Well said Prafulla ji. The ability of the astrologer
is a concern rather than the accuracy of the science
itself. This forum is democratic and even a novice can
give his/her prediction and the party receiving the
prediction will not even know the credebility of the
astrologer. That is the danger, specially in such
delicate matters.

Regards,
Krishna

--- Prafulla Gang <jyotish (AT) inbox (DOT) com> wrote:

> I will endorse the views of Shri Kishore ji, if any
> of us can predict like those quoted sages (i.e. 100%
> accuracy). and If we can not (for lacking that
> ability), then let us not question astrology, but
> the astrologer.
>
> regards / Prafulla Gang
>
> The soul is pure when it leaves the body and drags
> nothing bodily with it, by virtue of having no
> willing association with the body in life but
> avoiding it.......Practicing philosophy in the right
> way is a training to die easily.
>
>
> > -----Original Message-----
> > From: r_maheshwari7 (AT) yahoo (DOT) com
> > Sent: Fri, 14 Jul 2006 10:01:49 -0000
> > To: vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com
> > Subject: [vedic-astrology] Re: urgent : husband in
> urgent need of
> > guidance
> >
> > pranam to all respected gurujis,
> >
> > with all due respect to the views of all highly
> learned astrologers
> > in this group i fully agree with the arguments
> given by shri kishore
> > patnikji. after all if vedic astrology is based on
> the scriptures of
> > great sages then we should there must have been
> some reason for
> > writing books like "STRIJATAKA" which give in
> detail on what
> > combinations a woman's character to be predicted.
> in fact to the best
> > of my knowledge this book even gives basis ofr
> predicting if a woman
> > can be prostitue or not. aslo if we talk abt
> sensitivity of the issue
> > it is as sensitive as predicting abt life death ,
> career and
> > marriages. there also a wrong prediction can ruin
> the life of a
> > staunch supporter and blind follower.
> >
> > with regards
> >
> >
> >>
> >> dear krishnamurthyji,
> >>
> >> with due respect to your views, what you said and
> what pandit
> > arjunji said
> >> are totally different.
> >>
> >> Now, coming to whether astrologers should predict
> on these issues,
> > i do not
> >> think you are right in saying that the astros
> should not predict on
> > the
> >> issue. If that were to be right, the scriptures
> would have never
> > given the
> >> combinations relating to the chastity of a man or
> woman.
> >>
> >> Secondly, while it is true that the wrong
> prediction could ruin an
> > entire
> >> family, dont you think this is true for any
> prediction, connected
> > with any
> >> matter? recently, i have seen a querrry
> lamenting a wrong
> > prediction with
> >> regard to his ruined career.Dont you think that
> is dangerous?
> >>
> >> Dont you think the marriage fixing through
> astrology is dangerous?
> > any wrong
> >> predictions can dash the hopes of poor young
> hearts
> >>
> >> Dont you think you are mentally make him die once
> you predict the
> > death of a
> >> native on so and so date? If the wrong prediction
> is made in this
> > issue, the
> >> whole life collapses, right???
> >>
> >> The astrology is a scinece of predictions. It is
> our duty to
> > predict without
> >> prejudice or favour, based on our knowledge and
> experience, only
> > with best
> >> intersts in mind! You should neither hurry with
> the predictions,
> > nor you
> >> should be careless or egoistic in your methods of
> predictions.
> > Intuition
> >> plays a great role in astrology and intuition can
> be gifted by god
> > only if
> >> you are pure and humble.
> >>
> >> If you make a wrong prediction in any case, not
> just in matters of
> > chastity
> >> or whatever, you can be as lethal as a doctor
> injecting the wrong
> > drug into
> >> his patient!!!
> >>
> >> Hope you will agree with me,
> >>
> >> Kishore patnaik
> >>
> >>
> >> On 7/12/06, Krishnamurthy Seetharama
> <krishna_1998@...> wrote:
> >>>
> >>> Dear Pandit Arjun Ji,
> >>>
> >>> Thanks for echoing similar views as of mine on
> this
> >>> subject. Any wrong prediction on such matters
> can ruin
> >>> not just an individual but many people and
> families
> >>> connected to them! This is serious. I hope
> people
> >>> giving predictions realize this.
> >>>
> >>> Hence, on such delicate matters, an astrologer
> should
> >>> give a prediction only if he/she has a long
> experience
> >>> of giving predictions and has not got even a
> single
> >>> prediction wrong. Do we have anyone like that?
> >>>
> >>> Though I am not an expert, I humbly suggest
> caution
> >>> and a sense of responsibility on part of the
> >>> astrologers while giving predictions especially
> in
> >>> areas that strongly affects the lives of people
> around
> >>> us.
> >>>
> >>> Regards,
> >>> Krishna
> >>>
> >>>
> >>> --- panditarjun2004
> <panditarjun2004@...<panditarjun2004%
> > 40yahoo.com>>
> >>> wrote:
> >>>
> >>>> dear friends
> >>>>
> >>>> on subjects such as incest, in my humble
> opinion,
> >>>> astrologers shall
> >>>> desist in giving any strong predictions, for it
> is a
> >>>> double edged
> >>>> sword. also if the astrologer paint adultery on
> a
> >>>> pativrata, he
> >>>> earns unforgivable bad karma and commit sin by
> >>>> causing separation
> >>>> between the couple.
> >>>>
> >>>> having said this, there is a village in
> uttaranchal
> >>>> where pandav
> >>>> pradha still thrives viz. any woman who comes
> home
> >>>> by marrying one
> >>>> person is shared by all her devars as a custom.
> >>>> this custom is also
> >>>> seen in several other parts of the north but
> not as
> >>>> a rule. is
> >>>> incest a social custom or a social evil. at
> least
> >>>> in dwapara yuga,
> >>>> it was not an evil as is the case in pandavas.
> has
> >>>> the evolution of
> >>>> a man from an animal removed his animal
> instincts or
>
=== message truncated ===


__________________________________________________
Do You Yahoo!?
Tired of spam? Yahoo! Mail has the best spam protection around
http://mail.yahoo.com