Guest guest Posted September 9, 2001 Report Share Posted September 9, 2001 --- Sarma Karra <sarmakarra wrote: > Dear Sarma, > Zai Ganesh. It is perfectly possible in cetain > situations and we shouldn't > generalise based on one combination. However, it is > easier tosay when we can > apply this rule and how? can you please tell me when and how precisely? I got an anolgy of a > particular native with no > maraka or planets aspecting marakas not coming any > where after 40 years. The > native finally passed away in 11th Lord Das and 1st > Lord Antardasa. Many an > astrologer has seen the horoscope and couldn't > predict or reason it until > after the event. yes.astrology is full of such incidents which cannot be explained by straitht rules.But you have a mass of knowledge and after all post-facto analysis is the most easiest thing on this planet,because you can always find a rule to suit your choice and convenience. > Coming back to the Jupiter issue, By any chance, Is > jupiter beyond 25 > degrees and is in 6th house in Bhava with a bit of > support from Navamsa as > well. Your observation could be true if the 7th lord > doesn't allow marriage > in the first instance. After all you can't harvest > until unless the Kshetram > is available and a seedling planted. In my view, > this gets aggravated, > particularly, if Ketu is aspecting the 5th house as > well. Last but not the > least, What about the Dasa? jupiter is in 14th degree and in 5th pada hence in leo in navamsa.The dasa running is of saturn.she is swati star native and thula rasi. > Rather than looking at which approach is right, my > view is to look at > alternate directions as you never get a probablity > of 1 in any approach. of course,one should be insane to disagree with you on this point.It is also THE point i want to stress.But alternate directions will assist you in post-facto analysis but again there is a problem --when to apply which alternative in future predictions? If > so, we wouldn't be on this list because we will be > advising the world > leaders in all fields then. Hope this will lead you > into another direction > of analysis. my argument right from the begining of my entry into this group is about one point,but i have to touch others as well in the course of discussion anyway. > Good Luck and God Bless you. > Sarma Karra thanks and namaskaar... > > >"r.sathyanarayana sharma" > <rssharmabza > >vedic astrology > >vedic astrology > >Re: [vedic astrology] Re: dear narasimha > >Sat, 8 Sep 2001 17:24:59 +0100 (BST) > > > > dear narasimha, > >namaskar.thanks for your reply.please consider my > >arguments. > >1.How to decide something is rishi proktam and > >something is not, especially in a subject like > >jyothisham, where you can explain a certain event > from > >so many angles and arrive at equally good > results.For > >example,the bhrigu sutram quoted by you might be > one > >of the interpolations as well.Please dont tell me > that > >experience proves it,because only yesterday i saw a > >horescope of leo lagna with jupiter in 5th.The > native > >is 40 years old and NEITHER married NOR having any > >children as on date.you may want to see the whole > >horoscope to refute me saying that 7 th lord or > bhava > >is bad etc,.but my point is proved by this > >horoscope,if charts stand as proof to rules,that > too > >picked up ones as per one's choice. > >2.The divisional chart is only subsidiary to rasi > >chart, and never a substitute to it.Neither it can > >totally alter the result shown in the rasi chart to > >the extent of marring the whole prospect of any > bhava. > >3.I can equally show any number of charts to prove > my > >point, but you can reject my point showing equally > >good reasons,so nothing is proved finally.This is > like > >fighting for nothing's sake. > >4.I WOULD like to point out that this divisional > >charts business is itself controversial,in the > >sense,when there is no agreement on the ayanamsa > >question,and given that all the birth times need > >correction this way or that,your divisional charts > >cannot be safe, because a slight variation in birth > >time can drastically affect the amsa charts like > D-60 > >or the nadi amsa. > >can i hope for any answer? > >sarma > > > >__________ > > > >Send a newsletter, share photos & files, conduct > polls, organize chat > >events. Visit http://in/ > > > _______________ > Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at > http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp > > __________ Send a newsletter, share photos & files, conduct polls, organize chat events. Visit http://in/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.