to Vinod 3x3

[Guest guest]

Dear Vinod

 

> Now you are revealing yourself as a racist and cultural suprmecist.

>

 

if you refrain from derogatory labels then I think this would be a good

idea - it doesn't serve a purposeful discussion, and is often the last

defense of somebody who has nothing useful to say

 

your many comments to my own have been taken then out of complete

context, or where you have disagreed with me you have made wholesale

generalizations like the glycemic index isn't relevant! I have

consistently provided citation and reference for everything I have

said, but you have not

 

you obviously believe in your perspective, but do not feel that you

need to support it other than to appeal to your own polemic

 

for what you have called me, and from the unkindness you this has

demonstrated, i feel an apology is in order, but since it is clear that

your intent is factionalism and label-calling, i won't expect it

 

my intent is to debate issues, not attack individuals, but I'm afraid

you have stepped over the line

please restrain yourself in the future

 

i am moderator on this list, but since i am involved in this matter, i

leave it to the others to decide how to address this

 

***

 

if you took any time to read what I am actually writing, you would see

that my argument was a demonstration of the fallacy in yogaman's

thinking

 

please read again what I said:

 

"experiment on vegetarianism has been an absolute disaster, as far as

longevity is concerned and I would ask you: are the Indian people

happy? most would say they are miserable, and have a miserable lot

 

these are of course unfair comparisons, but I am only trying to

illustrate the fallacy of your thinking"

 

is this clear? do you understand what my intent was? do you

understand that I don't think that diet is the cause of the myriad

troubles that plague India?

 

hello-oo?

Caldecott

phyto

http://www.wrc.net/phyto