Guest guest Posted March 4, 2002 Report Share Posted March 4, 2002 dear lakshmi I think saturn has some special rules. a) he will give benefic results late b) he will punish people without any delay-i know it from personal experience c) he is slow in giving material comforts d) he is fast in giving spiritual blessings, dont know why he increases his speed when "fating out someone". regards partha Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2002 Report Share Posted March 5, 2002 Dear Partha, >From where did you get this info about special rules? Visti also mentioned something similar. Let me know the source so I too can look it up. Coming to "retribution" I too thought it was quite swift sometimes, until in the 3-4 cases I checked up it was either Saturn dasa/Antar/pratyantar or Sade Sathi running. The link to Saturn was always there. My premise that Saturn is Slow is based on the fact that he's huge & solid (ghanaya), slow (manda), manda chestaya (slow actioned), lame and represents "year" (the longest time unit) in vedic time segments (BPHS). All these attributes certainly do not describe an agile personality. I did not find any other reference to the contrary. Have I missed something somewhere? But, Partha, I found another interesting reference in Sani ashtottaram...it says "dhanurmandala samsthaaya"..how come? Now, I have a few questions coming up. And, these are more for my enlightenment: 1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or karma is leftover in some cases? 2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two really malefic ones have how much time separating them? 3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to other conditions.Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka.How do we reconcile these statements? Regards,Lakshmi P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His companions kill, is it? partvinu5 <partvinu5 > wrote: dear lakshmiI think saturn has some special rules.a) he will give benefic results lateb) he will punish people without any delay-i know it from personal experiencec) he is slow in giving material comfortsd) he is fast in giving spiritual blessings, dont know why he increases his speed when "fating out someone".regardsparthaYour use of Groups is subject to the Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 5, 2002 Report Share Posted March 5, 2002 dear Lakshmi Honestly i dont remember in which book i read these rules. But in practice i have seen sani doing what i had mentioned earlier. i lost my job swiftly in rahu-sani only. > My premise that Saturn is Slow is based on the fact that he's huge & solid (ghanaya), slow (manda), manda chestaya (slow actioned), lame and represents "year" (the longest time unit) in vedic time segments (BPHS). All these attributes certainly do not describe an agile personality. I did not find any other reference to the contrary. Have I missed something somewhere? partha: Yes probably the fact that sani is fate, he is kaal, he is grief, he is the shadow and he is the TERMINATOR. thus he doesnot waste time to show his headmasterliness. please give meanings for the sanskrit slokas that you quote. 1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or karma is leftover in some cases? ans) everyone who has taken the birth is due to the fact that he has not attained moksha and has commited some sins, he has to pay them. The people who are dying as infants must have indulged in abortioning children, killing children etc, thus these fellows die so young. > 2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two really malefic ones have how much time separating them? partha: the concept of sade-saath is different. no matter what every person who lives for minimum 30 years has to face it. the general rules are that 1st one is bad, 2nd is progressive and 3rd one is maraka. these are very general. But it is based on the moon sign. what about those fellows who do not allow the "disturbances" affect them. See in the first saade saath, my mother died and i had few accidents, but honestly i did enjoy my life. so i cant see the point. 3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to other conditions. > Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka. > How do we reconcile these statements? saturn doesnot kill. he wants to grow. he wants the houses that he aspects to live long. that is why even if i want to leave my job i am not allowed (laughs, my saturn aspects 10th house through 3rd aspect). mars kills, rahu can give sudden results. weak moon can give disorders for the mind and asking him to commit suicide. saturn does not kill. he just frustrates and delays, it is upto the individual to take everything in his stride. yes saturn is maraka, but he needs to combine. as a general rule saturn doesnot kill , so for him he needs support of moon and venus to and lastly mars to kill. > Regards, > Lakshmi > P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His companions kill, is it? > > > partvinu5 <partvinu5> wrote: dear lakshmi > > I think saturn has some special rules. > > a) he will give benefic results late > b) he will punish people without any delay-i know it from personal > experience > > c) he is slow in giving material comforts > > d) he is fast in giving spiritual blessings, dont know why he > increases his speed when "fating out someone". > > regards > partha > > > > Sponsor > > Terms of Service. > > > > > > Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2002 Report Share Posted March 6, 2002 Vyam Vysadevaya Namah ---------------------------- Dear Lakshmi, >Now, I have a few questions coming up. And, these are more for my >enlightenment: >1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of >unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we >explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not >obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant >moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or >karma is leftover in some cases? > Visti: If our desires are satisfied, its farely easy to get moksha. In most cases, people do not get their desires satisfied. > >2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits >of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second >one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two >really malefic ones have how much time separating them? > Visti: Gurudeva allready explained this on Vedic-Astrology list, where he described the 3 types of Sade Sathi, where Saturn removes support from wife(12th), Family(2nd) and in the middle part, it sits on your head and punished you for your mistakes. Depending on the Dasa period and Karma, the effects will be felt acordingly. > >3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to >other conditions. >Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka. >How do we reconcile these statements? > Visti: Easy. Saturn has no more longevity to give. >Regards, >Lakshmi >P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His >companions kill, is it? Visti: Functional nature is something else. 8th lord shows the type of Rudra. Best wishes, Visti. _______________ Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2002 Report Share Posted March 6, 2002 om gurave namah------------------------Dear Lakshmi Partha was only giving the general point that people are reborn (these days) largely due to strong unfulfilled desires. Take the drunkard next door. He has to be born so many more times because that last glass of beer is not over! That is Karmic rebirth where Bhagavan is kind enough to let him come again and again for that last glass, and perhaps alternating between other bodies of buffallo and other animals ( if more fortunate). Now, saturn also has a say in this matter and for this reason, Saturn and Gulika (his bright eyed son so very good at preparing poison) have a strong say in rebirth as well. Here they are used to calculate the date of conception by reducing the tentative date by the difference between their degrees. (Conception chart). At least one case is sure to be remembered . That of Bhagavan Ram, and here we cannot blame it all on Rahu (Ravana) alone and Saturn also holds the key to this. Thus when Rahu becomes the AK, I guess Rama will come to take you back to Godhead...With best wishesSanjay RathWeb: http://sanjayrath.tripod.comServices: http://sanjayrath.tripod.com/zservices.htmJyotish Digest: http://jyotishdigest.com/SJVC: http://www.sjvc.org/ - lakshmi ramesh sjvc Tuesday, March 05, 2002 3:16 PM Re: [sjvc] saturn Om Gurave Namah Dear Partha, From where did you get this info about special rules? Visti also mentioned something similar. Let me know the source so I too can look it up. Coming to "retribution" I too thought it was quite swift sometimes, until in the 3-4 cases I checked up it was either Saturn dasa/Antar/pratyantar or Sade Sathi running. The link to Saturn was always there. My premise that Saturn is Slow is based on the fact that he's huge & solid (ghanaya), slow (manda), manda chestaya (slow actioned), lame and represents "year" (the longest time unit) in vedic time segments (BPHS). All these attributes certainly do not describe an agile personality. I did not find any other reference to the contrary. Have I missed something somewhere? But, Partha, I found another interesting reference in Sani ashtottaram...it says "dhanurmandala samsthaaya"..how come? Now, I have a few questions coming up. And, these are more for my enlightenment: 1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or karma is leftover in some cases? 2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two really malefic ones have how much time separating them? 3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to other conditions.Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka.How do we reconcile these statements? Regards,Lakshmi P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His companions kill, is it? partvinu5 <partvinu5 > wrote: dear lakshmiI think saturn has some special rules.a) he will give benefic results lateb) he will punish people without any delay-i know it from personal experiencec) he is slow in giving material comfortsd) he is fast in giving spiritual blessings, dont know why he increases his speed when "fating out someone".regardspartha Terms of Service. Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Your use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 6, 2002 Report Share Posted March 6, 2002 Dear Visti, Thanks for the replies and the references. I shall start excavating ... Regards, Lakshmi Visti Larsen <vlarsen (AT) hotmail (DOT) com> wrote: Vyam Vysadevaya Namah----------------------------Dear Lakshmi,>Now, I have a few questions coming up. And, these are more for my >enlightenment:>1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of >unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we >explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not >obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant >moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or >karma is leftover in some cases?>Visti: If our desires are satisfied, its farely easy to get moksha. In most cases, people do not get their desires satisfied.>>2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits >of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second >one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two >really malefic ones have how much time separating them?>Visti: Gurudeva allready explained this on Vedic-Astrology list, where he described the 3 types of Sade Sathi, where Saturn removes support from wife(12th), Family(2nd) and in the middle part, it sits on your head and punished you for your mistakes. Depending on the Dasa period and Karma, the effects will be felt acordingly.>>3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to >other conditions.>Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka.>How do we reconcile these statements?>Visti: Easy. Saturn has no more longevity to give.>Regards,>Lakshmi>P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His >companions kill, is it?Visti: Functional nature is something else. 8th lord shows the type of Rudra.Best wishes, Visti._______________Get your FREE download of MSN Explorer at http://explorer.msn.com/intl.asp.Your use of is subject to the Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted March 7, 2002 Report Share Posted March 7, 2002 Shri Sanjay, Exactly! I too was thinking of Sri Rama. And, Guruji, isn't punishment a cumulative result? I mean, the 100th error might triggerthe "Sudarshana chakra", but the count starts from the 1st, na? Is it the last strawor the first few weights that "begins" to break the camel's back? While Partha was right in saying that Saturn bestows longevity on the houseshe aspects, what about the house where he sits? Is he not a reduction factor?BTW, Partha raised a very interesting point about him not being able to quit the job,because of Saturn's aspect. It could be my problem too. Regards,Lakshmi P.S: Interesting point about the beer n' the buffalo. That makes the species definitely much more intriguing! Sanjay Rath <srath (AT) vsnl (DOT) com> wrote: om gurave namah------------------------Dear Lakshmi Partha was only giving the general point that people are reborn (these days) largely due to strong unfulfilled desires. Take the drunkard next door. He has to be born so many more times because that last glass of beer is not over! That is Karmic rebirth where Bhagavan is kind enough to let him come again and again for that last glass, and perhaps alternating between other bodies of buffallo and other animals ( if more fortunate). Now, saturn also has a say in this matter and for this reason, Saturn and Gulika (his bright eyed son so very good at preparing poison) have a strong say in rebirth as well. Here they are used to calculate the date of conception by reducing the tentative date by the difference between their degrees. (Conception chart). At least one case is sure to be remembered . That of Bhagavan Ram, and here we cannot blame it all on Rahu (Ravana) alone and Saturn also holds the key to this. Thus when Rahu becomes the AK, I guess Rama will come to take you back to Godhead...With best wishesSanjay RathWeb: http://sanjayrath.tripod.comServices: http://sanjayrath.tripod.com/zservices.htmJyotish Digest: http://jyotishdigest.com/SJVC: http://www.sjvc.org/ - lakshmi ramesh sjvc Tuesday, March 05, 2002 3:16 PM Re: [sjvc] saturn Om Gurave Namah Dear Partha, From where did you get this info about special rules? Visti also mentioned something similar. Let me know the source so I too can look it up. Coming to "retribution" I too thought it was quite swift sometimes, until in the 3-4 cases I checked up it was either Saturn dasa/Antar/pratyantar or Sade Sathi running. The link to Saturn was always there. My premise that Saturn is Slow is based on the fact that he's huge & solid (ghanaya), slow (manda), manda chestaya (slow actioned), lame and represents "year" (the longest time unit) in vedic time segments (BPHS). All these attributes certainly do not describe an agile personality. I did not find any other reference to the contrary. Have I missed something somewhere? But, Partha, I found another interesting reference in Sani ashtottaram...it says "dhanurmandala samsthaaya"..how come? Now, I have a few questions coming up. And, these are more for my enlightenment: 1) If the punishment is immediate, then rebirth is caused only because of unfulfilled desires (Rahu) / moksha (Ketu). If this is the case, how do we explain early deaths / infant deaths, because natives here have not obviously fulfilled any latent desires or done any fresh karma to warrant moksha. Even in normal cases why so much suffering for some people? Or karma is leftover in some cases? 2) If punishment is immediate, then what happens during the three transits of Sade sathi? What's the function of these transits? Of course the second one is supposed to be least malefic or even benefic. That means the two really malefic ones have how much time separating them? 3) The third round of Sade Sathi is supposed to bring death, subject to other conditions.Visti Says that Saturn does not kill and Saturn is definitely ayushkaraka.How do we reconcile these statements? Regards,Lakshmi P.S: What happens to Sagittarians like us, where he's the maraka? His companions kill, is it? partvinu5 <partvinu5 > wrote: dear lakshmiI think saturn has some special rules.a) he will give benefic results lateb) he will punish people without any delay-i know it from personal experiencec) he is slow in giving material comfortsd) he is fast in giving spiritual blessings, dont know why he increases his speed when "fating out someone".regardspartha Terms of Service. Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Your use of is subject to the Your use of Groups is subject to the Try FREE Mail - the world's greatest free email! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.