Guest guest Posted November 9, 2003 Report Share Posted November 9, 2003 Dear Respected Ajitsingh Ji: You Said: >>>>> After arriving here and discussing with my Hindu friends, i got some idea as to why Hindus are mocked at and insulted by others. Still can anybody enlighten me? <<<<<<<<<< Can you please enlighten us, what your Hindu Friends told you? Along with your own thoughts ?? I believe that you are a Sikh, and that makes you a barer of Indian cultural staff. You further said: >>>>>> I always wondered why American always insulted Hindus like this. Why they never do such things with holy symbols of Christians, or Muslims. <<<<<<<< It is not just the Americans who abuse "Hindu ICONS" !!! Indians are no exceptions. Ganesh BIDI, Shankar BIDI. Are sole in India and Exported to US as well? How about, ShriRam Videshi Wine Emporium? Or Undergarments from Gajaana Mills ??? How come none of Hindu's take an offence to it? If we do not care for ourselves, then why other Nationals should respect it?? One will need to do some soul searching before joining the band- wagon, because charity begins at home. Once objections have been raised they (Foreign Nationals) will stop such practices, however, who is watching the chicken fence at HOME? You concern was answered by Justice Warren Burger (US Supreme Court): "If you ask the question who is responsible?; the answer must be I am, You are and we are ...... " (Inaugural speech Justice Warren Burger, 1984). Regards, Dr. Yadu , "the-hermit" <the-hermit@i...> wrote: > Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest guest Posted November 9, 2003 Report Share Posted November 9, 2003 Yes, I totally agree with Dr. Yadu. In fact, specifically with respect to the book in question, it was written 18 years ago, and it is being reprinted by non other than the respectable Indian publisher Motilal Banarsidass who chose to put the naked Ganesha picture on the cover! As to the author of the book, the professor Paul Courtright, is director of the Asian Studies Program at Emory University, and had recently denounced the Southern Baptist's virulently anti-Hindu prayer book. He has a Ph D from Princeton University, and the author of Ganesha: Lord of Obstacles, Lord of Beginnings (Oxford University Press, 1989), and co-editor and contributor of From the Margins of Hindu Marriage (Oxford University Press, 1994). The US edition of the book has a Dancing Ganesh!!!!!!!! As it has been said, everytime a piece of academic research material is presented, whether it is palatable to believers or not, they cannot take permission from 1 billion Hindus! Hindus on their part have the total freedom, to produce their own research, use academic tools to present counter arguments and discredit the study. In this particular case where the author had used Freudian Psychoanalysis to explain some of the events surounding Ganesha, it should not be difficult to provide counter-arguments since many aspects of Freudian theory has been discredited a long time ago! While a Hindu may avoid addressing controversial issues and looking at themselves analytically, they cannot stop research in the field. Has anyone read Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown? Do you think all Christians are very happy about that book's insinuations, even though it is presented as a novel? Do we as Hindus take responsibility for cleaning up our own house? We treat our poor and lower castes like dirt, and then wonder why others come and convert them and continue to treat them badly! Every day there is a story in the news about mistreatment of our women, including female infanticide .. how many petitions are taken up on that and followed up to stop it? How many of us came together to denounce the butchery that took place in Gujarat in the name of Revenge! Personally I did and our numbers were small compared to our total strength. We can go on and on about the multitudes of issues (social or pseudo-religious) that we choose to turn our backs on, and then we wonder why someone else mocks us? We make a mockery of ourselves with our own collective behavior disrespecting ourselves, we don't need anyone else to do it for us! Its time for more people to stop and think, and do whatever it takes to LIVE the teachings of our great Gurus/Avatars/Devas/Devis, not just quote, analyse, paraphrase, and re-paraphrase the paraphrase, parse, and regurgititate, and indulge in sycophancy to those who do so! Thank goodness there still is a small crop of teachers/Gurus who are focused on doing just that! _/\_ Tat twam asi Uma Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.