAGANNATHA! > > Dear Nandan and Visti, > > Namaste. > > 5. Nodes conjoin planet: I thought they simply eclipse any planet they > conjoin incl Sn/ Mn, but unclear fm Pt Rath, whether this is only if they > win the yudh with that plnt. Also, what is the orb for such yudh/ eclipse, > for the nodes in particular > > Nononono, this is a silly misunderstanding. Tell me, have you ever experienced a Jupiter-eclipse? I think not. The PanchaGrahas have their own nodes, which we don't use in astrology. Some western astrologers do use them thou. > > Dear Nandan, are you trying to sya that Sanjayji refers to Graha yuddha between the nodes and soem toher planets? Are you sure? Please point out the page in his books or extract from emails, as I can't recall hearing anything similar from him or from the classics. According to my understanding, there's three classes of the planets: teh luminaries, the pancha-grahas and the chaya grahas (nodes) which behave distinctly in many ways, including yuddha or planetary war. The five grahas (Mars, Mercury, Jupiter, Venus and Saturn) may enter into a war with each other, once within 1 degree of longitude. According to Varahamihira, the planet with a higher latitude will win the yuddha. On the other hand, no planet may enter into a war with the Sun and the Moon. The Sun is the overlord of all the planets, so he will burn them up if they are too close to him. The Moon is Krishna, who is karuna-sindhu and dina-bandhu (the ocean of mercy and the friend of the fallen) thus He will not fight with anyone, but be everyone's friend. The nodes however are shadowy planets, so you can't fight with them. But true, if they approach any planet, they will eclipse it (i.e. cast a negative influence on it) because they represent the law of karma, and no one can fight these laws. I have given some info in another mail how their eclipse is especially harmful to the luminaries, as they can overpower even them. > > Yours, > > Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer > gauranga@b... > Jyotish Remedies: > WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET > Phone:+36-309-140-839 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 2, 2002 Report Share Posted January 2, 2002 JAYA JAGANNATHA! Dear Nandan, Namaste. Well, maybe my understanding is imperfect, but I still think that the nodes of course attack any planet, but in no way can they be defeated in a war with any planet, because they are shadowy, hence untraceable. Therefore I do not see the necessity to invent any way to decide who is the winner in a battle between a node and another planet. Because they are so inimical towards anyone, they cane bear even each other's company only by staying at the two opposite ends of the zodiac all the time. Now my understanding is that any palanet is harmed by the nodes (in case when their influence is taken as malefic) in the proportion of the nodes' proximity (of course an applying aspect would be more heinous than a separating one). There is only one way to counteract their influence: an aspect of another planet may relieve the attacked planet from the effect. The aspecting planet should be Mercury in case of Rahu and Sun (I'm not sure about this one) in case of Ketu. Yours, Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer gauranga Jyotish Remedies: WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET Phone:+36-309-140-839 > 3. Please refer to my recent mail just sent in response to Visti's > reply on this, before I recd your reply. I am attaching my > clarificatory query on this, which I asked in that mail to > Visti: "OK, from your reply, can I summarise that: a) both the nodes > eclipse both the luminaries if they conjoin (is there any orb, or > the normal same-sign definition alone holds) AND this is irrespective > of which has the higher/ lower longitude, as they dont need to > participate in yudh with the luminaries; & b) the nodes do NOT > eclipse the other planets, but do participate in yudh with them, with > the caveat that the degrees are to be counted from the BEGINNING of > the sign even for the nodes, & it is particularly virulent for Ra-Jp > & Ke-Ma yudhs" > > NOW, could you or Visti or Pt Rath clarify the question in the last > para above, which is, I think, quite clearly enunciated on > this "nodes conjoining planets" thing, unlike my usual queries > Best wishes > > Nandan > > vedic astrology, "Gauranga Das" <gauranga@b...> wrote: > > JAYA JAGANNATHA! > > > > Dear Nandan and Visti, > > > > Namaste. > > > > 5. Nodes conjoin planet: I thought they simply eclipse any planet > they > > conjoin incl Sn/ Mn, but unclear fm Pt Rath, whether this is only > if they > > win the yudh with that plnt. Also, what is the orb for such yudh/ > eclipse, > > for the nodes in particular > > > > Nononono, this is a silly misunderstanding. Tell me, have you > ever experienced a Jupiter-eclipse? I think not. The PanchaGrahas > have their own nodes, which we don't use in astrology. Some western > astrologers do use them thou. > > > > Dear Nandan, are you trying to sya that Sanjayji refers to Graha > yuddha between the nodes and soem toher planets? Are you sure? Please > point out the page in his books or extract from emails, as I can't > recall hearing anything similar from him or from the classics. > According to my understanding, there's three classes of the planets: > teh luminaries, the pancha-grahas and the chaya grahas (nodes) which > behave distinctly in many ways, including yuddha or planetary war. > The five grahas (Mars, Mercury, Jupiter, Venus and Saturn) may enter > into a war with each other, once within 1 degree of longitude. > According to Varahamihira, the planet with a higher latitude will win > the yuddha. On the other hand, no planet may enter into a war with > the Sun and the Moon. The Sun is the overlord of all the planets, so > he will burn them up if they are too close to him. The Moon is > Krishna, who is karuna-sindhu and dina-bandhu (the ocean of mercy and > the friend of the fallen) thus He will not fight with anyone, but be > everyone's friend. The nodes however are shadowy planets, so you > can't fight with them. But true, if they approach any planet, they > will eclipse it (i.e. cast a negative influence on it) because they > represent the law of karma, and no one can fight these laws. I have > given some info in another mail how their eclipse is especially > harmful to the luminaries, as they can overpower even them. > > > > Yours, > > > > Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer > > gauranga@b... > > Jyotish Remedies: > > WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET > > Phone:+36-309-140-839 > > > > > > > > > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > Your use of is subject to > _______ Get your free @ address at Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 3, 2002 Report Share Posted January 3, 2002 Dear Gauranga! I beg to differ on the issue on whether Nodes can be defeated. While talking with Gurudev on one horoscope, I found him mentioning that Rahu was defeated by Sun, even though he was the Atmakaraka (Rahu) and hence Sun is still stronger in that Aditya Chandal Yoga. However to some extent I do agree with you that even though Rahu is defeated, the mere proximity of Rahu eclipses Sun and will show its colour whether it time would come during dasa etc. Why you need Sun's influence to remove the blemish of Ketu? Ketu is not that malefic as Rahu! In fact it is a boon in diaguise. Regards Sarajit - "Gauranga Das" <gauranga <vedic astrology> Wednesday, January 02, 2002 11:21 PM Re: [vedic astrology] Quoting Pt Rath on yudh.nodes Re: To Pt Rath: Queries from CoVA > JAYA JAGANNATHA! > > Dear Nandan, > > Namaste. > > Well, maybe my understanding is imperfect, but I still think that the nodes > of course attack any planet, but in no way can they be defeated in a war > with any planet, because they are shadowy, hence untraceable. Therefore I do > not see the necessity to invent any way to decide who is the winner in a > battle between a node and another planet. Because they are so inimical > towards anyone, they cane bear even each other's company only by staying at > the two opposite ends of the zodiac all the time. Now my understanding is > that any palanet is harmed by the nodes (in case when their influence is > taken as malefic) in the proportion of the nodes' proximity (of course an > applying aspect would be more heinous than a separating one). There is only > one way to counteract their influence: an aspect of another planet may > relieve the attacked planet from the effect. The aspecting planet should be > Mercury in case of Rahu and Sun (I'm not sure about this one) in case of > Ketu. > > Yours, > > Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer > gauranga > Jyotish Remedies: > WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET > Phone:+36-309-140-839 > > > > 3. Please refer to my recent mail just sent in response to Visti's > > reply on this, before I recd your reply. I am attaching my > > clarificatory query on this, which I asked in that mail to > > Visti: "OK, from your reply, can I summarise that: a) both the nodes > > eclipse both the luminaries if they conjoin (is there any orb, or > > the normal same-sign definition alone holds) AND this is irrespective > > of which has the higher/ lower longitude, as they dont need to > > participate in yudh with the luminaries; & b) the nodes do NOT > > eclipse the other planets, but do participate in yudh with them, with > > the caveat that the degrees are to be counted from the BEGINNING of > > the sign even for the nodes, & it is particularly virulent for Ra-Jp > > & Ke-Ma yudhs" > > > > NOW, could you or Visti or Pt Rath clarify the question in the last > > para above, which is, I think, quite clearly enunciated on > > this "nodes conjoining planets" thing, unlike my usual queries > > Best wishes > > > > Nandan > > > > vedic astrology, "Gauranga Das" <gauranga@b...> wrote: > > > JAYA JAGANNATHA! > > > > > > Dear Nandan and Visti, > > > > > > Namaste. > > > > > > 5. Nodes conjoin planet: I thought they simply eclipse any planet > > they > > > conjoin incl Sn/ Mn, but unclear fm Pt Rath, whether this is only > > if they > > > win the yudh with that plnt. Also, what is the orb for such yudh/ > > eclipse, > > > for the nodes in particular > > > > > > Nononono, this is a silly misunderstanding. Tell me, have you > > ever experienced a Jupiter-eclipse? I think not. The PanchaGrahas > > have their own nodes, which we don't use in astrology. Some western > > astrologers do use them thou. > > > > > > Dear Nandan, are you trying to sya that Sanjayji refers to Graha > > yuddha between the nodes and soem toher planets? Are you sure? Please > > point out the page in his books or extract from emails, as I can't > > recall hearing anything similar from him or from the classics. > > According to my understanding, there's three classes of the planets: > > teh luminaries, the pancha-grahas and the chaya grahas (nodes) which > > behave distinctly in many ways, including yuddha or planetary war. > > The five grahas (Mars, Mercury, Jupiter, Venus and Saturn) may enter > > into a war with each other, once within 1 degree of longitude. > > According to Varahamihira, the planet with a higher latitude will win > > the yuddha. On the other hand, no planet may enter into a war with > > the Sun and the Moon. The Sun is the overlord of all the planets, so > > he will burn them up if they are too close to him. The Moon is > > Krishna, who is karuna-sindhu and dina-bandhu (the ocean of mercy and > > the friend of the fallen) thus He will not fight with anyone, but be > > everyone's friend. The nodes however are shadowy planets, so you > > can't fight with them. But true, if they approach any planet, they > > will eclipse it (i.e. cast a negative influence on it) because they > > represent the law of karma, and no one can fight these laws. I have > > given some info in another mail how their eclipse is especially > > harmful to the luminaries, as they can overpower even them. > > > > > > Yours, > > > > > > Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer > > > gauranga@b... > > > Jyotish Remedies: > > > WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET > > > Phone:+36-309-140-839 > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > > > > > Your use of is subject to > > > > > _______ > > Get your free @ address at > > > > > > > > > > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us ....... > > > > Your use of is subject to > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.