Fundamental question about Vedik Astrology.

[Guest guest]

I have one very fundamental question about science of vedik astrology which

people ask from a astrologer. And I am sure that you have also faced this

question.

It is how the planetory position at the time of birth effects the whole life of

a person. If we think in terms of science of Radiation and Effect of any

particle present around the person, then their effects will be limited to the

particuler position and it will not be for whole life. What if some person born

at one place and after that he is shifted to some other place, then how the

planetory position at the time of birth at one place gives the results through

out the life of the person at other place.

Hope I have cleared the question and I expect everybody to give his opinion so

that we all will be able to understand science of astrology.

Regards,

Upesh Srivastava.

The New Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.

[Guest guest]

Now a days there is huge debate going on in India whether Astrology is Science

or not. But according to me, Vedic Astrology or better Jyotish cannot be

understood from the point of view of science. You can call it meta-science. And

today's science is incomplete to understand astrology. Present age of science

has some important laws undiscovered that's why Jyotish cannot be explained

scientifically. You can compare this age with Newtonian age where there was no

Einstein's law. Einstein's law extended laws of Newton from universal point of

view. So according to me another great-integrated law after Einstein's law

needed to be discovered; only after that we will be able to explain Jyotish

scientifically.

Lots of Jyotish authors have discussed/ written about "Theory of Karma the

destiny." I suggest you to go trough those articles/books and try to understand

this. It can explain the rational behind astrology. (but not scientifically)

Regards,

Punit Pandey

Note: Whatever written above is just my opinion and not written anywhere in

Jyotish books. So there is no guarantee of being correct.

 

Upesh Srivastava <upesh_s > wrote:

Dear All,

I have one very fundamental question about science of vedik astrology which

people ask from a astrologer. And I am sure that you have also faced this

question.

It is how the planetory position at the time of birth effects the whole life of

a person. If we think in terms of science of Radiation and Effect of any

particle present around the person, then their effects will be limited to the

particuler position and it will not be for whole life. What if some person born

at one place and after that he is shifted to some other place, then how the

planetory position at the time of birth at one place gives the results through

out the life of the person at other place.

Hope I have cleared the question and I expect everybody to give his opinion so

that we all will be able to understand science of astrology.

Regards,

Upesh Srivastava.

The New Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.

[Guest guest]

Dear Upesh, Now a days there is huge debate going on in India whether Astrology

is Science or not. But according to me, Vedic Astrology or better Jyotish

cannot be understood from the point of view of science. You can call it

meta-science. And today's science is incomplete to understand astrology.

Present age of science has some important laws undiscovered that's why Jyotish

cannot be explained scientifically. You can compare this age with Newtonian age

where there was no Einstein's law. Einstein's law extended laws of Newton from

universal point of view. So according to me another great-integrated law after

Einstein's law needed to be discovered; only after that we will be able to

explain Jyotish scientifically.

Lots of Jyotish authors have discussed/ written about "Theory of Karma the

destiny." I suggest you to go trough those articles/books and try to understand

this. It can explain the rational behind astrology. (but not scientifically)

Regards,

Punit Pandey

Note: Whatever written above is just my opinion and not written anywhere in

Jyotish books. So there is no guarantee of being correct.

 

Upesh Srivastava <upesh_s > wrote:

Dear All,

I have one very fundamental question about science of vedik astrology which

people ask from a astrologer. And I am sure that you have also faced this

question.

It is how the planetory position at the time of birth effects the whole life of

a person. If we think in terms of science of Radiation and Effect of any

particle present around the person, then their effects will be limited to the

particuler position and it will not be for whole life. What if some person born

at one place and after that he is shifted to some other place, then how the

planetory position at the time of birth at one place gives the results through

out the life of the person at other place.

Hope I have cleared the question and I expect everybody to give his opinion so

that we all will be able to understand science of astrology.

Regards,

Upesh Srivastava.

The New Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo. Get Free!

astrological consultancy!http://www.sonipat.com/supraastrology/index.shtmlTo

from this group, send an email

to:Vedic Astrology-OM TAT SATYour use of is

subject to the

The New Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo.

[Guest guest]

Hi Upesh,

I find the birth chart gives results through the life, but a location chart can

give more specific results. Sally

Dear All,

I have one very fundamental question about science of vedik astrology which

people ask from a astrologer. And I am sure that you have also faced this

question.

It is how the planetory position at the time of birth effects the whole life of

a person. If we think in terms of science of Radiation and Effect of any

particle present around the person, then their effects will be limited to the

particuler position and it will not be for whole life. What if some person born

at one place and after that he is shifted to some other place, then how the

planetory position at the time of birth at one place gives the results through

out the life of the person at other place.

Hope I have cleared the question and I expect everybody to give his opinion so

that we all will be able to understand science of astrology.

Regards,

Upesh Srivastava.

The New Search - Faster. Easier. Bingo. Get Free!

astrological consultancy!http://www.sonipat.com/supraastrology/index.shtmlTo

from this group, send an email

to:Vedic Astrology-OM TAT SATYour use of is

subject to the