Guest guest Posted January 21, 2002 Report Share Posted January 21, 2002 Dear Robert Well it is just as you calculate vimshottari using the Moon and its progression through the nakshatras. You just do it for all of the planets. He said he met a Sihk astrologer who did this and made some excellent long term observations of his chart. I see little difference to this and western progressions which I feel also offer excellent results. Pundit last week told me he himself was also very impressed with western progressions. I have been looking into tertiary progressions as I now have the software to do them. Pundit told me he met a Singahlese astrologer in Sri Lanka who made about 5 predictions on his chart using western progressions. Every date and event was so totally correct Pundit has never forgotten this. What was also very interesting is he said to me "lets look at the day of my heart attack when I was clinically dead to see what the progressions were" I cast a tertiary progressed chart and his progressed Moon was exactly conjunct Saturn and aspected exactly by progressed Mars in a hard mutual square aspect. This was very interesting as Cancer was also the lagna rising in the progressed chart. If there was ever an aspect to die by it was this!! I have no problems with both secondary or tertiary progressed charts as they are based on sound mathematics. I have never done them before as I have always used Parasharas Light or P.C Jyotish which are purely Vedic programs. You may have seen my posting regarding the nasdaq chart and the indications of a fall in the stockmarket this coming weekend. This Uranus ingress in very interesting in terms of the U.S. Firstly it will become exactly square to the Saturn at 00 degrees in the inauguaration chart 2nd house. Apart from all the aspects in the nasdaq chart including the nodes at 00 degrees Aq/Leo, there is the fact if you tertiary progress the inauguration chart, Mars also ends up at 00 degrees Scorpio. So in terms of the inauguration chart we have Mars square Uranus who is square Saturn who opposes Mars. This may trigger a very sudden violent act as well. Next Monday is full Moon day and on Tuesday Moon will also pass 00 degrees Leo putting it in in aspect to Uranus, Saturn and tertiary progressed Mars. Any astrologer would agree these are explosive aspects and explosive event usually go down on a Tuesday. As a side issue I was reading a book about Australia's history and couldn't believe how many of the worst bushfires occured on a Tuesday. They all had a name like "black Tuesday" or something similar. There is also the probability of nothing happening at this time but I strongly suspect something major. My Pundit says Uranus in Aquarius must bring reform and humanitarian concerns to the fore. Unfortunately it takes a September 11th style incident to occur before people start to question just what is important in life. Andrew > Dear Andrew, > > At 06:45 PM 1/21/02 +1100, you wrote: > > >Another interesting but seldom used technique is to progress all the > >planets like the Moon in vimshottari. My Pundit did some interesting > >research on this and I have the print-outs of the charts of all the timing > >for doing this depending where the natal planet is located............. > > Sounds interesting. Could you be more specific as to how these > progressions are calculated? Thanks! > > Robert > > ===================================== > Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer > Faculty member SJVC and ACVA > Phone: 541-318-0248 > visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail > rk. rk > > > > > Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat Sat > : gjlist- > > > > Your use of is subject to > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 > Sounds interesting. Could you be more specific as to how these progressions are calculated? Thanks!< Robert, The nakshatra Moon progression was discussed on another list. I think this is the same technique Andrew is referring to. Here is an example- J F Kennedy 29 May 1917 3pm TZ5 Brookline MA Assassination 22 Nov 1963 This event happened in his Jupiter MD. ie the Mo had progressed from Purva Phalguni to Vishaka. The nakshatra progressed Mo at Nov 1963 was 14.5% into the nakshatra Vishaka or 21*56' Libra. This becomes a sensitive point for transits etc. At the event this point was conjunct Transit Neptune and Trined by Tr Rahu. It's D30 division falls in the 8H of natal D30 (Trimsamsa). Take the D8 division of this point -25Vi 30. This is closely conjunct natal ascendent. Dasas can be initiated from other planets(as karakas) and the ascendent. Eg to confirm death the dasas can be started from Sa and progression of Sa can be followed. Regards Ron Send FREE video emails in Mail! http://promo./videomail/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Robert Another thing about this idea of planets being in trine is going to appear this weekend also. Sun, Mercury and Neptune will be trine to Saturn. They all fall together in the navamsha in Taurus. Mars and Uranus are 40 degrees apart so are also in the same navamsha. Mars and Rahu also fall 80 degrees apart so are also on the same navamsha. Another aspect that has been mostly ignored is transit Uranus in exact trine to Rahu within 1 degree. This puts Mars, Rahu and Uranus all together in navamsha. There are some potent powers gathering on a full Moon. I was just sent an email from America where someone called Ray Merriman also is vary of this. He mentions chemical weapons as Neptune is involved. Excuse my ignorance but I have no actual idea who Ray is. He is obviously a keen watcher of the stockmarkets as the posting I was sent reveals he has great knowledge of these things. I notice when Uranus gets involved in these things revolutions and uprisings can happen also. Rons spin on the JFK chart is very true. I don't dismiss the outer planets- particularly when they become very close to important inner planets. Beginners may be unaware that planets in multiples of 40 degrees apart are conjunct in navamsha. Andrew Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Robert and Ron, Ron, this is my understanding too. Goravani Jyotish can calculate the dashas from all the planets and all the house cusps. Click on the "L" button down in the lower right hand corner of the opening page. (this is at least how my ancient 1.92 version is configured) One can then figure out where the progressed planet would be at a particular time in the dasha. Time converted into space. It's a experimenter's dream come true. Chris At 02:02 AM 1/22/02 -0800, Ron Day wrote: >> Sounds interesting. Could you be more specific as >to how these > progressions are calculated? Thanks!< > >Robert, >The nakshatra Moon progression was discussed on >another list. I think this is the same technique >Andrew is referring to. > >Here is an example- >J F Kennedy 29 May 1917 3pm TZ5 Brookline >MA >Assassination 22 Nov 1963 > >This event happened in his Jupiter MD. ie the Mo had >progressed from Purva Phalguni to Vishaka. >The nakshatra progressed Mo at Nov 1963 was 14.5% >into the nakshatra Vishaka or 21*56' Libra. >This becomes a sensitive point for transits etc. >At the event this point was conjunct Transit Neptune >and Trined by Tr Rahu. > >It's D30 division falls in the 8H of natal D30 >(Trimsamsa). >Take the D8 division of this point -25Vi 30. This >is closely conjunct natal ascendent. > >Dasas can be initiated from other planets(as karakas) >and the ascendent. Eg to confirm death the dasas can >be started from Sa and progression of Sa can be >followed. > >Regards >Ron > > > > > > > >Send FREE video emails in Mail! >http://promo./videomail/ > > > >Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat Sat >: gjlist- > > > >Your use of is subject to > > > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Andrew, Thanks for the progression update. I wasn't aware that astrologers are doing this, so that is a new one to try out. Regarding 'western' progressions: Evidently, there are a variety of progressions that are similar in nature in some very old Vedic books as well. The one that I have been made aware of, is the Manu Smriti. Progressions by one Ephemeris day = one month (Tertiary), or one day = one year (Secondary), were known about and practised in those Vedic times as well. They use other progressions also, such as: progressing the Sun at one Navamsa per year (3:20 d.), until the degree of Venus or other karaka for marriage is reached, and then time the marriage. Or, progress the Sun at 1:30 d. per year (1:30 is one Vimsamsa), until Jupiter or other karaka for spirituality is reached, for timing spiritual initiation, meeting the guru, etc. Similarly, the starting point can be the sun, the lagna, or other karakas, at increments of other divisions, to time affairs related to those vargas. Anyway, regarding Tertiary and Secondaries: astrologers need not be fanatical about one school or the other (Vedic or western), and rather use what works. In my experience, striking correspondences between events and progressions according to these methods, are found consistently, especially when the Tertiary or Secondary stations occur. In the year when my 12th house Mercury in Virgo, for example, stationed by Secondary progression, I started studying Jyotish like there was no tomorrow, and my life changed for good after that. That's just one out of many examples. Rick Houck, in fact, did much convincing research re: Tertiary stations, and correspondences with significant events. Tertiaries may be more significant vis a vis outer planets, because the time lapse is much faster. Anyway, that's it, I'm out, more later.......... Robert ===================================== Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer Faculty member SJVC and ACVA Phone: 541-318-0248 visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail rk. rk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Ron, At 02:02 AM 1/22/02 -0800, you wrote: >Robert, >The nakshatra Moon progression was discussed on >another list. I think this is the same technique >Andrew is referring to. > >Here is an example- >J F Kennedy 29 May 1917 3pm TZ5 Brookline >MA >Assassination 22 Nov 1963 > >This event happened in his Jupiter MD. ie the Mo had >progressed from Purva Phalguni to Vishaka. >The nakshatra progressed Mo at Nov 1963 was 14.5% >into the nakshatra Vishaka or 21*56' Libra. >This becomes a sensitive point for transits etc. >At the event this point was conjunct Transit Neptune >and Trined by Tr Rahu. > >It's D30 division falls in the 8H of natal D30 >(Trimsamsa). >Take the D8 division of this point -25Vi 30. This >is closely conjunct natal ascendent. > >Dasas can be initiated from other planets(as karakas) >and the ascendent. Eg to confirm death the dasas can >be started from Sa and progression of Sa can be >followed. OK, very good, this is good food. Thanks for that! So, then, this would re-adjust your orientation to many natal configurations in a chart. With a given stressful grouping of natal malefic aspects, for example, to some planet or significator, you would think to remind yourself when the Moon or other significator would progress to conjoin one of the key planets in that configuration, right? Is that what you would do? Or, you could set your software to show you when transit planets would come to the sensitive progressed degree? Anyway, any more demonstrations on how you use this, would be good. Robert ===================================== Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer Faculty member SJVC and ACVA Phone: 541-318-0248 visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail rk. rk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Andrew, I've been also absolutely aware of the fact that (western, as you say) progressions work- as well as change of direction for both inner and outer planets: they are proven prediction tools- they always work: I haven't seen yet progesssion(s) or change of sign or planetary direction failed to coincide with outer significant events. However, I've started to question if they are necessary in Vedic astrology? I just want to share my experience: when I had NDE, my progressed Moon was (also) conjuct Saturn- along with other progressions' indications..but it's not relevant for what I want to communicate... Robert Koch made that prediction far in advance with an amazing acuracy!!!(suggesting that I be aware about my health, along with so precise diagnosis and description of my condition that doctors can only dream about!!) which he supported, in his easy to understand, analytical way with the VEDIC facts ONLY, based on my chart(s)- I remember, he told me once at the list, that when I knew vedic rules well , I wouldn't need progressions, and western tools that I've been experienced with- I apreciate very much his openess to accept others' opinions, and not forcing his on anybody, not insisting on what he knows is right- rather letting you find out yourself... While I was respectful of his opinion the very first time he told that, after this experience, he "won me over"- I really question now if that's lack of vedic knowledge that makes us search for additional tools? I will certainly look at progressions at least until I become more knowledgable in vedic a., but the question is/will be still valid, I guess. (MO). Thanks, A. PS: I am not regularly on the net, don't read mail often, sorry if I missed something.. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 > So, then, this would re-adjust your orientation to > many natal > configurations in a chart. With a given stressful > grouping of natal > malefic aspects, for example, to some planet or > significator, you would > think to remind yourself when the Moon or other > significator would progress > to conjoin one of the key planets in that > configuration, right? Is that > what you would do? Or, you could set your software > to show you when > transit planets would come to the sensitive > progressed degree? Anyway, any > more demonstrations on how you use this, would be > good. Robert, This technique has only recently emerged from it's hiding place. For future research the following could be considered. 1. Aspects of the nakshatra progressed Mo (or other karaka) to natal planets,cusps or sahams 2.Transits to the progressed Mo point which include prior eclipses. 3.Varga positions of the progressed Mo point in varga charts or natal chart overlay. Regards Ron Send FREE video emails in Mail! http://promo./videomail/ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Ron: "2.Transits to the progressed Mo point which include prior eclipses." Robert: Or you could set your software> to show you when > transit planets would come to the sensitive> progressed degree? It seems to me that this question implies another one:if that comparison btw. "fictive" facts, as progr.'s are, and REAL, factual movement of planets, i.e. transit, is possible. I don't think so. That's, IMO mix of completely different levels- progressed planets can be compared with natal , so can tr. planets. Eclipses are transit issue, of course. As far as I know and have experienced so far, progressions being rather "mystical"-direct, as well as converse, secondary, tertiary progressions...they all work, indeed, but they are of "unknown nature", nobody knows why- and cannot be mixed with real planetary movement. Tr. planets triggering natal, that's ok. Progressions serve to tell us in advance that a major occurrence will happen in, say, couple of months- then we look at transits, eclipses, other sensitive points. Information is available, but not in that direct way as is the transiting "hit" over progressed point;rather in a symbolic way, bearing the meaning of the progr.'s, only. I've read from some (western) authors that they do that in support of (most often "post factum) prediction, as well as (majority) opinions that it's like mixing orange juice with milk- hard to swallow. Others may have different opinions. Would be nice to hear. Thanks. A. - Ron Day gjlist Tuesday, January 22, 2002 9:44 PM Re: [GJ] Progressions: Andrew > So, then, this would re-adjust your orientation to> many natal > configurations in a chart. With a given stressful> grouping of natal > malefic aspects, for example, to some planet or> significator, you would > think to remind yourself when the Moon or other> significator would progress > to conjoin one of the key planets in that> configuration, right? Is that > what you would do? Or, you could set your software> to show you when > transit planets would come to the sensitive> progressed degree? Anyway, any > more demonstrations on how you use this, would be> good.Robert,This technique has only recently emerged from it'shiding place. For future research the following couldbe considered.1. Aspects of the nakshatra progressed Mo (or otherkaraka) to natal planets,cusps or sahams2.Transits to the progressed Mo point which include prior eclipses.3.Varga positions of the progressed Mo point in varga charts or natal chart overlay.RegardsRonDo You ?Send FREE video emails in Mail!http://promo./videomail/Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat Sat: gjlist-http://www.goravani.com Your use of is subject to Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Andrew, I've been also absolutely aware of the fact that (western, as you say) progressions work- as well as change of direction for both inner and outer planets: they are proven prediction tools- they always work: I haven't seen yet progesssion(s) or change of sign or planetary direction failed to coincide with outer significant events. We will all see this week with Uranus moving Rasi's. I don't like using the term "western" or "eastern astrology" as both have valid techniques. I do however place a huge difference between the tropically cast chart and the sidereal. My teacher always says there is no western astrology. There is simply astrology as there always has been, briefly some have lost their way with the wrong calculations but given time the sidereal zodiac will prevail. However, I've started to question if they are necessary in Vedic astrology? I just want to share my experience: when I had NDE, my progressed Moon was (also) conjuct Saturn- along with other progressions' indications..but it's not relevant for what I want to communicate... Robert Koch made that prediction far in advance with an amazing acuracy!!!(suggesting that I be aware about my health, along with so precise diagnosis and description of my condition that doctors can only dream about!!) which he supported, in his easy to understand, analytical way with the VEDIC facts ONLY, based on my chart(s)- I remember, he told me once at the list, that when I knew vedic rules well , I wouldn't need progressions, and western tools that I've been experienced with- I apreciate very much his openess to accept others' opinions, and not forcing his on anybody, not insisting on what he knows is right- rather letting you find out yourself... While I was respectful of his opinion the very first time he told that, after this experience, he "won me over"- I really question now if that's lack of vedic knowledge that makes us search for additional tools? I will certainly look at progressions at least until I become more knowledgable in vedic a., but the question is/will be still valid, I guess. (MO). No doubt a good Vedic astrologer may not need the outer planets or progressions. I often don't bother with them at all myself- but at times things are clear and at other times they are not. I suggest the more tools you can usefully use well will give more ability to clarify a matter. Any hard aspect of Saturn on Moon or Sun can generally bring health problems in either transit or progression. Perhaps if you could post this prediction we all could look at the reasons given to see for ourselves. Andrew Thanks, A. PS: I am not regularly on the net, don't read mail often, sorry if I missed something.. Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat SatTo , send an email to: gjlist-http://www.goravani.comYour use of is subject to the Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 > Dear Andrew, > > Thanks for the progression update. I wasn't aware that astrologers are > doing this, so that is a new one to try out. I don't know if anybody actually uses it but it is something to keep in mind. > > Regarding 'western' progressions: Evidently, there are a variety of > progressions that are similar in nature in some very old Vedic books as > well. The one that I have been made aware of, is the Manu > Smriti. Progressions by one Ephemeris day = one month (Tertiary), or one > day = one year (Secondary), were known about and practised in those Vedic > times as well. The first thing we must remember is we can click on a computer button and get all this information in seconds. In the old days just to calculate a chart by hand was time consuming, so to expect progresssions to have been used widely is unrealistic. However, it is not unrealistic to think people endorsed them in theory. We are all in fantastic position for research with computers so I for one often get disappointed with people making rigid and dogmatic interpretations from Parasara and others. Research is the best way to vindicate these things. They use other progressions also, such as: progressing the > Sun at one Navamsa per year (3:20 d.), until the degree of Venus or other > karaka for marriage is reached, and then time the marriage. Or, progress > the Sun at 1:30 d. per year (1:30 is one Vimsamsa), until Jupiter or other > karaka for spirituality is reached, for timing spiritual initiation, > meeting the guru, etc. Similarly, the starting point can be the sun, the > lagna, or other karakas, at increments of other divisions, to time affairs > related to those vargas. As long as correct mathematics is used I see no problem with these things in theory. However, we must also be aware of what we can use and communicate to others. The more techniques you use the more chance you have of confusing yourself or finding and alternative answer. Experienced astrologers can usually intuitively make the correct decision but beginners should stick to very basic rules as they may just end up misleading themselves or others. On the plus side it makes astrology something that can be studied for lifetimes without becoming boring. > > Anyway, regarding Tertiary and Secondaries: astrologers need not be > fanatical about one school or the other (Vedic or western), and rather use > what works. In my experience, striking correspondences between events and > progressions according to these methods, are found consistently, especially > when the Tertiary or Secondary stations occur. This is hardcore fact and should not be questioned-they work! In the year when my 12th > house Mercury in Virgo, for example, stationed by Secondary progression, I > started studying Jyotish like there was no tomorrow, and my life changed > for good after that. That's just one out of many examples. Rick Houck, in > fact, did much convincing research re: Tertiary stations, and > correspondences with significant events. Tertiaries may be more > significant vis a vis outer planets, because the time lapse is much faster. Eclipses are another powerful factor in major events. There was a solar eclipse before I was born at 22 degrees Capricorn. When I was born natal Ketu was at 22 Degrees Capricorn in the 12th house where my lagna lord is. Before I was born the last lunar eclipse was at 7degrees Leo and this was where my natal Moon was placed at birth. All very interesting but what does it mean and how can it be interpreted, does it actually mean anything???? Andrew > > Anyway, that's it, I'm out, more later.......... > Robert > > ===================================== > Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer > Faculty member SJVC and ACVA > Phone: 541-318-0248 > visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail > rk. rk > > > > > Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat Sat > : gjlist- > > > > Your use of is subject to > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 22, 2002 Report Share Posted January 22, 2002 Dear Crusty I need another Vedic program as I'm sick of Parashara's Light. You can't load it onto another computer and you need to email them and get another code, so if you go overseas it is pointless to take it to use on friends computers etc. They have lost me forever after this. Das is at least willing to add these new things like stations and progressions for people to use. I would like to see a Vedic program with all progressions available for use as well as planetary speed noted. I don't actually know if the speeds of planets are on PL but is is good to know in particular if a planet is stationary or close to stationary. Visual Jyotish also allows you to calculate the dashas from every planet but PL doesn't. A program for me is extremely expensive with our dollar at .49 cents U.S. Andrew > Robert and Ron, > > > Ron, this is my understanding too. Goravani Jyotish can calculate the > dashas from all the planets and all the house cusps. Click on the "L" > button down in the lower right hand corner of the opening page. (this is > at least how my ancient 1.92 version is configured) One can then figure out > where the progressed planet would be at a particular time in the dasha. > Time converted into space. It's a experimenter's dream come true. > > Chris Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2002 Report Share Posted January 23, 2002 Hi Andrew, Well, now you're really confusing me! First you wrote this: "I suggest the more tools you can usefully use well will give more ability to clarify a matter. " Then, you wrote this: " The more techniques you use the more chance you have of confusing yourself or finding an alternative answer. " So, what actually is your position? Please clarify... Thanks! Robert ===================================== Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer Faculty member SJVC and ACVA Phone: 541-318-0248 visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail rk. rk Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted January 23, 2002 Report Share Posted January 23, 2002 Dear Robert Both are valid, a lot of tools for the experienced astrologer can help greatly, a lot for the inexperienced astrologer will more likely lead to confusion. Enough said, I have more important things to do with my life. LOL The key word in the first statement was "Usefully" This is definitely my last post..... Andrew > > ===================================== > Robert A. Koch, Vedic Astrologer > Faculty member SJVC and ACVA > Phone: 541-318-0248 > visit <http://www.robertkoch.com> or e-mail > rk. rk > > > > > Om Namo Bhagavate Vasudevaya; Hare Krishna; Om Tat Sat > : gjlist- > > > > Your use of is subject to > > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.