Astrology, destiny, determinism - logical error ???

[Guest guest]

If we assume there is no such thing as free will (that is, what we

call free will is just an illusion)..........

 

Consider a child is born with a certain birth chart

 

1. "Paap" or sins lead to bad results. In particular, you will be

born with a "bad chart" in your next life.

 

2. A "bad chart" is afflicted with "Paap-Grahas", or malefics.

 

3. "Paap-Grahas" force you to commit sin ("Paap").

 

As you can all see, anybody who has strong malefic presence in

his/her chart is endlessly stuck in this infinite loop and will never

get out.

 

 

Dear indigenous

I cannot speak from the logic of theory...only from practice.

I see folks with strongly afflicted charts living out peaceful and

productive lives.

They are not endlessly stuck. The gift of astrology is to consult an

astrologer who helps you navigate the waters of the chart you were born

with.

 

Oh, I have also seen folks with great benefic charts do little with their

gifts.

c