Digest Number 908

[Guest guest]

Dear Jagannath,

Namaste to you too.

 

You are unnecessarily antagonizing every thing that I say, without even knowing

me.

 

As a child I was raised on Homeopathy by my own faher, who had also studied

other substances like the Dechane's oils, etc.. He asked me to pursue Modern

medicine, as everything cannot be cured by Homeopathy either. Although I studied

Medicine and practiced it for several years, I do know that this form does not

cure everything either. I have studied Ayurveda and Accupuncture. Perhaps I

should study Chinese Herbology to complete all medical sciences. My children

were raised on both Homeopathy or Modern Medicine, depending on the acuteness of

the problems. There are different needs and different treatments as the occasion

/ problem demands.

 

I have also studied all the Upanishads, and practice meditation and yoga, and

have no problem with the holistic approach either. You have unnecessarily taken

me on, because of your bias against Modern medicine, which I do understand.

There is no need to lecture me on the principles of this or other traditional

medical or para medical phiolosophies. I may voice strongly my opinion, but

there may be many others like me in these 1800 members, who get turned off by

your constant tirade.

 

This forum should be for mutual learning and not for throwing vitriolic barbs.

The fact that you buy your own books, is commendable, so do most of us, and has

nothing to do with either Ayurveda or this column.

ayurveda wrote:

 

Jagannath Chatterjee

Re: Ayurveda is also Allopathy, unlike Homeopathy ?????

 

Dear Dr Durgesh,

I also admit that this is an ayurvedic forum. This forum is meant to encourage

ayurveda, value the comments of the ayurveds, provide direction to the ayurvedic

students and last BUT NOT THE LEAST, cater to the queries of the patients.

Unfortunately you like none of these.

...

...

[Guest guest]

Dear Sirs,

 

This is not a place for drama; it is a place for us to learn and

share our knowledge about

Ayurveda. If you have personal issues, this forum is not the proper

arena to express them.

Please send personal emails to one another if you have an argument.

Throwing around

your negative comments to each other only serve to vitiate the minds

of we readers

unnecessarily. Thank you.

 

 

 

 

ayurveda, durgesh mankikar

<d_mankikar> wrote:

> Dear Jagannath,

> Namaste to you too.

>

> You are unnecessarily antagonizing every thing that I say, without

even knowing me.

>

[Guest guest]

Dear Dr Durgesh,

 

Thank you for your mail. It does not please me to oppose you. I do

know you. I know that your family is well respected in New Jersey and

that you like entertaining people by inviting Indians over to your

house by holding various cultural programmes. You are also on the

board of various organisations who value your opinion. I appreciate

your efforts and sincerely hope and pray to God that you prosper in

all respects. Please convey my regards to Madam Mankikar and the rest

of your family.

 

I'm not as bad a person as my mails make me to be. Being an activist

and fighting the system is not easy, it will make the best of persons

very bitter.

 

Respect & Regards,

Jagannath.

 

ayurveda, durgesh mankikar

<d_mankikar> wrote:

> Dear Jagannath,

> Namaste to you too.