Jump to content
IndiaDivine.org
Sign in to follow this  
Guest guest

Royal Patronage

Rate this topic

Recommended Posts

Guest guest

Hi all,

 

Taken from: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,8125-1748270_1,00.html

 

THE Prince of Wales has secretly commissioned a report into the benefits of

complementary therapies in an attempt to persuade the Government to offer

more of them on the NHS, The Times has learnt.

 

The study ordered by the Prince, a long-standing enthusiast for alternative

medicine, seeks to influence government policy by claiming that wider

provision could save the tax-payer billions of pounds.

 

 

Its initial findings have been condemned as “outrageous and deeply flawed”

by Britain’s leading scientific expert in the field, who said it exaggerates

merits while “glossing over” problems of safety and effectiveness.

 

 

The Prince’s move has also triggered a row over his constitutional role, as

doctors and MPs questioned whether the heir to the throne should be issuing

so blatant a challenge to the Government’s agenda.

 

 

The report, led by Christopher Smallwood, a former chief economics adviser

to Barclays Bank, will be sent to ministers and officials in October. A

draft of its conclusions, seen by The Times, suggests that “economy-wide”

savings of between £500 million and £3.5 billion could be achieved by

offering spinal manipulation therapies such as chiropractic as a standard

NHS option for back pain.

 

 

It claims that up to £480 million could be cut from the prescription drugs

bill if 10 per cent of GPs were to offer homoeopathy as an alternative to

standard drugs, and that £38 million could be saved by switching 10 per cent

of depression patients to St John’s wort, a herbal remedy.

 

 

Edzard Ernst, Professor of Complementary and Alternative Medicine at the

University of Exeter, said that the recommendations flew in the face of

scientific evidence, which shows a net cost to providing alternative

therapies.

 

 

“These are outrageous estimates without any strong evidence to support

them,” Professor Ernst said. “The report glosses over the science and its

methodology is deeply flawed.

 

 

“It is highly selective in its use of evidence and it looks like the

conclusions have been written before everything else. It is based on such

poor science it’s just hair-raising. The Prince of Wales also seems to have

overstepped his constitutional role.”

 

 

Mr Smallwood, who has no previous expertise in complementary medicine, was

approached by Fresh Minds, a research consultancy employed by the Prince.

Professor Ernst, who was interviewed by Mr Smallwood and asked to advise on

the study, said that his criticisms about its methodology and conclusions

had been ignored. He has insisted that his contribution be withdrawn from

the final document.

 

 

“They have selected all the positive evidence and left out all the negative

studies,” the professor said. “They have over interpreted and misinterpreted

the data they do include. They changed the study’s methodology repeatedly as

they went along, which is a well-known source of error and bias.”

 

The leak of the report, which is a first draft and has since been rewritten

substantially, has caused fury at Clarence House. Mr Smallwood said that it

was shown to the professor in confidence. He has complained privately of

being “betrayed” by the professor’s comments.

 

The Prince of Wales has yet to see the work, which is still not complete.

 

 

 

 

 

Clarence House emphasised that the Prince of Wales had asked Mr Smallwood to

head the inquiry because he was independent of the Prince’s Foundation for

Integrated Health, which promotes alternative medicine therapies. Professor

Ernst is a long-standing critic of the foundation.

 

Paddy Harverson, the Prince’s communications secretary, said the Prince had

not sought to influence the conclusions of the study, which is financed by

two private char-ities not linked to the Prince.

 

 

“It is entirely inappropriate for anyone to be commenting on the report when

it has not even been completed, let alone published,” Mr Harverson said.

Criticism would be legitimate when it was completed, he said.

 

 

Clarence House also rejected the charge that the Prince was in breach of his

constitutional role in trying to influence government policy. Mr Harverson

added: “He merely asked an eminent independent economist to look at the

effectiveness, especially from a financial point of view, of integrated

healthcare.”

 

 

Professor Ernst said that there had been hardly any rigorous studies of the

cost effectiveness of complemen-tary treatments — almost all for acupuncture

and spinal manipulation — which found added costs for the NHS. He said that

it was impossible to assess the costs and benefits of providing free

complementary medicine without first considering how well various treatments

worked, and their risks.

 

 

He said: “In homoeopathy, there is no indication for which it is better or

even remotely similar to a conventional treatment, so to recommend it like

this is astonishing.

 

 

“You can always save money in the health service by doing nothing, at least

in the short term, but you will not help patients.”

 

 

Evan Harris, the Liberal Democrat science spokesman, said: “If Prince

Charles is going to seek to influence healthcare or science policy —

especially without going through the normal peer review process — he must

allow himself to be challenged in debate or interview, something that he has

never done.

 

 

“If the Palace believes that it is not appropriate for him to lower himself

into public debate, then he should stay out of public policy.”

 

Warm regards,

 

Attilio D'Alberto

Doctor of (Beijing, China)

B.Sc. (Hons) T.C.M., M.A.T.C.M.

07786198900

enquiries

<http://www.attiliodalberto.com/> www.attiliodalberto.com

 

“A human being is part of the whole, called by us the Universe, a part

limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and

feelings, as something separated from the rest - - a kind of optical

illusion in his consciousness.” (Albert Einstein)

 

 

 

 

 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Guest guest

Attilio D'Alberto wrote:

> Hi all,

>

> Taken from: http://www.timesonline.co.uk/article/0,,8125-1748270_1,00.html

>

> THE Prince of Wales has secretly commissioned a report into the benefits of

> complementary therapies in an attempt to persuade the Government to offer

> more of them on the NHS, The Times has learnt.

>

> The study ordered by the Prince, a long-standing enthusiast for alternative

> medicine, seeks to influence government policy by claiming that wider

> provision could save the tax-payer billions of pounds.

>

>

> Its initial findings have been condemned as “outrageous and deeply flawed”

> by Britain’s leading scientific expert in the field, who said it exaggerates

> merits while “glossing over” problems of safety and effectiveness.

 

Hi Attilio!

 

Cool! Looks like a first class turf war about to erupt! Have to get some

popcorn and a cold drink.

 

Regards,

 

Pete

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You are posting as a guest. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
Sign in to follow this  

×
×
  • Create New...