Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org

ADMIN: Some arguments

Rate this topic


Guest guest

Recommended Posts

Dear all,

 

There are some arguments and clashes going on in JR right now. As the moderator

I really do not like to interfere in to anything right at the beginning, so I

let it continue for a while hoping it would settle down soon. But things are

getting worse so I have to put some things very stright right at this point.

 

I would be extremely annoyed to listen to the comment that anyone who is not

giving free analysis is 'selfish'. Everyone has their own work, profession,

studies and life is very tough. Everyone has to face and fight his own life. We

never promissed that we would offer free service. This list is for learning

astrology and not for free services. Still when we have the time we offer free

services and analysis. This is for the purpose of humanity. But if someone takes

the advantage of this and makes unfair comments, it would not be tolerated.

 

This is a discussion list and if we ban a member who is not here for discussion,

that would be okay. Because the purpose is learning astrology and nothing else.

Still for the purpose of humanity we listen to the problems of people and try to

help if we can.

 

If a member complains that he joined here for discussions and why is he

receiving mails of free help, we would not be able to answer him anything. A

member joining for astrology discussions have to download a lot of mails just of

free help, and he can certainly make a complaint about it.

 

So whatever free help you get or do not get, be satisfied with that.

 

If your problem is serious you should consult a professional astrologer and pay

him, rather than submitting your plea of free help to students like us. If you

are sincere about your problem you should not hesitate to pay for it. A person

deserves the value of his time, skill and labour.

 

Anyone showing such behaviour would be taken care of. A moderator sometimes need

to be very strict, and that I would have to be against my wishes. I do not like

to be strict but if someone forces me, I would not have a choice.

 

I personally am not currently responding to the list about astrology, I am all

overloaded with works. I am in need of some more astrology study that I am

trying to do now. I have a lot to learn. That is why I am discussing charts in

private only. In my experience I have seen that in private discussion people

freely discuss anything about their lives, that is great for my learning and

even it helps me a lot to deal with the charts and remedies etc. So now I decide

to pay attention in reading one chart in depth than reading 10 charts in an

incomplete manner.

 

I have also started paid consultancy and I put the page online today in my

website. This is because even though I have not ever talked about a paid reading

in my site, I always have been offered for this. And I refused all the requests

very politely. Last time a man from Pakistan requested me a lot and then later I

forward him to PVR Narasimha Rao Ji.

 

But lately I felt this is not fair. If I can offer short insight for free, where

is the problem going deeper if they want it with a charge? This people ask me.

It is not fair when someone sincerely seeks your help by being ready to pay you

for your labour and wants a solution, and you refuse. When someone is ready to

pay you for your labour, it generally shows he is serious and sincere about it

and not just having fun around. I say that I am a student and would never be

like a professional one, and even after knowing this, people want readings. So,

that is okay for me from now on.

 

I did a professional reading for a lady from the USA and she is impressed to say

the least, and for that she is going to invest some $ 1700-1800 for yajnas to

solve her problems. And she would do it from whoever Pundit I suggest. I did not

really suggest her about yajnas but talked about all sort of remedies subject to

being suitable for her. This is for I was very successful with her chart and she

is impressed for Gods grace and now has faith in Jyotish and also in me. This is

not my credit, but God is leading her to a better life through me. The lady's

destiny is unfolding through me and I just play my role in her life. She is in

her Ve AD, Ve Yoga Karaka alone, 4th and 9th lord, is in own sign and also

directionally strong in 4th house. This is leading her to me and my success with

her chart and she is doing something good like yajnas and I do know they would

work like a magic. As I say, remedies are generally done in a good period,

otherwise you are not really allowed. I talked a lot about it with a lot of

exmaples, in a previous discussion thread - many of you might know.

 

After that she told me she wants some honest yajna provider and to make it sure

I mailed one yajna provider asking if there is any referral fee they grant if I

send them a client. Needless to say, I am not looking for a fee but just trying

to understand the dealings. This I did consulting the lady.

 

Now what if I did not do a professional reading for the lady?

 

I am also doing a professional reading for an Indian living in Europe. But I

would never be able to pay so much time to their charts if it was free, perhaps.

When someone approaches for a free reading, you consider if you have time or not

etc., but when someone is a paid customer you must make the best of you since

you are liable for it. Still, to err is human being and no astrologer can help

someone who is under the karmic test of God.

 

Anyway, at last, all I have to say is to exercise politeness and mutual respect.

This warning I am giving after much tolerance since I have to hear that who is

not giving a free reading is selfish.

 

There also tends to be some misunderstanding relating Rohini Ji, I think he did

not involve in any arguments. But that I leave up on him to let him clarify

himself.

 

Thanks,

Tanvir.

 

Owner and Moderator

Jyotish Remedies forum

 

 

 

What can not happen, can never happen.

Which is mine, is forever mine.

 

Tanvir Chowdhury

lord_narayana

http://www.jyotish-remedies.com

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Aadarniya Tanvirji namaskar

I am really feel sorry about what is going on. I joined this group only to learn

astrology.Yes, its my good fortune that Aadarniya Shri Gauravaji gave me a such

a perfect advice for my career.I am Arts Graduate from India.I suffered lot in

life,but its my good fortune that i get married with a very respective person

with the help of some remedies like Shri.Kudevata pujan

I read many books on Astrology and remedies, Numerology and Gems.When My

neighbour's astrologer suggests me to wear some Gem,i did it.I get such a

wonderful backing from that Ratna.

So i decided to join this group and trying to share some remedies Like Shivpuja

and Shri.Devi Puja.I also have some good experience At Dargaha in India,which

was suggesed by a God Believer Muslim Brother.Ours family is a God believer

family.So i respects Sadhus and Fakir,who are really selfless.My aadarniya

father also Get Aashirvad from a Fakir.

I tried to look Mrs Sneha's Kundli,that kundli was Very simple,but with some

problems.But i suggests her to pray for Sun.I always do the same.But after that

one of our readers made a contact with me online.Shri Gauravaji already send her

a mail with some remedies,they informed me about that when i forward her email

to them.But that member denied that she received any e-mail from them.she asked

me to ask them for her,so i told her to keep her igo aside and try to make

contact with shri Gauravaji again,i also give her their email address and also

suggested her to pray for Shri shankar(Shri kalbhairavashtaka Stotra for Rahu)

and Shri Ganesh for Mangal.Then i also told her that i am not expert in

astrology,so she must ask any other respected member.So she accused me as i am a

selfish woman and trying to fooling the people.I just shocked to read that

online.i am suffering from Ulcer like symptoms from 3 months,but still trying to

forget the pain and also trying to suggests some remedies.

Yes,i am also working on some remedies which i am traslating to English from

Marathi.which i am going to send for members.So i feel very hurt when somebody

accused me while i am trying to suggests some remedies.This site is really very

knowledgeble and supportive.

Astrology is a very deep subject,it has Mathematical base,i am not good at

maths,so not able to see Aantardasha,Mahadasha. i can not predict,but can share

some remedies.Yes.its my fault that i replied that member's on line message.I do

hope and promise that it won't happen again.I trying to forget that bitter

experience.I am thankful to those respected readers and members(Astrologers)

about their emails of sympathy and good advice and also thankful to you for

such a wonderful site.i do hope that other readers will forgive me for troubles.

Thank you very much for sending the mail.I wish that everybody will get good

responce and good advice for their future.

 

With so many good wishes

Mrs.Vasumati

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear Tanvir,

 

While I admire yr efforts to keep discipline on the network, I think

u completely missed the point Balaji was trying to make.

 

1.The point here is of the contribution to the discussions. I am a

new member and I did look at all the old postings. Can I ask one

question to Rohini , whts yr contribution here. Even though Balaji is

new to Astrology , as one of the posting says, he is pretty accurate.

In fact he looked at my horoscope, said he cld not read it and

suggested that I post it on the network here. No single astrologer

has been able to interpret my horoscope until now. These include the

so called professional astrologers who were very evasive. My question

is what was Rohini waiting for ? Cldnt he have taken the information

from my post, made a reading, posted it back on the network so that

other members could benefit from how he made the interpretation ?

Instead of just making sarcastic comments which hardly contribute

anything to the discussions, I suggest to him to please contribute

something to the discussions rather being a nosy and arrogant

character.

 

2. Why are you as the moderator of this group, feeling guilty bcos

Balaji made the statement that anyone who is not giving free analysis

is 'selfish'. Of course he is right. I can tell my own experiences of

dealing with so called professional/well known astrologers who just

charge money and offer no solutions!!!!! In fact the best reading

until now of my horoscope was given not by a professional astrologer

or anyone in this group but by a person in another astrology group on

and he ddnt ask me anything. And when I asked him abt the

gurudakshina he only said "I am doing it for my satisfaction, not for

money". Why cant everyone be like him. He was so accurate with his

readings he even pin pointed dates for some events that had happened

in my past. Could Mr.Rohini ever have done this?? I dbt he would. !!!

Above all I simply doubt I wld ever go to him to seek a reading !!

 

3. How does the issue of you offering paid services to a Foriegner,

matter in the tussle between Balaji and Rohini and the discussions in

this group ? . I think a lot of what you wrote was irrelevant to the

topic wasting not only all our time but your time also. As a

moderator it is your duty to moderate only, not to take offence at

comments by members of this group.

 

4. Lastly I have a suggestion for you. Why dont you as a moderator

make a posting every week where one Horoscope of an individual is

taken(cld be anybody famous)and analysed as to why they became

famous. This will help a lot of beginners .

 

regards

 

Sudheendra

 

"Whatever happens it happens for the good"

 

 

 

 

 

, "Tanvir"

<lord_narayana@l...> wrote:

> Dear all,

>

> There are some arguments and clashes going on in JR right now. As

the moderator I really do not like to interfere in to anything right

at the beginning, so I let it continue for a while hoping it would

settle down soon. But things are getting worse so I have to put some

things very stright right at this point.

>

> I would be extremely annoyed to listen to the comment that anyone

who is not giving free analysis is 'selfish'. Everyone has their own

work, profession, studies and life is very tough. Everyone has to

face and fight his own life. We never promissed that we would offer

free service. This list is for learning astrology and not for free

services. Still when we have the time we offer free services and

analysis. This is for the purpose of humanity. But if someone takes

the advantage of this and makes unfair comments, it would not be

tolerated.

>

> This is a discussion list and if we ban a member who is not here

for discussion, that would be okay. Because the purpose is learning

astrology and nothing else. Still for the purpose of humanity we

listen to the problems of people and try to help if we can.

>

> If a member complains that he joined here for discussions and why

is he receiving mails of free help, we would not be able to answer

him anything. A member joining for astrology discussions have to

download a lot of mails just of free help, and he can certainly make

a complaint about it.

>

> So whatever free help you get or do not get, be satisfied with that.

>

> If your problem is serious you should consult a professional

astrologer and pay him, rather than submitting your plea of free help

to students like us. If you are sincere about your problem you should

not hesitate to pay for it. A person deserves the value of his time,

skill and labour.

>

> Anyone showing such behaviour would be taken care of. A moderator

sometimes need to be very strict, and that I would have to be against

my wishes. I do not like to be strict but if someone forces me, I

would not have a choice.

>

> I personally am not currently responding to the list about

astrology, I am all overloaded with works. I am in need of some more

astrology study that I am trying to do now. I have a lot to learn.

That is why I am discussing charts in private only. In my experience

I have seen that in private discussion people freely discuss anything

about their lives, that is great for my learning and even it helps me

a lot to deal with the charts and remedies etc. So now I decide to

pay attention in reading one chart in depth than reading 10 charts in

an incomplete manner.

>

> I have also started paid consultancy and I put the page online

today in my website. This is because even though I have not ever

talked about a paid reading in my site, I always have been offered

for this. And I refused all the requests very politely. Last time a

man from Pakistan requested me a lot and then later I forward him to

PVR Narasimha Rao Ji.

>

> But lately I felt this is not fair. If I can offer short insight

for free, where is the problem going deeper if they want it with a

charge? This people ask me. It is not fair when someone sincerely

seeks your help by being ready to pay you for your labour and wants a

solution, and you refuse. When someone is ready to pay you for your

labour, it generally shows he is serious and sincere about it and not

just having fun around. I say that I am a student and would never be

like a professional one, and even after knowing this, people want

readings. So, that is okay for me from now on.

>

> I did a professional reading for a lady from the USA and she is

impressed to say the least, and for that she is going to invest some

$ 1700-1800 for yajnas to solve her problems. And she would do it

from whoever Pundit I suggest. I did not really suggest her about

yajnas but talked about all sort of remedies subject to being

suitable for her. This is for I was very successful with her chart

and she is impressed for Gods grace and now has faith in Jyotish and

also in me. This is not my credit, but God is leading her to a better

life through me. The lady's destiny is unfolding through me and I

just play my role in her life. She is in her Ve AD, Ve Yoga Karaka

alone, 4th and 9th lord, is in own sign and also directionally strong

in 4th house. This is leading her to me and my success with her chart

and she is doing something good like yajnas and I do know they would

work like a magic. As I say, remedies are generally done in a good

period, otherwise you are not really allowed. I talked a lot about it

with a lot of exmaples, in a previous discussion thread - many of you

might know.

>

> After that she told me she wants some honest yajna provider and to

make it sure I mailed one yajna provider asking if there is any

referral fee they grant if I send them a client. Needless to say, I

am not looking for a fee but just trying to understand the dealings.

This I did consulting the lady.

>

> Now what if I did not do a professional reading for the lady?

>

> I am also doing a professional reading for an Indian living in

Europe. But I would never be able to pay so much time to their charts

if it was free, perhaps. When someone approaches for a free reading,

you consider if you have time or not etc., but when someone is a paid

customer you must make the best of you since you are liable for it.

Still, to err is human being and no astrologer can help someone who

is under the karmic test of God.

>

> Anyway, at last, all I have to say is to exercise politeness and

mutual respect. This warning I am giving after much tolerance since I

have to hear that who is not giving a free reading is selfish.

>

> There also tends to be some misunderstanding relating Rohini Ji, I

think he did not involve in any arguments. But that I leave up on him

to let him clarify himself.

>

> Thanks,

> Tanvir.

>

> Owner and Moderator

> Jyotish Remedies forum

>

>

>

> What can not happen, can never happen.

> Which is mine, is forever mine.

>

> Tanvir Chowdhury

> lord_narayana@l...

> http://www.jyotish-remedies.com

>

>

>

>

>

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Dear Madam,

 

Just forget abt all this things and concentrate on your duty and

helping others..one bad person should not stop you....remember

krishna's word and go ahead helping others...have confidence..

in fact some of your remedies are interesting ...just share with all

in the general interest..

 

regards

 

sriganeshh

Link to comment
Share on other sites

WOW! :-)

 

RR

 

, "Sudheendra"

<sudhee03> wrote:

> Dear Tanvir,

>

> While I admire yr efforts to keep discipline on the network, I

think

> u completely missed the point Balaji was trying to make.

>

> 1.The point here is of the contribution to the discussions. I am a

> new member and I did look at all the old postings. Can I ask one

> question to Rohini , whts yr contribution here. Even though Balaji

is

> new to Astrology , as one of the posting says, he is pretty

accurate.

> In fact he looked at my horoscope, said he cld not read it and

> suggested that I post it on the network here. No single astrologer

> has been able to interpret my horoscope until now. These include

the

> so called professional astrologers who were very evasive. My

question

> is what was Rohini waiting for ? Cldnt he have taken the

information

> from my post, made a reading, posted it back on the network so

that

> other members could benefit from how he made the interpretation ?

> Instead of just making sarcastic comments which hardly contribute

> anything to the discussions, I suggest to him to please contribute

> something to the discussions rather being a nosy and arrogant

> character.

>

> 2. Why are you as the moderator of this group, feeling guilty bcos

> Balaji made the statement that anyone who is not giving free

analysis

> is 'selfish'. Of course he is right. I can tell my own experiences

of

> dealing with so called professional/well known astrologers who

just

> charge money and offer no solutions!!!!! In fact the best reading

> until now of my horoscope was given not by a professional

astrologer

> or anyone in this group but by a person in another astrology group

on

> and he ddnt ask me anything. And when I asked him abt the

> gurudakshina he only said "I am doing it for my satisfaction, not

for

> money". Why cant everyone be like him. He was so accurate with his

> readings he even pin pointed dates for some events that had

happened

> in my past. Could Mr.Rohini ever have done this?? I dbt he

would. !!!

> Above all I simply doubt I wld ever go to him to seek a reading !!

>

> 3. How does the issue of you offering paid services to a

Foriegner,

> matter in the tussle between Balaji and Rohini and the discussions

in

> this group ? . I think a lot of what you wrote was irrelevant to

the

> topic wasting not only all our time but your time also. As a

> moderator it is your duty to moderate only, not to take offence at

> comments by members of this group.

>

> 4. Lastly I have a suggestion for you. Why dont you as a moderator

> make a posting every week where one Horoscope of an individual is

> taken(cld be anybody famous)and analysed as to why they became

> famous. This will help a lot of beginners .

>

> regards

>

> Sudheendra

>

> "Whatever happens it happens for the good"

>

>

>

>

>

> , "Tanvir"

> <lord_narayana@l...> wrote:

> > Dear all,

> >

> > There are some arguments and clashes going on in JR right now.

As

> the moderator I really do not like to interfere in to anything

right

> at the beginning, so I let it continue for a while hoping it would

> settle down soon. But things are getting worse so I have to put

some

> things very stright right at this point.

> >

> > I would be extremely annoyed to listen to the comment that

anyone

> who is not giving free analysis is 'selfish'. Everyone has their

own

> work, profession, studies and life is very tough. Everyone has to

> face and fight his own life. We never promissed that we would

offer

> free service. This list is for learning astrology and not for free

> services. Still when we have the time we offer free services and

> analysis. This is for the purpose of humanity. But if someone

takes

> the advantage of this and makes unfair comments, it would not be

> tolerated.

> >

> > This is a discussion list and if we ban a member who is not here

> for discussion, that would be okay. Because the purpose is

learning

> astrology and nothing else. Still for the purpose of humanity we

> listen to the problems of people and try to help if we can.

> >

> > If a member complains that he joined here for discussions and

why

> is he receiving mails of free help, we would not be able to answer

> him anything. A member joining for astrology discussions have to

> download a lot of mails just of free help, and he can certainly

make

> a complaint about it.

> >

> > So whatever free help you get or do not get, be satisfied with

that.

> >

> > If your problem is serious you should consult a professional

> astrologer and pay him, rather than submitting your plea of free

help

> to students like us. If you are sincere about your problem you

should

> not hesitate to pay for it. A person deserves the value of his

time,

> skill and labour.

> >

> > Anyone showing such behaviour would be taken care of. A

moderator

> sometimes need to be very strict, and that I would have to be

against

> my wishes. I do not like to be strict but if someone forces me, I

> would not have a choice.

> >

> > I personally am not currently responding to the list about

> astrology, I am all overloaded with works. I am in need of some

more

> astrology study that I am trying to do now. I have a lot to learn.

> That is why I am discussing charts in private only. In my

experience

> I have seen that in private discussion people freely discuss

anything

> about their lives, that is great for my learning and even it helps

me

> a lot to deal with the charts and remedies etc. So now I decide to

> pay attention in reading one chart in depth than reading 10 charts

in

> an incomplete manner.

> >

> > I have also started paid consultancy and I put the page online

> today in my website. This is because even though I have not ever

> talked about a paid reading in my site, I always have been offered

> for this. And I refused all the requests very politely. Last time

a

> man from Pakistan requested me a lot and then later I forward him

to

> PVR Narasimha Rao Ji.

> >

> > But lately I felt this is not fair. If I can offer short insight

> for free, where is the problem going deeper if they want it with a

> charge? This people ask me. It is not fair when someone sincerely

> seeks your help by being ready to pay you for your labour and

wants a

> solution, and you refuse. When someone is ready to pay you for

your

> labour, it generally shows he is serious and sincere about it and

not

> just having fun around. I say that I am a student and would never

be

> like a professional one, and even after knowing this, people want

> readings. So, that is okay for me from now on.

> >

> > I did a professional reading for a lady from the USA and she is

> impressed to say the least, and for that she is going to invest

some

> $ 1700-1800 for yajnas to solve her problems. And she would do it

> from whoever Pundit I suggest. I did not really suggest her about

> yajnas but talked about all sort of remedies subject to being

> suitable for her. This is for I was very successful with her chart

> and she is impressed for Gods grace and now has faith in Jyotish

and

> also in me. This is not my credit, but God is leading her to a

better

> life through me. The lady's destiny is unfolding through me and I

> just play my role in her life. She is in her Ve AD, Ve Yoga Karaka

> alone, 4th and 9th lord, is in own sign and also directionally

strong

> in 4th house. This is leading her to me and my success with her

chart

> and she is doing something good like yajnas and I do know they

would

> work like a magic. As I say, remedies are generally done in a good

> period, otherwise you are not really allowed. I talked a lot about

it

> with a lot of exmaples, in a previous discussion thread - many of

you

> might know.

> >

> > After that she told me she wants some honest yajna provider and

to

> make it sure I mailed one yajna provider asking if there is any

> referral fee they grant if I send them a client. Needless to say,

I

> am not looking for a fee but just trying to understand the

dealings.

> This I did consulting the lady.

> >

> > Now what if I did not do a professional reading for the lady?

> >

> > I am also doing a professional reading for an Indian living in

> Europe. But I would never be able to pay so much time to their

charts

> if it was free, perhaps. When someone approaches for a free

reading,

> you consider if you have time or not etc., but when someone is a

paid

> customer you must make the best of you since you are liable for

it.

> Still, to err is human being and no astrologer can help someone

who

> is under the karmic test of God.

> >

> > Anyway, at last, all I have to say is to exercise politeness and

> mutual respect. This warning I am giving after much tolerance

since I

> have to hear that who is not giving a free reading is selfish.

> >

> > There also tends to be some misunderstanding relating Rohini Ji,

I

> think he did not involve in any arguments. But that I leave up on

him

> to let him clarify himself.

> >

> > Thanks,

> > Tanvir.

> >

> > Owner and Moderator

> > Jyotish Remedies forum

> >

> >

> >

> > What can not happen, can never happen.

> > Which is mine, is forever mine.

> >

> > Tanvir Chowdhury

> > lord_narayana@l...

> > http://www.jyotish-remedies.com

> >

> >

> >

> >

> >

Link to comment
Share on other sites

~ Om Namah Shivaya ~

 

Dear List Members,

 

I believe that arguments can be done in a much better

way without blaming anyone and can be lead towards a

fruitful discussion. Let's omit the word "argument"

and take it in a healthy way towards "DISCUSSION".

 

Members should be polite in their postings and should

have a respect for other members. Kindly do not post

any ambiguous message / post, where you by yourself do

not mean to be offensive or hurting other but the

other one feels so. Just change your writing style a

bit and it can be done.

 

Also please bear in mind free reading Vs. Paid Reading

- It is upto the astrologer, to whom he wants to give

paid reading and to whom he wants to give free

reading. Let the decision of the person who is giving

a reading should be final. If someone is not doing

paid reading he cannot be termed as selfish (I don't

like that word) as there are some astrolgers in this

*world* (not necessarily in this list), for whom paid

reading is their bread and butter. Also no astrologer

is 100% correct in all the cases. Even if you have

read about PVR Ji's books or have discussed with Shri

Sanjay Rath Ji, they too fail sometimes and accept

their mistakes (basically predictions). I have seen

Shri Sanjay Rath ji publically (on list) accepting his

failure on certain prediction and I believe this is a

very good thing to do. This shows his honesty and a

way of saying that he too as human can be wrong

sometimes.

 

Also regarding paid reading I would like to tell you,

that Shri Sanjay Rath Ji, whose charges seem quite

huge for me, has given me a free advise (not exactly

in readings, but regarding some yogas) to help me

improve in my Jyotish Studies. Also Shri Visti Ji

(Jyotish Guru at SJC, corrected analysis done for me

by some other member). So it is upto the person to

decide wether or not he will do a free / paid reading

for anyone or not.

 

We are here to share our knowledge with other members

at the same time, we also learn from other members in

the group. Astrology is a great divine science and I

just had a drop from this vast ocean. There is so much

to learn. The members who analyze the chart on list,

do it as per their time, resources, energy etc. and

they cannot be blamed if they are not replying to

every query or not analyzing all charts. Ofcourse, it

is not mandatory contribute on this list. There are

certain members who are just following the posts

silently and learning by their own (from books, from

messages posted here). Even there are some members,

who join for a couple of days, post their chart, take

a free reading and then go. I don't think they are

wrong, in a way they also helped us, gave us a chance

to interpret their chart and helped us in our learning

process. But to think that everytime, everyone gets a

free reading should not be there.

 

I know many astrologers (professionals) in Delhi, who

just look at your Rashi Chart and Navamasa (no other

D-Charts), Vishm Dasha Started from moon (no

variations and no usage of other dashas) and they do

paid reading. Some of them are actually good also.

 

So keep your DISCUSSIONS (not arguments) get going.

 

Regards,

 

Neeraj Gupta

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

--- Tanvir <lord_narayana wrote:

 

> Dear all,

>

> There are some arguments and clashes going on in JR

> right now. As the moderator I really do not like to

> interfere in to anything right at the beginning, so

> I let it continue for a while hoping it would settle

> down soon. But things are getting worse so I have to

> put some things very stright right at this point.

>

> I would be extremely annoyed to listen to the

> comment that anyone who is not giving free analysis

> is 'selfish'. Everyone has their own work,

> profession, studies and life is very tough. Everyone

> has to face and fight his own life. We never

> promissed that we would offer free service. This

> list is for learning astrology and not for free

> services. Still when we have the time we offer free

> services and analysis. This is for the purpose of

> humanity. But if someone takes the advantage of this

> and makes unfair comments, it would not be

> tolerated.

>

> This is a discussion list and if we ban a member who

> is not here for discussion, that would be okay.

> Because the purpose is learning astrology and

> nothing else. Still for the purpose of humanity we

> listen to the problems of people and try to help if

> we can.

>

> If a member complains that he joined here for

> discussions and why is he receiving mails of free

> help, we would not be able to answer him anything. A

> member joining for astrology discussions have to

> download a lot of mails just of free help, and he

> can certainly make a complaint about it.

>

> So whatever free help you get or do not get, be

> satisfied with that.

>

> If your problem is serious you should consult a

> professional astrologer and pay him, rather than

> submitting your plea of free help to students like

> us. If you are sincere about your problem you should

> not hesitate to pay for it. A person deserves the

> value of his time, skill and labour.

>

> Anyone showing such behaviour would be taken care

> of. A moderator sometimes need to be very strict,

> and that I would have to be against my wishes. I do

> not like to be strict but if someone forces me, I

> would not have a choice.

>

> I personally am not currently responding to the list

> about astrology, I am all overloaded with works. I

> am in need of some more astrology study that I am

> trying to do now. I have a lot to learn. That is why

> I am discussing charts in private only. In my

> experience I have seen that in private discussion

> people freely discuss anything about their lives,

> that is great for my learning and even it helps me a

> lot to deal with the charts and remedies etc. So now

> I decide to pay attention in reading one chart in

> depth than reading 10 charts in an incomplete

> manner.

>

> I have also started paid consultancy and I put the

> page online today in my website. This is because

> even though I have not ever talked about a paid

> reading in my site, I always have been offered for

> this. And I refused all the requests very politely.

> Last time a man from Pakistan requested me a lot and

> then later I forward him to PVR Narasimha Rao Ji.

>

> But lately I felt this is not fair. If I can offer

> short insight for free, where is the problem going

> deeper if they want it with a charge? This people

> ask me. It is not fair when someone sincerely seeks

> your help by being ready to pay you for your labour

> and wants a solution, and you refuse. When someone

> is ready to pay you for your labour, it generally

> shows he is serious and sincere about it and not

> just having fun around. I say that I am a student

> and would never be like a professional one, and even

> after knowing this, people want readings. So, that

> is okay for me from now on.

>

> I did a professional reading for a lady from the USA

> and she is impressed to say the least, and for that

> she is going to invest some $ 1700-1800 for yajnas

> to solve her problems. And she would do it from

> whoever Pundit I suggest. I did not really suggest

> her about yajnas but talked about all sort of

> remedies subject to being suitable for her. This is

> for I was very successful with her chart and she is

> impressed for Gods grace and now has faith in

> Jyotish and also in me. This is not my credit, but

> God is leading her to a better life through me. The

> lady's destiny is unfolding through me and I just

> play my role in her life. She is in her Ve AD, Ve

> Yoga Karaka alone, 4th and 9th lord, is in own sign

> and also directionally strong in 4th house. This is

> leading her to me and my success with her chart and

> she is doing something good like yajnas and I do

> know they would work like a magic. As I say,

> remedies are generally done in a good period,

> otherwise you are not really allowed. I talked a lot

> about it with a lot of exmaples, in a previous

> discussion thread - many of you might know.

>

> After that she told me she wants some honest yajna

> provider and to make it sure I mailed one yajna

> provider asking if there is any referral fee they

> grant if I send them a client. Needless to say, I am

> not looking for a fee but just trying to understand

> the dealings. This I did consulting the lady.

>

> Now what if I did not do a professional reading for

> the lady?

>

> I am also doing a professional reading for an Indian

> living in Europe. But I would never be able to pay

> so much time to their charts if it was free,

> perhaps. When someone approaches for a free reading,

> you consider if you have time or not etc., but when

> someone is a paid customer you must make the best of

> you since you are liable for it. Still, to err is

> human being and no astrologer can help someone who

> is under the karmic test of God.

>

> Anyway, at last, all I have to say is to exercise

> politeness and mutual respect. This warning I am

> giving after much tolerance since I have to hear

> that who is not giving a free reading is selfish.

>

> There also tends to be some misunderstanding

> relating Rohini Ji, I think he did not involve in

> any arguments. But that I leave up on him to let him

> clarify himself.

>

> Thanks,

> Tanvir.

>

> Owner and Moderator

> Jyotish Remedies forum

>

>

>

> What can not happen, can never happen.

> Which is mine, is forever mine.

>

> Tanvir Chowdhury

> lord_narayana

> http://www.jyotish-remedies.com

>

>

>

>

> [Non-text portions of this message have been

> removed]

>

>

 

 

=====

http://www.neerajgupta.com

 

 

 

 

 

Mail is new and improved - Check it out!

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...