My Reply- Rupinder (Rationalist)

[Guest guest]

Dear Rupinder,

There is a big difference between western

astrological studies and vedic jyotish. Vedic astrology is much deeper, more

analytical and precise. Here we do not stop at the ascendent chart of a

native but all other charts, which can change with minute differences in

time, are also studied.

 

They had studied 2000 babies born within minutes of each other. It

is obvious that all these babies could not have been born in London itself.

If they were born in some other places, then there will be big differences

in their horoscopes.

 

In short, all such research work and data collection is passe for

me. They form an integral part of psychological studies and I am fully aware

of the efficacies and precision of data used in them.

 

I will again emphasize that you should learn vedic jyotish yourself

and then judge its worth. you can make a good astrologer because good

opponents can become good followers and also vice-versa.

 

Regards,

 

 

Ashutosh.

 

 

 

 

-

rupinderrinku <rupinderrinku

Astrologer Ashutosh <astrologerashutosh

Monday, July 04, 2005 00:03

My Reply- Rupinder (Rationalist)

 

 

> Dear Ashutosh ji,

> I would like to thank you for giving response to my views(no

> matter positive or negative). i sent my reply for the message board

> but moderator has not given me space for it as it was being requested

> by some of your members to the moderator, that he should not allow

> such kind of views on the message board. But we Rationalists welcome

> the people who are ready to share their views with rational conducts

> instead of running away from the topic. So here i am sending you an

> article privately to few of your members, who responded to me in any

> way...

>

> Here is article for you.

>

> There is nothing written in the stars!

>

> Astrology fails scientific mega test

>

> A detailed scientific long-term study by researchers in Britain

> proves the central principle of astrology invalid and baseless. It

> puts an end to the fantastic old claim that the constellation of

> stars and planets at the time of birth could influence or even

> determine the development of an individual's character and course of

> life.

> The "Time Twin Study" was started in London in 1958 as a medical

> research project. Registering more than 2,000 babies, born within

> minutes of each other on a day in early March, it had the objective

> to compare the time twins' health development. The field of

> investigation was soon extended. The research team monitored the test

> persons over several decades, recording observations about more than

> 100 parameters in connection with health, occupation, marital

> situation, anxiety level, aggressiveness, sociability, IQ levels,

> abilities in music, art, sport, mathematics, language etc. They tried

> to collect evidences for similarities between the time twins.

> However, no similarities could be identified.

> "The test conditions could hardly have been more conducive to success

> but the results are uniformly negative", stated Dr. Geoffrey Dean,

> astrologer turned scientist from Perth, Australia, in a report about

> the study, published in the current issue of the Journal of

> Consciousness Studies. Carrying out an analysis of the study, Dr.

> Dean and his collegue Prof. Ivan Kelley, Psychologist at the

> University of Saskatchewan, Canada, found that there was no special

> trait or tendency shared by the time twins. They were just as

> different as people born on any other day under any other planetary

> constellation.

> The claim that stars and planets could influence character and life

> of human beings has long been dismissed by rationalists and

> scientists as there is according to all known scientific principles

> no kind of mechanism imaginable by way of which this influence could

> possibly work. Here is empirical proof that it does not work at all.

> The study shows clearly that astrological predictions based on the

> coordinates of birth do not correspond with reality. They are nothing

> but exercises in deception.

> This should be the end of one of the oldest superstitions. But it is

> not hard to predict that the show will still go on. There are

> obviously too many people, who like to be deceived and too many, who

> make enormous money by deceiving them..

>

>

>

 

 

 

 

 

 

_________________________

Appel audio GRATUIT partout dans le monde avec le nouveau Messenger

Téléchargez cette version sur http://fr.messenger.