Kaishore vs.Yogaraj Guggulu in Arthritis treatment

[Guest guest]

I have been treating a patient,a 42 year old female of strongly Pitta

Prakruti with Pitta and Vata Vikruti. She has been variously

diagnosed my various Western MDs as having; Fibromyalgia, Reitters

Syndrome, Systemic Lupis and Arthritis( no overall agreement). She

suffers severe joint pain which manifests in various locations from

day to day. I began treating with Kaishore Guggulu 6 caps per day,

she has still not felt any relief. After one month, would it be

correct to consider this a case of "upashaya" and assume that her

imbalance was not Pitta to be treated with Kaishore Guggulu but

actually a Vata imbalance to be treated with Yogaraj Guggulu? Any

thoughts of advice from Vaidyas would be most welcome. Thank You!

David Wells