Is D-1 a superset of other D-charts? (reply to Mahalinga)

[Guest guest]

Namaste Mahalinga,

 

> 2. If we have a unique individual like Rajiv Gandhi (for example),

> and if we assign one Nadiamsa to him (based on his birth time

> and known Nadiamsa effects), then we have to assume that he

> does not share that Nadiamsa with anybody. Because if he did,

> then that other person with whom he shared the Nadiamsa did

> not become the PM etc etc, so the Nadiamsa effects did not

> manifest for that other person! Note that I am not saying that

> *only* the Nadiamsa should not be shared, but that we have to

> essentially assume that nobody else was born within a minute

> of Rajiv Gandhi in that same place. Can we reasonably make

> that assumption??

 

Have you taken into account the effects of the parents charts, and

other family member charts on the individual? If the parets charts

promise a powerful child, then they will help to lift up the child.

 

Likewise the charts of all family members, wife, friends, etc will

affect the destiny of the person. Similarily the past generations of

family, local townsmen, and so on. Even the fate of the country in

such cases. There are millions of factors externally influencing the

chart of the owner through their own karmas.

 

In this case, even with the same D-300, you will get differing

results. The DKP distinction is neccessary keeping this in mind.

There are many yogas that state that someone born of a royal family

will be a king, while one born ordinary will be merely rich; which

can be extrapolated to the entire chart. This is one of the reasons

why.

 

All the best,

 

Alex J

[Guest guest]

Namaste Alex,

 

> Have you taken into account the effects of the parents charts, and

> other family member charts on the individual? If the parets charts

> promise a powerful child, then they will help to lift up the child.

 

The parents charts' may *indicate* a powerful child. I don't believe

charts "lift up" or "pull down" anybody. In any case, can you

illustrate what you are saying further?

 

> Likewise the charts of all family members, wife, friends, etc will

> affect the destiny of the person. Similarily the past generations

of

> family, local townsmen, and so on. Even the fate of the country in

> such cases. There are millions of factors externally influencing

the

> chart of the owner through their own karmas.

 

Sure. But are you suggesting I take a quick look at a random sample

of local townsmen's charts?

 

Look, I am not saying nothing other than the chart will influence

the destiny of the person. My question has to do with how we are

going to analyse a chart to see those influences.

 

In my opinion, sorry - analysing the parents' or siblings' charts

is not an option, it would complicate the picture further. Other

list members may or may not agree with you on this...

 

I remain,

 

Mahalinga Iyer

[Guest guest]

Namaste,

 

vedic astrology, mahalinga_iyer wrote:

> Namaste Alex,

>

> > Have you taken into account the effects of the parents charts, and

> > other family member charts on the individual? If the parets charts

> > promise a powerful child, then they will help to lift up the

child.

>

> The parents charts' may *indicate* a powerful child. I don't believe

> charts "lift up" or "pull down" anybody. In any case, can you

> illustrate what you are saying further?

 

Karma in present life may lift/pull down the chart. Thats why one need

to look at the horary chart along with Natal chart.

 

Regards, V

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

>

> > Likewise the charts of all family members, wife, friends, etc will

> > affect the destiny of the person. Similarily the past generations

> of

> > family, local townsmen, and so on. Even the fate of the country in

> > such cases. There are millions of factors externally influencing

> the

> > chart of the owner through their own karmas.

>

> Sure. But are you suggesting I take a quick look at a random sample

> of local townsmen's charts?

>

> Look, I am not saying nothing other than the chart will influence

> the destiny of the person. My question has to do with how we are

> going to analyse a chart to see those influences.

>

> In my opinion, sorry - analysing the parents' or siblings' charts

> is not an option, it would complicate the picture further. Other

> list members may or may not agree with you on this...

>

> I remain,

>

> Mahalinga Iyer

[Guest guest]

AUM SRI GURUVE NAMAH

Dear Venkateswara!

 

 

> Karma in present life may lift/pull down the chart. Thats why one need

> to look at the horary chart along with Natal chart.

>

 

You cannot infer that one need horary chart because, the karma lifts or

pulls down the chart. This is only done because the indications from the

natal horoscope is not easily deciphered due to our own limitations. Taking

help of prashna chart ease our effort of deciphering something.

 

Regards

Sarajit

 

> Regards, V

[Guest guest]

JAYA JAGANNATHA!

 

Namaste.

 

 

 

>

>

> AUM SRI GURUVE NAMAH

> Dear Venkateswara!

>

>

> > Karma in present life may lift/pull down the chart. Thats why one need

> > to look at the horary chart along with Natal chart.

> >

>

> You cannot infer that one need horary chart because, the karma lifts or

> pulls down the chart. This is only done because the indications from the

> natal horoscope is not easily deciphered due to our own limitations.

Taking

> help of prashna chart ease our effort of deciphering something.

>

 

I think that this is a very interesting question indeed, and please allow me

to throw in my two cents. This is the understanding that I have come up

with, and may not necessarily be perfect, so comments are welcome. The natal

chart indicates the soul's karmic situation as a result of the summary

reactions of the activities coimmitted by him in his previous lives. Now

coming to this lifetime he has certain situations in his karma that will

manifest in the future. Dr. Raman also makes this difference in his books.

But the individual goes on commuitting certain activities and making

decisions in this life, which may still give some influence on the

situations which are to manifest in the future. This is the principle of

applying remedial measures.

 

Therefore my understanding is that the birth chart should indicate a set of

options that are in front of the individual, and according to his

decisions, he will realise one aspect of them. Now to pinpoint how his

decisions will go from moment to moment, the Prasha chart ios very useful.

Dr. Raman said that if an event is indicated by the boirth chart, then it is

caused by the karma of the previous life, and if it is indicated only in the

Prasna chart, then it is caused by the karma accumulated in this life.

 

I hope this makes sense.

 

Yours,

 

Gauranga Das Vedic Astrologer

<gauranga

Phone: +36-309-140-839

Jyotish Remedies:

WWW.BRIHASPATI.NET

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

_______

 

Get your free @ address at