Guest guest Posted April 7, 2005 Report Share Posted April 7, 2005 dear learned astrologers, i have a question regarding reciting the maha mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra so it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the question, as it would help me from committing a paap. may god bless you all renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 7, 2005 Report Share Posted April 7, 2005 NO renu...u cannot!some say u can after the 5th day provided uve taken a headbath..not sure abt that part tho.. , "renu4c" <renu4c> wrote: > > dear learned astrologers, > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra so > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > may god bless you all > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 8, 2005 Report Share Posted April 8, 2005 Hi Renu It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become impure or inauspicious during the menses. You can recite the mantra during this period too. Best Regards , "renu4c" <renu4c> wrote: > > dear learned astrologers, > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra so > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > may god bless you all > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 8, 2005 Report Share Posted April 8, 2005 Dear friend, ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you know what is the final effect? Know well about what you say, do and think! humbly, KAD , "natalcharts_biz" <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > Hi Renu > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > Best Regards > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> wrote: > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra so > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > may god bless you all > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 9, 2005 Report Share Posted April 9, 2005 I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or while having sex too cos it is all natural.. So why bother at all. It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur advice. People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have serious knowledge too. It was a dumb statement on ur part. This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according to the prescribed norms. Regards Dhruv , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> wrote: > > Dear friend, > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you > know what is the final effect? > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > humbly, > KAD > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > Hi Renu > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > wrote: > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra > so > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 9, 2005 Report Share Posted April 9, 2005 The brahman contains us all.. the shakti rupini is the one which manifests. A shakti chants Brahman's mantra... and you are asking the veda. Think again before raising your voice. Mantra is made of syallables to reverberate the forces of nature and direct us and help us to this realization. Mahamritunjya mantra is for the Lord of Time... Lord Shiva himself and you want to contain its japa through time of menses! Tradition does not support the Veda...Authority is needed only when tarka is missing and here it is none. If you still feel, I have said something wrong... I will still stand by it and wait for you to decide again. Best regards , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> wrote: > > Dear friend, > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you > know what is the final effect? > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > humbly, > KAD > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > Hi Renu > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > wrote: > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra > so > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 9, 2005 Report Share Posted April 9, 2005 Identifying oneself as separate from the lord and then dividing the lord's nature Shakti into pure and impure... must be Sattwa for you... not for me. I implore you to think again and I stand by my words. Regards , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the > mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or > while having sex too cos it is all natural.. > So why bother at all. > It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur > advice. > People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have > serious knowledge too. > It was a dumb statement on ur part. > This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made > If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according > to the prescribed norms. > Regards > Dhruv > > > , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> wrote: > > > > Dear friend, > > > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell > > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT > > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right > > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, > > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you > > know what is the final effect? > > > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > > > humbly, > > KAD > > > > > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > > > Hi Renu > > > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra > > so > > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 9, 2005 Report Share Posted April 9, 2005 Obviously you do not understand the difference between an activity and something natural... Shitting and pissing is activity as your need to concentrate and force it. Sex is an activity too and in Tantra ...this activity is also used as a means to meditate. Menses is not an activity and it is not forced. People do pray at Graveyard and at the Hospital. Temple is not the only place where people pray. As lord is all and all is Lord, praying anywhere is not any different except of the mind's notions of purity and impurity. I do not wish to fight collective ignorance of people. You are as free to think what is right and wrong and I am. I have given my reasonings and my comments. It is for the person concerned to see whether or not she wishes to follow these comments. Thanks and Regards , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the > mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or > while having sex too cos it is all natural.. > So why bother at all. > It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur > advice. > People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have > serious knowledge too. > It was a dumb statement on ur part. > This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made > If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according > to the prescribed norms. > Regards > Dhruv > > > , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> wrote: > > > > Dear friend, > > > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell > > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT > > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right > > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, > > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you > > know what is the final effect? > > > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > > > humbly, > > KAD > > > > > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > > > Hi Renu > > > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra > > so > > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 9, 2005 Report Share Posted April 9, 2005 Namaste all, When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... Regards Arun Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? Respectfully, Sana arun <savitarcyber wrote: Namaste all, When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... Regards Arun ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Hello Members, I am afraid aspects of divinity and bodily functions have differeent apsects from soul and perishable issues. When we are referring to spirtual issues,it is not that we have no reference to our culture and traditions.Astrology basically is a field that always gives highest priority and preference to Desha and Kaal Maan practices.Let us not get into the course of discussions prepare for condemnation of significant Vedic belief.We may not practice but we may not go in and ingnore and question the veracity too Krishnan John Sana <sanajohn2000 wrote: Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? Respectfully, Sana arun wrote: Namaste all, When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... Regards Arun ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Make your home page Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Dear Arun, this is a good story that uve told but where in this story is the justification of allowing chanting during periods? If ur goignt o chant a mantra written by some one u have to follow the procedure too. Its better to be safe than sorry.. that goes for everything REgards Dhruv , "arun" <savitarcyber> wrote: > > Namaste all, > > When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own > father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. > Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. > Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every > month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly > priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. > > During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british > collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its > further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had > non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer > removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. > > What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... > > Regards > > Arun Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Dear Sana, its being compared to sex and takin a dump because they too are bodily functions. If spirituality is about soul..forget mantra. No need to chant mantras too. Cos they have been written by a human..just think with ur spirit and it will be allright. Regards Dhruv , John Sana <sanajohn2000> wrote: > Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? > > Respectfully, > Sana > > arun <savitarcyber> wrote: > > Namaste all, > > When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own > father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. > Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. > Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every > month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly > priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. > > During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british > collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its > further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had > non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer > removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. > > What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... > > Regards > > Arun > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 SHE WILL NOT DO IT .. Here is y.. COS ITS BETTER TO BE SAFE THAN SORRY Regards Dhruv btw even piss n dump are not forced ..they are completely natural and the first things everyone inthe world does in the morning at brahm muhurat ...before they chant !! , "natalcharts_biz" <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > Obviously you do not understand the difference between an activity and > something natural... > Shitting and pissing is activity as your need to concentrate and force > it. > > Sex is an activity too and in Tantra ...this activity is also used as > a means to meditate. > > Menses is not an activity and it is not forced. > > People do pray at Graveyard and at the Hospital. Temple is not the > only place where people pray. As lord is all and all is Lord, praying > anywhere is not any different except of the mind's notions of purity > and impurity. > > I do not wish to fight collective ignorance of people. You are as free > to think what is right and wrong and I am. I have given my reasonings > and my comments. It is for the person concerned to see whether or not > she wishes to follow these comments. > > Thanks and Regards > > , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > > > I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the > > mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or > > while having sex too cos it is all natural.. > > So why bother at all. > > It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur > > advice. > > People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have > > serious knowledge too. > > It was a dumb statement on ur part. > > This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made > > If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according > > to the prescribed norms. > > Regards > > Dhruv > > > > > > , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> > wrote: > > > > > > Dear friend, > > > > > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please tell > > > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > > > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > > > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > > > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > > > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > > > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > > > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > > > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > > > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > > > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO NOT > > > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > > > > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when right > > > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > > > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > > > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > > > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > > > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > > > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper way(KAVACHA, > > > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > > > > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do you > > > know what is the final effect? > > > > > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > > > > > humbly, > > > KAD > > > > > > > > > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > > > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > > > > > Hi Renu > > > > > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha mantra > > > so > > > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer the > > > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Namaste Dhruv, Can you tell me where in the Rig Veda is it said that Women cannot chant during mensus? The Mantras of the Rig-Veda are said to above all defect. Now the Mritunjaya mantra of Vasishtha Maharishi is in the Rig -Veda and therefore above defect. regards arun , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > Dear Arun, > this is a good story that uve told but where in this story is the > justification of allowing chanting during periods? > If ur goignt o chant a mantra written by some one u have to follow the > procedure too. > Its better to be safe than sorry.. that goes for everything > REgards > Dhruv > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Dear ARun, I am sorry i did not grasp what ur trying to say here. Perhaps my poor knowledge of english.. but can u explain what you are saying? Regards Dhruv , "arun" <savitarcyber> wrote: > > Namaste Dhruv, > > Can you tell me where in the Rig Veda is it said that Women cannot > chant during mensus? The Mantras of the Rig-Veda are said to above all > defect. Now the Mritunjaya mantra of Vasishtha Maharishi is in the Rig > -Veda and therefore above defect. > > regards > > arun > > , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > > > Dear Arun, > > this is a good story that uve told but where in this story is the > > justification of allowing chanting during periods? > > If ur goignt o chant a mantra written by some one u have to follow the > > procedure too. > > Its better to be safe than sorry.. that goes for everything > > REgards > > Dhruv > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Dear Dhruv Do you become impure because you shit and piss? Should you not chant your mantras as you have pissed everyday? By correcting your thinking, I do not wish to show you down or cause disrespect. To your other contention, that if Brahman is all then why chant... it is because the mind does not let us see... through its pair of opposites - likes-dislikes, purity-impurity, etc.... The lady wants to pray for her parent's health and well being and you are stopping a prayer to the Lord by her just because you do not agre e to the idea? I ask you to sit alone and think again. Again I say, Menstruation is a natural function governed by the Lord, it does not change your devotion or your ability to pray to the Lord. And you cannot force your "decision" on others. Thanks and Regards. , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > SHE WILL NOT DO IT .. > Here is y.. > COS ITS BETTER TO BE SAFE THAN SORRY > Regards > Dhruv > btw even piss n dump are not forced ..they are completely natural and > the first things everyone inthe world does in the morning at brahm > muhurat ...before they chant !! > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > Obviously you do not understand the difference between an activity and > > something natural... > > Shitting and pissing is activity as your need to concentrate and force > > it. > > > > Sex is an activity too and in Tantra ...this activity is also used as > > a means to meditate. > > > > Menses is not an activity and it is not forced. > > > > People do pray at Graveyard and at the Hospital. Temple is not the > > only place where people pray. As lord is all and all is Lord, praying > > anywhere is not any different except of the mind's notions of purity > > and impurity. > > > > I do not wish to fight collective ignorance of people. You are as free > > to think what is right and wrong and I am. I have given my reasonings > > and my comments. It is for the person concerned to see whether or not > > she wishes to follow these comments. > > > > Thanks and Regards > > > > , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> > wrote: > > > > > > I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the > > > mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or > > > while having sex too cos it is all natural.. > > > So why bother at all. > > > It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur > > > advice. > > > People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have > > > serious knowledge too. > > > It was a dumb statement on ur part. > > > This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made > > > If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according > > > to the prescribed norms. > > > Regards > > > Dhruv > > > > > > > > > , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear friend, > > > > > > > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please > tell > > > > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > > > > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > > > > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > > > > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > > > > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > > > > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > > > > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > > > > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > > > > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > > > > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO > NOT > > > > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > > > > > > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when > right > > > > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > > > > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > > > > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > > > > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > > > > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > > > > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper > way(KAVACHA, > > > > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > > > > > > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do > you > > > > know what is the final effect? > > > > > > > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > > > > > > > humbly, > > > > KAD > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > > > > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hi Renu > > > > > > > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > > > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > > > > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > > > > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha > mantra > > > > so > > > > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer > the > > > > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 And one more thing: The only way a mantra can cause problem for oneself is when it is used for nefarious purposes - to kill a noble person, etc... One more thought to ponder: A pure mind is better than a pure body. Have you been to Rishikesh? There are hundreds of Sannyasis and some of them in deep meditation. Their bodies sometimes are very dirty ... yet mind is absorbed in meditation. It would be foolish to ask them to take a bath in Gangaji and then teach them a method of puja. Best Regards , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > SHE WILL NOT DO IT .. > Here is y.. > COS ITS BETTER TO BE SAFE THAN SORRY > Regards > Dhruv > btw even piss n dump are not forced ..they are completely natural and > the first things everyone inthe world does in the morning at brahm > muhurat ...before they chant !! > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > Obviously you do not understand the difference between an activity and > > something natural... > > Shitting and pissing is activity as your need to concentrate and force > > it. > > > > Sex is an activity too and in Tantra ...this activity is also used as > > a means to meditate. > > > > Menses is not an activity and it is not forced. > > > > People do pray at Graveyard and at the Hospital. Temple is not the > > only place where people pray. As lord is all and all is Lord, praying > > anywhere is not any different except of the mind's notions of purity > > and impurity. > > > > I do not wish to fight collective ignorance of people. You are as free > > to think what is right and wrong and I am. I have given my reasonings > > and my comments. It is for the person concerned to see whether or not > > she wishes to follow these comments. > > > > Thanks and Regards > > > > , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> > wrote: > > > > > > I can add to that. Going by HIS logic it must be allright to chant the > > > mantra while shitting and pissing and at the graveyard or hospital or > > > while having sex too cos it is all natural.. > > > So why bother at all. > > > It is a Sattvic mantra mister. Use some brains before putting up ur > > > advice. > > > People here take advice seriously and they expect people to have > > > serious knowledge too. > > > It was a dumb statement on ur part. > > > This is a science and we follow some rules that have been made > > > If the mantra is going to be chanted then it has to chanted according > > > to the prescribed norms. > > > Regards > > > Dhruv > > > > > > > > > , "kadrudra" <kadrudra> > > wrote: > > > > > > > > Dear friend, > > > > > > > > ARE YOU SURE ABOUT WHAT YOU ARE ADVISING? If so, can you please > tell > > > > me WHICH VEDIC AUTHORITATIVE WORK supports your view? > > > > If you are 'just feeling like that' by your own logic, never advise > > > > it to anybody; Mantra recital is not a game nor a play! > > > > Do you think Vedic scriptures are garbage in making rules for > > > > reciting Mantra? You can refer to old messages in archive about > > > > the arguments on same topic. Do you think a mere chemical EQUATION > > > > gives you the product? It needs RIGHT chemicals, RIGHT > > > > process, RIGHT catalyst, RIGHT moderator, RIGHT temperature and > > > > pressure and so on. How can you expect result otherwise? Or > > > > do you know WHAT is the outcome, if anything is wrong? IF YOU DO > NOT > > > > KNOW, DO NOT ADVISE OTHERS.. that is a request and a caution! > > > > > > > > A MANTRA is an empirical formula. It ensures results only when > right > > > > elements(DHYANA, DHYAATR, DHYEYA) are rightly processed > > > > (JAPA, HOMA, DAANA, BHOJANA) in right methods or rules(YAMA, NIYAMA > > > > etc) described by the inventor(RISHI) and under the strict > > > > observation(GURU), with the aid of Catalysts(TRIKARANA SHUDDHI) and > > > > moderators(SANKALPA, CHANDAS, DEVATA, VINIYOGA, NYASA etc). > > > > The result is obtained is stored and protected in proper > way(KAVACHA, > > > > ARGALA, KEELAKA, MANDALA BANDHA). > > > > > > > > NOW tell me...you dare to change any rules/regulations? If so do > you > > > > know what is the final effect? > > > > > > > > Know well about what you say, do and think! > > > > > > > > humbly, > > > > KAD > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "natalcharts_biz" > > > > <natalcharts_biz> wrote: > > > > > > > > > > Hi Renu > > > > > > > > > > It is only natural to have menses for ladies. One does not become > > > > > impure or inauspicious during the menses. > > > > > > > > > > You can recite the mantra during this period too. > > > > > > > > > > Best Regards > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > , "renu4c" <renu4c> > > > > wrote: > > > > > > > > > > > > dear learned astrologers, > > > > > > i have a question regarding reciting the maha > > > > > > mrityunjaya mantra. First of all, i know that it is a maha > mantra > > > > so > > > > > > it can be recited anytime. My question is that if a women is > > > > > > menstruating, can she still recite the mantra. Please answer > the > > > > > > question, as it would help me from committing a paap. > > > > > > > > > > > > may god bless you all > > > > > > renu ji Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 absolutely! we chant the mantras to uplift our soul & mind & not the body! dhruv_gs <dhruv_gs wrote: Dear Sana, its being compared to sex and takin a dump because they too are bodily functions. If spirituality is about soul..forget mantra. No need to chant mantras too. Cos they have been written by a human..just think with ur spirit and it will be allright. Regards Dhruv , John Sana <sanajohn2000> wrote: > Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? > > Respectfully, > Sana > > arun <savitarcyber> wrote: > > Namaste all, > > When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own > father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. > Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. > Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every > month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly > priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. > > During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british > collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its > further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had > non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer > removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. > > What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... > > Regards > > Arun > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / Mail Mobile Take Mail with you! Check email on your mobile phone. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Mantras have been written by sages. And some mantras came as part of the vedas. Humans like you & me fight over such trivial matters in this world. Let the lady who posted her query ask a saint or spiritual person to resolve this matter instead of you & me fighting back and forth about monthly menses. dhruv_gs <dhruv_gs wrote: Dear Sana, its being compared to sex and takin a dump because they too are bodily functions. If spirituality is about soul..forget mantra. No need to chant mantras too. Cos they have been written by a human..just think with ur spirit and it will be allright. Regards Dhruv , John Sana <sanajohn2000> wrote: > Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? > > Respectfully, > Sana > > arun <savitarcyber> wrote: > > Namaste all, > > When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own > father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. > Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. > Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every > month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly > priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. > > During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british > collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its > further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had > non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer > removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. > > What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... > > Regards > > Arun > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Hehe :-) Read about a cartoon the other day. The cartoon shows a road which divides into two, the sign going to right reads "To God", the sign pointing to the left reads, "To discussion about God" RR , John Sana <sanajohn2000> wrote: > Mantras have been written by sages. And some mantras came as part of the vedas. Humans like you & me fight over such trivial matters in this world. Let the lady who posted her query ask a saint or spiritual person to resolve this matter instead of you & me fighting back and forth about monthly menses. > > dhruv_gs <dhruv_gs> wrote: > Dear Sana, > its being compared to sex and takin a dump because they too are bodily > functions. If spirituality is about soul..forget mantra. > No need to chant mantras too. > Cos they have been written by a human..just think with ur spirit and > it will be allright. > Regards > Dhruv > > > , John Sana <sanajohn2000> > wrote: > > Correctly said Arun! Divinity is not subjected to the bodily > functions. When the soul is pure everything else is tiny particle of > the dust. Fighting over this issue is limiting oneself to the > highest spiritual goal. If everything else is perishable and if soul > is the ultimate source of divinity then why are some people posting > harsh responses by comparing to shitting & sex? > > > > Respectfully, > > Sana > > > > arun <savitarcyber> wrote: > > > > Namaste all, > > > > When Sati Devi immolated herself, after she was insulted by her own > > father Daksha, her body was cut to pieces and strewn over the earth. > > Her genitals fell in a place called Chegannur, in Kerala, India. > > Here in this temple the Diety (feminine) has regular periods every > > month, and the blood stained cloth removed from the deity is highly > > priced and devotees book years in advance to get a piece of this cloth. > > > > During the times when India was ruled by the British, a young british > > collector, finding this practice impure and despicable, banned its > > further continuance. It is said that from that day on, his wife had > > non-stop bleeding. This continued until the shocked British officer > > removed the ban. The bleeding stopped immediately. > > > > What is impure? Purity and impurity are in the mind..... > > > > Regards > > > > Arun > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > > > > Sponsor > > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click > Here to meet a Girl > > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > > And Change His Life Learn More > > > > > > Links > > > > > > / > > > > > > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Krishnan, Dhruv, Renu, I am writing this post for the last time not for discussion of God nor to lead us to the path of God!" Either ways it is fine with me! And neither am I preaching somebody their culture or divinity lessons. I had taken diksha from an eminent acharya about 5 years back when I was 20. He had mentioned to me that during the menses a woman can chant the mantra but not go near the altar. And thats what I have been doing. When in menses I just chant the mantra with the japa mala after washing it in water. And on the 4th day, I simply wash the japa mala & resume my pooja. Just like members posting their responses in anger, happiness, joy & pain. I posted my views too. > > > > > > / > > > > > > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Hi everyone, I cant argue on the spiritual aspect bcoz im not that learned yet but i can say somthing on the biological aspect as I come frm that background! why normally mantras are not chanted during menses is that mantras normally unlock a lot of energy in a person ( kundalini shakti I guess ).It produces a certain ushnam( body heat). At the time of menses, biologically a womans immune system & body is weak...this is differnt from when a person is sick/weak otherwise as this involves a lot of internal hormonal changes....some who chant during this period may claim it really doesnt affect them but surely it does on an internal level..! Elders through the ages have mention a cetain refrain frm chanting mantras during the periods for this purpous only...They were HIGHLY advanced in their knowledge of Science as everything they hav said is based on scientific principles!!!It is sad that the resons hav got diluted and are almost lost in todays world. All scriptures say that a healthy body is required for a healthy mind..Saint & sages who have been in meditation for yrs together hav progressed to a state where they can contol their physical state & their outer body doesnt bother them...for normall laypersons who are yet to reach that level it is better to maintain a cerain healthy ( pun unintended :- ) ) respect for the bodys states of health & slight weakness till then... just my two cents !!! , John Sana <sanajohn2000> wrote: > Krishnan, Dhruv, Renu, > > I am writing this post for the last time not for discussion of God nor to lead us to the path of God!" Either ways it is fine with me! And neither am I preaching somebody their culture or divinity lessons. I had taken diksha from an eminent acharya about 5 years back when I was 20. He had mentioned to me that during the menses a woman can chant the mantra but not go near the altar. And thats what I have been doing. When in menses I just chant the mantra with the japa mala after washing it in water. And on the 4th day, I simply wash the japa mala & resume my pooja. Just like members posting their responses in anger, happiness, joy & pain. I posted my views too. > > > > > > > > > > > / > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Terms of > Service. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > > > > Sponsor > > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? > ·Click Here to meet a Girl > > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > > And Change His Life Learn More > > > > > > Links > > > > > > / > > > > > > > > > > Terms of > Service. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 10, 2005 Report Share Posted April 10, 2005 Namaste Dhruv The mantras of the Rig-Veda (Mrityunjaya mantra of Vasishtha Maharishi is one of them) are above any defect of time and space. There are no restrictions imposed on chanting these mantras in the Rig-Veda. Regards Arun , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> wrote: > > Dear ARun, > I am sorry i did not grasp what ur trying to say here. > Perhaps my poor knowledge of english.. but can u explain what you are > saying? > Regards > Dhruv > > > , "arun" <savitarcyber> wrote: > > > > Namaste Dhruv, > > > > Can you tell me where in the Rig Veda is it said that Women cannot > > chant during mensus? The Mantras of the Rig-Veda are said to above all > > defect. Now the Mritunjaya mantra of Vasishtha Maharishi is in the Rig > > -Veda and therefore above defect. > > > > regards > > > > arun > > > > , "dhruv_gs" <dhruv_gs> > wrote: > > > > > > Dear Arun, > > > this is a good story that uve told but where in this story is the > > > justification of allowing chanting during periods? > > > If ur goignt o chant a mantra written by some one u have to follow the > > > procedure too. > > > Its better to be safe than sorry.. that goes for everything > > > REgards > > > Dhruv > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted April 11, 2005 Report Share Posted April 11, 2005 just to join in in this free for all, my $0.02 in case the women is doing this to ward off death, then they are in a serious delima during their period days, if they chose not to chant this mantra. John Sana <sanajohn2000 wrote: Krishnan, Dhruv, Renu, I am writing this post for the last time not for discussion of God nor to lead us to the path of God!" Either ways it is fine with me! And neither am I preaching somebody their culture or divinity lessons. I had taken diksha from an eminent acharya about 5 years back when I was 20. He had mentioned to me that during the menses a woman can chant the mantra but not go near the altar. And thats what I have been doing. When in menses I just chant the mantra with the japa mala after washing it in water. And on the 4th day, I simply wash the japa mala & resume my pooja. Just like members posting their responses in anger, happiness, joy & pain. I posted my views too. > > > > > > / > > > > > > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ > > > Sponsor > Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl > And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy > And Change His Life Learn More > > > Links > > > / > > > > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > > > > ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ Sponsor Children InternationalWould you give Hope to a Child in need? ·Click Here to meet a Girl And Give Her Hope·Click Here to meet a Boy And Change His Life Learn More / ~! LIFE MEANS STRUGGLE, THE FITTEST WINS SURVIVAL !~ soumit guha java_sgt Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.