Is ISKCON going to build the Adbhuta Mandira between Bhaktivinoda's house & Mayapura?

krsna · 09-20-2005, 03:20 AM

Bhaktivinoda's Vision

KrsnaTalk # 57 by Swami B.G. Narasingha

Question: I have read your articles about the Adbhuta Mandira being built at Yogapitha
but I have also seen a video, The New World of Hare Krishna, wherein a sannyasi is
standing on the roof of Bhaktivinoda's house in Godrumadvipa and he is pointing in the
direction of Mayapura and saying that from there on the roof Bhaktivinoda had a vision of
the Adbhuta Mandira. The sannyasi is indicating that since the ISKCON project is in
between Bhaktivinoda's house and Mayapura that it must be ISKCON that is going to build the
Adbhuta Mandira. Do you have any comment of this?

Swami Narasingha: That is of course ISKCON's misunderstanding, a novel idea, but such
thinking was not present in the time of Srila Prabhupada (A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami) nor
is it a fact.

In the first place Bhaktivinoda Thakura was not staying in Godrumadvipa when he had his
vision of the Adbhuta Mandira. In fact Bhaktivinoda's house at Godruma was not built
until two years later. Bhaktivinoda's house, Svananda Sukhada Kunja, was constructed in
1889 whereas his vision of the Adbhuta Mandira occurred in 1887 when he was staying at
the Rani Dharmasala across the Ganga in Navadvipa town. Rani Dharmasala is the same
place where Gaura-kishora Dasa Babaji used to spend much of his time doing bhajana.

Bhaktivinoda was living and working in government service at Krsnanagara during those
days. He used to come to Navadvipa on the weekends to try to find out the places of Sri
Caitanya Mahaprabhu's pastimes. Bhaktivinoda has mentioned that he was especially
disappointed in that the residents of Navadvipa were not very interested in such things (he
has specifically mentioned that they only pay heed to their stomach). It was on one
such visit to Navadvipa when he was staying at the Rani Dharmasala that Bhaktivinoda had
the vision of the Adbhuta Mandira.

One Saturday evening Bhaktivinoda was standing on the roof of the dharmasala with his
son Kamala Prasada and a clerk from his office. He was looking in a northerly direction
when a brilliant light appeared on the horizon across the Ganga. Within that effulgence
appeared the Adbhuta Mandira.

When looking in the northerly direction from the place where Bhaktivinoda was standing
the present day ISKCON project does not come into view and even if it did the point to
remember is that the vision of the Adbhuta Mandira was specifically revealing the birth
site of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu, therefore the Adbhuta Mandira must be built at
Yogapitha and not just anywhere in Mayapura.

Bhaktivinoda had the vision of the Adbhuta Mandir on two consecutive occasions. Some
years later in a letter to one of his sons Bhaktivinoda detailed the experience of his
vision of the Adbhuta Mandira and the events that led to the discovery of Mahaprabhu's
birth site (Yogapitha) in Mayapura. That segment of Bhaktivinoda's letter follows:
"During the Christmas break I took a train to Navadvipa with my wife. Arriving there
and seeing the land in all four directions the hair on my body stood on end. Upon
crossing the Ganga, and I went to Rani Dharmasala and I made arrangements to cook for Sriman
Mahaprabhu. Having taken darsana of the Lord with difficultly I honored prasada at
around 1 o'clock. After 45 days [of dieting], I took grains, jackfruit dahl, banana-flour
sabji, and soup etc., which were like nectar. Since my very birth I had not eaten such
nectarine food. Even Bimal ate everything on his plate, and with great devotion.
"We had to go to the house at Krsnanagara before evening and thus, buying some cooking
pots and utensils, and quickly crossing [the river], we took the train to Krsnanagara.
The next day I went to Baro Gosvami's house in Santipura, took prasada, and before
evening returned home. At that time I was beginning to become strong. Every Saturday, I
went to Navadvipa to search out the places of the lila of the Lord, but I did not find
many and I was very unhappy. At the present time the people of Navadvipa only pay heed to
their stomach etc. They do not make even a little effort in relation to the places of
the lila of the Lord. One night, Kamala and a clerk and I went up on the roof in order
to look around.
"It was 10 o'clock, and was very dark and cloudy. Across the Ganga, in a northerly
direction, I saw a large building flooded with light. I asked Kamala (if he saw it) and he
said he had. I asked the clerk and he said, "I did not see anything." Because of that I
was utterly amazed. In the morning I looked carefully at the place [where I saw the
building] from the roof of the Rani Dharmasala, and I observed that there was one Tal tree
in that location. When I asked others about this place they said that this distant
place was known as Ballaldighi and that the remains of the fort etc. of Laksmana Sena were
close by. That Monday I returned to Krsnanagara and the following Saturday I went back
to Ballaldighi. I saw that wonderful phenomenon in that place again at night, and the
next day I went to see the area on foot. Upon inquiring of the elderly people of that
place, I was informed that this was the birthplace of Sriman Mahaprabhu. I gradually saw
everything (in the area) and ascertained where all the small villages mentioned in the
Caitanya-bhagavata and in Narahari Thakura's Bhakti-ratnakara and Parikrama Paddhati
were.
"While staying in Krsnanagara I wrote Sri Navadvipa-Dhama Mahatmya and sent it to
Calcutta to be printed. I explained all these matters to Dvarik Babu, an engineer from
Krsnanagara, and through the strength of his intellect understood everything. He made a map
of the area around Navadvipa for me. That also was printed in a reduced form in Dhama
Mahatmya. While I travelled around Navadvipa Dhama and wrote Navadvipa-dhama Mahatmya I
saw that there was very little opportunity to do more."
(Bhaktivinoda's letter to Lalita Prasad, written 1896)

We have been criticized by some of our friends for making too much of the issue of the
Adbhuta Mandira but we see no advantage in distorting the facts, allowing such
distortions to flourish or in denying the reality that Bhaktivinoda's vision was fulfilled by
Srila Bhaktisiddhanta who constructed the Adbhuta Mandira at Yogapitha in 1933 - which
is indeed a most wonderful temple.

One devotee from ISKCON has written to suggest that "Couldn't there be two Adbhuta
Mandiras, one at Yogapitha and one at ISKCON?" But that would be tantamount to saying,
"Couldn't there be two founder-acaryas of ISKCON?" - obviously unacceptable!

Of course there can be many wonderful temples at Mayapur and indeed there are, but we
should remember that 'big isn't always best'- small is beautiful, small is also
wonderful. In spiritual life proper conception is everything and the vision of Bhaktivinoda and
the conception of Lord Nityananda, as given in Navadvipa-dhama Mahatmya, is that the
Adbhuta Mandira is located at the birth site of Sri Caitanya Mahaprabhu.

The ISKCON project of late that is being referred to as the Adbhuta Mandira, was
originally started by our spiritual master, Srila A.C. Bhaktivedanta Swami Prabhupada.
Prabhupada, laid the cornerstone of the temple in 1977. Prabhupada however never made any
reference to his ambitious temple project being the Adbhuta Mandira. In fact Srila
Prabhupada distinctly referred to his project as the Temple of Understanding or the
Planetarium. It is only now, within the past decade or so, that some energetic disciples of
Prabhupada have hyped up the ISKCON Planetarium project (for fund raising purposes) by
calling it the Adbhuta Mandira. This however has no basis. It is indisputable - the Adbhuta
Mandira was constructed at Yogapitha in 1933.

Additional reference published in The Gaudiya and The Harmonist in the 1930s:
http://www.gosai.com/chaitanya/pilgr...yapura-fs.html

GOSAI.COM HOME PAGE
http://www.gosai.com/chaitanya/

MOTHER COW WEBSITE
http://www.mothercow.org/

SWAMI B. G. NARASINGHA MP3 LECTURES ONLINE
http://www.devavision.org/gosai/audio.html

SWAMI B. G. NARASINGHA ARTICLES
http://www.gosai.com/chaitanya/saran...s/indexna.html

KRSNA TALK ARTICLES & SUBSCRIPTION
http://www.gosai.com/krishnatalk_fs.html

To be removed from this mailing visit:
http://www.optinpro.com/scripts/remo...339&i=31514125