IndiaDivine Home



Powered by IndiaDivine Communications
|   IndiaDivine Home   |   Forum Home   |    Video Directory   |    Members List   |    Search   |    Today's Posts   |    Mark Forums Read   |   
IndiaDivine Menu
Picture Gallery
Email Newsletter

Online Donations
Videos and DVDs
Ayurvedic Medicines
(#1 (Link))
Old
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default God is separate from this world - 08-18-2005, 02:30 AM

Consider a potter making a pot with mud. Potter is the efficient cause, mud the material cause and pot the effect. The effect is related to the material cause ONLY. That's why once you break the pot (effect), it goes back into the material cause, mud. But the effect has nothing to do with the efficient cause. The pot, when broken, doesn't merge into the efficient cause, or every pot will become the potter.

Likewise, God is the efficient cause, his shakti the material cause of this universe. This universe can only merge into the material cause. So man is NOT god, this world is NOT god, nor can it become god because the effect is only related to the material cause and NOT to the efficient cause. Man becoming God is tantamount to saying that the pot can become the potter.

Therefore, advaita, buddhism and other SOTs are absurd. Dvaita defines Hinduism best.
Reply With Quote


(#2 (Link))
Old
Member
 
Posts: 185
Join Date: Jun 2005
Default Examples should not be taken beyond their limit - 08-18-2005, 02:40 AM

Hari OM:

Dwaita Gurus had given much more efficient examples and had been refuted by Others.

Your example holds good only if God and His energy would "ALWAYS" remain two seperate identities like the "potter" and the "Clay" (mud is not the correct term)

However if the Potter creates Clay out of himself and merges back into himself then the example fails.
Reply With Quote


(#3 (Link))
Old
Sephiroth's Avatar
Senior Member
 
Posts: 1,491
Join Date: Jun 2005
Default Bad analog ... - 08-18-2005, 02:40 AM

Pot and Man are not the same ... this is a bad analog.

Man have free will to act and at same time, alive. A pot has no free will to act and not alive. To break itself, the pot will need an exterior force to play onto displacing and breaking it.

While Man cannot become God, it doesn't mean God cannot become Man or that Man will not return back to God.
Reply With Quote


(#4 (Link))
Old
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default God is not separate from World or Universe. - 08-19-2005, 03:59 AM

I will try to give an example why God is not separate from World or Universe.

I feel the relation between a Seeker (Bhakta) and God is like Mass and Energy respectively.
You can transfer the energy from one mass to another mass through some ways/means. That doesnt mean like mass is separate from energy (Potential Energy). You are breaking mass to explode in atom bomb, there you are converting mass to energy (Einstiens priciple). In the same way Bhakta has to explode/evolve himself to reach God.

There can never be Bhakta without God and vice-versa is also true. Energy prevails at every place, in the same way God is Omnipresent.

Catch my point..!!

Thanks.
Reply With Quote


Reply

Bookmarks


Currently Active Users Viewing This Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
 
Thread Tools
Display Modes Rate This Thread
Rate This Thread:


Similar Threads
Thread Forum Replies Last Post
If Buddhism&Hinduism are separate than Catholics&Protestants are Separate Religi Vedic Culture 0 07-19-2005 09:25 AM
The Supreme Separate Identity Spiritual Discussions 0 06-09-2004 12:30 PM
Therefore I want to keep BBT separate. Vedic Culture 0 08-31-2003 04:25 AM
the body is separate from the Self Advaita Vedanta 0 08-01-2002 08:37 AM


Free Shipping






All orders have free shipping to any country in the world.
Account Information



Ayurvedic Medicines
Search IndiaDivine
Ask a Question
Do you have a spiritual question? Please write.

Translate this Page


Video Library
Audio CDs
Multimedia CDs
Malas
(Prayer Beads)
Advertise | Contact Us | About this Site | Privacy Policy | Bhaktivedanta Ashram | Puja Sponsorships | Charity in India |





Hindi Arabic Bulgarian Chinese (Simplified) Chinese (Traditional) Croatian Czech Danish Dutch Finnish French German Greek Hebrew Hungarian Italian Japanese Korean Norwegian Polish Portuguese Romanian Russian Serbian Slovak Spanish Swedish Thai Turkish

IndiaDivine has had 77,972,440 page views since creation.