Rupinder Singh ji - a rationalist reply

[Guest guest]

Rupinder Singh ji,

 

<<<Our tarksheel society has exposed so many Astrologers in

front of people as they are fraud.>>>

 

This is quite good. Of course, I know of many astrologers who

have exposed the half-baked assumptions of "rationalists" too!

 

<<<Till today no one won our challenge and we know nobody can

win our challenge.>>>

 

I agree with you. You have deliberately chosen questions that

cannot be answered by astrology.

 

So, let me ask you this, Mr Want-to-be-a-doctor - can you tell

me, if I produce a cancer patient, EXACTLY how long he will

live? Of course not! You will hem and haw about chemotheraphy,

modern medicine, etc, but can you tell me that "He will die on

20 July 2005?" No way! So, is medicine a fraud?

 

There are fake astrologers - but, need I remind you that there

are so many fake doctors too?

 

<<<Anyway i am student in a medical college, and going to become

a doctor. I don't have enough time to stay online because of my

studies.>>>

 

How nice! You have time to throw challenges, but not the time to

stay online because of your studies! Most convinient for you, I

suppose!

 

<<<My duty is just to bring our challenge infront of as many

people as possible, so that people should come to know that

astrology is just a fraud.>>>

 

Why not stick to your own profession and expose the fake doctors

instead? A far more noble calling!

 

And, by the way, you are just a yet-to-become doctor. If you

read Shri BV Raman's books, you will know that there are doctors

who actually see the chart of a patient to gain knowlewdge that

their puny scalpels cannot tell them! Let me recommend his

auto-biographical book "My experience in Astrology" Read it, and

hopefully, it will make you wise, becasue Shri BV Raman, himself

a great astrologer, also managed to expose many frauds.

 

<<<Mahatma Gandhi ji aslo wrote in one of his book that

"Astrology is one of old superstion.>>>

 

With due respect to our beloved Father of the Nation, the

Supreme Court has said that Astrology is a science. So, do you

want to commit contempt of court?

 

<<<From 18 to 20 December 2004 thousands of great and famous

Astrologers get together for "Jyotish maha-samelan" at

Jalandhar(Punjab) but no one of them was able to predict that

just after one week there will be "Tsunami" which will kill

lakhs of people.>>>

 

So many doctors have met time and again, and still AIDS and

cancer continues to kill is...

 

<<<At last I request to all the people that you should not waste

your money which you have got by your hard work, to the

Astrologers.>>>

 

Hello! Most of us on this group do readings for FREE. If you had

visited the group and checked out the postings for a week or so,

you would have never heard money being mentioned. You are the

first person to mention money on this forum!

 

So, Mr Motor Mouth, might I advice you to get back to your

studies? If you don't, you might fail, and be forced to become

one of the fake astrologers (maybe, you could use a parrot for

added effect!) you so much despise!

 

If I have failed to insult, I apologize.

 

 

~~~~~~~

Balaji Narasimhan * http://www.sherlock-holmes.com/balaji.htm

Author, Sherlock Holmes: Solutions from the Sussex Downs

Editor, The Partial Art of Detection

~~~~~~~

 

Send instant messages to your online friends http://uk.messenger.