Guest guest Posted May 8, 2004 Report Share Posted May 8, 2004 Dear Kaimal Jee, For the following reasons SA is popular to west - 1. Westerners are generally bothered and confused with aparent looking contradictions and huge number of theories Jyotish owns. We all know the theories, available in BPHS, but can't apply them well. Well, very few of us can do some of it. 2. SA is some times better result giving than western systems. Because it [sA] has some blood of VA [Vedic Astrology] remember! So that part of it sometimes give result which is better than wester systems bec WS [western system] is generally a psychological analysis and not prediction-oriented. So people from west like SA. When I *came to know* about SA theories [but didnt apply them yet] I already knew it can't be possible, all bogus theories. And the first chart that I tried to do with SA was of mine, and it didnt match at all. Like SA says my moon is bright and non afflicted, it's AD should be excellent, but in general it was really painful and troublesome. Also theories like conjunction for 5 degree and affliction methods never make any sense, nor their remedial system that without 6,8,12 lords ALL are benefical and you can wear their stones!!!! Another damn mistake of SA is that, any malefic lord [6/8/12] would do bad in EVERYTHING, and that many people believe who dont practice SA! Thats very wrong. Surprisingly, I went far like 30% deeper with only 3/4 charts in my life, and with this SHORT TRAVEL I have developed my *OWN* (yes, completely OWN) theories to EXPLAIN the facts in the charts I have seen. [like, I tried to find the answer, "WHY IT HAPPENED THEN IN THAT YEAR?"] Well I also learn from small lookings at so many charts, and all of my own theories work in other charts. And later I saw that my start theory has some similarity with KP but is a lot simple and but more useful I would say. You can read all my written articles in my articles page and grab the theories I used there and try to apply them in other charts of people you know, and see what happens. ALso you can apply SA theories to charts and see. I have saved some excellent posts on SA in other lists, I have them. It's just a money making policy and Gurus like Sanjay Jee and Narasimha Jee is well aware of them and Sanjay Jee once said that we would have to do something against them who is altering jyotish and using it to make money. Narasimha Jee politely said that he has bought a lot of books on SA and tried it a lot but he never found it to be valid. If God allows I want to seriously devote a few months to Jyotish after July and find some more theories of TRUE JYOTISH. That is NOT in my fate to involve in Jyotish that time, because I know my chart, but I would try :-) Regards Tanvir. , SRCKaimal <srckaimal@a...> wrote: > Dear Tanvir, > You have made a sweping statement against SA "Honestly, neither SA nor their > Kavach make any sense." But why?Astrologically is it not a sound system?It > seems to be very popular in the West and usually they accept things only > after a lot of verification. > Regards > Kaimal Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.