Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

Gohanta Yoga Chart of a Butcher?

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Visti

 

>From my notes:

 

1. Cruelty Yogas: Ref Gohanta Yoga= Jp in 8, & malefic in kendra w/o any

benefic asps= Butcher, not literally, but Cruel. Raman: also if Mn in 1st

pada of Vishakha & asp by St & Sn. Also if Mn in Li & asp by Ma/ St. Of

course, many other combos wrt Ma, d-60, etc to do with cruelty in general

 

2. Dead-body rel yogas: eg 8th house association with occupn indicators

 

3. Medicine/ Surgery rel yogas

 

3. Naks: Bharani is specifically Butcher by profession, tho not by caste.

Some Naks are Butcher by caste: Ardra, Swati, Mool & Satabhishak: which may

be just a classification for low-caste, not literally butcher.

 

Visti, I know u prob'ly know all this. Just wanted to remind u on Gohanta

Yoga

 

Nandan

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vyam Vysadevaya Namaha!

------------

Dear Nandan,

Thankyou for your input, no i didn't know about the

Gohanta Yoga.

 

Regarding Varnadas, ones caste is ones classification

of ones activity, not birth-right. Maybe if you see

the Varanadas in D-108, you'll be able to classify the

persons birth-right. Hence someone born a Sudra can

become a Brahmin and etc.

 

Classifying a persons birthright as their activity is

straight-forward discrimination, and shouldn't be

encouraged. My Grand-dad was a farmer(Sudra), but my

father traveled alot and now he's a

consultant(Brahmin).

 

Hence my reasoning for analysing the Varnadas vs

Nakshatras.

But i still need a Butchers chart to experiment on.

Best wishes, Visti.

 

 

--- Nandan.Chakraborty wrote:

>

> Visti

>

> From my notes:

>

> 1. Cruelty Yogas: Ref Gohanta Yoga= Jp in 8, &

> malefic in kendra w/o any

> benefic asps= Butcher, not literally, but Cruel.

> Raman: also if Mn in 1st

> pada of Vishakha & asp by St & Sn. Also if Mn in Li

> & asp by Ma/ St. Of

> course, many other combos wrt Ma, d-60, etc to do

> with cruelty in general

>

> 2. Dead-body rel yogas: eg 8th house association

> with occupn indicators

>

> 3. Medicine/ Surgery rel yogas

>

> 3. Naks: Bharani is specifically Butcher by

> profession, tho not by caste.

> Some Naks are Butcher by caste: Ardra, Swati, Mool &

> Satabhishak: which may

> be just a classification for low-caste, not

> literally butcher.

>

> Visti, I know u prob'ly know all this. Just wanted

> to remind u on Gohanta

> Yoga

>

> Nandan

>

>

 

 

 

 

Make a great connection at Personals.

http://personals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hare Rama Krishna

Dear Visti!

 

The issue of caste by work or birth is not that simple. According to the

doctrine of karma, one is born in this life in different situations due to

his own inclination (predeliction). A person who loves food and attracted by

it will take birth in such situation where he will get his desire (i.e.,)

eating food is fulfilled. If a person is a dharmik and want's to achieve

moksha, then it is highly likely that he will take birth in a brahmin

family, so that he can fulfill his desire of meditation etc. in that

situation. Thus eventhough it is not necessary that a brahmin born is also

brahmin by karma, however, there is high likelihood that he will be a

brahmin in karma too.

 

Infact whatever I wrote is very short and just to give you some idea to

ponder upon. Believe me.. these are not my ideas and supported by

scriptures. The confusion came due to the Kali..... There is a lot to

appreciate in ancient Varna system than to criticise it saying it to be of

discrimanation. Anyway I don't wish to get into any kind of Arguements.

 

The Varna System was done for division of labour and not to give some varna,

a status that is superior over others. However, over period, the main

principles for which it is made is eroded. Thats why the confusion...

 

Regards

Sarajit

 

-

"Visti Larsen" <in_joy_i_scream

 

> Regarding Varnadas, ones caste is ones classification

> of ones activity, not birth-right. Maybe if you see

> the Varanadas in D-108, you'll be able to classify the

> persons birth-right. Hence someone born a Sudra can

> become a Brahmin and etc.

>

> Classifying a persons birthright as their activity is

> straight-forward discrimination, and shouldn't be

> encouraged. My Grand-dad was a farmer(Sudra), but my

> father traveled alot and now he's a

> consultant(Brahmin).

>

> Hence my reasoning for analysing the Varnadas vs

> Nakshatras.

> But i still need a Butchers chart to experiment on.

> Best wishes, Visti.

>

>

> --- Nandan.Chakraborty wrote:

> >

> > Visti

> >

> > From my notes:

> >

> > 1. Cruelty Yogas: Ref Gohanta Yoga= Jp in 8, &

> > malefic in kendra w/o any

> > benefic asps= Butcher, not literally, but Cruel.

> > Raman: also if Mn in 1st

> > pada of Vishakha & asp by St & Sn. Also if Mn in Li

> > & asp by Ma/ St. Of

> > course, many other combos wrt Ma, d-60, etc to do

> > with cruelty in general

> >

> > 2. Dead-body rel yogas: eg 8th house association

> > with occupn indicators

> >

> > 3. Medicine/ Surgery rel yogas

> >

> > 3. Naks: Bharani is specifically Butcher by

> > profession, tho not by caste.

> > Some Naks are Butcher by caste: Ardra, Swati, Mool &

> > Satabhishak: which may

> > be just a classification for low-caste, not

> > literally butcher.

> >

> > Visti, I know u prob'ly know all this. Just wanted

> > to remind u on Gohanta

> > Yoga

> >

> > Nandan

> >

> >

>

>

>

>

> Make a great connection at Personals.

> http://personals.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......

>

>

>

> Your use of is subject to

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hare Rama Krishna!

----

Actually Sarajit, our views aren't that far apart, i

was infact subtly-referring to Kali Yugas corruption

of the varna system.

 

Nevertheless my example was still regarding the labor

one does.

 

Best wishes, Visti.

 

 

--- Sarajit Poddar <sarajitp wrote:

> Hare Rama Krishna

> Dear Visti!

>

> The issue of caste by work or birth is not that

> simple. According to the

> doctrine of karma, one is born in this life in

> different situations due to

> his own inclination (predeliction). A person who

> loves food and attracted by

> it will take birth in such situation where he will

> get his desire (i.e.,)

> eating food is fulfilled. If a person is a dharmik

> and want's to achieve

> moksha, then it is highly likely that he will take

> birth in a brahmin

> family, so that he can fulfill his desire of

> meditation etc. in that

> situation. Thus eventhough it is not necessary that

> a brahmin born is also

> brahmin by karma, however, there is high likelihood

> that he will be a

> brahmin in karma too.

>

> Infact whatever I wrote is very short and just to

> give you some idea to

> ponder upon. Believe me.. these are not my ideas and

> supported by

> scriptures. The confusion came due to the Kali.....

> There is a lot to

> appreciate in ancient Varna system than to criticise

> it saying it to be of

> discrimanation. Anyway I don't wish to get into any

> kind of Arguements.

>

> The Varna System was done for division of labour and

> not to give some varna,

> a status that is superior over others. However, over

> period, the main

> principles for which it is made is eroded. Thats why

> the confusion...

>

> Regards

> Sarajit

>

> -

> "Visti Larsen" <in_joy_i_scream

>

> > Regarding Varnadas, ones caste is ones

> classification

> > of ones activity, not birth-right. Maybe if you

> see

> > the Varanadas in D-108, you'll be able to classify

> the

> > persons birth-right. Hence someone born a Sudra

> can

> > become a Brahmin and etc.

> >

> > Classifying a persons birthright as their activity

> is

> > straight-forward discrimination, and shouldn't be

> > encouraged. My Grand-dad was a farmer(Sudra), but

> my

> > father traveled alot and now he's a

> > consultant(Brahmin).

> >

> > Hence my reasoning for analysing the Varnadas vs

> > Nakshatras.

> > But i still need a Butchers chart to experiment

> on.

> > Best wishes, Visti.

> >

> >

> > --- Nandan.Chakraborty wrote:

> > >

> > > Visti

> > >

> > > From my notes:

> > >

> > > 1. Cruelty Yogas: Ref Gohanta Yoga= Jp in 8, &

> > > malefic in kendra w/o any

> > > benefic asps= Butcher, not literally, but Cruel.

> > > Raman: also if Mn in 1st

> > > pada of Vishakha & asp by St & Sn. Also if Mn in

> Li

> > > & asp by Ma/ St. Of

> > > course, many other combos wrt Ma, d-60, etc to

> do

> > > with cruelty in general

> > >

> > > 2. Dead-body rel yogas: eg 8th house association

> > > with occupn indicators

> > >

> > > 3. Medicine/ Surgery rel yogas

> > >

> > > 3. Naks: Bharani is specifically Butcher by

> > > profession, tho not by caste.

> > > Some Naks are Butcher by caste: Ardra, Swati,

> Mool &

> > > Satabhishak: which may

> > > be just a classification for low-caste, not

> > > literally butcher.

> > >

> > > Visti, I know u prob'ly know all this. Just

> wanted

> > > to remind u on Gohanta

> > > Yoga

> > >

> > > Nandan

> > >

> > >

> >

> >

> >

> >

> > Make a great connection at Personals.

> > http://personals.

> >

> >

> > Archives:

> vedic astrology

> >

> > Group info:

>

vedic astrology/info.html

> >

> > To UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to

> vedic astrology-

> >

> > ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......

> >

> > || Om Tat Sat || Sarvam Sri

> Krishnaarpanamastu ||

> >

> > Your use of is subject to

>

> >

> >

>

>

 

 

 

 

Make a great connection at Personals.

http://personals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Chart of surgeon

1st Aprill 1951

16:15 pm

80E0

9N40

+5:30 GMT

 

Note Raja Yoga in 8th with 1st and 5th lords strongly placed. Also 10th

ruler with vargottama own sign mars in 9th. 8th ruler exalted in navamsa.

Strong navamsa and dasamsa.

-

<Nandan.Chakraborty

<vedic astrology>

Monday, October 15, 2001 6:15 AM

Gohanta Yoga Re: [vedic astrology] Chart of a Butcher?

 

 

>

>

> Visti

>

> From my notes:

>

> 1. Cruelty Yogas: Ref Gohanta Yoga= Jp in 8, & malefic in kendra w/o any

> benefic asps= Butcher, not literally, but Cruel. Raman: also if Mn in 1st

> pada of Vishakha & asp by St & Sn. Also if Mn in Li & asp by Ma/ St. Of

> course, many other combos wrt Ma, d-60, etc to do with cruelty in general

>

> 2. Dead-body rel yogas: eg 8th house association with occupn indicators

>

> 3. Medicine/ Surgery rel yogas

>

> 3. Naks: Bharani is specifically Butcher by profession, tho not by caste.

> Some Naks are Butcher by caste: Ardra, Swati, Mool & Satabhishak: which

may

> be just a classification for low-caste, not literally butcher.

>

> Visti, I know u prob'ly know all this. Just wanted to remind u on Gohanta

> Yoga

>

> Nandan

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......

>

>

>

> Your use of is subject to

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Vyam Vysadevaya Namaha!

--------

Dear Nimmi,

Is this a cosmetic surgeon(rahu+venus in 10th

Dasamsa)?

Notably: (Navamsa)See Ketu placed in 3rd; Scorpio from

Lagnamsa = Precise hands.

 

Venus and Mars influence 2nd in Navamsa(Strong sexual

desires), as Rahu and Moon are in 9th(Shakti Yoga).

Venus is also Atmakaraka.

 

Has the surgeon ever had any problems with patients of

opposite sex?

Best wishes, Visti.

 

 

 

--- Nimmi Ragavan <106350.3660 wrote:

> Chart of surgeon

> 1st Aprill 1951

> 16:15 pm

> 80E0

> 9N40

> +5:30 GMT

>

> Note Raja Yoga in 8th with 1st and 5th lords

> strongly placed. Also 10th

> ruler with vargottama own sign mars in 9th. 8th

> ruler exalted in navamsa.

> Strong navamsa and dasamsa.

> -

> <Nandan.Chakraborty

> <vedic astrology>

> Monday, October 15, 2001 6:15 AM

> Gohanta Yoga Re: [vedic astrology] Chart of

> a Butcher?

 

 

 

 

 

Make a great connection at Personals.

http://personals.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Hi Visti,

 

No, he is a heart surgeon (strong 5th ruler Jupiter and sun in rasi yoga?).

And in dasamsa 10th ruler is strongly placed in the 10th and happens to be

5th ruler. Sun is exalted and mutually aspects the 10th lord from the 4th.

If he was a cosmetic surgeon, would you not expect mercury the artificer

(creator of bhadra yog) to be also involved in it somewhere? Rahu distorts

rather than cures I would have thought. It would be interesting to look at a

chart for a cosmetic surgeon. I would also expect venus in own sign in rasi

for that.

 

I also do not think the 8th house would be so strong. Here he is dealing

with matters of life and death as indicated by the 8th. I would more likely

expect the association of mars in the 10th where surgeory is used as a tool

to achieve other matters, with strong venus, mercury etc.

 

I find that I need to look for confirmation in the divisional charts rather

than for interpretations. This may be the selection of charts I have come

across. For example, if I look at my rasi chart, my 10th ruler is in the

12th with sun and mars. So almost from the beginning, except for around 4

months, my whole working career was overseas. Sun rules the 3rd and my

current and main area is in computing. Mars rules the 6th and 11th, and is

very close to my rather strong mercury. So for a while I had a very

mathematical career where maths was used as an analytical tool - actuarial

valuations of pension funds. I did some teaching at university for a while -

9th ruler saturn aspecting the 10th and in turn aspected by jupiter from the

12th - the teaching was in an overseas university largely during

jupiter/saturn. But if I look at my dasamsa, the 10th lord is in the 3rd

with the 3rd ruler. So I have stayed longest with the computing career.

There is no confirmation of the teaching job - for me it was just something

I did while pursuing postgrad studies. Mercury is in the 4th but with moon,

not mars. So the mathematical career faded away though I have fond

recollections of it and do go back to it occasionally just to some more

studies in the area. But the focus seems to be stuck on the 3rd house.

Current dasa is saturn. In rasi it is in the 4th house, in dasamsa in the

12th. During this dasa, in Sat/Venus for 2 years I worked from home on

software development(that 3rd house again!), but home at that time was

overseas! My feeling is that the divisional charts add colour, but within

the picture of the rasi chart. I tend now to interpret divisional charts to

perhaps narrow something down (if I actually do bother, mostly I am happy

with the broad picture) or look for modifying influences.

 

No, he has had no problems with patients at all, but he once had a run in

with a nurse

who tried to claim he came to operations drunk! This was a subject of an

inquiry. It turned out she was married to a rival surgeon who was not happy

with this guy's reputation getting too big. He came out of it with shining

honours.

 

He is married with children and is rather religious, though he was

considered a very handsome eligible bachelor and heartbreaker (!) in his

younger days. But he works very hard and is usually stressed out.

 

Regards,

 

Nimmi

 

-

"Visti Larsen" <in_joy_i_scream

<vedic astrology>

Monday, October 15, 2001 9:21 PM

Re: Gohanta Yoga Re: [vedic astrology] Chart of a Butcher?

 

 

>

> Vyam Vysadevaya Namaha!

> --------

> Dear Nimmi,

> Is this a cosmetic surgeon(rahu+venus in 10th

> Dasamsa)?

> Notably: (Navamsa)See Ketu placed in 3rd; Scorpio from

> Lagnamsa = Precise hands.

>

> Venus and Mars influence 2nd in Navamsa(Strong sexual

> desires), as Rahu and Moon are in 9th(Shakti Yoga).

> Venus is also Atmakaraka.

>

> Has the surgeon ever had any problems with patients of

> opposite sex?

> Best wishes, Visti.

>

>

>

> --- Nimmi Ragavan <106350.3660 wrote:

> > Chart of surgeon

> > 1st Aprill 1951

> > 16:15 pm

> > 80E0

> > 9N40

> > +5:30 GMT

> >

> > Note Raja Yoga in 8th with 1st and 5th lords

> > strongly placed. Also 10th

> > ruler with vargottama own sign mars in 9th. 8th

> > ruler exalted in navamsa.

> > Strong navamsa and dasamsa.

> > -

> > <Nandan.Chakraborty

> > <vedic astrology>

> > Monday, October 15, 2001 6:15 AM

> > Gohanta Yoga Re: [vedic astrology] Chart of

> > a Butcher?

>

>

>

>

>

> Make a great connection at Personals.

> http://personals.

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

>

> ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......

>

>

>

> Your use of is subject to

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...