Dear All,
No where in Vedas it is said that Horoscope matching should be done.
How this system came into existence? Is it necessary that we should
follow it? If we have to, can we be sure that horoscope matching will
decrease the hardships in one's horoscope? If so, how? In Papasamya/
Kuja dosha etc we match the position of Malifics. Here what is meant
by Samya (in papa samya). What is the authentic sloka related to it?
Or is there any authentic sloka related to it? Is star match
important or graha samya?
There are thousands of questions that may come up related to
Horoscope matching. Can't we try to answer at least some of them? At
least the fundamental ones? I hope a hot discussion of the subject
would take place. Let us make it a good exercise. Also dear ones,
suggest a position for me in this game. Should I talk in support of
Horoscope matching or against it? Let new ideas come up. I will full
fill my roll and later expose my original stand as well.
Please, anybody don't come up with saying that I am egotic and
that is why starting such a discussion!! I am a poor fellow who enjoys
astrology, and nothing else but love to share
Love,
Sreenadh

Dear Sreenadhji,

This is a very relevant and worthy topic that should
be taken up for a hot discussion. In the world of
changing values both moral and ethical, where ego has
taken the first place in everyones life, mental
compatibility at times of bad patches in one another's
live has become all the more important issue to
continue to live to gether as Husband and Wife.

I would like that every Porutham should be critically
viewed and properly understood as to why it is
necessary to look into these aspects in the first
place.

You have been doing a very good job of putting forth
very pertinent and important issues that everone has
in mind but is kept to himself.

Thank you,

Namaskar,
Nagarajan


Send instant messages to your online friends http://in.messenger.yahoo.com

Dear Sreenadh,
I agree. I too feel that horoscope matching can't change one's destiny which
is fixed, always. Rather, if advise is to be rendered it should be given in
terms of basic nature, health, financial potential and general happiness.
You are writing good stuff.

P.Kumar (Mumbai, India)

----- Original Message -----
From: "Sreenadh" <sreelid@...>
To: <vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com>
Sent: Friday, January 13, 2006 5:13 PM
Subject: [vedic-astrology] Horoscope Matching


> Dear All,
> No where in Vedas it is said that Horoscope matching should be done.
> How this system came into existence? Is it necessary that we should
> follow it? If we have to, can we be sure that horoscope matching will
> decrease the hardships in one's horoscope? If so, how? In Papasamya/
> Kuja dosha etc we match the position of Malifics. Here what is meant
> by Samya (in papa samya). What is the authentic sloka related to it?
> Or is there any authentic sloka related to it? Is star match
> important or graha samya?
> There are thousands of questions that may come up related to
> Horoscope matching. Can't we try to answer at least some of them? At
> least the fundamental ones? I hope a hot discussion of the subject
> would take place. Let us make it a good exercise. Also dear ones,
> suggest a position for me in this game. Should I talk in support of
> Horoscope matching or against it? Let new ideas come up. I will full
> fill my roll and later expose my original stand as well.
> Please, anybody don't come up with saying that I am egotic and
> that is why starting such a discussion!! I am a poor fellow who enjoys
> astrology, and nothing else but love to share
> Love,
> Sreenadh
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
>
> Archives: http://www.egroups.com/group/vedic-astrology
>
> Group info: http://www.egroups.com/group/vedic-astrology/info.html
>
> To UNSUBSCRIBE: Blank mail to vedic-astrology-unsubscribe (AT) egroups (DOT) com
>
> ....... May Jupiter's light shine on us .......
>
> || Om Tat Sat || Sarvam Sri Krishnaarpanamastu ||
> Yahoo! Groups Links
>
>
>
>
>
>

Dear Shree. Sreenadh,
Let me hand it to you: you're a maven. First for initiating the bare-
essential brain-storming that your 'Let's predict...' set off. Now
you are on to matchmaking, possibly egged on (not miffed) by
concurrent exchanges now also on at the group forum.

Yes, I do feel the same way. On the one hand we talk of papasamya and
on the other we say a girl with a fate (or possiblity) of widowhood
be married to a boy with good longevity. The issues and challenges
facing vedic astrology are deep indeed. It awaits a standardisation
after a long spell of corruption, possibly due to some of the
vagaries the oral tradition is subject to.

Good starters, good work.

Touched by your 'BTW observation'.

Best,
RK Dash

--- In vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com, "Sreenadh" <sreelid@y...>
wrote:
>
> Dear All,
> No where in Vedas it is said that Horoscope matching should be
done.
> How this system came into existence? Is it necessary that we should
> follow it? If we have to, can we be sure that horoscope matching
will
> decrease the hardships in one's horoscope? If so, how? In
Papasamya/
> Kuja dosha etc we match the position of Malifics. Here what is
meant
> by Samya (in papa samya). What is the authentic sloka related to
it?
> Or is there any authentic sloka related to it? Is star match
> important or graha samya?
> There are thousands of questions that may come up related to
> Horoscope matching. Can't we try to answer at least some of them?
At
> least the fundamental ones? I hope a hot discussion of the subject
> would take place. Let us make it a good exercise. Also dear ones,
> suggest a position for me in this game. Should I talk in support of
> Horoscope matching or against it? Let new ideas come up. I will
full
> fill my roll and later expose my original stand as well.
> Please, anybody don't come up with saying that I am egotic and
> that is why starting such a discussion!! I am a poor fellow who
enjoys
> astrology, and nothing else but love to share
> Love,
> Sreenadh
>

Dear Nagarajan ji,
You said:
> This is a very relevant and worthy topic that should
> be taken up for a hot discussion.
I feel the same.
> In the world of
> changing values both moral and ethical, where ego has
> taken the first place in everyones life, mental
> compatibility at times of bad patches in one another's
> live has become all the more important issue to
> continue to live to gether as Husband and Wife.
Wow! Well said!
> I would like that every Porutham should be critically
> viewed and properly understood as to why it is
> necessary to look into these aspects in the first
> place.
Do you mean that every porutham should be crittically analysed,
broken into pieces, and thrown to the wind to take away!! ) It is
sure to happen if we look into the porutham (especially star related
matchings) followed today.
> why it is
> necessary to look into these aspects in the first
> place.
Yes, why Horoscope mathcing is necessory is the primary question that
needs to be answered. Also the logic behind each and every porutham
(let it be star related/papa samya/ dasa sandhi or anything else)
should also be discussed I would add.
> You have been doing a very good job of putting forth
> very pertinent and important issues that everone has
> in mind but is kept to himself.
Yes, it is when one feels that, it is his idea and that he would have
said it, if not uttered by someone else now, the words become
meaningfull!! Then they convay and communicate the experience of both
- the one who says and the one who hear!!! Then, we term it, the free
flow of thought, since it is owned by none!!
Love,
Sreenadh

--- In vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com, nagarajan chidambaram
<ngrjn_chidambaram@y...> wrote:
>
>
>
> Dear Sreenadhji,
>
> This is a very relevant and worthy topic that should
> be taken up for a hot discussion. In the world of
> changing values both moral and ethical, where ego has
> taken the first place in everyones life, mental
> compatibility at times of bad patches in one another's
> live has become all the more important issue to
> continue to live to gether as Husband and Wife.
>
> I would like that every Porutham should be critically
> viewed and properly understood as to why it is
> necessary to look into these aspects in the first
> place.
>
> You have been doing a very good job of putting forth
> very pertinent and important issues that everone has
> in mind but is kept to himself.
>
> Thank you,
>
> Namaskar,
> Nagarajan
>
>
> Send instant messages to your online friends http://in.messenger.
yahoo.com
>

Dear RK Dash ji,
I had to look in the dictionary while reading your mail - to
understand, maven, egged on, miffed, vagaries etc. I am just a
beginner as far as English is concerned, and that is why such a
situation. But sir, what a language! Quite impressive!
> Let me hand it to you: you're a maven. First for
> initiating the bare-essential brain-storming that
> your 'Let's predict...' set off.
Well, if 'Let's predict....' set off any kind of brain storming, then
truly, I am glad!! Though it was not that reflective here in this
forum, I hope you will be right.
> Now you are on to matchmaking, possibly egged on (not miffed) by
> concurrent exchanges now also on at the group forum.
True!!... But we people are like jackals - we sit wait and when we
feel that it it proper time to introduce a subject, jump in and have
our word!!!.....) Ask Dakshinamoorthi ji - he may agree to the same
!!
> Yes, I do feel the same way. On the one hand we
> talk of papasamya and on the other we say a girl with
> a fate (or possibility) of widowhood
> be married to a boy with good longevity.
How can we fee the same way??!!! I never exposed the fact that, I am
in support of Horoscope matching or Against it!!! Are you inviting me
to the platform that talks against papasamya and horoscope matching?.
....) Please wait, and see what others feel....
> The issues and challenges
> facing vedic astrology are deep indeed. It awaits a standardisation
> after a long spell of corruption,
I agree, completely.
> possibly due to some of the
> vagaries the oral tradition is subject to.
No sir!!! Actually it is the oral tradition that kept astrology in
its original form and saved it from corruption!!! In Kerala it never
underwent much corruption only because of the fact that the oral
tradition was also present!! The presnamagachaya never said/talked
about interpreting Navamsa chart(and the other vargas) independently,
and look at the north Indian system where people are interpreting
Navamsa chart independently for the past 300 or more years, without
the support of a single book or sloka!!! And now they have started
interpreting Presnamarga also in the same way!!! The primary reason
could only be break occurred in the continuity of the oral tradition!
!! This is a conclusion we draw upon when we compare the systems
followed in North/South. OK. It is all together a different subject
and should not be brought into the issue of Horoscope Matching.....
Love,
Sreeandh


--- In vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com, "arkaydash" <arkaydash@y...>
wrote:
>
> Dear Shree. Sreenadh,
> Let me hand it to you: you're a maven. First for initiating the
bare-
> essential brain-storming that your 'Let's predict...' set off. Now
> you are on to matchmaking, possibly egged on (not miffed) by
> concurrent exchanges now also on at the group forum.
>
> Yes, I do feel the same way. On the one hand we talk of papasamya
and
> on the other we say a girl with a fate (or possiblity) of widowhood
> be married to a boy with good longevity. The issues and challenges
> facing vedic astrology are deep indeed. It awaits a standardisation
> after a long spell of corruption, possibly due to some of the
> vagaries the oral tradition is subject to.
>
> Good starters, good work.
>
> Touched by your 'BTW observation'.
>
> Best,
> RK Dash
>
> --- In vedic-astrology (AT) yahoogroups (DOT) com, "Sreenadh" <sreelid@y...>
> wrote:
> >
> > Dear All,
> > No where in Vedas it is said that Horoscope matching should be
> done.
> > How this system came into existence? Is it necessary that we
should
> > follow it? If we have to, can we be sure that horoscope matching
> will
> > decrease the hardships in one's horoscope? If so, how? In
> Papasamya/
> > Kuja dosha etc we match the position of Malifics. Here what is
> meant
> > by Samya (in papa samya). What is the authentic sloka related to
> it?
> > Or is there any authentic sloka related to it? Is star match
> > important or graha samya?
> > There are thousands of questions that may come up related to
> > Horoscope matching. Can't we try to answer at least some of them?
> At
> > least the fundamental ones? I hope a hot discussion of the subject
> > would take place. Let us make it a good exercise. Also dear ones,
> > suggest a position for me in this game. Should I talk in support
of
> > Horoscope matching or against it? Let new ideas come up. I will
> full
> > fill my roll and later expose my original stand as well.
> > Please, anybody don't come up with saying that I am egotic and
> > that is why starting such a discussion!! I am a poor fellow who
> enjoys
> > astrology, and nothing else but love to share
> > Love,
> > Sreenadh
> >
>